Computational exploration of borophane-supported single transition metal atoms as potential oxygen reduction and evolution electrocatalysts

Enhanced Superconductivity of Hydrogenated β12 Borophene

Borophene stands out among elemental two-dimensional materials due to its extraordinary physical properties, including structural polymorphism, strong anisotropy, metallicity, and the potential for phonon-mediated superconductivity. However, confirming superconductivity in borophene experimentally has been evasive to date, mainly due to the detrimental effects of metallic substrates and its susceptibility to oxidation. In this study, we present an ab initio analysis of superconductivity in the experimentally synthesized hydrogenated β12 borophene, which has been proven to be less prone to oxidation. Our findings demonstrate that hydrogenation significantly enhances both the stability and superconducting properties of β12 borophene. Furthermore, we reveal that tensile strain and hole doping, achievable through various experimental methods, significantly enhance the critical temperature, reaching up to 29 K. These findings not only promote further fundamental research on superconducting borophene and its heterostructures, but also position hydrogenated borophene as a versatile platform for low-dimensional superconducting electronics.

Theoretical study of transition metal-doped β12 borophene as a new single-atom catalyst for carbon dioxide electroreduction

The electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR) presents a viable and cost-effective approach for the elimination of CO2 by transforming it into valuable products. Nevertheless, this process is impeded by the absence of exceptionally active and stable catalysts. Herein, a new type of electrocatalyst of transition metal (TM)-doped β12-borophene (TM@β12-BM) is investigated via density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Through comprehensive screening, two promising single-atom catalysts (SACs), Sc@β12-BM and Y@β12-BM, are successfully identified, exhibiting high stability, catalytic activity and selectivity for the CO2RR. The C1 products methane (CH4) and methanol (CH3OH) are synthesized with limiting potentials (UL) of -0.78 V and -0.56 V on Sc@β12-BM and Y@β12-BM, respectively. Meanwhile, CO2 is more favourable for reduction into the C2 product ethanol (CH3CH2OH) compared to ethylene (C2H4) via C-C coupling on these two SACs. More importantly, the dynamic barriers of the key C-C coupling step are 0.53 eV and 0.73 eV for the "slow-growth" sampling approach in the explicit water molecule model. Furthermore, Sc@β12-BM and Y@β12-BM exhibit higher selectivity for producing C1 compounds (CH4 and CH3OH) than C2 (CH3CH2OH) in the CO2RR. Compared with Sc@β12-BM, Y@β12-BM demonstrates superior inhibition of the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) in the liquid phase. These results not only demonstrate the great potential of SACs for direct reduction of CO2 to C1 and C2, but also help in rationally designing high-performance SACs.

Interplay between Defects and Short-Range Disorder Manipulating the Oxygen Evolution Reaction on a Layered Double Hydroxide Electrocatalyst

Improving the efficiency of the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is crucial for advancing sustainable and environmentally friendly hydrogen energy. Layered double hydroxides (LDHs) have emerged as promising electrocatalysts for the OER. However, a thorough understanding of the impact of structural disorder and defects on the catalytic activity of LDHs remains limited. In this work, a series of NiAl-LDH models are systematically constructed, and their OER performance is rigorously screened through theoretical density functional theory. The acquired results unequivocally reveal that the energy increase induced by structural disorder is effectively counteracted at the defect surface, indicating the coexistence of defects and disorder. Notably, it is ascertained that the simultaneous presence of defects and disorder synergistically augments the catalytic activity of LDHs in the context of the OER. These theoretical findings offer valuable insights into the design of highly efficient OER catalysts while also shedding light on the efficacy of LDH electrocatalysts.

