The stability enhancement factor beyond eight-electron shell closure in thiacalix[4]arene-protected silver clusters

Thiacalix[4]arene-Stabilized Sb/Ag Bimetallic Nanoclusters: Elucidating the Effects of Sb Doping on Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction in Ag Clusters

Accurately identifying the metal doping effects within heterogeneous catalysts presents a formidable challenge due to the complex nature of controlling the interfacial chemistry at the molecular level. Herein, we use two sets of atomically precise nanoclusters to demonstrate the impact of Sb doping on the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction activity in Ag nanoclusters. Leveraging the unique properties of the thiacalix[4]arene, we have pioneered a methodology for incorporating catalytic Ag1+ and Sb3+ sites, culminating in the synthesis of the pioneering Sb-Ag bimetallic cluster, Sb2Ag11. We refined this structure by replacing the two Sb3+ sites with Na+ sites, resulting in a Na2Ag10 cluster. Broadening our investigative scope, we isolated the core components from both Sb2Ag11 and Na2Ag10 and obtained two clusters: Sb2Ag4 and Ag4. The subtle compositional variations between two pairs of structurally analogous clusters, Sb2Ag11 and Na2Ag10, as well as Sb2Ag4 and Ag4, create opportunities to investigate how the Sb doping impacts the catalytic activity of Ag clusters. Clearly, compared to the undoped clusters, those doped with Sb exhibit higher catalytic current densities and enhanced CO selectivity. The theoretical calculations suggest that Sb doping can enhance the adsorption barrier of *H, thereby inhibiting hydrogen evolution activity and conversely promoting eCO2RR to CO activity.

Advancements in calixarene-protected titanium-oxo clusters: from structural assembly to catalytic functionality

This review explores calixarenes, a prominent family of third-generation supramolecules celebrated for their distinct hollow, cavity-shaped structures. These macrocycles are intricately assembled by linking multiple phenolic units orthogonally through methylene (-CH2-), sulfur (-S-), or sulfonyl (-SO2-) bridges. This structural framework plays a pivotal role in the intricate assembly of nanoclusters, significantly advancing the field of cluster chemistry. A key focus of current research is the remarkable ability of calixarenes to stabilize titanium-oxo clusters. Our review details the application of calixarenes in constructing titanium-oxo cluster structures, emphasizing how these clusters, when encapsulated within calixarenes, exploit flexible coordination sites for structural modifications and serve as foundational units for more complex assemblies. Additionally, we investigate how these calixarene-stabilized metal-oxo clusters function as versatile scaffolds for catalytically active metal ions, facilitating the creation of bimetallic nanoclusters. These clusters not only exhibit unique structural diversity but also demonstrate exceptional catalytic efficiency. This review aims to inspire ongoing exploration and innovation in the use of calixarenes for the synthesis and application of advanced cluster materials.

All-Calixarene-Protected Silver Nanocluster with All Silver Atoms in a Face-Centered Cubic Arrangement

Tailoring the surface ligands of metal nanoclusters is important for engineering unique configurations of metal nanoclusters. Thiacalix[4]arene has found extensive applications in the construction of metal nanoclusters. In this investigation, we present the synthesis and characterization of the first all-calixarene-protected silver nanoclusters, [Ag(CH3CN)4]2[Ag44(BTCA)6] (Ag44, H4BTCA = p-tert-butylthiacalix[4]arene). Single-crystal X-ray structural analysis reveals that all silver atoms are in a face-centered cubic (fcc) arrangement. The formation of such an fcc structure is attributed to the selectively passivation on {100} facets by BTCA4-. Thiacalixarene substantially facilitates the stability of Ag44 due to its multiple coordination sites and bulkiness. Mass spectrometry and theoretical calculations reveal that Ag44 is a superatomic silver nanocluster with 22 free electrons in the following configuration: 1S21P61D61F22S21D4. This work not only elucidates the impact of macrocyclic ligands on the stabilization of silver clusters but also furnishes an approach for assembling atomically precise fcc nanoclusters.

Advancements in Atomically Precise Nanocluster Protected by Thiacalix[4]arene

Coinage metal nanoclusters (NCs), comprising a few to several hundred atoms, are prized for their size-dependent properties crucial in catalysis, sensing, and biomedicine. However, their practical application is often hindered by stability and reactivity challenges. Thiacalixarene, a macrocyclic ligand, shows promise in stabilizing silver, copper, and bimetallic NCs, enhancing their structural integrity and chemical stability. This investigation delves into the unique properties of thiacalix[4]arene and their role in bolstering NC stability, catalytic efficiency, and sensing capabilities. The current challenges and future prospects are critically evaluated, underscoring the transformative impact of thiacalix[4]arene in nanoscience. This review aims to broaden the utilization of atomically precise coinage metal NCs, unlocking new avenues across scientific and industrial applications.

Ag1+ incorporation via a Zr4+-anchored metalloligand: fine-tuning catalytic Ag sites in Zr/Ag bimetallic clusters for enhanced eCO2RR-to-CO activity

