Mechanistic insights of electrocatalytic CO2 reduction by Mn complexes: synergistic effects of the ligands

The electrocatalytic mechanisms of CO2 reduction catalyzed by pyridine-oxazoline (pyrox)-based Mn catalysts were investigated by DFT calculations. In-depth comparative analyses of pyrox-based and bipyridine-based Mn complexes were carried out. C-OH cleavage is the rate-determining step for both the protonation-first path and the reduction-first path. The free energy of CO2 activation (ΔG1) and the electrons donated by CO ligands in this step are effective descriptors in regulating the C-OH cleavage barrier. The reduction of carboxylate complex 6 (E6) is the potential-determining step for the reduction-first path. Meanwhile, for the protonation-first path, the initial generation (E2) or the regeneration (E8) of active catalyst might be potential-determining. Hirshfeld charge and orbital contribution analysis indicate that E6 is definitely based on the heterocyclic ligand and E2 is related to both the heterocyclic ligand and three CO ligands. Therefore, replacement of the CO ligand by a stronger electron donating ligand can effectively boost the catalytic activity of CO2 reduction without increasing the overpotential in the reduction-first path. This hypothesis is supported by the mechanism calculations of the Mn complex in which the axial CO ligand is replaced by a pyridine or PMe3.

Analyzing Structure-Activity Variations for Mn-Carbonyl Complexes in the Reduction of CO2 to CO

Contemporary electrocatalysts for the reduction of CO₂ often suffer from low stability, activity, and selectivity, or a combination thereof. Mn-carbonyl complexes represent a promising class of molecular electrocatalysts for the reduction of CO₂ to CO as they are able to promote this reaction at relatively mild overpotentials, whereby rare-earth metals are not required. The electronic and geometric structure of the reaction center of these molecular electrocatalysts is precisely known and can be tuned via ligand modifications. However, ligand characteristics that are required to achieve high catalytic turnover at minimal overpotential remain unclear. We consider 55 Mn-carbonyl complexes, which have previously been synthesized and characterized experimentally. Four intermediates were identified that are common across all catalytic mechanisms proposed for Mn-carbonyl complexes, and their structures were used to calculate descriptors for each of the 55 Mn-carbonyl complexes. These electronic-structure-based descriptors encompass the binding energies, the highest occupied and lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals, and partial charges. Trends in turnover frequency and overpotential with these descriptors were analyzed to afford meaningful physical insights into what ligand characteristics lead to good catalytic performance, and how this is affected by the reaction conditions. These insights can be expected to significantly contribute to the rational design of more active Mn-carbonyl electrocatalysts.

Photocatalytic Reduction of CO2 to CO in Aqueous Solution under Red-Light Irradiation by a Zn-Porphyrin-Sensitized Mn(I) Catalyst

This work demonstrates photocatalytic CO₂ reduction by a noble-metal-free photosensitizer-catalyst system in aqueous solution under red-light irradiation. A water-soluble Mn(I) tricarbonyl diimine complex, [MnBr(4,4′-{Et₂O₃PCH₂}₂-2,2′-bipyridyl)(CO)₃] (1), has been fully characterized, including single-crystal X-ray crystallography, and shown to reduce CO₂ to CO following photosensitization by tetra(N-methyl-4-pyridyl)porphyrin Zn(II) tetrachloride [Zn(TMPyP)]Cl₄ (2) under 625 nm irradiation. This is the first example of 2 employed as a photosensitizer for CO₂ reduction. The incorporation of −P(O)(OEt)₂ groups, decoupled from the core of the catalyst by a −CH₂– spacer, afforded water solubility without compromising the electronic properties of the catalyst. The photostability of the active Mn(I) catalyst over prolonged periods of irradiation with red light was confirmed by ¹H and ¹³C{¹H} NMR spectroscopy. This first report on Mn(I) species as a homogeneous photocatalyst, working in water and under red light, illustrates further future prospects of intrinsically photounstable Mn(I) complexes as solar-driven catalysts in an aqueous environment.

A Mn(I) bipyridyl tricarbonyl complex, where the diimine ligand is functionalized with water-solubilizing phosphonate ester groups, has been prepared and is shown to catalytically convert CO₂ to CO in aqueous solution following photosensitization from a water-soluble Zn(II) porphyrin under red-light irradiation.

