Being negative can be positive: metal oxide anions promise more selective methane to methanol conversion

Electronic structure of metal oxide dications with ammonia ligands and their reactivity towards the selective conversion of methane to methanol

High-level quantum chemical calculations are performed for the (NH3)MO2+ and (NH3)5MO2+ species (M = Ti-Cu), extending our previous work on the bare MO2+ ions. The potential energy curves along the M-O distance are constructed for the ground and multiple excited electronic states of (NH3)MO2+ and are compared to those of MO2+. We see that ammonia stabilizes the oxo states (M4+O2-) over the oxyl (M3+O⋅-) ones. This trend is intensified in the (NH3)5MO2+ species. We then examined the reaction of the latter species with both methane and methanol. We find that the oxyl states activate a C-H bond easily with barriers smaller than 10 kcal/mol across all first-row transition metals, while the barriers for the oxo states start from about 50 kcal/mol for M = Ti and decrease linearly to 10 kcal/mol going toward M = Ni. This is attributed to the increasing spin density on the oxygen atom observed for the oxo states. The most important finding is that the formation of hydrogen bonds between the OH group of methanol and the N-H bonds of the ammonia ligands increases the activation barriers for methanol considerably, making them comparable to and slightly higher than those of methane. This finding suggests a new strategy to slow the oxidation of methanol, leading to the long-desired higher methane-to-methanol selectivity.

Selective conversion of methane to methanol facilitated by molecular metal-methoxy complexes via a self-correcting chemical cycle

The controlled oxidation of methane to methanol has been an area of intense research over the past decades. Despite the efforts, the identification of an efficient catalyst with high selectivity is still elusive. Here we propose a thoroughly different strategy employing catalysts containing a metal methoxy unit. This family of catalysts has been used for the activation of C-H bonds but this is the first systematic investigation for the conversion of methane to methanol highlighting the advantages over the typically used metal oxides. Specifically, we start our investigation with an Fe(III) center coordinated by four ammonia ligands, (NH3)4FeOCH32+. Structures and energetics are reported for two mechanisms ([2+2] and proton coupled electrons transfer) and for different spin multiplicities via density functional theory, multi-reference, and coupled cluster quantum chemical calculations. The excited low-spin doublet state of this model system exhibits the best performance in terms of activation barriers and selectivity. Therefore, we then switched to the corresponding Ru(III) complex, which has a doublet ground state and manifests better performance than the doublet state of Fe(III). For both systems the activation barrier for methanol is larger than that of methane due to the interaction of the OH group of methanol with the coordinated NH3 ligands (hydrogen bonding) and/or the metal center. This observation suggests that the activation of methanol is slower, hindering its oxidation. In addition, we show that the metal-methoxy family of catalysts offers a potential mechanism that can prevent the oxidation of an activated methanol molecule (self-correcting chemical loop). This work aspires to induce experimental interest and pave the road for the development of high-performance high-selectivity methane to methanol direct conversion routes under mild conditions.

Potential of Molecular Catalysts with Electron-Rich Transition Metal Centers for Addressing Long-Standing Chemistry Enigmas

Molecular complexes with electron-rich metal centers are highlighted as potential catalysts for the following five important chemical transformations: selective conversion of methane to methanol, capture and utilization of carbon dioxide, fixation of molecular nitrogen, water splitting, and recycling of perfluorochemicals. Our initial focus lies on negatively charged metal centers and ligands that can stabilize anionic metal atoms. Catalysts with electron-rich metal atoms (CERMAs) can sustain catalytic cycles with a "ping-pong" mechanism, where one or more electrons are transferred from the metal center to the substrate and back. The donated electrons can activate the chemical bonds of the substrate by populating its antibonding orbitals. At the last step of the catalytic cycle, the electrons return to the metal and the product interacts only weakly with the formed anion, which enables the solvent molecules to remove the product fast from the catalytic cycle and prevent subsequent unfavorable reactions. This process resembles electrocatalysis, but the metal serves as both an anode and a cathode (molecular electrocatalysis). We also analyze the usage of CERMAs as the base of Frustrated Lewis pairs proposing a new type of bimetallic catalysts. This Featured Article aspires to initiate systematic experimental and theoretical studies on CERMAs and their reactivity, the potential of which has probably been underestimated in the literature.