Attaining meticulous dominion over the binding milieu of catalytic metal sites remains an indispensable pursuit to tailor product selectivity and elevate catalytic activity. By harnessing the distinctive attributes of a Zr4+-anchored thiacalix[4]arene (TC4A) metalloligand, we have pioneered a methodology for incorporating catalytic Ag1+ sites, resulting in the first Zr-Ag bimetallic cluster, Zr2Ag7, which unveils a dualistic configuration embodying twin {ZrAg3(TC4A)2} substructures linked by an {AgSal} moiety. This cluster unveils a trinity of discrete Ag sites: a pair ensconced within {ZrAg3(TC4A)2} subunits and one located between two units. Expanding the purview, we have also crafted ZrAg3 and Zr2Ag2 clusters, meticulously mimicking the two Ag site environment inherent in the {ZrAg3(TC4A)2} monomer. The distinct structural profiles of Zr2Ag7, ZrAg3, and Zr2Ag provide an exquisite foundation for a precise comparative appraisal of catalytic prowess across three Ag sites intrinsic to Zr2Ag7. Remarkably, Zr2Ag7 eclipses its counterparts in the electroreduction of CO2, culminating in a CO faradaic efficiency (FECO) of 90.23% at -0.9 V. This achievement markedly surpasses the performance metrics of ZrAg3 (FECO: 55.45% at -1.0 V) and Zr2Ag2 (FECO: 13.09% at -1.0 V). Utilizing in situ ATR-FTIR, we can observe reaction intermediates on the Ag sites. To unveil underlying mechanisms, we employ density functional theory (DFT) calculations to determine changes in free energy accompanying each elementary step throughout the conversion of CO2 to CO. Our findings reveal the exceptional proficiency of the bridged-Ag site that interconnects paired {ZrAg3(TC4A)2} units, skillfully stabilizing *COOH intermediates, surpassing the stabilization efficacy of the other Ag sites located elsewhere. The invaluable insights gleaned from this pioneering endeavor lay a novel course for the design of exceptionally efficient catalysts tailored for CO2 reduction reactions, emphatically underscoring novel vistas this research unshrouds.

Sulfur atom-directed metal-ligand synergistic catalysis in zirconium/hafnium-oxo clusters for highly efficient amine oxidation

The performance applications (e.g., photocatalysis) of zirconium (Zr) and hafnium (Hf) based complexes are greatly hindered by the limited development of their structures and the relatively inert metal reactivity. In this work, we constructed two ultrastable Zr/Hf-based clusters (Zr9-TC4A and Hf9-TC4A) using hydrophobic 4-tert-butylthiacalix[4]arene (H4TC4A) ligands, in which unsaturated coordinated sulfur (S) atoms on the TC4A4- ligand can generate strong metal-ligand synergy with nearby active metal Zr/Hf sites. As a result, these two functionalized H4TC4A ligands modified Zr/Hf-oxo clusters, as catalysts for the amine oxidation reaction, exhibited excellent catalytic activity, achieving very high substrate conversion (>99%) and product selectivity (>90%). Combining comparative experiments and theoretical calculations, we found that these Zr/Hf-based cluster catalysts accomplish efficient amine oxidation reactions through synergistic effect between metals and ligands: (i) The photocatalytic benzylamine (BA) oxidation reaction was achieved by the synergistic effect of the dual active sites, in which, the naked S sites on the TC4A4- ligand oxidize the BA by photogenerated hole and oxygen molecules are reduced by photogenerated electrons on the metal active sites; (ii) in the aniline oxidation reaction, aniline was adsorbed by the bare S sites on ligands to be closer to metal active sites and then oxidized by the oxygen-containing radicals activated by the metal sites, thus completing the catalytic reaction under the synergistic catalytic effect of the proximity metal-ligand. In this work, the Zr/Hf-based complexes applied in the oxidation of organic amines have been realized using active S atom-directed metal-ligand synergistic catalysis and have demonstrated very high reactivity.

Three in One: Three Different Molybdates Trapped in a Thiacalix[4]arene Protected Ag72 Nanocluster for Structural Transformation and Photothermal Conversion

Polyoxometalates (POMs) represent crucial intermediates in the formation of insoluble metal oxides from soluble metal ions, however, the rapid hydrolysis-condensation kinetics of MoVI or WVI makes the direct characterization of coexisted molecular species in a given medium extremely difficult. Silver nanoclusters have shown versatile capacity to encapsulate diverse POMs, which provides an alternative scene to appreciate landscape of POMs in atomic precision. Here, we report a thiacalix[4]arene protected silver nanocluster (Ag72b) that simultaneously encapsulates three kinds of molybdates (MoO4 2- , Mo6 O22 8- and Mo7 O25 8- ) in situ transformed from classic Lindqvist Mo6 O19 2- , providing more deep understanding on the structural diversity and condensation growth route of POMs in solution. Ag72b is the first silver nanocluster trapping so many kinds of molybdates, which in turn exert collective template effect to aggregate silver atoms into a nanocluster. The post-reaction of Ag72b with AgOAc or PhCOOAg produces a discrete Ag24 nanocluster (Ag24a) or an Ag28 nanocluster based 1D chain structure (Ag28a), respectively. Moreover, the post-synthesized Ag28a can be utilized as potential ignition material for further application. This work not only provides an important model for unlocking dynamic features of POMs at atom-precise level but also pioneers a promising approach to synthesize silver nanoclusters from known to unknown.

Thiacalix[4]arene-Protected Silver Nanoclusters Encapsulating Different Two-Electron Superatom Oligomers

The subvalent silver kernel represents the nascent state of silver cluster formation, yet the growth mechanism has long been elusive. Herein, two silver nanoclusters (Ag30 and Ag34) coprotected by TC4A4- (H4TC4A = p-tert-butylthiacalix[4]arene) and TBPMT- (TBPMTH = 4-tert-butylbenzenemethanethiol) containing 6e and 4e silver kernels are synthesized and characterized. The trimer of the 2e superatom Ag14 kernel in Ag30 is built from a central Ag6 octahedron sandwiched by two orthogonally oriented Ag5 trigonal bipyramids through sharing vertexes, whereas a double-octahedral Ag10 kernel in Ag34 is a dimer of 2e superatoms. They manifest disparate polyhedron fusion growth patterns at the beginning of the silver cluster formation. Their excellent solution stabilities are contributed by the multisite and multidentate coordination fashion of TC4A4- and the special valence electron structures. This work demonstrates the precise control of silver kernel growth by the solvent strategy and lays a foundation for silver nanocluster application in photothermal conversion.