Using Light and Electrons to Bend Carbon Dioxide: Developing and Understanding Catalysts for CO2 Conversion to Fuels and Feedstocks

Our global society generates an unwieldy amount of CO₂ per unit time. Therefore, the capture of this greenhouse gas must involve a diverse set of strategies. One solution to this problem is the conversion of CO₂ into a more useful chemical species. Again, a multiplicity of syntheses and products will be necessary. No matter how elegant the chemistry is, commercial markets often have little use for a small set of compounds made in tremendous yield. Following this reasoning, the Bocarsly Research Group seeks to develop new electrochemical and photochemical processes that may be of utility in the conversion of CO₂ to organic compounds. We focus on investigating proton-coupled charge transfer mechanisms that produce both C1 and carbon-carbon bonded products (C2+).In early work, we considered the reduction of CO₂ to formate at electrocatalytic indium and tin electrodes. These studies demonstrated the key role of surface oxides in catalyzing the reduction of CO₂. This work generated efficient systems for the formation of formate and paved the way to studies using non-copper, intermetallic electrocatalysts for the generation of C2+ species. Most notable is the efficient formation of oxalate at an oxidized Cr₃Ga electrode. Oxalate has recently been suggested as a potential nonfossil, alternate organic feedstock.Separately, we have focused on the electrocatalytic effects of pyridine on the reduction of CO₂ in aqueous electrolyte. These studies demonstrated that electrodes that normally yield a low hydrogen overpotential (Pd and Pt) show suppressed H₂ evolution and strongly enhanced activity for CO₂ reduction in the presence of pyridinium. Methanol was observed to form in high Faradaic yield at low overpotential using this system. The 6-electron, 6-proton reduction of CO₂ in the presence of pyridinium was intriguing, and significant effort was placed on understanding the mechanism of this reaction both on metal electrodes and on semiconducting photocathodes. P-GaP electrodes were found to provide exceptional behavior for the formation of methanol using only light as the energy source.The pyridinium studies highlighted the role of protons in the overall reduction of CO₂, stimulating our interest in the chemistry of MnBr(bpy)(CO)₃ and related compounds. This complex was reported to electrochemically reduce CO₂ to CO. We saw these reports as an opportunity to study the detailed nature of the proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) mechanism associated with CO₂ reduction. Our investigation of this system revealed the role of hydrogen-bonding in CO₂ reduction and pointed the way for the construction of a photochemical process for CO generation using a [(bpy)(CO)₃Mn(CN)Mn(bpy)(CO)₃]⁺ photocatalyst.Based on our studies to date, it appears likely that heterogeneous systems can be assembled to convert CO₂ into products that are "beyond C2 products." This may open up new practical chemistry in the area of fossil-based replacements for both synthesis and fuels. Systems with pragmatic efficiencies are close to reality. Electrochemical reactors using heterogeneous electrocatalysts show the stability and product selectivity needed to generate industrial opportunities. Continued growth of mechanistic understanding is expected to facilitate the chemical design of cogent systems for the taming of CO₂.

Secondary Coordination Effect on Monobipyridyl Ru(II) Catalysts in Photochemical CO2 Reduction: Effective Proton Shuttle of Pendant Brønsted Acid/Base Sites (OH and N(CH3)2) and Its Mechanistic Investigation

While the incorporation of pendant Brønsted acid/base sites in the secondary coordination sphere is a promising and effective strategy to increase the catalytic performance and product selectivity in organometallic catalysis for CO₂ reduction, the control of product selectivity still faces a great challenge. Herein, we report two new trans(Cl)-[Ru(6-X-bpy)(CO)₂Cl₂] complexes functionalized with a saturated ethylene-linked functional group (bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine; X = -(CH₂)₂-OH or -(CH₂)₂-N(CH₃)₂) at the ortho(6)-position of bpy ligand, which are named Ru-bpy^OH and Ru-bpy^diMeN, respectively. In the series of photolysis experiments, compared to nontethered case, the asymmetric attachment of tethering ligand to the bpy ligand led to less efficient but more selective formate production with inactivation of CO₂-to-CO conversion route during photoreaction. From a series of in situ FTIR analyses, it was found that the Ru-formate intermediates are stabilized by a highly probable hydrogen bonding between pendent proton donors (-diMeN⁺H or -OH) and the oxygen atom of metal-bound formate (Ru^I-OCHO···H-E-(CH₂)₂-, E = O or diMeN⁺). Under such conformation, the liberation of formate from the stabilized Ru^I-formate becomes less efficient compared to the nontethered case, consequently lowering the CO₂-to-formate conversion activities during photoreaction. At the same time, such stabilization of Ru-formate species prevents the dehydration reaction route (η¹-OCHO → η¹-COOH on Ru metal) which leads toward the generation of Ru-CO species (key intermediate for CO production), eventually leading to the reduction of CO₂-to-CO conversion activity.

