Comparative theoretical study of CO2 activation on clean and potassium-preadsorbed low index surfaces of transition metals

CONTEXT

The efficient catalysis of CO2 adsorption and activation presents a formidable challenge due to its pronounced thermodynamic stability and kinetic inertia. Previous experiments have left gaps in understanding the promotional effects and underlying mechanism of potassium. In this study, we systematically investigate CO2 adsorption and activation on clean and potassium-preadsorbed low index surfaces of transition metals. Theoretical results reveal a substantial augmentation in CO2 binding strength when potassium is introduced, concomitant with a general reduction in activation energies. Notably, linear correlations are significant on close-packed metal surfaces without and with potassium additive. Through a comprehensive analysis encompassing geometric parameters, electronic structures, and energy decomposition, we discern the physical underpinnings of the potassium effect. This enhancement is primarily ascribed to direct electron transfer and dipole-dipole interactions. Furthermore, we scrutinize the impact of an external electric field, demonstrating that the application of a negative electric field accelerates CO2 activation, mirroring the effects observed with potassium.

METHODS

All the periodic density function theory (DFT) calculations were performed by the Vienna Ab Initio Simulation package (VASP). The interaction between nucleus and valence electron was described using the pseudopotentials found in the projector augmented wave method (PAW). Throughout the entire work, the Bayesian error estimation functional (BEEF) was used.

Theoretical insight into the promotion effect of potassium additive on the water-gas shift reaction over low-coordinated Au catalysts

CONTEXT

How to elucidate the effect of alkali metal promoters on gold-catalyzed water-gas shift reaction intrinsically remains a challenging, because that the complex synergy effects such as strong metal-support interactions, interfacial effects, and charge transfer of supported metal catalysts makes people difficulty in the understanding the alkali promotion phenomenon in nature. Herein, we report a systematically study of whole water-gas shift reaction mechanism on pure and the K-modified defected-Au(211) (i.e., by removing one surface Au atom from perfect Au(211) and make one model with the Au-Au coordination number is six) by using the microkinetic modeling based on first principles. Our results indicate that the presence of K can increase the adsorption ability of oxygen-containing species via the attractive coulomb interaction, has no significant effect on the adsorption of H species, but inhibits the adsorption of CO due to the steric effect. K promoter stabilizes the water adsorption by ~0.3 eV, which results in one order increasing of whole reaction rate. Interestingly, the strong promotion effect of the K can be assigned to the significant direct space interaction between K and the adsorbate H2O* through the inducted electric field, which can be further confirmed by the posed negative electric field on the unpromoted D-Au(211). Microkinetic modeling results revealed that the carboxyl mechanism is the most likely to occur, redox mechanism is the next one, and the formate mechanism is the least likely to occur. For different kinds of alkali metal additives, the adsorption strength of water molecules gradually weakens from Li to Cs, but Na shows the best promoter behavior at the low temperature. By considering the effect of K contents on the reactivity of water-gas shift reaction, we found that the K with the medium coverage (~0.2~0.3 ML) has the strongest promoting effect. It is expected that the conclusion of this work can be extended to other WGSR catalytic systems like Cu(or Pt).

METHODS

All calculations were performed by using the plane-wave based periodic method implemented in Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP, version 5.4.4), where the ionic cores are described by the projector augmented wave (PAW) method. The exchange and correlation energies were computed using the Perdew, Burke and Ernzerhof functional with the vdw correction (PBE-D3). The transition states (TSs) were searched using the climbing image nudged elastic band (CI-NEB) method. Some electronic structure properties like work function was predicated by the DS-PAW software. Microkinetic simulation was carried out using MKMCXX software.

A density functional theory study of a water gas shift reaction on Ag(111): potassium effect

Density functional theory (DFT) calculations are executed to investigate the effect of a potassium (K) promoter on the activity of the water gas shift reaction (WGSR) over an Ag(111) surface.

Unveiling the Origin of Alkali Metal (Na, K, Rb, and Cs) Promotion in CO2 Dissociation over Mo2C Catalysts

Molybdenum carbide (Mo2C) is a promising and low-cost catalyst for the reverse water−gas shift (RWGS) reaction. Doping the Mo2C surface with alkali metals can improve the activity of CO2 conversion, but the effect of these metals on CO2 conversion to CO remains poorly understood. In this study, the energies of CO2 dissociation and CO desorption on the Mo2C surface in the presence of different alkali metals (Na, K, Rb, and Cs) are calculated using density functional theory (DFT). Alkali metal doping results in increasing electron density on the Mo atoms and promotes the adsorption and activation of CO2 on Mo2C; the dissociation barrier of CO2 is decreased from 12.51 on Mo2C surfaces to 9.51−11.21 Kcal/mol on alkali metal-modified Mo2C surfaces. Energetic and electronic analyses reveal that although the alkali metals directly bond with oxygen atoms of the oxides, the reduction in the energy of CO2 dissociation can be attributed to the increased interaction between CO/O fragments and Mo in the transition states. The abilities of four alkali metals (Na, K, Rb, and Cs) to promote CO2 dissociation increase in the order Na (11.21 Kcal/mol) < Rb (10.54 Kcal/mol) < Cs (10.41 Kcal/mol) < K (9.51 Kcal/mol). Through electronic analysis, it is found that the increased electron density on the Mo atoms is a result of the alkali metal, and a greater negative charge on Mo results in a lower energy barrier for CO2 dissociation.

