Molecular mechanism of RNA-phage morphogenesis

A novel delivery platform based on Bacteriophage MS2 virus-like particles

•

Here we reviewed Bacteriophage MS2 virus-like particles, including introduction to their structure, their potential as a delivery platform, and their expected use in medicine and other fields.

•

Bacteriophage MS2 virus-like particles represent the novel delivery platform.

•

Bacteriophage MS2 virus-like particles possess promising application prospect.

Our objective here is to review the novel delivery platform based on Bacteriophage MS2 virus-like particles (VLPs), including introduction to their structure, their potential as a delivery platform, and their expected use in medicine and other fields. Bacteriophage MS2 VLPs are nanoparticles devoid of viral genetic material and can self-assemble from the coat protein into an icosahedral capsid. As a novel delivery platform, they possess numerous features that make them suitable and attractive for targeted delivery of RNAs or DNAs, epitope peptides, and drugs within the protein capsid. In short, as a novel delivery platform, MS2 VLPs are suitable for delivery of targeted agents and hold promise for use in diagnostics, vaccines, and therapeutic modalities.

Structure and stability of icosahedral particles of a covalent coat protein dimer of bacteriophage MS2

Particles formed by the bacteriophage MS2 coat protein mutants with insertions in their surface loops induce a strong immune response against the inserted epitopes. The covalent dimers created by fusion of two copies of the coat protein gene are more tolerant to various insertions into the surface loops than the single subunits. We determined a 4.7-A resolution crystal structure of an icosahedral particle assembled from covalent dimers and compared its stability with wild-type virions. The structure resembled the wild-type virion except for the intersubunit linker regions. The covalent dimer orientation was random with respect to both icosahedral twofold and quasi-twofold symmetry axes. A fraction of the particles was unstable in phosphate buffer because of assembly defects. Our results provide a structural background for design of modified covalent coat protein dimer subunits for use in immunization.

Assembly of mixed rod-like and spherical particles from group I and II RNA bacteriophage coat proteins

The capsids of single-stranded RNA bacteriophages show remarkable structural similarity. In an attempt to test whether the coat protein (CP) from one bacteriophage could substitute for the CP of another and form mixed particles, we reassembled capsids in vitro from a mixture of different RNA phage CP dimers together with E. coli ribosomal RNA. Surprisingly, mixing CPs from phages belonging to groups I and II led to appearance of rod-like particles along with icosahedral spherical capsids, both containing a mixture of the two CPs. Rods and mixed spherical capsids containing host RNA were also obtained in vivo in bacteria expressing simultaneously fr and GA CPs. In a co-infection of the two phages, however, only authentic fr and GA virions were formed. Coat protein mutants in the FG loop were unable to assemble into rods, suggesting that these loops are involved in the formation of the aberrant particles.

RNase-resistant virus-like particles containing long chimeric RNA sequences produced by two-plasmid coexpression system

RNase-resistant, noninfectious virus-like particles containing exogenous RNA sequences (armored RNA) are good candidates as RNA controls and standards in RNA virus detection. However, the length of RNA packaged in the virus-like particles with high efficiency is usually less than 500 bases. In this study, we describe a method for producing armored L-RNA. Armored L-RNA is a complex of MS2 bacteriophage coat protein and RNA produced in Escherichia coli by the induction of a two-plasmid coexpression system in which the coat protein and maturase are expressed from one plasmid and the target RNA sequence with modified MS2 stem-loop (pac site) is transcribed from another plasmid. A 3V armored L-RNA of 2,248 bases containing six gene fragments-hepatitis C virus, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus (SARS-CoV1, SARS-CoV2, and SARS-CoV3), avian influenza virus matrix gene (M300), and H5N1 avian influenza virus (HA300)-was successfully expressed by the two-plasmid coexpression system and was demonstrated to have all of the characteristics of armored RNA. We evaluated the 3V armored L-RNA as a calibrator for multiple virus assays. We used the WHO International Standard for HCV RNA (NIBSC 96/790) to calibrate the chimeric armored L-RNA, which was diluted by 10-fold serial dilutions to obtain samples containing 10(6) to 10(2) copies. In conclusion, the approach we used for armored L-RNA preparation is practical and could reduce the labor and cost of quality control in multiplex RNA virus assays. Furthermore, we can assign the chimeric armored RNA with an international unit for quantitative detection.