Dirhodium complexes as electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction to HCOOH: role of steric hindrance on selectivity

A series of Rh₂(ii,ii) complexes were shown to electrocatalytically reduce CO₂ to HCOOH. Electrochemical and spectroelectrochemical studies reveal a correlation between catalytic selectivity and efficiency with the steric bulk at the axial sites afforded by the bridging ligands. Mechanistic studies point to the presence of a Rh₂(ii,i)-H hydride as a key intermediate in the catalytic cycle.

Electro- and Photochemical Reduction of CO2 by Molecular Manganese Catalysts: Exploring the Positional Effect of Second-Sphere Hydrogen-Bond Donors

A series of molecular Mn catalysts featuring aniline groups in the second-coordination sphere has been developed for electrochemical and photochemical CO₂ reduction. The arylamine moieties were installed at the 6 position of 2,2'-bipyridine (bpy) to generate a family of isomers in which the primary amine is located at the ortho- (1-Mn), meta- (2-Mn), or para-site (3-Mn) of the aniline ring. The proximity of the second-sphere functionality to the active site is a critical factor in determining catalytic performance. Catalyst 1-Mn, possessing the shortest distance between the amine and the active site, significantly outperformed the rest of the series and exhibited a 9-fold improvement in turnover frequency relative to parent catalyst Mn(bpy)(CO)₃ Br (901 vs. 102 s^-1 , respectively) at 150 mV lower overpotential. The electrocatalysts operated with high faradaic efficiencies (≥70 %) for CO evolution using trifluoroethanol as a proton source. Notably, under photocatalytic conditions, a concentration-dependent shift in product selectivity from CO (at high [catalyst]) to HCO₂ H (at low [catalyst]) was observed with turnover numbers up to 4760 for formic acid and high selectivities for reduced carbon products.

Molecular Catalysts with Intramolecular Re-O Bond for Electrochemical Reduction of Carbon Dioxide

A new Re bipyridine-type complex, namely, fac-Re(pmbpy)(CO)₃Cl (pmbpy = 4-phenyl-6-(2-hydroxy-phenyl)-2,2′-bipyridine), 1, carrying a single OH moiety as local proton source, has been synthesized, and its electrochemical behavior under Ar and under CO₂ has been characterized. Two isomers of 1, namely, 1-cis characterized by the proximity of Cl to OH and 1-trans, are identified. The interconversion between 1-cis and 1-trans is clarified by DFT calculations, which reveal two transition states. The energetically lower pathway displays a non-negligible barrier of 75.5 kJ mol^–1. The 1e^– electrochemical reduction of 1 affords the neutral intermediate 1-OPh, formally derived by reductive deprotonation and loss of Cl^– from 1. 1-OPh, which exhibits an entropically favored intramolecular Re–O bond, has been isolated and characterized. The detailed electrochemical mechanism is demonstrated by combined chemical reactivity, spectroelectrochemistry, spectroscopic (IR and NMR), and computational (DFT) approaches. Comparison with previous Re and Mn derivatives carrying local proton sources highlights that the catalytic activity of Re complexes is more sensitive to the presence of local OH groups. Similar to Re-2OH (2OH = 4-phenyl-6-(phenyl-2,6-diol)-2,2′-bipyridine), 1 and Mn-1OH display a selective reduction of CO₂ to CO. In the case of the Re bipyridine-type complex, the formation of a relatively stable Re–O bond and a preference for phenolate-based reactivity with CO₂ slightly inhibit the electrocatalytic reduction of CO₂ to CO, resulting in a low TON value of 9, even in the presence of phenol as a proton source.

A new Re bipyridine-type complex, namely, fac-Re(pmbpy)(CO)₃Cl (pmbpy = 4-phenyl-6-(2-hydroxy-phenyl)-2,2′-bipyridine), 1, carrying a single OH moiety as local proton source, has been synthesized, and its electrochemical behavior under Ar and under CO₂ has been characterized. Two isomers of 1, namely, 1-cis characterized by the proximity of Cl to OH and 1-trans, are identified.