Enabling sequential rupture for lowering atomistic ice adhesion

Unraveling Ice-Solid Interface Rupture Dynamics: Insights from Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Unwanted icing on exposed surfaces poses significant risks, driving the quest for effective anti-icing mechanisms. While fracture mechanics concepts have been developed for designing coatings that weaken the ice-solid interface on soft surfaces, the factors that dictate ice adhesion strength and its counterpart, ice removal force, on hard surfaces remain poorly understood. In this study, we employ molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the interface rupture between ice and a hard solid substrate. The results indicate that the ice adhesion strength is contingent on the length of the ice cube. By examining the shearing behavior, we reveal a nanoscale critical force-bearing length. The shear force required to detach the ice scales proportionally with the length of the ice cube when it is smaller than the critical length. Once the ice cube length exceeds the critical length, the shear force stabilizes at a constant maximum value, revealing the existence of a maximum ice-removal force. The results align with the so-called strength versus toughness-controlled deicing regimes and are in agreement with cohesive zone modeling at the continuum length scale and recent experimental results. Our results extend this understanding to the nanoscale, confirming consistency between macro and micro scales. This consistency suggests that the toughness of the ice-solid interface is intrinsically governed by ice-surface interactions. By unraveling key intrinsic factors and their scale-dependent effects on the interface rupture of ice on surfaces, this study lays a solid theoretical foundation for the design and fabrication of next-generation anti-icing surfaces.

Investigating Shear Stress of Ice Accumulated on Surfaces with Various Roughnesses: Effects of a Quasi-Water Layer

The investigation of the anti-icing/deicing is essential because the icing phenomenon deteriorates the natural environment and various projects. By conducting molecular dynamics simulation, this work analyzes the effect of the quasi-water layer on the ice shear stress over smooth and rough surfaces, along with the underlying physics of the quasi-water layer. The results indicate that the thickness of the quasi-water layer monotonically increases with temperature, resulting in a monotonic decrease in the ice shear stress on the smooth surface. Due to the joint effects of the smooth surface wettability and the quasi-water layer, the ice shear stress increases and then decreases to almost a constant value when the surface changes from a hydrophobic to a hydrophilic one. For rough surfaces with stripe nanostructures, when the width of the bump for one case equals the depression for the other case, the variations of shear stress with height for these two cases are almost the same. The rough surface is effective in reducing the ice shear stress compared to the smooth surface due to the thickening of the quasi-water layer. Each molecule in the quasi-water layer and its four nearest neighboring molecules gradually form a tetrahedral ice-like structure along the direction away from the surface. The radial distribution function also shows that the quasi-water layer resembles the liquid water rather than the ice structure. These findings shed light on developing anti-icing and deicing techniques.

Synergistic Effects of the Superhydrophilic and Superhydrophobic Components on the Antifreezing Performances of Latex Particles and Anti-Icing Properties of Latex Films

The development of new materials for antifreezing and anti-icing applications is a big challenge in industry and academic area. Inspired by the antifreeze proteins, latex particles with superhydrophilic zwitterionic shells and superhydrophobic cores are synthesized by reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer emulsion polymerization, and the applications of the latex particles in antifreezing and anti-icing applications are investigated. In antifreezing study, the critical aggregate temperature (CAT) of the latex particles decreases, and the separation of the melting and freezing temperature of ice increases with the particle concentration. Enzyme molecules can be cryopreserved in the particle solution, and their bioactivities are well maintained. Latex particles are casted into latex films with dynamic surfaces. Anti-icing performances, including antifrosting properties, freezing delay time, and ice adhesion strengths, are studied; and the water-treated latex films present stronger anti-icing properties than other films, due to the synergistic effects of the superhydrophilic and superhydrophobic components. In addition, latex particles with zwitterionic shells and poly(n-butyl methacrylate) cores, and latex particles with small molecular surfactant on the surfaces are synthesized. The antifreezing performances of the latex particles and anti-icing properties of the latex films are compared.

Molecular dynamics simulation-based study to analyse the properties of entrapped water between gold and graphene 2D interfaces

Heterostructures based on graphene and other 2D materials have received significant attention in recent years. However, it is challenging to fabricate them with an ultra-clean interface due to unwanted foreign molecules, which usually get introduced during their transfer to a desired substrate. Clean nanofabrication is critical for the utilization of these materials in 2D nanoelectronics devices and circuits, and therefore, it is important to understand the influence of the "non-ideal" interface. Inspired by the wet-transfer process of the CVD-grown graphene, herein, we present an atomistic simulation of the graphene-Au interface, where water molecules often get trapped during the transfer process. By using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we investigated the structural variations of the trapped water and the traction-separation curve derived from the graphene-Au interface at 300 K. We observed the formation of an ice-like structure with square-ice patterns when the thickness of the water film was <5 Å. This could cause undesirable strain in the graphene layer and hence affect the performance of devices developed from it. We also observed that at higher thicknesses the water film is predominantly present in the liquid state. The traction separation curve showed that the adhesion of graphene is better in the presence of an ice-like structure. This study explains the behaviour of water confined at the nanoscale region and advances our understanding of the graphene-Au interface in 2D nanoelectronics devices and circuits.