Dissecting the role of protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions in MS2 bacteriophage stability

To investigate the role of protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions in virus assembly, we compared the stabilities of native bacteriophage MS2, virus-like particles (VLPs) containing nonviral RNAs, and an assembly-defective coat protein mutant (dlFG) and its single-chain variant (sc-dlFG). Physical (high pressure) and chemical (urea and guanidine hydrochloride) agents were used to promote virus disassembly and protein denaturation, and the changes in virus and protein structure were monitored by measuring tryptophan intrinsic fluorescence, bis-ANS probe fluorescence, and light scattering. We found that VLPs dissociate into capsid proteins that remain folded and more stable than the proteins dissociated from authentic particles. The proposed model is that the capsid disassembles but the protein remains bound to the heterologous RNA encased by VLPs. The dlFG dimerizes correctly, but fails to assemble into capsids, because it lacks the 15-amino acid FG loop involved in inter-dimer interactions at the viral fivefold and quasi-sixfold axes. This protein was very unstable and, when compared with the dissociation/denaturation of the VLPs and the wild-type virus, it was much more susceptible to chemical and physical perturbation. Genetic fusion of the two subunits of the dimer in the single-chain dimer sc-dlFG stabilized the protein, as did the presence of 34-bp poly(GC) DNA. These studies reveal mechanisms by which interactions in the capsid lattice can be sufficiently stable and specific to ensure assembly, and they shed light on the processes that lead to the formation of infectious viral particles.

Visualization by cryo-electron microscopy of genomic RNA that binds to the protein capsid inside bacteriophage MS2

The icosahedrally symmetrized structure of bacteriophage MS2 as determined by cryo-electron microscopy (EM) reveals the presence of genomic RNA that attaches to coat-protein dimers. Earlier X-ray diffraction studies revealed similar interactions between the unique operator hairpin of the MS2 genomic RNA and the coat-protein dimer. This observation leads us to conclude that not only the operator, but also many other RNA sequences in the genome of MS2, are able to bind to the coat-protein dimer. A substantial number of potential coat-protein-dimer binding sites are present in the genome of MS2 that can account for the observed RNA densities in the EM map. Moreover, it appears that these stem-loop structures are able to bind in a similar fashion to the coat protein dimer as the wild-type operator hairpin. The EM map also shows additional density between the potential operator-binding sites, linking the RNA stem-loops together to form an icosahedral network around the 3 and 5-fold axes. This RNA network is bound to the inside of the MS2 capsid and probably influences both capsid stability and formation, supporting the idea that capsid formation and RNA packaging are intimately linked to each other.

Isolation of viral coat protein mutants with altered assembly and aggregation properties

A method was developed to screen bacteria for synthesis of mutant proteins with altered assembly and solubility properties using bacteriophage MS2 coat protein as a model self-associating protein. Colonies expressing coat protein from a plasmid were covered with an agarose overlay under conditions that caused the lysis of some of the cells in each colony. The proteins thus liberated diffused through the overlay at rates depending on their molecular sizes. After transfer of the proteins to a nitrocellulose membrane, probing with coat protein-specific antiserum revealed spots whose sizes and intensities were related to the aggregation state of coat protein. The method was employed in the isolation of assembly defective mutants and to find soluble variants of an aggregation-prone coat protein mutant.

Probing the kinetics of formation of the bacteriophage MS2 translational operator complex: identification of a protein conformer unable to bind RNA

We have investigated the kinetics of complex formation between bacteriophage MS2 coat protein subunits and synthetic RNA fragments encompassing the natural translational operator site, or the consensus sequences of three distinct RNA aptamer families, which are known to bind to the same site on the protein. Reactions were assayed using stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopy and either the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of the protein or the signals from RNA fragments site-specifically substituted with the fluorescent adenosine analogue 2'-deoxy, 2-aminopurine. The kinetics observed were independent of the fluorophore being monitored or its position within the complex, indicating that the data report global events occurring during complex formation. Competition assays show that the complex being formed consists of a single coat protein dimer and one RNA molecule. The binding reaction is at least biphasic. The faster phase, constituting 80-85 % of the amplitude, is a largely diffusion driven RNA-protein interaction (k1 approximately 2x10(9) M(-1) s(-1)). The salt dependence of the forward reaction and the similarities of the on-rates of lower-affinity RNA fragments are consistent with a diffusion-controlled step dominated by electrostatic steering. The slower phase is independent of reactant concentration, and appears to correspond to isomerisation of the coat protein subunit(s) prior to RNA binding (k(iso) approximately 0.23 s(-1)). Measurements with a coat protein mutant (Pro78Asn) show that this phase is not due to cis-trans isomerisation at this residue. The conformational changes in the protein ligand during formation of an RNA-protein complex might play a role in the triggering of capsid self-assembly and a model for this is discussed.