Stepwise assembly of thiacalix[4]arene-protected Ag/Ti bimetallic nanoclusters: accurate identification of catalytic Ag sites in CO2 electroreduction

The accurate identification of catalytic sites in heterogeneous catalysts poses a significant challenge due to the intricate nature of controlling interfacial chemistry at the molecular level. In this study, we introduce a novel strategy to address this issue by utilizing a thiacalix[4]arene (TC4A)-protected Ti-oxo core as a template for loading Ag1+ ions, leading to the successful synthesis of a unique Ag/Ti bimetallic nanocluster denoted as Ti8Ag8. This nanocluster exhibits multiple surface-exposed Ag sites and possesses a distinctive "core-shell" structure, consisting of a {Ti4@Ag8(TC4A)4} core housing a {Ti2O2@Ag4(TC4A)2} motif and two {Ti@Ag2(TC4A)} motifs. To enable a comprehensive analysis, we also prepared a Ti2Ag4 cluster with the same {Ti2O2@Ag4(TC4A)2} structure found within Ti8Ag8. The structural disparities between Ti8Ag8 and Ti2Ag4 provide an excellent platform for a comparison of catalytic activity at different Ag sites. Remarkably, Ti8Ag8 exhibits exceptional performance in the electroreduction of CO2 (eCO2RR), showcasing a CO faradaic efficiency (FECO) of 92.33% at -0.9 V vs. RHE, surpassing the FECO of Ti2Ag4 (69.87% at -0.9 V vs. RHE) by a significant margin. Through density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we unveil the catalytic mechanism and further discover that Ag active sites located at {Ti@Ag2(TC4A)} possess a higher εd value compared to those at {Ti2O2@Ag4(TC4A)2}, enhancing the stabilization of the *COOH intermediate during the eCO2RR. This study provides valuable insights into the accurate identification of catalytic sites in bimetallic nanoclusters and opens up promising avenues for efficient CO2 reduction catalyst design.

Thiacalix[4]arene-protected alkynyl Agn (n = 9, 18) nanoclusters: syntheses, structural characterizations, photocurrent responses and fluorescence properties

Two thiacalix[4]arene-protected silver(I) alkynyl nanoclusters, [Na2(H2O)2][Ag9(TC4A)(tBuCC)4(CH3OH)2(SbF6)0.5(OH)2.5]·3.5H2O·CH3OH (1, abbreviated as Ag9) and [Ag9(TC4A)(tBuCC)4(CF3COO)]2·4CH3OH (2, abbreviated as Ag18), were synthesized by the reaction of [tBuCCAg]n, p-tert-butylthiacalix[4]arene (H4TC4A), NaBH4, and AgSbF6 or CF3COOAg in the mixed solvent of methanol-trichloromethane-toluene under solvothermal conditions, respectively. Driven by SbF6- and CF3COO- with different coordination properties, the structural unit [Ag9(TC4A)(tBuCC)4]+ in both the compounds migrated in different modes, accompanied by distinct Ag⋯Ag distances. Ag9 and Ag18 exhibit similar UV-Vis absorption and diffuse reflection spectra along with contrary tendency between photocurrent responses and solid-state fluorescence. The solution stability of Ag9 and Ag18 was demonstrated by 1H NMR and MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry. The fluorescence responses of Ag9 and Ag18 towards different organic molecules were also investigated, which indicated that the polarity of solvent has a certain effect on the emission intensities of Ag9 and Ag18. This study provides a positive guide for the controlled synthesis and further study of the structure-activity relationship of thiacalix[4]arene-protected silver alkynyl nanoclusters.

Unveiling the Remarkable Stability and Catalytic Activity of a 6-Electron Superatomic Ag30 Nanocluster for CO2 Electroreduction

Nanocluster catalysts face a significant challenge in striking the right balance between stability and catalytic activity. Here, we present a thiacalix[4]arene-protected 6-electron [Ag30(TC4A)4(iPrS)8] nanocluster that demonstrates both high stability and catalytic activity. The Ag30 nanocluster features a metallic core, Ag104+, consisting of two Ag3 triangles and one Ag4 square, shielded by four {Ag5@(TC4A)4} staple motifs. Based on DFT calculations, the Ag104+ metallic kernel can be viewed as a trimer comprising 2-electron superatomic units, exhibiting a valence electron structure similar to that of the Be3 molecule. Notably, this is the first crystallographic evidence of the trimerization of 2-electron superatomic units. Ag30 can reduce CO2 into CO with a Faraday efficiency of 93.4% at -0.9 V versus RHE along with excellent long-term stability. Its catalytic activity is far superior to that of the chain-like AgI polymer ∞1{[H2Ag5(TC4A)(iPrS)3]} (∞1Agn), with the composition similar to Ag30. DFT calculations elucidated the catalytic mechanism to clarify the contrasting catalytic performances of the Ag30 and ∞1Agn polymers and disclosed that the intrinsically higher activity of Ag30 may be due to the greater stability of the dual adsorption mode of the *COOH intermediate on the metallic core.

