Hydrogen Bonds Are Never of an "Anti-electrostatic" Nature: A Brief Tour of a Misleading Nomenclature

A large amount of scientific works have contributed through the years to rigorously reflect the different forces leading to the formation of hydrogen bonds, the electrostatic and polarization ones being the most important among them. However, we have witnessed lately with the emergence of a new terminology, anti-electrostatic hydrogen bonds (AEHBs), that seems to contradict this reality. This nomenclature is used in the literature to describe hydrogen bonds between equally charged systems to justify the existence of these species, despite numerous proofs showing that AEHBs are, as any other hydrogen bond between neutral species, mostly due to electrostatic forces. In this Viewpoint, we summarize the state of the art regarding this issue, try to explain why this terminology is very misleading, and strongly recommend avoiding its use based on the hydrogen bond physical grounds.

Competition between In-Plane vs Above-Plane Configurations of Water with Aromatic Molecules: Non-Covalent Interactions in 1,4-Naphthoquinone-(H2O)1-3 Complexes

Non-covalent interactions between aromatic molecules and water are fundamental in many chemical and biological processes, and their accurate description is essential to understand molecular relative configurations. Here we present the rotational spectroscopy study of the water complexes of the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon 1,4-naphthoquinone (1,4-NQ). In 1,4-NQ-(H₂O)_1,2, water molecules bind through O-H···O and C-H···O hydrogen bonds and are located on the plane of 1,4-NQ. For 1,4-NQ-(H₂O)₃, in-plane and above-plane water configurations are observed exhibiting O-H···O, C-H···O, and lone pair···π-hole interactions. The observation of different water arrangements for 1,4-NQ-(H₂O)₃ allows benchmarking theoretical methods and shows that they have great difficulty in predicting energy orderings due to the strong competition of C-H···O binding with π and π-hole interactions. This study provides important insight into water interactions with aromatic systems and the challenges in their modeling.

Terpene dispersion energy donor ligands in borane complexes

Structural characterization of the complex [B(β-pinane)₃] (1) reveals non-covalent H⋯H contacts that are consistent with the generation of London dispersion energies involving the β-pinane ligand frameworks. The homolytic fragmentations of 1, and camphane and sabinane analogues ([B(camphane)₃] (2) and [B(sabinane)₃] (3)) were studied computationally. Isodesmic exchange results showed that London dispersion interactions are highly dependent on the terpene's stereochemistry, with the β-pinane framework providing the greatest dispersion free energy (ΔG = -7.9 kcal mol^-1) with Grimme's dispersion correction (D3BJ) employed. PMe₃ was used to coordinate to [B(β-pinane)₃], giving the complex [Me₃P-B(β-pinane)₃] (4), which displayed a dynamic coordination equilibrium in solution. The association process was found to be slightly endergonic at 302 K (ΔG = +0.29 kcal mol^-1).

Rotational Spectrum and Conformational Analysis of Perillartine: Insights into the Structure-Sweetness Relationship

We used high-resolution rotational spectroscopy coupled to a laser ablation source to study the conformational panorama of perillartine, a solid synthetic sweetener. Four conformers were identified under the isolation conditions of the supersonic expansion, showing that all of them present an E configuration of the C=N group with respect to the double bond of the ring. The observed structures were verified against Shallenberger–Acree–Kier’s sweetness theory to shed light on the structure–sweetness relationship for this particular oxime, highlighting a deluge of possibilities to bind the receptor.

Interactions of limonene with the water dimer

The interactions of limonene with the water dimer have been characterised through the identification of seven different isomers.

London Dispersion Helps Refine Steric A-Values: Dispersion Energy Donor Scales

We suggest a scale of dispersion energy donors (DEDs) that allows for direct comparisons with steric effects. This scale is based on the classic A-values and allows groups to reorient to minimize strain, thereby providing an advantage over raw group polarizabilities. The A-value can no longer be considered purely a steric factor. Even for groups that do not participate in charge transfer or electrostatic interactions, the A-value includes Pauli repulsion (steric hindrance) and attractive London dispersion (LD) interactions. Although the common assumption is that, at the distances found in monosubstituted cyclohexanes, steric demands are the key factors influencing conformer preferences, we show in this computational study that there is a non-negligible LD part. We use this system to build a DED scale and a complementary steric scale. These scales are quantitatively comparable, as they are based on the same system, and allow for comparison of the two competing interactions in experimentally relevant settings. In addition, we show that LD interactions can be used to explain puzzling data regarding relative group sizes.

A rotational spectroscopic and ab initio study of cis- and trans-(-)-carveol: further insights into conformational dynamics in monoterpenes and monoterpenoids

Broadband rotational spectra of cis- and trans-(-)-carveol were recorded using a chirped pulse Fourier transform microwave spectrometer in the 2-6 GHz region. To aid in spectroscopic assignments a theoretical conformational search was carried out using a combination of a two dimensional potential energy scan, scanning over the isopropenyl and hydroxyl groups torsional angles, and the Conformer-Rotamer Ensemble Sampling Tool. The theoretical results yielded a total of 23 conformers for the trans- and 19 for the cis-conformer. Utilizing these results, a total of five conformers could be assigned in the spectra, two for trans- and three for cis-(-)-carveol. In both conformers of trans-carveol, the isopropenyl group is in an equatorial position and adopts the gauche- conformation in one and the the antiperiplanar conformation in the other, with the hydroxyl group in the axial position and adopting the antiperiplanar conformation in both. For cis-carveol the analogous conformers were found but with the hydroxyl in a equatorial position, in addition to an axial isopropenyl conformer. To interpret the experimental intensity patterns and examine conformational cooling effects, transition states were identified using the Synchronous Transit Quasi-Newton method. We found that most of the higher energy conformers cool out to the five experimentally observed ones and the others are too high in energy to be sufficiently populated in the molecular expansion for an experimental observation. To investigate the interesting preference for the axial position of the isopropenyl group in cis-(-)-carveol, which has not been seen before in monoterpenoids, non-covalent interactions and quantum theory of atoms-in-molecules analyses were carried out. These analyses reveal a hydrogen bonding interaction between the hydroxyl group and the isopropenyl π-system. A natural bond orbital analysis of the hydrogen bond allowed us to decompose the interaction into its constituent natural bond orbitals, and to quantify its strength. Although relatively weak, the hydrogen bond tips the balance towards the axial position of the isopropenyl group.

