Are all planar and quasi-planar boron clusters aromatic? Counter examples of island or global π antiaromaticity from chemical bonding analysis

Does Aromaticity Play a Role in Electronic and Structural Properties of YBn (n=2-14) Clusters?

Nanoclusters exhibit electronic, optical, and magnetic properties that differ significantly from those of extended and molecular systems with comparable stoichiometries. In this work, we examined the structural, energetic, and electronic characteristics of yttrium-doped boron clusters (YBn, where n ranges from 2 to 14) with the aid of robust wavefunction analysis tools. Special emphasis is placed on the elucidation of the potential aromatic character exhibited by the resultant molecules and how it can affect their chemical bonding and stability. Our results revealed that the YBn stability is governed by the maximization of the ionic Y-B interactions. This circumstance is evidenced from the lowest-energy conformations, which manifest as half-sandwich structures wherein the majority of boron atoms are bonded to yttrium. The stabilization of such chemical contacts comes at the expense of a notorious depletion of the Y local electron density, crystallizing in a considerable ionic character, close to Y2++B n 2 - ${{\rm{B}}_{\rm{n}}^{2 - } }$ . Such a prominent charge transfer is coupled to the enhancement of the electron delocalization within the Bn lattice, resulting in quite remarkable local and global aromatic characters. Altogether, this study shows how the toolkit of real space chemical bonding descriptors can offer valuable insights into the structural and electronic properties, along with the chemical bonding, of YBn clusters, contributing to a more comprehensive understanding of their behavior.

A topological path to the formation of a quasi-planar B70 boron cluster and its dianion

In view of the competing assignments regarding the most stable isomer of the B70 boron cluster including the quasi-planar and bilayer structures, we reinvestigated the structural motifs of B70 using a genetic algorithm for structure search (MEGA) in conjunction with density functional theory computations using the PBE functional. The quasi-planar structure was also constructed using the topological leapfrog algorithm. The latter search aimed to give us unique insight into its formation and the growth pattern of boron clusters. Also, the di-anionic state of B70 was explored. Our extensive search suggested a competition between the quasi-planar, tubular and bilayer isomers for the ground state of B70 in both neutral and dianionic states. While the bilayer form is more stable in the neutral state, the quasi-planar counterpart becomes more stable in the dianionic B702-. The stability arises due to the fact that the B702- dianion possesses 50 π electrons that satisfy the disk aromaticity model rule. These results tend to extend the stabilization of the quasi-planar structure upon negative charge addition previously found in small size boron clusters to larger sizes.

Electron correlation effects in boron clusters BQn (for Q = -1, 0, 1 and n ≤ 13) based on quantum Monte Carlo simulations

We present all-electron quantum Monte Carlo simulations on the anionic, neutral, and cationic boron clusters BQn with up to 13 atoms (Q = -1, 0, +1 and n ≤ 13). Accurate total energies of these clusters are obtained and an excellent agreement is reached with available experimental results for adiabatic and vertical detachment energies. We also perform very accurate Hartree-Fock calculations in the complete-basis-set limit where electron correlation is absent. In combination with the FN-DMC and HF-CBS results, we quantify the correlation effects and present the first attempt for a systematic investigation on the electron correlation effects in boron clusters. The obtained results show that, in general, electron correlation may contribute significantly to both the atomic and electronic structures of the boron clusters, manifested in the quantities such as the average binding energies of the clusters, atomic dissociation energies, detachment energies, and ionization potentials. For instance, the calculations indicate that the electron correlation maintains the bound state of cationic cluster B₂⁺ and it also contributes 99% of the detachment energy of the anionic cluster B₅^-.