A route to metalloligands consolidated silver nanoclusters by grafting thiacalix[4]arene onto polyoxovanadates

Metalloligands provide a potent strategy for manipulating the surface metal arrangements of metal nanoclusters, but their synthesis and subsequent installation onto metal nanoclusters remains a significant challenge. Herein, two atomically precise silver nanoclusters {Ag14[(TC4A)6(V9O16)](CyS)3} (Ag14) and {Ag43S[(TC4A)2(V4O9)]3(CyS)9(PhCOO)3Cl3(SO4)4(DMF)3·6DMF} (Ag43) are synthesized by controlling reaction temperature (H4TC4A = p-tert-butylthiacalix[4]arene). Interestingly, the 3D scaffold-like [(TC4A)6(V9O16)]11- metalloligand in Ag14 and 1D arcuate [(TC4A)2(V4O9)]6- metalloligand in Ag43 exhibit a dual role that is the internal polyoxovanadates as anion template and the surface TC4A4- as the passivating agent. Furthermore, the thermal-induced structure transformation between Ag14 and Ag43 is achieved based on the temperature-dependent assembly process. Ag14 shows superior photothermal conversion performance than Ag43 in solid state indicating its potential for remote laser ignition. Here, we show the potential of two thiacalix[4]arene modified polyoxovanadates metalloligands in the assembly of metal nanoclusters and provide a cornerstone for the remote laser ignition applications of silver nanoclusters.

Atomically accurate structural tailoring of thiacalix[4]arene-protected copper(II)-based metallamacrocycles

Accurate manipulation of ligands at specific sites in robust clusters is attractive but difficult, especially for those ligands that coordinate in intricate binding patterns. By linking the shuttlecock-like {Cu₄(μ₄-Cl)TC4A} motif and the phenylphosphate (PhPO₃^2-) ligand, we elaborately design and synthesize two Cu(II)-thiacalix[4]arene metallamacrocycles (MMCs), namely Cu₁₂L₃ and Cu₁₆L₄, which have regular triangular and quadrilateral topologies, respectively. While keeping the core intact, the Cl^- and PhPO₃^2- in those two MMCs, which coordinated in a μ₄-bridging fashion, can be accurately substituted with salicylate ligands. Theoretical calculations have been carried out to reveal the effect of ligand tailoring on the electronic structure of clusters. Structural regulation can affect the catalytic activity of these clusters, which has been verified by using the clusters as catalysts for selective sulfide oxidation.

Monocarboxylate-protected two-electron superatomic silver nanoclusters with high photothermal conversion performance

The first series of monocarboxylate-protected superatomic silver nanoclusters was synthesized and fully characterized by X-ray diffraction, fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). Specifically, compounds [Ag₁₆(L)₈(9-AnCO₂)₁₂]²⁺ (L = Ph₃P (I), (4-ClPh)₃P (II), (2-furyl)₃P (III), and Ph₃As (IV)) were prepared by a solvent-thermal method under alkaline conditions. These clusters exhibit a similar unprecedented structure containing a [Ag₈@Ag₈]⁶⁺ metal kernel, of which the 2-electron superatomic [Ag₈]⁶⁺ inner core shows a flattened and puckered hexagonal bipyramid of S₆ symmetry. Density functional theory calculations provide a rationalization of the structure and stability of these 2-electron superatoms. Results indicate that the 2 superatomic electrons occupy a superatomic molecular orbital 1S that has a substantial localization on the top and bottom vertices of the bipyramid. The π systems of the anthracenyl groups, as well as the 1S HOMO, are significantly involved in the optical and photothermal behavior of the clusters. The four characterized nanoclusters show high photothermal conversion performance in sunlight. These results show that the unprecedented use of mono-carboxylates in the stabilization of Ag nanoclusters is possible, opening the door for the introduction of various functional groups on their cluster surface.

Au10Ag17(TPP)10(SR)6Cl5 nanocluster: structure, transformation and the origin of its photoluminescence

Nanocluster photoluminescence (PL) has important practical applications and its rationalization is therefore of significant interest. Here, we report the synthesis, structure determination and photoluminescence of Au₁₀Ag₁₇(TPP)₁₀(SR)₆Cl₅ (TPP = triphenylphosphine, SR = 3, 5-bis(trifluoromethyl)thiophenol, denoted as Au10Ag17). Au10Ag17 exhibited a low photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY) of 2.8%, which could be increased 15-fold by removing the two terminal silver atoms to give Ag_xAu_25-x(SR)₅(TPP)₁₀Cl₂²⁺ (x = 11-13, SR = 2-phenylethylmercaptan, abbrev. Au12Ag13). The discovery of such a PL switch constitutes an interesting opportunity to further understand the origin of fluorescence in nanoclusters.

Regulating the assembly and expansion of the silver cluster from the Ag37 to Ag46 nanowheel driven by heteroanions

Precise control over the shape and size of metal nanoclusters through anion template-driven self-assembly is one of the key scientific goals in the nanocluster community, however, it is still not understood comprehensively. In this work, we report the controllable synthesis and atomically precise structures of silver nanowheels Ag37 and Ag46, using homo (Cl^- ions) and heteroanion (Cl^- and CrO₄ ^2- ions) template strategies, along with macrocyclic p-phenyl-thiacalix[4]arene and small ⁱPrS^- ligands. Structural analyses revealed that in Ag37, Cl^- ions serve as both local and global templates, whereas CrO₄ ^2- ions function as local and Cl^- ions as global templates in Ag46, resulting in a pentagonal nanowheel (Ag37) and a hexagonal (Ag46) nanowheel. The larger ionic size and more negative charges of CrO₄ ^2- ions than Cl^- ions offer more coordination sites for the silver atoms and are believed to be the key factors that drive the nanowheel core to expand significantly. Also, by taking advantage of the deep cavity of thiacalix[4]arene with an extended phenyl group, Ag46 has been used as a host material for dye adsorption depending on the charge and size of organic dyes. The successful use of heteroanions to control the expansion of well-defined silver nanowheels fills the knowledge gap in understanding the directing role of heteroanions in dictating the shape and size of nanoclusters at the atomic level.