Electronic Structure and Ligand Effects on the Activation and Cleavage of N2 on a Molybdenum Center

Dinitrogen fixation under ambient conditions remains a challenge in the field of catalytic chemistry due to the inertness of N2. Nitrogenases and heterogeneous solid catalysts have displayed remarkable performance in the catalytic conversion of dinitrogen to ammonia. By introduction of molybdenum centers in molecular complexes, one of the most azophilic metals of the transitional metal series, moderate ammonia yields have been attained. Here, we present a combined multiconfigurational/density functional theory study that addresses how ligand fields of different strengths affect the binding and activation of dinitrogen on molybdenum atoms. First, we explored with MRCI computations the diatomic Mo-N and triatomic Mo-N2 molecular systems. Then, we performed a systematic examination on the stabilization effects introduced by external NH3 ligands, before we explore model neutral and charged complexes with different types of ligands (H2O, NH3, and PH3) and their consequences on the N2 binding and activation.

Theoretical study of the saturation and nature of the hydrogen bonds to gold

Traditional hydrogen bonds are well-known to exhibit directionality and saturation. By contrast, gold involved hydrogen bonds (GHBs) have been extensively studied but remain lack of in-depth understanding towards the intrinsic nature and saturation property. This work exemplifies three series of complexes: [L-Au-L]-⋯(HF)n (L = H, CH3, (CH3)3; n = 1-8) containing GHBs to dig into the intrinsic nature with the aid of multiple theoretical analysis methods, finding that the formation of GHB is highly subject to orbital interactions along with steric hindrance. Moreover, the saturation level of GHBs largely depends on the ligand attached to the gold center, since different ligands typically possess varying electron-giving ability and steric volume. This work confirms the coexistence of as many as 6 GHBs for one Au atom and thoroughly studies the saturation level of GHBs, which will provide new insights into GHBs and facilitate future synthesis of more complicated gold complexes.

Computational Discovery of Stable Metal-Organic Frameworks for Methane-to-Methanol Catalysis

The challenge of direct partial oxidation of methane to methanol has motivated the targeted search of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) as a promising class of materials for this transformation because of their site-isolated metals with tunable ligand environments. Thousands of MOFs have been synthesized, yet relatively few have been screened for their promise in methane conversion. We developed a high-throughput virtual screening workflow that identifies MOFs from a diverse space of experimental MOFs that have not been studied for catalysis, yet are thermally stable, synthesizable, and have promising unsaturated metal sites for C-H activation via a terminal metal-oxo species. We carried out density functional theory calculations of the radical rebound mechanism for methane-to-methanol conversion on models of the secondary building units (SBUs) from 87 selected MOFs. While we showed that oxo formation favorability decreases with increasing 3d filling, consistent with prior work, previously observed scaling relations between oxo formation and hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) are disrupted by the greater diversity in our MOF set. Accordingly, we focused on Mn MOFs, which favor oxo intermediates without disfavoring HAT or leading to high methanol release energies─a key feature for methane hydroxylation activity. We identified three Mn MOFs comprising unsaturated Mn centers bound to weak-field carboxylate ligands in planar or bent geometries with promising methane-to-methanol kinetics and thermodynamics. The energetic spans of these MOFs are indicative of promising turnover frequencies for methane to methanol that warrant further experimental catalytic studies.

Transition metal oxide complexes as molecular catalysts for selective methane to methanol transformation: any prospects or time to retire?

Transition metal oxides have been extensively used in the literature for the conversion of methane to methanol. Despite the progress made over the past decades, no method with satisfactory performance or economic viability has been detected. The main bottleneck is that the produced methanol oxidizes further due to its weaker C-H bond than that of methane. Every improvement in the efficiency of a catalyst to activate methane leads to reduction of the selectivity towards methanol. Is it therefore prudent to keep studying (both theoretically and experimentally) metal oxides as catalysts for the quantitative conversion of methane to methanol? This perspective focuses on molecular metal oxide complexes and suggests strategies to bypass the current bottlenecks with higher weight on the computational chemistry side. We first discuss the electronic structure of metal oxides, followed by assessing the role of the ligands in the reactivity of the catalysts. For better selectivity, we propose that metal oxide anionic complexes should be explored further, while hydrophylic cavities in the vicinity of the metal oxide can perturb the transition-state structure for methanol increasing appreciably the activation barrier for methanol. We also emphasize that computational studies should target the activation reaction of methanol (and not only methane), the study of complete catalytic cycles (including the recombination and oxidation steps), and the use of molecular oxygen as an oxidant. The titled chemical conversion is an excellent challenge for theory and we believe that computational studies should lead the field in the future. It is finally shown that bottom-up approaches offer a systematic way for exploration of the chemical space and should still be applied in parallel with the recently popular machine learning techniques. To answer the question of the title, we believe that metal oxides should still be considered provided that we change our focus and perform more systematic investigations on the activation of methanol.