Ice Adhesion Properties on Micropillared Superhydrophobic Surfaces

In this work, we investigate the freezing behavior and ice adhesion properties of sessile drops on micropillared superhydrophobic surfaces (SHSs) with various sizes, which are of practical importance for anti/deicing. First of all, it is demonstrated that the recalescence is related only to the supercooling degree of drops but not to the geometrical parameters of micropillars. The freezing time of sessile drops first increases and then decreases with the area fraction of the SHSs, which demonstrates the nonmonotonic dependence of the icing time on the area fraction. Moreover, the influence of the geometrical parameters of the micropillars on the ice adhesion is discussed. With the decrease of the substrate temperature, the wetting state of the adhesive ice can be transformed from the Cassie ice to the Wenzel ice. For the Cassie ice, the adhesive force is proportional to the area fraction of the SHSs. Interestingly, experimental results show that there exist two interfacial debonding modes of the Wenzel ice: translational debonding and rotational debonding. Furthermore, it is found that the rotational debonding mode contributes to a much lower adhesive force between the ice and the micropillared surface compared to that of the translational debonding mode. By analyzing the critical interfacial energy release rate of the two modes, we deduce the threshold between the two modes, which is quantified as the geometrical parameters of the micropillars. In addition, quantitative relations between the geometrical parameters and the adhesion strengths of the two modes are also obtained. We envision that this work would shed new light on the design optimization of anti/deicing materials.

Assembly of Graphene Platelets for Bioinspired, Stimuli-Responsive, Low Ice Adhesion Surfaces

Design and fabrication of functional materials for anti-icing and deicing attract great attention from both the academic research and industry. Among them, the study of fish-scale-like materials has proved that enabling sequential rupture is an effective approach for weakening the intrinsic interface adhesion. Here, graphene platelets were utilized to construct fish-scale-like surfaces for easy ice detachment. Using a biomimicking arrangement of the graphene platelets, the surfaces were able to alter their structural morphology for the sequential rupture in response to external forces. With different packing densities of graphene platelets, all the surfaces showed universally at least 50% reduction in atomistic tensile ice adhesion strength. Because of the effect of sequential rupture, stronger ice-surface interactions did not lead to an obvious increase in ice adhesion. Interestingly, the high packing density of graphene platelets resulted in stable and reversible surface morphology in cyclic tensile and shearing tests, and subsequently high reproducibility of the sequential rupture mode. The fish-scale-like surfaces built and tested, together with the nanoscale deicing results, provided a close view of ice adhesion mechanics, which can promote future bioinspired, stress-responsive, anti-icing surface designs.

Unraveling Adhesion Strength between Gas Hydrate and Solid Surfaces

Natural gas hydrate is a promising future energy source, but it also poses a huge threat to oil and gas production due to its ability to deposit within and block pipelines. Understanding the atomistic mechanisms of adhesion between the hydrate and solid surfaces and elucidating its underlying key determining factors can shed light on the fundamentals of novel antihydrate materials design. In this study, large-scale molecular simulations are employed to investigate the hydrate adhesion on solid surfaces, especially with focuses on the atomistic structures of intermediate layer and their influences on the adhesion. The results show that the structure of the intermediate layer formed between hydrate and solid surface is a competitive equilibrium of induced growth from both sides, and is regulated by the content of guest molecules. By comparing the fracture behaviors of the hydrate-solid surface system with different intermediate structures, it is found that both the lattice areal density of water structure and the adsorption of guest molecules on the interface together determine the adhesion strength. Based on the analysis of the adhesion strength distribution, we have also revealed the origins of the drastic difference in adhesion among different water structures such as ice and hydrate. Our simulation indicates that ice-adhesion strength is approximately five times that of lowest hydrate adhesion strength. This finding is surprisingly consistent with the available experimental results.