Polymolybdate-guided assembly of a thiacalix[4]arene-protected Ag nanocluster for electrocatalytic CO2 reduction

A large polymolybdate-templated {Ag49Mo16} cluster protected by six thiacalix[4]arene (TC4A) molecules was synthesized by a one-pot solvothermal reaction. Structural analysis shows that the {Ag49Mo16} is assembled by inserting a [Mo₆O₂₂]^8- cluster into a [Ag₄₉Mo₁₀@(TC4A)₆] cage, representing the first polyoxometalate-templated Ag cluster protected by calixarene macrocyclic ligands. The solution stability and photoelectric properties of {Ag49Mo16} are discussed. Furthermore, this POM-templated Ag nanocluster realized electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction applications, and 44.75% CO faradaic efficiency (FE) was obtained at a voltage of -0.8 V (vs. RHE).

Synthesis and Study of Photothermal Properties of a Mixed-Valence Nanocluster CuI/CuII with Strong near-Infrared Optical Absorption Supported by 4-tert-Butylcalix[4]arene Ligand

The first mixed-valence nanocluster Cu^I/Cu^II with the highest percentage of Cu^II ions was synthesized by using 4-tert-butylcalix[4]arene (Calix4), with the formula DMF₂⊂[(CO₃)^2-@Cu^II₆Cu^I₃(Calix4)₃Cl₂(DMF)₅(H₃O)]•DMF (1), as a photothermal nanocluster. Its structure was characterized using single-crystal X-ray diffraction, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, and powder X-ray diffraction. In addition, the charge state and chemical composition of the nanocluster were determined using electrospray ionization spectrometry and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) spectrum. The results of the XPS and X-ray crystallography revealed that there are two independent Cu^II and Cu^I centers in nanocluster 1 with the relative abundances of 66.6 and 33.3% for Cu^II and Cu^I, respectively. The nanocluster contains three four-coordinated Cu^I ions with a square-planar geometry and six five-coordinated Cu^II ions with a square pyramid geometry. The nanocluster shows strong near-infrared optical absorption in the solid state and excellent photothermal conversion ability (the equilibrium temperature ∼78.2 °C) with the light absorption centers in 286-917 nm over previous reported pentanucleus Cu^I₄Cu^II clusters and Cu^II compounds.

Structural Engineering toward Gold Nanocluster Catalysis

Atomically precise gold nanoclusters provide great opportunities to explore the relationship between the structure and properties of nanogold catalysts. A nanocluster consists of a metal core and a surface ligand shell, and both the core and shell have significant effects on the catalytic properties. Thanks to their precise structures, the active metal site of the clusters can be readily identified and the effects of ligands on catalysis can be disclosed. In this Minireview, we summarize recent advances in catalytic research of gold nanoclusters, emphasizing four strategies for constructing open metal sites, including by post-treatment, the bulky ligands strategy, the surface geometric mismatch method, and heteroatom doping procedures. We also discuss the effects of ligands on the catalytic activity, selectivity, and stability of gold cluster catalysts. Finally, we present future challenges relating to gold cluster catalysis.

Solvent-Controlled Condensation of [Mo2 O5 (PTC4A)2 ]6- Metalloligand in Stepwise Assembly of Hexagonal and Rectangular Ag18 Nanoclusters

Stepwise assembly starting from a preassembled metalloligand is a promising approach to obtain otherwise unattainable silver nanoclusters, but hard to be intrinsically identified due to the lack of convincing evidence to justify such a process. Herein, hexagonal and rectangular Ag₁₈ nanoclusters are constructed from the [Mo₂ O₅ (PTC4A)₂ ]^6- (H₄ PTC4A=p-phenyl-thiacalix[4]arene) metalloligand through stepwise assembly. The formation of the metalloligand is confirmed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, then assembled with silver ions to form two geometrically different Ag₁₈ nanoclusters in different solvents. The cyclization from the metalloligand to [(Mo₂ O₅ PTC4A)₆ ]^12- can be realized without alcohols and otherwise blocked by them. The installation of this metalloligand not only provides comprehensive understanding of how the solvents regulate the silver nanocluster structures, but also brings new insights for the controllable ligand metallization and subsequent condensation.

Ligand Engineering toward the Trade-Off between Stability and Activity in Cluster Catalysis

We report the structures, stability and catalysis properties of two Ag₂₁ nanoclusters, namely [Ag₂₁ (H₂ BTCA)₃ (O₂ PPh₂ )₆ ]SbF₆ (1) and [Ag₂₁ (C≡CC₆ H₃ -3,5-R₂ )₆ (O₂ PPh₂ )₁₀ ]SbF₆ (2) (H₄ BTCA=p-tert-butylthiacalix[4]arene, R=OMe). Both Ag₂₁ structures possess an identical icosahedral kernel that is surrounded by eight peripheral Ag atoms. Single-crystal structural analysis and ESI-MS revealed that 1 is an 8-electron cluster and 2 has four free electrons. Theoretical results show that the P-symmetry orbitals are found as HOMO-1 and HOMO states in 1, and the frontier unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMO, LUMO+1 and LUMO+2) show D-character, indicating 1 is a superatomic cluster with an electronically closed shell 1S² 1P⁶ , while 2 has an incomplete shell configuration 1S² 1P² . These two Ag₂₁ clusters show superior stability under ambient conditions, and 1 is robust even at 90 °C in toluene and under oxidative conditions (30 % H₂ O₂ ). Significantly, 2 exhibits much higher activity than 1 as catalyst in the reduction of 4-nitrophenol. This work demonstrates that ligands can influence the electronic structures of silver clusters, and further affect their stability and catalytic performance.

