The nickel-sirohydrochlorin formation mechanism of the ancestral class II chelatase CfbA in coenzyme F430 biosynthesis

Nickel-chelatase activity of SirB variants mimicking the His arrangement in the naturally occurring nickel-chelatase CfbA

Metal-tetrapyrrole cofactors are involved in multiple cellular functions, and chelatases are key enzymes for the biosynthesis of these cofactors. CfbA is an ancestral, homodimeric-type class II chelatase which is able to use not only Ni2+ as a physiological metal substrate, but also Co2+ as a nonphysiological substrate with higher activity than for Ni2+. The Ni/Co-chelatase function found in CfbA is also observed in SirB, a descendant, monomeric-type class II chelatase. This is despite the distinct active site structure of CfbA and SirB; specifically, CfbA shows a unique four His residue arrangement, unlike other monomeric class II chelatases such as SirB. Herein, we studied the Ni-chelatase activity of SirB variants R134H, L200H, and R134H/L200H, the latter of which mimics the His alignment of CfbA. Our results showed that the SirB R134H variant exhibited the highest Ni-chelatase activity among the SirB enzymes, which in turn suggests that the position of His134 could be more important for the Ni-chelatase activity than that of His200. The SirB R134H/L200H variant showed lower activity than R134H, despite the four His residues found in SirB R134H/L200H. CD spectroscopy showed secondary structure denaturation and a slight difficulty in Ni-binding of SirB R134H/L200H, which may be related to its lower activity. Finally, a docking simulation suggested that the His134 of the SirB R134H variant could function as a base catalyst for the Ni-chelatase reaction in a class II chelatase architecture.

Two Distinct Thermodynamic Gradients for Cellular Metalation of Vitamin B12

The acquisition of Co^II by the corrin component of vitamin B₁₂ follows one of two distinct pathways, referred to as early or late Co^II insertion. The late insertion pathway exploits a Co^II metallochaperone (CobW) from the COG0523 family of G3E GTPases, while the early insertion pathway does not. This provides an opportunity to contrast the thermodynamics of metalation in a metallochaperone-requiring and a metallochaperone-independent pathway. In the metallochaperone-independent route, sirohydrochlorin (SHC) associates with the CbiK chelatase to form Co^II-SHC. Co^II-buffered enzymatic assays indicate that SHC binding enhances the thermodynamic gradient for Co^II transfer from the cytosol to CbiK. In the metallochaperone-dependent pathway, hydrogenobyrinic acid a,c-diamide (HBAD) associates with the CobNST chelatase to form Co^II-HBAD. Here, Co^II-buffered enzymatic assays indicate that Co^II transfer from the cytosol to HBAD-CobNST must somehow traverse a highly unfavorable thermodynamic gradient for Co^II binding. Notably, there is a favorable gradient for Co^II transfer from the cytosol to the Mg^IIGTP-CobW metallochaperone, but further transfer of Co^II from the GTP-bound metallochaperone to the HBAD-CobNST chelatase complex is thermodynamically unfavorable. However, after nucleotide hydrolysis, Co^II transfer from the chaperone to the chelatase complex is calculated to become favorable. These data reveal that the CobW metallochaperone can overcome an unfavorable thermodynamic gradient for Co^II transfer from the cytosol to the chelatase by coupling this process to GTP hydrolysis.