A study of one of the iron-sulphur clusters in oxidized hydrogenase from Megasphaera elsdenii by magnetic-circular-dichroism spectroscopy

Computational Studies of the H-Cluster of Fe-Only Hydrogenases: Geometric, Electronic, and Magnetic Properties and Their Dependence on the [Fe4S4] Cubane

The active sites of Fe-only hydrogenases (FeHases) feature an unusual polynuclear iron-sulfur cluster, known as the H-cluster, that consists of a [Fe4S4] cubane linked to a di-iron subunit (the [2Fe]H component) via a bridging cysteine ligand (SCys). While previous computational studies of FeHases employed H-cluster models that only included the [2Fe]H component, we have utilized density functional theory (DFT), in conjunction with the broken-symmetry (BS) approach, to explore the geometric, electronic, and magnetic properties of the entire H-cluster. These calculations have allowed us to evaluate, for the first time, the influence of the [Fe4S4] cubane on the [2Fe]H component of the H-cluster in its active (Hox) and CO-inhibited (Hox-CO) states, both of which are paramagnetic (S=1/2). Our results reveal that the presence of the cubane tunes both the position and the donor strength of the SCys ligand, which, in turn, modulates the internal geometric and electronic structures of the [2Fe]H subcluster. Importantly, the BS methodology provides an accurate description of the exchange interactions within the H-cluster, permitting insight into the electronic origin of the changes in magnetic properties observed experimentally upon conversion of Hox to Hox-CO. Specifically, while the unpaired spin density in the Hox state is localized on the distal Fe center, in the Hox-CO state, it is delocalized over the [2Fe]H component, such that the proximal Fe center acquires significant spin density (where distal and proximal refer to the positions of the Fe centers relative to the cubane). To validate our H-cluster models on the basis of experimental data, two DFT-based approaches and the semiempirical INDO/S method have been employed to compute electron paramagnetic resonance parameters for the H-cluster states. While most computations yield reasonably accurate g values and ligand hyperfine coupling constants (i.e., A values) for the Hox and Hox-CO states, they fail to reproduce the isotropic 57Fe A tensors found experimentally. Finally, extension of the computational methodology employed successfully for the Hox and Hox-CO states to the metastable Hoxphoto state, generated by irradiation of the Hox-CO state at cryogenic temperatures, has allowed us to discriminate between proposed structural models for this species.

Mössbauer and EPR studies of Azotobacter vinelandii ferredoxin I

Azotobacter vinelandii ferredoxin I (FdI) is a small protein that contains one Fe4S4 cluster and one Fe3S4 cluster. Previous studies of FdI have shown that the redox potential of the Fe3S4 cluster and the MCD and CD spectra of the reduced Fe3S4 cluster are pH-dependent. Using Mössbauer and EPR spectroscopy, we have studied FdI in different oxidation states and at different pH values. Here, we report the spin Hamiltonian parameters of the oxidized (S = 1/2) Fe3S4 cluster at pH 7.4 and the reduced (S = 2) Fe3S4 cluster at pH 6.0 and 8.5. The pH dependence observed by MCD is also evident in the Mössbauer spectra which show a change of the magnetic hyperfine tensor for one Fe site of the valence-delocalized pair. The Fe4S4 cluster is ligated by cysteines 20, 39, 42, and 45, but not by the adjacent cysteine 24. Treatment of FdI with 3 equiv of ferricyanide alters the Fe4S4 cluster, yielding a new species, [Fe4S4]'. The S = 1/2 EPR signal of [Fe4S4]' has previously been attributed to the formation of a cysteine disulfide radical from Cys24 and cluster sulfide. Here we show that the EPR signal is broadened by 57Fe, indicating that the electronic spin is significantly coupled to the cluster iron. Consistent with this, substantial magnetic hyperfine interactions are observed by Mössbauer spectroscopy. In addition, the average isomer shift of the four Fe sites is smaller for [Fe4S4]' than for [Fe4S4]2+, indicating that the oxidation is iron-based to at least some extent. Incubation of FdI with excess ferricyanide destroys the Fe4S4 cluster but leaves the Fe3S4 cluster intact. Our studies of (3Fe)FdI show that the S = 1/2 spin of the Fe3S4 cluster interacts with another paramagnet, presumably a radical generated at the site left vacant by the removal of the Fe4S4 cluster.

The hydrogen-tritium exchange activity of Megasphaera elsdenii hydrogenase

The hydrogenase of Megasphaera elsdenii was purified to a specific activity of 350 units/mg. The hydrogen-tritium exchange assay of Hallahan et al. [Hallahan, D.L., Fernandez, V. M., Hatchikian, E. C. and Hall, D. O. (1986) Biochimie (Paris) 68, 49-54] was adapted to allow its use in the study of the M. elsdenii hydrogenase preparation. Under the assay conditions routinely employed, the enzyme's exchange activity was inhibited by Tris/HCl and MgCl2; it was stimulated by ethylene glycol. Maximal activity in this standard assay occurred at pH 7.1. The effect of the concentration of molecular hydrogen (1H2 plus 3H1H) on the exchange activity was studied. The resulting double-reciprocal plot was linear; its slope and its intercepts on the ordinate and abscissa were pH-dependent. The rate equations for a number of models of the exchange activity were derived. Each model gave rise to a linear double-reciprocal plot at constant pH, but none could explain fully the observed effects of varying pH. The experimental data corresponded most closely to the predictions of models in which protons were treated both as substrates and as regulators of the enzyme's activity.