Structure of phage fr capsids with a deletion in the FG loop: implications for viral assembly

The loop between beta-strands F and G in the coat protein of small RNA bacteriophages forms the interactions at the fivefold and threefold (quasi-sixfold) icosahedral axes. In many cases, mutations in this region renders the coat protein unable to form capsids. This FG loop has therefore been suggested to be of major importance for the virus assembly process by guiding the assembly and helping to define the correct curvature of the virus shell. We have determined the crystal structure of a phage fr capsid where the coat protein has a four-residue deletion in the FG loop. This mutant retains the ability to form virus capsids of normal size but has a significantly lower temperature stability than the wild type. The structure reveals that the mutated loops are flexible and too short to interact with each other. This seems incompatible with a role of the FG loop in the regulation of capsid size.

Dissecting the key recognition features of the MS2 bacteriophage translational repression complex

The MS2 RNA operator capsid offers an unparalleled opportunity to study sequence-specific protein-protein and RNA-protein interactions in molecular detail. RNA molecules encompassing the minimal translational operator recognition elements can be soaked into crystals of RNA-free coat protein shells, allowing the RNA to access the interior of the capsids and make contact with the operator binding sites. Correct interpretation of these structural studies depends critically on functional analysis in solution to confirm that the interactions seen in the crystal are not an artefact of the unusual approach used to generate the RNA-protein complexes. Here we present a series of in vivo and in vitro functional assays, using coat proteins carrying single amino acid substitutions at residues which either interact with the operator RNA or are involved in stabilizing the conformation of the FG loop, the site of the major quasi-equivalent conformational change. Variant operator RNAs have been assayed for coat protein affinity in vitro. The results reveal the robustness of the operator-coat protein interaction and the requirement for both halves of a protein dimer to contact RNA in order to achieve tight binding. They also suggest that there may be a direct link between the conformation of the FG loop and RNA binding.

Crystal structures of MS2 coat protein mutants in complex with wild-type RNA operator fragments

In MS2 assembly of phage particles results from an interaction between a coat protein dimer and a stem-loop of the RNA genome (the operator hairpin). Amino acid residues Thr45, which is universally conserved among the small RNA phages, and Thr59 are part of the specific RNA binding pocket and interact directly with the RNA; the former through a hydrogen bond, the latter through hydrophobic contacts. The crystal structures of MS2 protein capsids formed by mutants Thr45Ala and Thr59Ser, both with and without the 19 nt wild-type operator hairpin bound, are reported here. The RNA hairpin binds to these mutants in a similar way to its binding to wild-type protein. In a companion paper both mutants are shown to be deficient in RNA binding in an in vivo assay, but in vitro the equilibrium dissociation constant is significantly higher than wild-type for the Thr45Ala mutant. The change in binding affinity of the Thr45Ala mutant is probably a direct consequence of removal of direct hydrogen bonds between the protein and the RNA. The properties of the Thr59Ser mutant are more difficult to explain, but are consistent with a loss of non-polar contact.

The crystal structure of bacteriophage GA and a comparison of bacteriophages belonging to the major groups of Escherichia coli leviviruses

The three-dimensional structure of the small T=3 RNA bacteriophage GA has been determined at 3.4 A resolution. The structure was solved by molecular replacement, using the phage MS2 as an initial model. A comparison of the protein shells of the four related phages GA, MS2, fr and Qbeta was carried out in order to define structural features of particular importance for their assembly and specific RNA interaction. A high degree of similarity was found in the RNA binding sites, whereas larger structural differences are located in the loop regions of the coat proteins, especially in the FG loops forming 5-fold and quasi-6-fold contacts. The overall arrangement of the protein subunits in the shells of these phages is very similar, although the details of the interactions differ. The few conserved interactions are suggested to govern the subunit packing during assembly.

