Comment on 'Structural characterization, reactivity and vibrational properties of silver clusters: a new global minimum for Ag16' by P. L. Rodríguez-Kessler, A. R. Rodríguez-Domínguez, D. MacLeod Carey and A. Muñoz-Castro, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2020, 22, 27255, DOI: D0CP04018E

Interactions of Nitric Oxide Molecules with Pure and Oxidized Silver ClustersAgn{plus minus}/AgnO{plus minus} (n=11-13). A Computational Study

In this work we studied, within DFT, the interaction of NO with pure and oxidized Agn, both anionic and cationic, composed from11 to 13 Ag atoms. In that size interval, shell closing effects are not expected, and structural and electronic odd-even effects will determine the strength of interaction. We obtained that species Agn{plus minus} and AgnO{plus minus} with odd number of electrons (n=12) adsorb NO with higher energy than their neighbours. This result agrees with the facts observed in recent mass spectroscopy measurements, which were performed at finite temperature. The adsorption energy is about twice for oxidized clusters compared to pure ones, and higher for anions than for cations. The adsorption of another NO molecule on AgnNO{plus minus} forms Agn(NO)2{plus minus}, with the dimer (NO)2 in cis configuration, and binding the two N atoms with two neigbour Ag atoms. The n=12 show the higher adsorption energy again. In absence of reaction barriers, Agn(NO)2{plus minus} dissociate spontaneously into AgnO{plus minus} and N2O, except the n= 12 anion. The máximum high barrier along the dissociation path of Ag13(NO)2- is about 0.7 eV. Further analysis of PDOS for Ag11-13 (NO)x{plus minus} (x=0,1,2) molecules shows that bonding between NO and Agn mainly occurs in the range between -3.0 eV and 3.0 eV. The overlap between 4 d of Ag and 2 p of N and O is larger for Ag12(NO)2{plus minus} than for neighbour sizes. For n=12, the d bands are close to the (NO)2 2π orbital, leading to extra back-donation charge from the 4 d of Ag to the closer 2π orbital of (NO)2.

Reply to 'Comment on "Structural characterization, reactivity, and vibrational properties of silver clusters: A new global minimum for Ag16"' by P. V. Nhat, N. T. Si, L. V. Duong and M. T. Nguyen, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2021, , DOI: D1CP00646K

Recently, P. V. Nhat et al., have discussed and commented on our article (DOI: 10.1039/D0CP04018E) for the case of the most stable structure of Ag15. They have found a new most stable structure (labeled as 15-1) in comparison to the putative global minimum reported by us, which is a four layered 1-4-6-4 stacking structure with a C2v point group (15-2). In this reply, we have performed a larger structure search which allowed us to confirm the results of Nhat et al. The results show the existence of multiple isoenergetic isomers with similar structure motifs for the Ag15 system, increasing the problem complexity to locate the global minimum. The results in regard to the structure and electronic properties of the new lowest energy structure are discussed.