London Dispersion Helps Refine Steric A-Values: The Halogens

Halogens are rarely considered as dispersion energy donors for organic reaction design. Here, we re-examine one of the textbook examples for assessing steric hindrance, the A-value, and demonstrate that even in this system, halogens cannot be treated solely as classic repulsive hard spheres. A significant part of the steric demand of the halogens is compensated by attractive London dispersion (LD) interactions, explaining the experimental lack of a clear trend when going down the halogens' row. Beyond monohalogenated cyclohexanes, dihalo- and perhalocyclohexanes also show significant LD interactions. We also explored several other small organic systems containing halogens. Our findings show that organic chemists should treat halogens as possible sources of LD interactions in reaction design, as these atoms can change the landscape of the potential energy surface and reverse trends of conformer stabilities and reaction selectivities.

New Insights into Secondary Organic Aerosol Formation: Water Binding to Limonene

Limonene is an abundant monoterpene in the atmosphere and one of the main precursors of secondary organic aerosol. Understanding its interactions with atmospheric molecules is crucial to explain aerosol formation and the various products obtained from competing reaction pathways. Here, using broadband rotational spectroscopy in combination with computational calculations, we show that limonene effectively interacts with water, forming a variety of complexes. Seven different isomers of limonene-H₂O, where water and limonene are connected by O-H···π and C-H···O interactions, have been unambiguously identified. Water has been found to preferentially bind to the endocyclic double bond of limonene. Our findings demonstrate a striking ability of water to attach to limonene and enrich our knowledge on the possible interactions of limonene in the atmosphere.

Quantifying soft degrees of freedom in volatile organic compounds: insight from quantum chemistry and focused single molecule experiments

Sampling of the vast conformational landscape of organic compounds remains a challenging task in computational chemistry, especially when it comes to the characterization of soft-degrees of freedom and relatively small energy barriers between different local minima. Therefore, studying the intrinsic properties of isolated molecules using focused experiments such as high-resolution molecular spectroscopy provides a powerful approach to validate and improve available quantum chemical methods. Here, we report on the most abundant gas-phase structure of ethyl 2-methyl pentanoate under molecular jet conditions, which we used to benchmark several exchange-correlation functionals and ab initio methods at the quantum chemical level. The observed conformer of ethyl 2-methyl pentanoate in the gas-phase is of C1 symmetry and exhibits a large amplitude motion around the C-C bond in proximity to the carbonyl moiety, which, unlike in the case of its structural isomer ethyl 2-ethyl butyrate, is very sensitive to the applied quantum chemical method and basis set. Depending on the applied quantum chemical method, the dihedral angle of the lowest energy conformer is optimized to absolute values of ±20°. This is far above the usual convergence error of the theoretical methods and has a tremendous impact on the rotational constants of this conformer, which complicates the prediction of rotational spectra and the assignment of experimental data. We show that the loss of symmetry in the aliphatic chain bound to the carboxylic moiety of ethyl esters results in a shift of the dihedral angle value due to a flat potential well around the corresponding C-C bond. Our benchmark calculations further indicate the potential relevance of the wB97X-D functional for this ethyl pentanoate and other related ethyl esters.

Binding Site Switch by Dispersion Interactions: Rotational Signatures of Fenchone-Phenol and Fenchone-Benzene Complexes

Non-covalent interactions between molecules determine molecular recognition and the outcome of chemical and biological processes. Characterising how non-covalent interactions influence binding preferences is of crucial importance in advancing our understanding of these events. Here, we analyse the interactions involved in smell and specifically the effect of changing the balance between hydrogen-bonding and dispersion interactions by examining the complexes of the common odorant fenchone with phenol and benzene, mimics of tyrosine and phenylalanine residues, respectively. Using rotational spectroscopy and quantum chemistry, two isomers of each complex have been identified. Our results show that the increased weight of dispersion interactions in these complexes changes the preferred binding site in fenchone and sets the basis for a better understanding of the effect of different residues in molecular recognition and binding events.

Gas-Phase Hydration of Perillaldehyde Investigated by Microwave Spectroscopy Assisted by Computational Chemistry

The microsolvated complexes of two equatorial conformers of perillaldehyde were experimentally investigated in a supersonic molecular jet coupled to a cavity-based Fourier transform microwave spectrometer, in the 2.3-8 GHz frequency range. The structures of hydrates C₁₀H₁₄O·(H₂O)_n (n = 1,2,3) were first optimized at the MP2/6-311++G(d,p) and B3LYP-D3BJ/def2-TZVP levels of theory. The spectral signatures of four monohydrates and of two dihydrates could then be obtained. Additional rotational constants from the analysis of the spectra of their ¹⁸O isotopologues allowed the calculation of the substitution coordinates of the water oxygen atoms of each hydrate. They were found to be in good agreement with those of the optimized structures. SAPT2 calculations and noncovalent interaction analysis highlight the role of dispersion and quasi-hydrogen bonds in the stabilization of the structures.