Structural Characterization of Boron Sheets beyond the Monolayer and Implication for Experimental Synthesis and Identification

The successful synthesis of quasi-freestanding bilayer borophene has aroused much attention for its superior physical properties and holds great promise for future electronic devices. Herein, we comprehensively explore six boron sheets beyond the monolayer and structurally characterize them via various methods using first-principles calculations for experimental references. On the basis of atomic models of borophenes, simulated scanning tunneling microscope (STM) images show different morphologies at different bias voltages and are explained by the partial densities of states and the height differences in the vertical direction. Simulated transmission electron microscope images further probe the internal atomic arrangement of boron sheets and compensate for the shortcomings of STM images to better distinguish different phases of boron sheets. The interlayer coupling strength is stronger in bilayer borophenes than in the three-layer system via the electron localization function and Mulliken bond population. In addition, simulated X-ray diffraction and infrared spectra show different characteristic peaks and corresponding vibrational modes to further characterize these boron sheets. These theoretical results can decrease the prime cost and provide vital guidance for the experimental synthesis and identification of boron sheets beyond the monolayer.

Metal-Doped C3B Monolayer as the Promising Electrocatalyst for Hydrogen/Oxygen Evolution Reaction: A Combined Density Functional Theory and Machine Learning Study

The development of high-efficiency electrocatalysts for hydrogen evolution reduction (HER)/oxygen evolution reduction (OER) is highly desirable. In particular, metal borides have attracted much attention because of their excellent performances. In this study, we designed a series of metal borides by doping of a transition metal (TM) in a C3B monolayer and further explored their potential applications for HER/OER via density functional theory (DFT) calculations and machine learning (ML) analysis. Our results revealed that the |ΔG*H| values of Fe-, Ag-, Re-, and Ir-doped C3B are approximately 0.00 eV, indicating their excellent HER performances. On the other hand, among all the considered TM atoms, the Ni- and Pt-doped C3B exhibit excellent OER activities with the overpotentials smaller than 0.44 V. Together with their low overpotentials for HER (<0.16 V), we proposed that Ni/C3B and Pt/C3B could be the potential bifunctional electrocatalysts for water splitting. In addition, the ML method was employed to identify the important factors to affect the performance of the TM/C3B electrocatalyst. Interestingly, the results showed that the OER performance is closely related to the inherent properties of TM atoms, i.e., the number of d electrons, electronegativity, atomic radius, and first ionization energy; all these values could be directly obtained without DFT calculations. Our results not only proposed several promising electrocatalysts for HER/OER but also suggested a guidance to design the potential TM-boron (TM-B)-based electrocatalysts.

Promising transition metal decorated borophene catalyst for water splitting†

Borophene has been recently reported to be a promising catalyst for water splitting. However, as a newly synthesized two-dimensional material, there are several issues that remain to be explored. In the present study, we investigate the catalytic performance of three kinds of pristine and decorated borophenes using first-principles calculations. Our calculations show that Ni-doped α borophene can be a highly active catalyst for water splitting. Doping or decorating with different transition metals such as Co or Ni at different sites shows a strong effect on the catalytic performance of α, β₁₂ and χ₃ borophenes. Ni-doped α borophene shows low Gibbs free energy of hydrogen adsorption (ΔG_H ∼ 0.055 eV) for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and promising overpotential (0.455 V) for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). This study provides some critical insights into the catalytic activity of borophene for water splitting by selecting suitable decorated metal.

Promising Ni metal decorated borophene catalyst for water splitting.

Water splitting by MnFe2O4/Na2CO3 reversible redox reactions

Future energy systems must call upon clean and renewable sources capable of reducing associated CO2 emissions. The present research opens new perspectives for renewable energy-based hydrogen production by water splitting using metal oxide oxidation/reduction reactants. An earlier multicriteria assessment defined top priorities, with MnFe2O4/Na2CO3/H2O and Mn3O4/MnO/NaMnO2/H2O multistep redox cycles having the highest potential. The latter redox system was previously assessed and proven difficult to be conducted. The former redox system was hence experimentally investigated in the present research at the 0.5 to 250 g scale in isothermal thermogravimetry, an electrically heated furnace, and a concentrated solar reactor. Over 30 successive oxidation/reduction cycles were assessed, and the H2 production efficiencies exceeded 98 % for the coprecipitated reactant after these multiple cycles. Tentative economics using a coprecipitated reactant revealed that 120 cycles are needed to achieve a 1 € per kg H2 cost. Improving the cheaper ball-milled reactant could reduce costs by approximately 30 %. The initial results confirm that future research is important.