Influence of Cs Loading on Pt/m-ZrO2 Water–Gas Shift Catalysts

Certain alkali metals (Na, K) at targeted loadings have been shown in recent decades to significantly promote the LT-WGS reaction. This occurs at alkali doping levels where a redshift in the C-H band of formate occurs, indicating electronic weakening of the bond. The C-H bond breaking of formate is the proposed rate-limiting step of the formate associative mechanism, lending support to the occurrence of this mechanism in H2-rich environments of the LT-WGS stage of fuel processors. Continuing in this vein of research, 2%Pt/m-ZrO2 was promoted with various levels of Cs in order to explore its influence on the rate of formate intermediate decomposition, as well as that of LT-WGS in a fixed bed reactor. In situ DRIFTS experiments revealed that Cs promoter loadings of 3.87% to 7.22% resulted in significant acceleration of the forward formate decomposition in steam at 130 °C. Of all of the alkali metals tested to date, the redshift in the formate ν(CH) band with the incorporation of Cs was the greatest. XANES difference experiments at the Pt L2 and L3 edges indicated that the electronic effect was not likely due to an enrichment of electronic density on Pt. CO2 TPD experiments revealed that, unlike Na and K promoters, Cs behaves more like Rb in that the decomposition of the second intermediate in LT-WGS, carbonate species, is hindered due to (1) increased basicity of Cs, (2) the tendency of Cs to cover Pt sites that facilitate CO2 decomposition, and (3) the tendency of Cs to increase Pt particle size as shown by EXAFS results, resulting in fewer Pt sites that facilitate CO2 decomposition. As such, the LT-WGS rate was hindered overall and the rate-limiting step shifted to carbonate decomposition (CO2 removal). Like its Rb counterpart, low levels of added Cs (e.g., 0.72%Cs) were found to improve the stability of the catalyst relative to the unpromoted catalyst; the stability comparison was made at similar CO conversion level as well as similar space velocity.

Low Temperature Water-Gas Shift: Enhancing Stability through Optimizing Rb Loading on Pt/ZrO2

Recent studies have shown that appropriate levels of alkali promotion can significantly improve the rate of low-temperature water gas shift (LT-WGS) on a range of catalysts. At sufficient loadings, the alkali metal can weaken the formate C–H bond and promote formate dehydrogenation, which is the proposed rate determining step in the formate associative mechanism. In a continuation of these studies, the effect of Rb promotion on Pt/ZrO2 is examined herein. Pt/ZrO2 catalysts were prepared with several different Rb loadings and characterized using temperature programmed reduction mass spectrometry (TPR-MS), temperature programmed desorption (TPD), diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS), an X-ray absorption near edge spectroscopy (XANES) difference procedure, extended X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy (EXAFS) fitting, TPR-EXAFS/XANES, and reactor testing. At loadings of 2.79% Rb or higher, a significant shift was seen in the formate ν(CH) band. The results showed that a Rb loading of 4.65%, significantly improves the rate of formate decomposition in the presence of steam via weakening the formate C–H bond. However, excessive rubidium loading led to the increase in stability of a second intermediate, carbonate and inhibited hydrogen transfer reactions on Pt through surface blocking and accelerated agglomeration during catalyst activation. Optimal catalytic performance was achieved with loadings in the range of 0.55–0.93% Rb, where the catalyst maintained high activity and exhibited higher stability in comparison with the unpromoted catalyst.

Effects of precipitants on the catalytic performance of Cu/CeO2 catalysts for the water–gas shift reaction

The ratio of the precipitant (K2CO3 : KOH) was confirmed to affect the Cu dispersion and OSC of the Cu/CeO2 catalyst, and the Cu/CeO2 catalyst prepared with the K2CO3 : KOH ratio of 3 : 1 showed the highest activity.

Platinum Based Catalysts in the Water Gas Shift Reaction: Recent Advances

The water gas shift (WGS) is an equilibrium exothermic reaction, whose corresponding industrial process is normally carried out in two adiabatic stages, to overcome the thermodynamic and kinetic limitations. The high temperature stage makes use of iron/chromium-based catalysts, while the low temperature stage employs copper/zinc-based catalysts. Nevertheless, both these systems have several problems, mainly dealing with safety issues and process efficiency. Accordingly, in the last decade abundant researches have been focused on the study of alternative catalytic systems. The best performances have been obtained with noble metal-based catalysts, among which, platinum-based formulations showed a good compromise between performance and ease of preparation. These catalytic systems are extremely attractive, as they have numerous advantages, including the feasibility of intermediate temperature (250–400 °C) applications, the absence of pyrophoricity, and the high activity even at low loadings. The particle size plays a crucial role in determining their catalytic activity, enhancing the performance of the nanometric catalytic systems: the best activity and stability was reported for particle sizes < 1.7 nm. Moreover the optimal Pt loading seems to be located near 1 wt%, as well as the optimal Pt coverage was identified in 0.25 ML. Kinetics and mechanisms studies highlighted the low energy activation of Pt/Mo2C-based catalytic systems (Ea of 38 kJ·mol−1), the associative mechanism is the most encountered on the investigated studies. This review focuses on a selection of recent published articles, related to the preparation and use of unstructured platinum-based catalysts in water gas shift reaction, and is organized in five main sections: comparative studies, kinetics, reaction mechanisms, sour WGS and electrochemical promotion. Each section is divided in paragraphs, at the end of the section a summary and a summary table are provided.