C-H oxidation in fluorenyl benzoates does not proceed through a stepwise pathway: revisiting asynchronous proton-coupled electron transfer

Reconciling Imbalanced and Nonadiabatic Reactivity in Transition Metal-Oxo-Mediated Concerted Proton Electron Transfer (CPET)

Recently, there have been several experimental demonstrations of how the rates of concerted proton electron transfer (CPET) are affected by stepwise thermodynamic parameters of only proton (ΔG°PT) or electron (ΔG°ET) transfer. Semiclassical structure-activity relationships have been invoked to rationalize these linear free energy relationships, but it is not clear how they would manifest in a nonadiabatic reaction. Using density functional theory calculations, we demonstrate how a decrease in ΔG°PT can lead to transition state imbalance in a nonadiabatic framework. We then use these calculations to anchor a theoretical model that reproduces experimental trends with ΔG°PT and ΔG°ET. Our results reconcile predictions from semiclassical transition state theory with models that treat proton transfer quantum mechanically in CPET reactivity, make new predictions about the importance of basicity for uphill CPET reactions, and suggest similar treatments may be possible for other nonadiabatic reactions.

The role of basicity in selective C-H bond activation by transition metal-oxidos

The development of (bio)catalysts capable of selectively activating strong C-H bonds is a continuing challenge in modern chemistry. In both metalloenzymes and synthetic systems capable of activating C-H bonds, transition metal-oxido intermediates serve as the active species for reactivity whose thermodynamic properties influence the bond strengths they are capable of activating. In this Frontier article, we present current ideas of how the basicity of transition metal-oxidos impacts their reactivity with C-H bonds and present new opportunities within this field. We highlight recent insights into the role basicity plays in the activation process and its influence on mechanism, as well as the important role that secondary coordination sphere effects, such as hydrogen bonds, in tuning the basicity of the metal-oxido species is discussed.

Testing the Limits of Imbalanced CPET Reactivity: Mechanistic Crossover in H-Atom Abstraction by Co(III)-Oxo Complexes

Transition metal-oxo complexes are key intermediates in a variety of oxidative transformations, notably C-H bond activation. The relative rate of C-H bond activation mediated by transition metal-oxo complexes is typically predicated on substrate bond dissociation free energy in cases with a concerted proton-electron transfer (CPET). However, recent work has demonstrated that alternative stepwise thermodynamic contributions such as acidity/basicity or redox potentials of the substrate/metal-oxo may dominate in some cases. In this context, we have found basicity-governed concerted activation of C-H bonds with the terminal CoIII-oxo complex PhB(tBuIm)3CoIIIO. We have been interested in testing the limits of such basicity-dependent reactivity and have synthesized an analogous, more basic complex, PhB(AdIm)3CoIIIO, and studied its reactivity with H-atom donors. This complex displays a higher degree of imbalanced CPET reactivity than PhB(tBuIm)3CoIIIO with C-H substrates, and O-H activation of phenol substrates displays mechanistic crossover to stepwise proton transfer-electron transfer (PTET) reactivity. Analysis of the thermodynamics of proton transfer (PT) and electron transfer (ET) reveals a distinct thermodynamic crossing point between concerted and stepwise reactivity. Furthermore, the relative rates of stepwise and concerted reactivity suggest that maximally imbalanced systems provide the fastest CPET rates up to the point of mechanistic crossover, which results in slower product formation.

Structural and Thermodynamic Effects on the Kinetics of C-H Oxidation by Multisite Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer in Fluorenyl Benzoates

Our recent experimental and theoretical investigations have shown that fluorene C-H bonds can be activated through a mechanism in which the proton and electron are transferred from the C-H bond to a separate base and oxidant in a concerted, elementary step. This multisite proton-coupled electron transfer (MS-PCET) mechanism for C-H bond activation was shown to be facilitated by shorter proton donor-acceptor distances. With the goal of intentionally modulating this donor-acceptor distance, we have now studied C-H MS-PCET in the 3-methyl-substituted fluorenyl benzoate (2-Flr-3-Me-BzO^-). This derivative was readily oxidized by ferrocenium oxidants by initial C-H MS-PCET, with rate constants that were 6-21 times larger than those for 2-Flr-BzO^- with the same oxidants. Structural comparisons by X-ray crystallography and by computations showed that addition of the 3-methyl group caused the expected steric compression; however, the relevant C···O^- proton donor-acceptor distance was longer, due to a twist of the carboxylate group. The structural changes induced by the 3-Me group increased the basicity of the carboxylate, weakened the C-H bond, and reduced the reorganization energy for C-H bond cleavage. Thus, the rate enhancement for 2-Flr-3-Me-BzO^- was due to effects on the thermochemistry and kinetic barrier, rather than from compression of the C···O^- proton donor-acceptor distance. These results highlight both the challenges of controlling molecules on the 0.1 Å length scale and the variety of parameters that affect PCET rate constants.