Doping effect on the structure and properties of eight-electron silver nanoclusters

The bimetallic M₂₀ and M₂₁ compounds, {[Cu₃Ag₁₇{S₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₁₂]_0.5 [Cu₄Ag₁₆{S₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₁₂]_0.5} ({[1a]_0.5[1b]_0.5}) and [Cu₄Ag₁₇{S₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₁₂](PF₆) (2), have been structurally characterized, in which the Cu(I) ions are randomly distributed on the eight outer positions capping the eight-electron [Ag₁₃]⁵⁺ core. DFT calculations show that the statistical disorder results from the nearly neutral preference of copper to occupy any of the eight outer positions. Surprisingly, the UV-Vis absorption spectra of the M₂₀ and M₂₁ bimetallic nanoclusters display an almost identical absorption profile as that of their homometallic [Ag₂₀{S₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₁₂] and [Ag₂₁{S₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₁₂]⁺ relatives. This is rationalized by TD-DFT calculations, which show that the frontier orbitals of such eight-electron alloys are largely independent from the nature of the capping metal ions. A blue-shifted absorption is observed upon replacing by Au the central Ag atom in 2, forming the trimetallic compound [Cu₄AuAg₁₆{S₂P(OⁱPr)₂}₁₂](PF₆) (3).

Toward Controlling the Electronic Structures of Chemically Modified Superatoms of Gold and Silver

Atomically precise gold/silver clusters protected by organic ligands L, [(Au/Ag)_x L_y ]^z , have gained increasing interest as building units of functional materials because of their novel photophysical and physicochemical properties. The properties of [(Au/Ag)_x L_y ]^z are intimately associated with the quantized electronic structures of the metallic cores, which can be viewed as superatoms from the analogy of naked Au/Ag clusters. Thus, establishment of the correlation between the geometric and electronic structures of the superatomic cores is crucial for rational design and improvement of the properties of [(Au/Ag)_x L_y ]^z . This review article aims to provide a qualitative understanding on how the electronic structures of [(Au/Ag)_x L_y ]^z are affected by geometric structures of the superatomic cores with a focus on three factors: size, shape, and composition, on the basis of single-crystal X-ray diffraction data. The knowledge accumulated here will constitute a basis for the development of ligand-protected Au/Ag clusters as new artificial elements on a nanometer scale.

The [Ag25Cu4H8Br6(CCPh)12(PPh3)12]3+ : Ag13H8 silver hydride core protected by [CuAg3(CCPh)3(PPh3)3]+ motifs

Copper alkynyl complexes [CuAg3(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CAr)3(PPh3)3]+ (Ar = Ph, p-C6H4Me), in which three Ag(PPh3) units are bound among three C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CAr arms of trigonal-planar [Cu(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CAr)3]2-, were selected as a protecting unit to cover the metal core of an atomically precise core-shell-type cluster. First, the formation of the protecting unit through the reaction of Cu(NCMe)4(PF6) with Ag(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CAr) and PPh3 in a 1 : 3 : 3 ratio was confirmed. The reaction gave dimeric [CuAg3(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CAr)3(PPh3)3]22+, in which the two planar [CuAg3(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CAr)3(PPh3)3]+ units were stacked. Next, core-shell-type clusters were synthesized by adding NaBH4 and Et4NX (X = Cl, Br) to a solution similar to that used to prepare the protecting unit. The trigonal-planar protecting units nicely formed core-shell-type Ag nanoclusters formulated as [Ag13H8X6{CuAg3(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CAr)3(PPh3)3}4]3+ (X = Cl, Ar = p-C6H4Me; X = Br, Ar = p-C6H4Me; X = Br, Ar = Ph). Their crystal structures revealed that the four [CuAg3(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CAr)3(PPh3)3]+ units are linked by six halogen ions to form a tetrahedral cage that accommodates a polyhydride-Ag cluster formulated as Ag13H85+. As a concrete proof of the existence of the polyhydride, deuterated analogs Ag13D85+ were synthesized and subsequently characterized by high-resolution electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry measurements.

Thiacalix[4]arene-supported molecular clusters for catalytic applications

Thiacalixarenes are intriguing ligands that have attracted sustained interest because of their changeable conformations and excellent coordination ability. Thiacalix[4]arene analogues, which can bind metal ions to form modular second building units, are capable of constructing molecular-based functional materials with defined structures and various applications via directional coordination assembly. Due to rich metal-sulfur bonds, thiacalix[4]arene-based molecular clusters also exhibit diverse properties compared to other clusters. In particular, the combination of thiacalixarenes with currently popular molecular architectures, such as high-nuclearity clusters and coordination cages, has shown special catalytic performances. In this perspective, the latest advances in catalytic applications of thiacalix[4]arene-based molecular clusters, including molecular clusters themselves as catalysts and coordination cages serving as reaction vessels encapsulating metal nano-components for catalysis, are highlighted.

First-principles exploration of the versatile configurations at an alkynyl-protected coinage metal(111) interface

