Cocrystallization-driven stabilization of metastable nanoclusters: a case study of Pd1Au9

Superlattice Assembly for Empowering Metal Nanoclusters

ConspectusAtomically precise metal nanoclusters, serving as an aggregation state of metal atoms, display unique physicochemical properties owing to their ultrasmall sizes with discrete electronic energy levels and strong quantum size effects. Such intriguing properties endow nanoclusters with potential utilization as efficient nanomaterials in catalysis, electron transfer, drug delivery, photothermal conversion, optical control, etc. With the assistance of atomically precise operations and theoretical calculations on metal nanoclusters, significant progress has been accomplished in illustrating their structure-performance correlations at the single-molecule level. Such research achievements, in turn, have contributed to the rational design and customization of functional nanoclusters and cluster-based nanomaterials.Most previous studies have focused on investigating structure-property correlations of nanocluster monomers, while the exploration of electronic structures and physicochemical properties of hierarchical cluster-based assembled structures was far from enough. Indeed, from the application aspect, the nanoclusters with controllably assembly states (e.g., crystalline assembled materials, host-guest hybrid materials, amorphous powders, and so on) were more suitable for performance expression relative to those in the monomeric state and more directed to downstream solid-state applications. In this context, more attention should be paid to the state-correlated property variations of metal nanoclusters occurring in their aggregating and assembling processes for better applications in accordance with their aptitude.Crystalline aggregates are crucial in the structural determination of metal nanoclusters, also acting as a cornerstone to analyze the structure-property correlations by affording atomic-level information. The regular arrangement, uniform composition, and close intermolecular distance of the cluster molecules in their supercrystal lattices are beneficial for property retention and amplification from the molecule itself as a monomeric state. Besides, for these nanoparticles with strong quantum size effects, the intercluster distances in the supercrystal lattices are still located at the nanoscale level, wherein the quantum size effect is highly likely to take effect with additional intermolecular synergistic effects. Accordingly, it is expected that novel performances might occur in the crystalline aggregates of nanoclusters that are completely different from those in the monomolecular state.In this Account, we emphasize our efforts in exploring the performance enhancement of atomically precise metal nanoclusters in their crystalline aggregate states, such as thermal stability, photoluminescence, optical activity, and an optical waveguide. Such performance enhancements further supported the practical uses of metal nanoclusters in structure determination, a polarization switch, an optical waveguide device, and so on. We also demonstrated that the differences in physicochemical properties between crystalline aggregates and monomers of metal nanoclusters might be attributed to the change in electronic structures during the crystalline aggregation processes in the superlattice. The "superlattice assembly" is intended to customize the function of cluster-based aggregates for downstream solid-state applications.

Structural Transformation of Metastable Two-Electron Superatom Au-Doped Cu-Rich Alloy Nanocluster

The ability to fabricate bimetallic clusters with atomic precision offers promising prospects for elucidating the correlations between their structures and properties. Nevertheless, achieving precise control at the atomic level in the production of clusters, including the quantity of dopant, characteristic of ligands, charge state of precursors, and structural transformation, have remained a challenge. Herein, we report the synthesis, purification, and characterization of a new bimetallic hydride cluster, [AuCu11(H){S2P(OiPr)2}6(C≡CPh)3] (AuCu11H). The hydride position in AuCu11H was determined using DFT calculations. AuCu11H comprises a ligand-stabilized defective fcc Au@Cu11 cuboctahedron. AuCu11H is metastable and undergoes a spontaneous transformation through ligand exchange into the isostructural [AuCu11(Cl){S2P(OiPr)2}6(C≡CPh)3] (AuCu11Cl) and into the complete cuboctahedral [AuCu12{S2P(OiPr)2}6(C≡CPh)4]+ (AuCu12) through an increase in nuclearity. These structural transformations were tracked by NMR and mass spectrometry.

Relationship between Structural Defects and Free Electrons in Icosahedral Nanoclusters

According to the classic superatom model, metal nanoclusters with a "magic number" of free valence electrons display high stability, manifesting as the closed-shell-dependent electronic robustness. The icosahedral nanobuilding blocks containing eight free electrons were the most common in constructing metal nanoclusters; however, the structure defect-dependent variations of the free electron count in icosahedral configurations are still far from thorough research. Here, we reported a hydride-containing [Pt2Ag15(SAdm)4(DPPOE)4H]2+ nanocluster with two largely defective Pt1Ag8 icosahedral cores. Together with previously reported complete or slightly defective icosahedra in metal nanoclusters, the largely defective Pt1Ag8 core provided important clues to reveal the evolutionary mode of structural defects and free electrons in icosahedral nanoclusters; the free electron count of icosahedron was reduced two-by-two (i.e., from 8e to 6e and then to 4e) accompanied by the structure defection. Overall, the work presented a novel Pt2Ag15 nanocluster with a largely defective core structure that enables an atomic-level understanding of the relationship between structural defects and free electrons in icosahedral nanoclusters.