The three-dimensional structures of two complexes between recombinant MS2 capsids and RNA operator fragments reveal sequence-specific protein-RNA interactions

Crystal structures of two complexes between recombinant MS2 capsids and RNA operator fragments have been determined at 2.7 A resolution. The coat protein of the RNA bacteriophage MS2 is bifunctional; it forms the icosahedral virus shell to protect the viral nucleic acid and it acts as a translational repressor by binding with high specificity to a unique site on the RNA, a single stem-loop structure, containing the initiation codon of the gene for the viral replicase. In order to determine the structure of these protein-RNA complexes, we have used chemically synthesized variants of the stem-loop fragment and soaked them into crystals of recombinant capsids. The RNA stem-loop, as bound to the protein, forms a crescent-like structure and interacts with the surface of the beta-sheet of a coat protein dimer. It makes protein contacts with seven phosphate groups on the 5' side of the stem-loop, with a pyrimidine base at position -5, which stacks onto a tyrosine, and with two exposed adenine bases, one in the loop and one at a bulge in the stem. Replacement of the wild-type uridine with a cytosine at position -5 increases the affinity of the RNA to the dimer significantly. The complex with RNA stem-loop having cytosine at this position differs from that of the wild-type complex mainly by having one extra intramolecular RNA interaction and one extra water-mediated hydrogen bond.

Analysis of phage MS2 coat protein mutants expressed from a reconstituted phagemid reveals that proline 78 is essential for viral infectivity

A full-length cDNA copy of the RNA genome of bacteriophage MS2 was assembled by the in-frame ligation of the central portion of the genome into a plasmid containing the 5' and 3' ends. Upon transformation of the ligation reaction into Escherichia coli, infectious phage particles were released into the medium. The plaquing ability of the phage produced from the cDNA construct was assessed against various bacterial strains confirming that the bacteriophage produced were male-specific. Sensitivity to RNase in agar overlay was used to confirm that the phage contained RNA. In addition, the phage were unable to infect piliated cells overexpressing MS2 coat protein, a resistance conferred by the binding of recombinant coat protein to the infecting strand of RNA at the replicase initiation region, thus preventing translation of the replicase gene. The phage capsids were visualised after negative staining by transmission electron microscopy, and appeared as spherical particles of approximately 25 nm diameter. The capsid proteins were examined by Western blotting, confirming the presence of a single protein of approximately 14 kDa, which bound anti-MS2 coat protein antibodies. The genomic RNA from single plaques was analysed by reverse transcription-PCR and the presence of the MS2 coat protein gene confirmed by DNA sequencing. The production of replicative MS2 phage from cDNA fragments was used to assess the viability of MS2 coat protein mutants, which had previously been shown to assemble into T = 3 capsid-like particles when expressed in vivo from a bacterial vector. The E76D mutation did not appear to affect phage viability, whilst replacement of the completely conserved P78 residue with asparagine abolished the production of infectious particles, suggesting that P78 may be involved in interactions with the phage maturation protein.

Crystal structure of the coat protein from the GA bacteriophage: model of the unassembled dimer

There are four groups of RNA bacteriophages with distinct antigenic and physicochemical properties due to differences in surface residues of the viral coat proteins. Coat proteins also play a role as translational repressor during the viral life cycle, binding an RNA hairpin within the genome. In this study, the first crystal structure of the coat protein from a Group II phage GA is reported and compared to the Group I MS2 coat protein. The structure of the GA dimer was determined at 2.8 A resolution (R-factor = 0.20). The overall folding pattern of the coat protein is similar to the Group I MS2 coat protein in the intact virus (Golmohammadi R, Valegård K, Fridborg K, Liljas L. 1993, J Mol Biol 234:620-639) or as an unassembled dimer (Ni Cz, Syed R, Kodandapani R. Wickersham J, Peabody DS, Ely KR, 1995, Structure 3:255-263). The structures differ in the FG loops and in the first turn of the alpha A helix. GA and MS2 coat proteins differ in sequence at 49 of 129 amino acid residues. Sequence differences that contribute to distinct immunological and physical properties of the proteins are found at the surface of the intact virus in the AB and FG loops. There are six differences in potential RNA contact residues within the RNA-binding site located in an antiparallel beta-sheet across the dimer interface. Three differences involve residues in the center of this concave site: Lys/Arg 83, Ser/Asn 87, and Asp/Glu 89. Residue 87 was shown by molecular genetics to define RNA-binding specificity by GA or MS2 coat protein (Lim F. Spingola M, Peabody DS, 1994, J Biol Chem 269:9006-9010). This sequence difference reflects recognition of the nucleotide at position -5 in the unpaired loop of the translational operators bound by these coat proteins. In GA, the nucleotide at this position is a purine whereas in MS2, it is a pyrimidine.