Alkynyl groups (R-C[triple bond, length as m-dash]C-) have attracted intense interest recently as alternative ligands to thiolates to protect atomically precise coinage metal nanoclusters, and more than two dozen compositions have been structurally resolved. However, structure determinations indicated that the interface shows strong metal sensitivity, where a staple motif is the common structural feature at the interface of Au-alkynyl nanoclusters, while the bridging motif dominates at the RC[triple bond, length as m-dash]C-/Ag and RC[triple bond, length as m-dash]C-/Cu interface. To understand their interfacial differences, we employed density functional theory (DFT) calculations to examine the versatile interfacial structures between CH3C[triple bond, length as m-dash]C- and the coinage metal surface; both the (111) surface as well as a surface with a metal adatom are investigated. We find that the alkynyl/gold(111) interface does prefer to form the staple motifs, and a linear flat-lying staple motif is preferred. The adatom occupies the bridge position and two CH3C[triple bond, length as m-dash]C- ligands lie diagonally at the fcc hollow sites with the C[triple bond, length as m-dash]C bond interacting with the surface Au by both σ- and π-coordination modes. In contrast, the bridging motif is energetically more favored on Ag(111) and Cu(111). The alkynyl carbons form strong σ, π- or σ-only bonds with the surface Ag/Cu, forming μ3-bridge coordination over the fcc hollow site. The binding strengths have the order of Cu(111) > Ag(111) > Au(111). The difference in structural preference is attributed to the intrinsic metal attributes with the different gaps of energetic penalty for surface energy, adatom creation and vacancy formation. The other two reasons are the differences of alkynyl-metal bond character and vdW interaction. We further show that this structure preference is also the preferred bonding mode of CH3C[triple bond, length as m-dash]C- on M55 clusters and the CH3S-/M(111) interface. Our insights greatly facilitate the structural elucidation and provide useful guidelines for future structure predictions in alkynyl-protected metal nanosystems.

Assembly of {Co14} nanoclusters from adenine-modified Co4-thiacalix[4]arene units

An adenine-modified Co₄-thiacalix[4]arene unit can serve as a second building unit for fabrication of three Co₁₄ clusters with different structures.

Atomically precise alloy nanoclusters: syntheses, structures, and properties

Metal nanoclusters fill the gap between discrete atoms and plasmonic nanoparticles, providing unique opportunities for investigating the quantum effects and precise structure-property correlations at the atomic level. As a versatile strategy, alloying can largely improve the physicochemical performances compared to the corresponding homo-metal nanoclusters, and thus benefit the applications of such nanomaterials. In this review, we highlight the achievements of atomically precise alloy nanoclusters, and summarize the alloying principles and fundamentals, including the synthetic methods, site-preferences for different heteroatoms in the templates, and alloying-induced structure and property changes. First, based on various Au or Ag nanocluster templates, heteroatom doping modes are presented. The templates with electronic shell-closing configurations tend to maintain their structures during doping, while the others may undergo transformation and give rise to alloy nanoclusters with new structures. Second, alloy nanoclusters of specific magic sizes are reviewed. The arrangement of different atoms is related to the symmetry of the structures; that is, different atoms are symmetrically located in the nanoclusters of smaller sizes, and evolve into shell-by-shell structures at larger sizes. Then, we elaborate on the alloying effects in terms of optical, electrochemical, electroluminescent, magnetic and chiral properties, as well as the stability and reactivity via comparisons between the doped nanoclusters and their homo-metal counterparts. For example, central heteroatom-induced photoluminescence enhancement is emphasized. The applications of alloy nanoclusters in catalysis, chemical sensing, bio-labeling, and other fields are further discussed. Finally, we provide perspectives on existing issues and future efforts. Overall, this review provides a comprehensive synthetic toolbox and controllable doping modes so as to achieve more alloy nanoclusters with customized compositions, structures, and properties for applications. This review is based on publications available up to February 2020.

Ligand accommodation causes the anti-centrosymmetric structure of Au13Cu4 clusters with near-infrared emission

We synthesized an [Au₁₃Cu₄(PPh₃)₄(SPy)₈]⁺ nanocluster co-capped by phosphine and thiolate ligands. Interestingly, this Au₁₃Cu₄ cluster corresponds to an anti-centrosymmetric structure with the four copper atoms coordinated to the mixed ligands on the same side of the Au₁₃ icosahedron, which is in sharp contrast to the [Au₁₃Cu₄(PPh₂Py)₄(SPhtBu)₈]⁺ and [Au₁₃Cu₂(PPh₃)₆(SPy)₆]⁺ clusters which possess highly symmetric structures with well-separated Cu adatoms. Both [Au₁₃Cu₄(PPh₃)₄(SPy)₈]⁺ and [Au₁₃Cu₂(PPh₃)₆(SPy)₆]⁺ clusters correspond to 8 valence electron superatoms with large HOMO-LUMO gaps, respectively. The difference in structure is rooted in the nature of the mixed ligands, with the bidentate SPy binding strongly to Cu on both binding sites (-N-Cu and Au-SR-Cu) leading to the co-linking of adjacent Cu atoms, while the bidentate PPh₂Py binds Cu on one site and Au on the other giving rise to a separation of the Cu atoms even in the presence of relatively higher monomer concentration. Both [Au₁₃Cu₄(PPh₃)₄(SPy)₈]⁺ and [Au₁₃Cu₂(PPh₃)₆(SPy)₆]⁺ display emissions in the near-IR regions. TD-DFT calculations reproduce the spectroscopic results with specified excited states, shedding light on the geometric and electronic behaviors of the ligand-protected Au₁₃M_x clusters.

Isomerization-induced enhancement of luminescence in Au28(SR)20 nanoclusters

Understanding the origin and structural basis of the photoluminescence (PL) phenomenon in thiolate-protected metal nanoclusters is of paramount importance for both fundamental science and practical applications. It remains a major challenge to correlate the PL properties with the atomic-level structure due to the complex interplay of the metal core (i.e. the inner kernel) and the exterior shell (i.e. surface Au(i)-thiolate staple motifs). Decoupling these two intertwined structural factors is critical in order to understand the PL origin. Herein, we utilize two Au₂₈(SR)₂₀ nanoclusters with different –R groups, which possess the same core but different shell structures and thus provide an ideal system for the PL study. We discover that the Au₂₈(CHT)₂₀ (CHT: cyclohexanethiolate) nanocluster exhibits a more than 15-fold higher PL quantum yield than the Au₂₈(TBBT)₂₀ nanocluster (TBBT: p-tert-butylbenzenethiolate). Such an enhancement is found to originate from the different structural arrangement of the staple motifs in the shell, which modifies the electron relaxation dynamics in the inner core to different extents for the two nanoclusters. The emergence of a long PL lifetime component in the more emissive Au₂₈(CHT)₂₀ nanocluster reveals that its PL is enhanced by suppressing the nonradiative pathway. The presence of long, interlocked staple motifs is further identified as a key structural parameter that favors the luminescence. Overall, this work offers structural insights into the PL origin in Au₂₈(SR)₂₀ nanoclusters and provides some guidelines for designing luminescent metal nanoclusters for sensing and optoelectronic applications.