Exploring the emerging applications of the advanced 2-dimensional material borophene with its unique properties

Borophene, a crystalline allotrope of monolayer boron, with a combination of triangular lattice and hexagonal holes, has stimulated wide interest in 2-dimensional materials and their applications. Although their properties are theoretically confirmed, they are yet to be explored and confirmed experimentally. In this review article, we present advancements in research on borophene, its synthesis, and unique properties, including its advantages for various applications with theoretical predictions. The uniqueness of borophene over graphene and other 2-dimensional (2D) materials is also highlighted along with their various structural stabilities. The strategy for its theoretical simulations, leading to the experimental synthesis, could also be helpful for the exploration of many newer 2D materials.

Density Functional Theory Study of the Oxygen Reduction Reaction Mechanism on Graphene Doped with Nitrogen and a Transition Metal

The active centers of carbon nonplatinum catalysts doped with cobalt, iron, nickel, and copper have been simulated by quantum-chemical density functional theory methods. The thermodynamics of the electrochemical oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) on model catalysts has been determined. It was found that among the studied catalysts, graphene doped with cobalt and iron showed the best properties. A two-state reactivity effect has been found on a cobalt-containing catalyst, and a more detailed reaction mechanism has been proposed, including the stages of charging by an extra electron and association with water. The proposed mechanism explains several effects that have arisen during the modeling in relation to the classical mechanism.

Role of Pt and PtO2 in the Oxygen-Evolution Reaction in the Presence of Iron under Alkaline Conditions

The oxygen-evolution reaction (OER) through water oxidation is an inevitable reaction for water splitting toward storing energy. However, OER is a four-electron and slow reaction, which is also a bottleneck for water splitting. To find the role of Pt and PtO₂ on the OER in the presence of Fe, the electrochemistry of Pt foil and PtO₂ is investigated in the absence/presence of K₂FeO₄ as a soluble Fe salt at pH ≈ 13. After the addition of K₂FeO₄, a remarkable increase in the OER is recorded in the presence of Pt or PtO₂. The obtained catalysts were characterized by operando visible spectroscopy, high-resolution transmission electron microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, electron-spin resonance spectroscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, and electrochemical methods. KOH solutions usually contain Fe and/or Ni impurities. It is found that neither Pt nor PtO₂ is an OER catalyst in a Ni/Fe-free KOH, and even at an overpotential of 570 mV in purified KOH (pH ≈ 13), no clear OER was observed.

Screening of catalytic oxygen reduction reaction activity of 2, 9-dihalo-1, 10-phenanthroline metal complexes: The role of transition metals and halogen substitution

The sluggish kinetics of oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) restricts the employment of fuel cells, it is urgent to design ORR catalysts with excellent performance. The ORR performances of 2, 9-dihalo-1, 10-phenanthroline metal complexes (named as TM-X, X = Cl, Br, I) are comprehensively studied by the density functional theory methods. From the stability point of view, chlorine is more suitable for substitution. The adsorption free energy reveals that the liner relationship between adsorption free energy of *OOH and *OH is changed positively by the steric hindrance caused by the orthogonal TM-X structures. The Ni-Br stands out with the lowest overpotential of 0.34 V, and many other TM-X also show the promising ORR activity. Combining with the analysis of the Gibbs free energy diagrams and d-band center results, the substitution of halogen can improve the electronic structures of TM-X, thus enhancing their ORR activities and changing the ORR mechanism possibly.

Borophene: Two-dimensional Boron Monolayer: Synthesis, Properties, and Potential Applications

Borophene, a monolayer of boron, has risen as a new exciting two-dimensional (2D) material having extraordinary properties, including anisotropic metallic behavior and flexible (orientation-dependent) mechanical and optical properties. This review summarizes the current progress in the synthesis of borophene on various metal substrates, including Ag(110), Ag(100), Au(111), Ir(111), Al(111), and Cu(111), as well as heterostructuring of borophene. In addition, it discusses the mechanical, thermal, magnetic, electronic, optical, and superconducting properties of borophene and the effects of elemental doping, defects, and applied mechanical strains on these properties. Furthermore, the promising potential applications of borophene for gas sensing, energy storage and conversion, gas capture and storage applications, and possible tuning of the material performance in these applications through doping, formation of defects, and heterostructures are illustrated based on available theoretical studies. Finally, research and application challenges and the outlook of the whole borophene's field are given.