Chemical Flexibility of Atomically Precise Metal Clusters

Ligand-protected metal clusters possess hybrid properties that seamlessly combine an inorganic core with an organic ligand shell, imparting them exceptional chemical flexibility and unlocking remarkable application potential in diverse fields. Leveraging chemical flexibility to expand the library of available materials and stimulate the development of new functionalities is becoming an increasingly pressing requirement. This Review focuses on the origin of chemical flexibility from the structural analysis, including intra-cluster bonding, inter-cluster interactions, cluster-environments interactions, metal-to-ligand ratios, and thermodynamic effects. In the introduction, we briefly outline the development of metal clusters and explain the differences and commonalities of M(I)/M(I/0) coinage metal clusters. Additionally, we distinguish the bonding characteristics of metal atoms in the inorganic core, which give rise to their distinct chemical flexibility. Section 2 delves into the structural analysis, bonding categories, and thermodynamic theories related to metal clusters. In the following sections 3 to 7, we primarily elucidate the mechanisms that trigger chemical flexibility, the dynamic processes in transformation, the resultant alterations in structure, and the ensuing modifications in physical-chemical properties. Section 8 presents the notable applications that have emerged from utilizing metal clusters and their assemblies. Finally, in section 9, we discuss future challenges and opportunities within this area.

Effects of bromine-containing counterion salts in directing the structures of medium-sized silver nanoclusters

The preparation and structural determination of silver nanoclusters (especially the medium-sized Ag clusters) remain more challenging relative to those of their gold counterparts because of the comparative instability of the former. In this work, three medium-sized Ag clusters were controllably synthesized and structurally determined, namely, [Ag52(S-Adm)30Br4H20]2- (Ag52 for short), Ag54(S-Adm)30Br4H20 (Ag54 for short), and [Ag58(S-Adm)30Br4(NO3)2H22]2+ (Ag58 for short) nanoclusters. Specifically, the introduction of PPh4Br gave rise to the generation of Ag52 and Ag54 nanoclusters with homologous compositions and configurations, while the TOABr salt selected Ag58 as the sole cluster product, whose geometric structure was completely different from those of Ag52 and Ag54 nanoclusters. In addition, the optical absorptions and emissions of the three medium-sized silver nanoclusters were compared. The findings in this work not only provide three uniquely medium-sized nanoclusters to enrich the silver cluster family but also point out a new approach (i.e., changing the counterion salt) for the preparation of new nanoclusters with novel structures.

Parasitism in Metal Nanoclusters: A Case Study of (AuAg)25·(AuAg)27

Studying the interactions of atomically precise metal nanoclusters in their assembly systems is of great significance in the nanomaterial research field, which has attracted increasing interest in the last few decades. Herein, we report the cocrystallization of two oppositely charged atomically precise metal nanoclusters in one unit cell: [Au1Ag24(SR)18]- ((AuAg)25 for short) and [AuxAg27-x(Dppf)4(SR)9]2+ (x = 10-12; (AuAg)27 for short) with a 1:1 ratio. (AuAg)27 could maintain its structure in the presence of (AuAg)25, whether in the crystalline and the solution state, while the metastable (AuAg)27 component underwent a spontaneous transformation to (AuAg)16(Dppf)2(SR)8 after dissociating the (AuAg)25 component from this cocrystal, demonstrating the "parasitism" relationship of the (AuAg)27 component over (AuAg)25 in this dual-cluster system. This work enriches the family of cluster-based assemblies and elucidates the delicate relationship between nanoparticles of cocrystals.

Recent developments in the investigation of driving forces for transforming coinage metal nanoclusters

Metal nanoclusters serve as an emerging class of modular nanomaterials. The transformation of metal nanoclusters has been fully reflected in their studies from every aspect, including the structural evolution analysis, physicochemical property regulation, and practical application promotion. In this review, we highlight the driving forces for transforming atomically precise metal nanoclusters and summarize the related transforming principles and fundamentals. Several driving forces for transforming nanoclusters are meticulously reviewed herein: ligand-exchange-induced transformations, metal-exchange-induced transformations, intercluster reactions, photochemical transformations, oxidation/reduction-induced transformations, and other factors (intrinsic instability, pH, temperature, and metal salts) triggering transformations. The exploitation of transforming principles to customize the preparations, structures, physicochemical properties, and practical applications of metal nanoclusters is also disclosed. At the end of this review, we provide our perspectives and highlight the challenges remaining for future research on the transformation of metal nanoclusters. Our intended audience is the broader scientific community interested in metal nanoclusters, and we believe that this review will provide researchers with a comprehensive synthetic toolbox and insights on the research fundamentals needed to realize more cluster-based nanomaterials with customized compositions, structures, and properties.