Gels as emerging anti-icing materials: a mini review

Gel materials have drawn great attention recently in the anti-icing research community due to their remarkable potential for reducing ice adhesion, inhibiting ice nucleation, and restricting ice propagation. Although the current anti-icing gels are in their infancy and far from practical applications due to poor durability, their outstanding prospect of icephobicity has already shed light on a new group of emerging anti-icing materials. There is a need for a timely review to consolidate the new trends and foster the development towards dedicated applications. Starting from the stage of icing, we first survey the relevant anti-icing strategies. The latest anti-icing gels are then categorized by their liquid phases into organogels, hydrogels, and ionogels. At the same time, the current research focuses, anti-icing mechanisms and shortcomings affiliated with each category are carefully analysed. Based upon the reported state-of-the-art anti-icing research and our own experience in polymer-based anti-icing materials, suggestions for the future development of the anti-icing gels are presented, including pathways to enhance durability, the need to build up the missing fundamentals, and the possibility to enable stimuli-responsive properties. The primary aim of this review is to motivate researchers in both the anti-icing and gel research communities to perform a synchronized effort to rapidly advance the understanding and making of gel-based next generation anti-icing materials.

Dynamic Anti-Icing Surfaces (DAIS)

Remarkable progress has been made in surface icephobicity in the recent years. The mainstream standpoint of the reported antiicing surfaces yet only considers the ice-substrate interface and its adjacent regions being of static nature. In reality, the local structures and the overall properties of ice-substrate interfaces evolve with time, temperature and various external stimuli. Understanding the dynamic properties of the icing interface is crucial for shedding new light on the design of new anti-icing surfaces to meet challenges of harsh conditions including extremely low temperature and/or long working time. This article surveys the state-of-the-art anti-icing surfaces and dissects their dynamic changes of the chemical/physical states at icing interface. According to the focused critical ice-substrate contacting locations, namely the most important ice-substrate interface and the adjacent regions in the substrate and in the ice, the available anti-icing surfaces are for the first time re-assessed by taking the dynamic evolution into account. Subsequently, the recent works in the preparation of dynamic anti-icing surfaces (DAIS) that consider time-evolving properties, with their potentials in practical applications, and the challenges confronted are summarized and discussed, aiming for providing a thorough review of the promising concept of DAIS for guiding the future icephobic materials designs.

Machine Learning Based Prediction of Nanoscale Ice Adhesion on Rough Surfaces

It is widely recognized that surface roughness plays an important role in ice adhesion strength, although the correlation between the two is far from understood. In this paper, two approaches, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and machine learning (ML), were utilized to study the nanoscale intrinsic ice adhesion strength on rough surfaces. A systematic algorithm for making random rough surfaces was developed and the surfaces were tested for their ice adhesion strength, with varying interatomic potentials. Using MD simulations, the intrinsic ice adhesion strength was found to be significantly lower on rougher surfaces, which was attributed to the lubricating effect of a thin quasi-liquid layer. An increase in the substrate–ice interatomic potential increased the thickness of the quasi-liquid layer on rough surfaces. Two different ML algorithms, regression and classification, were trained using the results from the MD simulations, with support vector machines (SVM) emerging as the best for classifying. The ML approach showed an encouraging prediction accuracy, and for the first time shed light on using ML for anti-icing surface design. The findings provide a better understanding of the role of nanoscale roughness in intrinsic ice adhesion and suggest that ML can be a powerful tool in finding materials with a low ice adhesion strength.

Stability, deformation and rupture of Janus oligomer enabled self-emulsifying water-in-oil microemulsion droplets

Microemulsions exist widely in nature, daily life and industrial manufacturing processes, including petroleum production, food processing, drug delivery, new material fabrication, sewage treatment, etc. The mechanical properties of microemulsion droplets and a correlation to their molecular structures are of vital importance to those applications. Despite studies on their physicochemical determinants, there are lots of challenges of exploring the mechanical properties of microemulsions by experimental studies. Herein, atomistic modelling was utilized to study the stability, deformation, and rupture of Janus oligomer enabled water-in-oil microemulsion droplets, aiming at revealing their intrinsic relationship with Janus oligomer based surfactants and oil structures. The self-emulsifying process from a water, oil and surfactant mixture to a single microemulsion droplet was modulated by the amphiphilicity and structure of the surfactants. Four microemulsion systems with an interfacial thickness in the range of 7.4-17.3 Å were self-assembled to explore the effect of the surfactant on the droplet morphology. By applying counter forces on the water core and the surfactant shell, the mechanical stability of the microemulsion droplets was probed at different ambient temperatures. A strengthening response and a softening regime before and after a temperature-dependent peak force were identified followed by the final rupture. This work demonstrates a practical strategy to precisely tune the mechanical properties of a single microemulsion droplet, which can be applied in the formation, de-emulsification, and design of microemulsions in oil recovery and production, drug delivery and many other applications.