Oxygen Evolution and Reduction Reaction Activity Investigations on Fe, Co or Ni embedded Tetragonal Graphene by A Thermodynamical Full-Landscape Searching Scheme

Single transition metal (TM) atoms such as Fe, Co and Ni occupying a carbon divacancy in tetragonal graphene (TG) and bonded with four nitrogen atoms (TM@N4 TG) as electrocatalysts are investigated by means of first-principles calculations. To consider the effect of solvent species on the local configuration of the active single metal, a thermodynamical full-landscape searching (TFLS) scheme is employed. The calculated thermodynamic overpotentials (ηtd ) from our TFLS indicate that Co@N4 TG displays high catalytic activity toward both oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and reduction reaction (ORR), with ηtd OER and ηtd ORR as 0.397 and 0.357 V, respectively. Its OER potential cannot be captured if only one four electron reaction loop (FERL) is considered. The actual active pathways do not always turn out to be the reactions starting from the bare site. Our findings demonstrate that TG is a promising support and TM confined TD can be used to design effective and cheap multifunctional electrocatalysts.

Borophene-supported single transition metal atoms as potential oxygen evolution/reduction electrocatalysts: a density functional theory study

Due to the maximal atom utilization, high activity, and selectivity, the two-dimensional (2D) matrix supported single-atom catalysts (SACs) have attracted substantial research interests. In this work, we carried out the theoretical study on the stability, activity for oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), and its dependence on the electronic structure of transition metal (TM) anchored on two types of borophene (called β₁₂ and χ₃) by density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The results show that the early- and VIII-TM anchored β₁₂ and χ₃ borophenes are structurally and thermodynamically stable. The overpotentials of OER (η^OER) over the Ni supported on β₁₂ and χ₃ borophene SACs, designated as β₁₂-Ni and χ₃-Ni, are 0.38 and 0.35 V, respectively. The η^ORR of β₁₂-Ni and χ₃-Ni are estimated to be as low as 0.34 and 0.39 V, respectively. The OER/ORR activity of the SACs can be well correlated with their electronic structures. The high η^OER values of early TM supported on borophene SACs correspond to high d-band center of TM. Both β₁₂-Ni and χ₃-Ni have a moderate d-band center. Since the overpotentials for OER and ORR on β₁₂-Ni and χ₃-Ni are comparable to those of Pt group metals and their oxides, β₁₂-Ni and χ₃-Ni can be considered as the promising bifunctional catalysts for OER and ORR.

Anchored atomic tungsten on a B40 cage: a highly active and selective single-atom catalyst for nitrogen reduction

In comparison with the prevalent 2D material-supported single atom catalysts (SACs), the design and fabrication of SACs with single molecule substrates are still challenging. Here we introduce a new type of SAC in which a recently identified all-boron fullerene B40 is employed as the support and its catalytic performance toward the nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) process is explored in theory. Taking advantage of the novel heptagonal ring substructure on the sphere and the electron-deficient nature of boron, the atomic metals are facile to reside on B40 to form atomically dispersed η7-B40M exohedral complexes. Among a series of candidates, originating from the proper metal-adsorbate interactions, the atomic tungsten-decorated B40W is screened out as the most feasible catalyst for the NRR with a low over-potential and high selectivity to passivate the competitive hydrogen evolution process.