Two Au₂₈(SR)₂₀ nanoclusters with an identical core but different shells exhibit a ∼15-fold difference in photoluminescence.

New protective ligands for atomically precise silver nanoclusters

Atomically precise silver nanoclusters (NCs) have emerged as a hot topic attracting immense research interest. Protecting ligands are needed for direct capping on cluster surfaces in order to prevent aggregation and to stabilize NCs. It has been demonstrated that protective ligands are critical to determining the sizes, structures and properties of silver NCs. The past decades have witnessed conventionally used organic ligands (thiolates/selenols, phosphines and alkynyls) and inorganic ligands (chalcogens and halogens) being extensively used to passivate NC surfaces. However, only in the most recent years have new-type protecting ligands beyond the conventional ones begun to be introduced in the protecting sphere of new functional silver NCs. The present Frontier article covers the most recent examples of some new protective agents for well-defined silver NCs. We describe four classes of novel silver NCs stabilized by newly-developed surface ligands, namely, nitrogen-donor organic ligands, oxygen-donor inorganic ligands, metalloligands and macrocyclic hosts, paying attention to the synthesis, structures and properties of these silver NCs. This Frontier article will hopefully attract more cluster scientists to explore more freshly ligated atomically precise silver NCs with novel structures and properties in the years ahead. The literature survey in this review is based on publications up to February 2020. Some suggestions for future directions in this field are also given.

A one-dimensional infinite silver alkynyl assembly [Ag8(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]C t Bu)5(CF3COO)3(CH3CN)] n : synthesis, crystal structure and properties

A high-yield silver alkynyl assembly [Ag8(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]C t Bu)5(CF3COO)3(CH3CN)] n (1) constructed from [AgC[triple bond, length as m-dash]C t Bu] n ligand, CF3COOAg and CH3CN auxiliary ligands with a one-dimensional infinite chain structure has been obtained in one pot. Compound 1 has been well-defined and characterized. The photocurrent properties and the temperature-sensitive luminescent properties of 1 have been investigated.

Isomerization in Alkynyl-Protected Gold Nanoclusters

We report the controlled synthesis and structures of two isomeric gold nanoclusters, whose compositions are determined to be Au₂₃(C≡CBu^t)₁₅ (denoted as Au₂₃-1 and Au₂₃-2) by single-crystal X-ray diffraction and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry. This is the first time isomerism is discovered in alkynyl-protected gold nanoclusters. The metal-to-ligand ratios in these two clusters are different from known Au_n(SR)_m systems and have not been observed in the Au_x(C≡CPh)_y family. This pair of isomers exhibits different optical properties, although they have similar structures and identical components. For both Au₂₃ clusters, time-dependent density functional theory calculations revealed the frontier orbitals highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO)-1, HOMO, and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) are mainly constructed from the Au₁₅ kernel and V-shaped alkynyl-gold motifs. The HOMO → LUMO transition of Au₂₃-1 is optically forbidden, whereas it is allowed in Au₂₃-2. It is also found that Au₂₃-2 cluster can be transformed to Au₂₃-1 spontaneously under ambient conditions. This work offers further insight into the synthesis and isomerism of all-alkynyl-protected gold nanoclusters and will stimulate more investigation of isomeric metal nanoclusters.

A hierarchically assembled 88-nuclei silver-thiacalix[4]arene nanocluster

Thiacalix[4]arenes as a family of promising ligands have been widely used to construct polynuclear metal clusters, but scarcely employed in silver nanoclusters. Herein, an anion-templated Ag₈₈ nanocluster (SD/Ag88a) built from p-tert-butylthiacalix[4]arene (H₄TC4A) is reported. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction reveals that C₄-symmetric SD/Ag88a resembles a metal-organic super calix comprised of eight TC4A⁴⁻ as walls and 88 silver atoms as base, which can be deconstructed to eight [CrO₄@Ag₁₁(TC4A)(EtS)₄(OAc)] secondary building units arranged in an annulus encircling a CrO₄²⁻ in the center. Local and global anion template effects from chromates are individually manifested in SD/Ag88a. The solution stability and hierarchical assembly mechanism of SD/Ag88a are studied by using electrospray mass spectrometry. The Ag₈₈ nanocluster represents the highest nuclearity metal cluster capped by TC4A⁴⁻. This work not only exemplify the specific macrocyclic effects of TC4A⁴⁻ in the construction of silver nanocluster but also realize the shape heredity of TC4A⁴⁻ to overall silver super calix.

The assembly of giant silver clusters by using macrocylic multidentate ligand remains a challenge. Here, the authors synthesize a chromate-templated 88-nuclei silver super calix and reveal the role of anion templating effects and a hierarchical assembly mechanism.

A rod-like hexanuclear nickel cluster based on a bi(pyrazole-alcohol) ligand: structure, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, magnetism and photocurrent response

An unusual one-dimensional zig-zag hexanuclear Ni(ii) cluster has been easily and successfully constructed using a designed multidentate pyrazole-alcohol ligand.