Modular Cocrystallization of Customized Carboranylthiolate-Protected Copper Nanoclusters via Host-Guest Interactions

Cocrystals containing distinct atom-precise metal nanoclusters (NCs) provide an opportunity to elucidate the crystallization process, architectural complexity, and newly emerging properties of condensed-state metal NC-assembled materials. However, the controllable preparation of such cocrystals is still challenging. Herein, we present a modular strategy to cocrystallize two customized carboranylthiolate-protected copper NCs, Cu₁₄(C₂B₁₀H₁₀S₂)₆(CH₃CN)₆ (Cu₁₄) and Cu₁₆(C₂B₁₀H₁₀S₂)₈ (Cu₁₆), which adopt matched surface patterns by host-guest chemistry. The Cu₁₄·Cu₁₆ cocrystals show integrated UV-vis adsorption and dual emission stemming from the Cu₁₄ and Cu₁₆ NCs. Moreover, the component NCs are selectively doped by gold atoms, which is a promising way to incorporate diverse properties of metal cluster-based cocrystals. This work not only provides a copper NC-based cocrystal for a profound study on a condensed-state copper nanomaterial but also develops a modular strategy for the cocrystallization of metal NCs.

Understanding a ligand's effects on intra-cluster and inter-cluster assembly

Ligands play an essential role in cluster assembly; however, understanding this behavior at the atomic level is far off. In this work, Cd₁₂Ag₃₂(S-PhOMe)₃₆(PPh)₄@Cd₆Ag₂(S-PhOMe)₆Cl₆(PPh₃)₈@Ag₆(S-PhOMe)₆Cl₂ (Abbrev. Cd12Ag32-1) and Cd₁₂Ag₃₂(S-c-C₆H₁₁)₃₆ (Abbrev. Cd12Ag32-2) were synthesized and structurally determined by single-crystal X-ray diffraction. An important finding is the selective adsorption of phosphine ligands that is caused by the different types of thiol ligands. In addition, Cd12Ag32-1 follows a unique stacking pattern in a superlattice with multiple inter-cluster channels. Overall, this study is helpful for an in-depth understanding of the effect of mixed ligands on nanocluster formation and the correlation between structure and properties in the nanocluster range.

A Review of State of the Art in Phosphine Ligated Gold Clusters and Application in Catalysis

Atomically precise gold clusters are highly desirable due to their well-defined structure which allows the study of structure-property relationships. In addition, they have potential in technological applications such as nanoscale catalysis. The structural, chemical, electronic, and optical properties of ligated gold clusters are strongly defined by the metal-ligand interaction and type of ligands. This critical feature renders gold-phosphine clusters unique and distinct from other ligand-protected gold clusters. The use of multidentate phosphines enables preparation of varying core sizes and exotic structures beyond regular polyhedrons. Weak gold-phosphorous (Au-P) bonding is advantageous for ligand exchange and removal for specific applications, such as catalysis, without agglomeration. The aim of this review is to provide a unified view of gold-phosphine clusters and to present an in-depth discussion on recent advances and key developments for these clusters. This review features the unique chemistry, structural, electronic, and optical properties of gold-phosphine clusters. Advanced characterization techniques, including synchrotron-based spectroscopy, have unraveled substantial effects of Au-P interaction on the composition-, structure-, and size-dependent properties. State-of-the-art theoretical calculations that reveal insights into experimental findings are also discussed. Finally, a discussion of the application of gold-phosphine clusters in catalysis is presented.

Directional Doping and Cocrystallizing an Open-Shell Ag39 Superatom via Precursor Engineering

Metal precursors employed in the bottom-up synthesis of metal nanoclusters (NCs) are of great importance in directing their composition and geometrical structure. In this work, a silver nanocluster co-protected by phosphine and thiolate, namely, [Ag₃₉(PFBT)₂₄(TPP)₈]^2- (Ag₃₉, PFBT = pentafluorobenzenethiol, TPP = triphenylphosphine), was isolated and structurally characterized. It adopts a three-layered Ag₁₃@Ag₁₈@Ag₈S₂₄P₈ core-shell structure. The Ag₁₃@Ag₁₈ kernel is unusual in multilayer noble metal NCs. By introducing a copper precursor in the synthesis, a bimetallic nanocluster [Ag₃₇Cu₂(PFBT)₂₄(TPP)₈]^2- (Ag₃₇Cu₂) with an identical structure to Ag₃₉ apart from two outer Ag atoms being substituted by Cu atoms was obtained. Astoundingly, the Cu precursor used in the synthesis was found to be critical in determining the final structure. The alteration of the Cu precursor led to the cocrystallization of the above alloy nanocluster with a Ag₁₄ nanocluster, namely, [Ag₃₇Cu₂(PFBT)₂₄(TPP)₈]^2-·[Ag₁₄(PFBT)₆(TPP)₈] (Ag₃₇Cu₂·Ag₁₄). The electronic structure analyzed by theoretical calculation reveals that Ag₃₉ is a 17-electron open-shell superatom. The optical absorption of Ag₃₉, Ag₃₇Cu₂, and Ag₃₇Cu₂·Ag₁₄ was compared and studied in detail. This work not only enriches the family of alloy metallic nanoclusters but also provides a metal NC-based cocrystal platform for in-depth study of its crystal growth and photophysical property.

Structural determination of a metastable Ag27 nanocluster and its transformations into Ag8 and Ag29 nanoclusters

The atomically precise structure of a metastable nanocluster, Ag27H11(SPhMe2)12(DPPM)6, was determined, and its transformations into size-reduction Ag8 and size-growth Ag29 nanoclusters have been mapped out.