Designed Single Atom Bifunctional Electrocatalysts for Overall Water Splitting: 3d Transition Metal Atoms Doped Borophene Nanosheets

Single atom catalysts (SAC) for water splitting hold the promise of producing H₂ in a highly efficient and economical way. As the performance of SACs depends on the interaction between the adsorbate atom and supporting substrate, developing more efficient SACs with suitable substrates is of significance. In this work, inspired by the successful fabrications of borophene in experiments, we systematically study the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) activities of a series of 3d transition metal-based SACs supported by various borophene monolayers (BMs=α_sheet, α₁ _sheet, and β₁ _sheet borophene), TM/BMs, using density functional theory calculations and kinetic simulations. All of the TM/BMs systems exhibit superior HER performance compared to Pt with close to zero thermoneutral Gibbs free energy (ΔG_H* ) of H adsorption. Furthermore, three Ni-deposited systems, namely, Ni/α_BM, Ni/α₁ _BM and Ni/β₁ _BM, were identified to be superior OER catalysts with remarkably reduced overpotentials. Based on these results, Ni/BMs can be expected to serve as stunning bifunctional electrocatalysts for water splitting. This work provides a guideline for developing efficient bifunctional electrocatalysts.

Borophene: New Sensation in Flatland

Borophene, a 2D allotrope of boron and the lightest elemental Dirac material, is the latest very promising 2D material owing to its unique structural and electronic characteristics of the X₃ and β₁₂ phases. The high atomic density on ridgelines of the β₁₂ phase of borophene provides a substantial orbital overlap, which leads to an excellent electron density in the conduction level and thus to a highly metallic behavior. These unique structural characteristics and electronic properties of borophene attract significant scientific interest. Herein, approaches for crystal growth/synthesis of these unique nanostructures and their potential technological applications are discussed. Various substrate-supported ultrahigh-vacuum growth techniques for borophene, such as molecular beam epitaxy, atomic layer deposition, and chemical vapor deposition, along with their challenges, are also summarized. The sonochemical exfoliation and modified Hummer's technique for the synthesis of free-standing borophene are also discussed. Solution-phase exfoliation seems to address the scalability issues and expands the applications of these unique materials to various fields, including renewable energy devices and ultrafast sensors. Furthermore, the electronic, optical, thermal, and elastic properties of borophene are thoroughly discussed and are compared with those of graphene and its "cousins." Numerous frontline applications are envisaged and an outlook is presented.

Unraveling the single-atom electrocatalytic activity of transition metal-doped phosphorene

The development of single-atom catalysts (SACs) for chemical reactions of vital importance in the renewable energy sector has emerged as an urgent priority. In this perspective, transition metal-based SACs with monolayer phosphorous (phosphorene) as the supporting material are scrutinized for their electrocatalytic activity towards the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), oxygen evolution reaction (OER), and hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) from first-principle calculations. The detailed screening study has confirmed a breaking of the scaling relationship between the ORR/OER intermediates, resulting in various activity trends across the transition metal series. Groups 9 and 10 transition metal-based SACs are identified as potential catalyst candidates with the platinum single atom offering bifunctional activity for OER and HER with diminished overpotentials. Ambient condition stability analysis of SACs confirmed a different extent of interaction towards oxygen and water compared to pristine phosphorene, suggesting room for improving the stability of phosphorene via chemical functionalization.

Strain effects on Co,N co-decorated graphyne catalysts for overall water splitting electrocatalysis

Lattice strain, either tensile or compressive, can fine-tune the electronic structure of surfaces via altering the distances between surface atoms, thereby modifying the catalytic activity of catalysts. Numerous examples of strain engineering have been applied to various electrocatalysts for both hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER), but strain-optimized 2D carbon-based single-atom electrocatalysts for catalyzing the overall water splitting reaction have received little attention. Here, we applied the lattice strain of Co,N co-decorated graphyne (Co@N₁-GY) to directly optimize its catalytic activity for the overall water splitting reaction based on first-principles calculations. Our calculations suggest that compressive strain and tensile strain lead to less stability of Co@N₁-GY and the distances between C and Co atoms increase linearly with the strain changing from compressive to tensile, thus linearly upshifting the p-band center of C atoms and the d-band center of Co atoms. In addition, biaxial strain has more remarkable effects on these properties than uniaxial strain. From compressive to tensile strain, the chemisorption of electrochemically generated intermediates in both HER and OER becomes weaker and weaker. A tensile strain of 0.5% on Co@N₁-GY gives an ideal HER performance, while the OER reaches the minimum overpotential of 0.33 V under the biaxial tensile strain of 3%.