The structure and mechanism of iron-hydrogenases

Hydrogenases devoid of nickel and containing only Fe-S clusters have been found so far only in some strictly anaerobic bacteria. Four Fe-hydrogenases have been characterized: from Megasphaera elsdenii, Desulfovibrio vulgaris (strain Hildenborough), and two from Clostridium pasteurianum. All contain two or more [4Fe-4S]1+,2+ or F clusters and a unique type of Fe-S center termed the H cluster. The H cluster appears to be remarkably similar in all the hydrogenases, and is proposed as the site of H2 oxidation and H2 production. The F clusters serve to transfer electrons between the H cluster and the external electron carrier. In all of the hydrogenases the H cluster is comprised of at least three Fe atoms, and possibly six. In the oxidized state it contains two types of magnetically distinct Fe atoms, has an S = 1/2 spin state, and exhibits a novel rhombic EPR signal. The reduced cluster is diamagnetic (S = 0). The oxidized H cluster appears to undergo a conformation change upon reduction with H2 with an increase in Fe-Fe distances of about 0.5 A. Studies using resonance Raman, magnetic circular dichroism and electron spin echo spectroscopies suggest that the H cluster has significant non-sulfur coordination. The H cluster has two binding sites for CO, at least one of which can also bind O2. Binding to one site changes the EPR properties of the cluster and gives a photosensitive adduct, but does not affect catalytic activity. Binding to the other site, which only becomes exposed during the catalytic cycle, leads to loss of catalytic activity. Mechanisms of H2 activation and electron transfer are proposed to explain the effects of CO binding and the ability of one of the hydrogenases to preferentially catalyze H2 oxidation.

Hydrodynamic, structural and magnetic properties of Megasphaera elsdenii Fe hydrogenase reinvestigated

Megasphaera elsdenii hydrogenase has been purified to homogeneity using an FPLC procedure as the final step. The protein gives a single band in SDS/PAGE with an apparent molecular mass of 57-59 kDa. There is no second hydrogenase activity in the soluble fraction of M. elsdenii. The hydrodynamics of the enzyme have been compared to those of the two-subunit Fe hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Hildenborough) in the analytical ultracentrifuge using the absorption of the intrinsic iron-sulfur clusters as the monitor. Sedimentation-velocity experiments indicate the M. elsdenii enzyme (s20,w = 4.95 S) to be essentially globular, while the D. vulgaris enzyme (s20,w = 4.1 S) has a less symmetric shape. From the sedimentation equilibrium measurements under a variety of conditions an average molecular mass is calculated of 58 kDa (M. elsdenii) and 54 kDa (D. vulgaris), respectively. Pure, maximally active M. elsdenii hydrogenase has A405/A280 = 0.36 and has a specific H2-production activity of 400 mumol H2.min-1.(mg protein)-1 at 30 degrees C and pH 8.0. The enzyme contains some 13-18 iron and acid-labile sulfur ions/58-kDa monomer. Eight of these Fe-S are present as two electron-transferring ferredoxin-like cubanes with Em approximately greater than -0.3 V, as indicated by pH-dependent EPR spectroscopy on the H2-reduced enzyme. In the (re)oxidized state the remainder iron gives rise to a single S = 1/2 rhombic EPR signal. Hydrogen-production activity, content of remainder iron and rhombic EPR signal intensity are mutually correlated. Purified hydrogenase appears to exist as a mixture of fully active holoenzyme and inactive protein still carrying the two cubanes but deficient in active-site iron.

EPR of a novel high-spin component in activated hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Hildenborough)

The EPR of reoxidized hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio vulgaris (H.) has been reinvestigated. In contrast to other workers [(1984) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 3728-3732] we find the axial signal with g = 2.06; 2.01 to be only a minor component of concentration 0.03 spin/mol. In the spectrum of fully active reoxidized enzyme this signal is overshadowed by a rhombic signal (0.1 spin/mol) with g = 2.11; 2.05; 2.00 reminiscent of the only signal found for other oxidized bidirectional hydrogenases. In addition, a novel signal has been detected with geff = 5.0 which, under the assumptions that S = 2 and [delta ms] = 2, quantitates to roughly one spin/mol. Ethylene glycol affects the relative intensity of the different signals. It is suggested that O2 sensitization parallels a spin-state transition of an iron-sulfur cluster.

On the novel H2-activating iron-sulfur center of the "Fe-only" hydrogenases

The two hydrogenases (I and II) of the anaerobic N2-fixing bacterium Clostridium pasteurianum (Cp) and the hydrogenases of the anaerobes Megasphaera elsdenii (Me) and Desulfovibrio vulgaris (strain Hildenborough, Dv), contain iron-sulfur clusters but not nickel. They are the most active hydrogenases known. All four enzymes in their reduced states give rise to EPR signals typical of [4Fe-4S]1+ clusters but exhibit novel EPR signals in their oxidized states. For example, Cp hydrogenase I exhibits a sharp rhombic EPR signal when oxidized under mild conditions but the enzyme is inactivated by over-oxidation and then exhibits an axial EPR signal. A similar axial signal is observed from mildly oxidized hydrogenase I after treatment with CO. EPR, Mössbauer and ENDOR spectroscopy indicate that the EPR signals from the oxidized enzyme and its CO derivative arise from a novel spin-coupled Fe center. Low temperature magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) studies reveal that an EPR-silent Fe-S cluster with S greater than 1/2 is also present in oxidized hydrogenase I. From a study of all spectroscopic properties of Cp, Dv, and Me hydrogenases, it is concluded that the H2-activating site of all four is a novel Fe-S cluster with S greater than 0 and integer, which in the oxidized state is exchange-coupled to a S = 1/2 species. The data are most consistent with the S = 1/2 species being a low spin Fe(III) center. The H2-activating site is susceptible to oxidative rearrangements to yield both active and inactive states of the enzyme. We discuss the possible implications of these finding to methods of enzyme oxidation and purification procedures currently used for hydrogenases.