Probing sequence-specific RNA recognition by the bacteriophage MS2 coat protein

We present the results of in vitro binding studies aimed at defining the key recognition elements on the MS2 RNA translational operator (TR) essential for complex formation with coat protein. We have used chemically synthesized operators carrying modified functional groups at defined nucleotide positions, which are essential for recognition by the phage coat protein. These experiments have been complemented with modification-binding interference assays. The results confirm that the complexes which form between TR and RNA-free phage capsids, the X-ray structure of which has recently been reported at 3.0 A, are identical to those which form in solution between TR and a single coat protein dimer. There are also effects on operator affinity which cannot be explained simply by the alteration of direct RNA-protein contacts and may reflect changes in the conformational equilibrium of the unliganded operator. The results also provide support for the approach of using modified oligoribonucleotides to investigate the details of RNA-ligand interactions.

Crystal structure of the MS2 coat protein dimer: implications for RNA binding and virus assembly

BACKGROUND

The coat protein in RNA bacteriophages binds and encapsidates viral RNA, and also acts as translational repressor of viral replicase by binding to an RNA hairpin in the RNA genome. Because of its dual function, the MS2 coat protein is an interesting candidate for structural studies of protein-RNA interactions and protein-protein interactions. In this study, unassembled MS2 coat protein dimers were selected to analyze repressor activity and virus assembly.

RESULTS

The crystal structure of a mutant MS2 coat protein that is defective in viral assembly yet retains repressor activity has been determined at 2.0 A resolution. The unassembled dimer is stabilized by interdigitation of alpha-helices, and the formation of a 10-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet across the interface between monomers. The substitution of arginine for tryptophan at residue 82 results in the formation of two new inter-subunit hydrogen bonds that further stabilize the dimer. Residues that influence RNA recognition, identified by molecular genetics, were located across the beta-sheet. Two of these residues (Tyr85 and Asn87) are displaced in the unliganded dimer and are located in the same beta-strand as the Trp-->Arg mutation.

CONCLUSIONS

When compared with the structure of the coat protein in the assembled virus, differences in orientation of residues 85 and 87 suggest conformational adjustment on binding RNA in the first step of viral assembly. The substitution at residue 82 may affect virus assembly by imposing conformational restriction on the loop that makes critical inter-subunit contacts in the capsid.

Crystal structure of an RNA bacteriophage coat protein-operator complex

The RNA bacteriophage MS2 is a convenient model system for the study of protein-RNA interactions. The MS2 coat protein achieves control of two distinct processes--sequence-specific RNA encapsidation and repression of replicase translation--by binding to an RNA stem-loop structure of 19 nucleotides containing the initiation codon of the replicase gene. The binding of a coat protein dimer to this hairpin shuts off synthesis of the viral replicase, switching the viral replication cycle to virion assembly rather than continued replication. The operator fragment alone can trigger self-assembly of the phage capsid at low protein concentrations and a complex of about 90 RNA operator fragments per protein capsid has been described. We report here the crystal structure at 3.0 A resolution of a complex between recombinant MS2 capsids and the 19-nucleotide RNA fragment. It is the first example of a structure at this resolution for a sequence-specific protein-RNA complex apart from the transfer RNA synthetase complexes. The structure shows sequence-specific interactions between conserved residues on the protein and RNA bases essential for binding.

Molecular mechanism of RNA phage morphogenesis

Recent progress on the molecular mechanism of RNA phage morphogenesis is described. Functional studies, both in vivo and in vitro, are correlated with the latest structural studies on phages, their capsids and the assembly initiation RNA stem-loop.

Synthetic oligoribonucleotides carrying site-specific modifications for RNA structure-function analysis

Synthetic oligoribonucleotides have become increasingly valuable in studies of RNA structure and function. A range of nucleotide analogues is available which carry modifications in the base, sugar or phosphate moieties. Such analogues have been incorporated into synthetic RNA structures to eliminate or alter individual functional groups in the RNA which potentially can take part in hydrogen-bonding or other non-covalent interactions. Comparisons of the properties of the modified RNAs with unmodified RNA models allow conclusions to be drawn concerning the importance or otherwise of specific functional groups within the RNA. These methods have been applied to studies of RNA interactions with proteins, RNA catalysis and RNA structure.

Effects of amino acid substitution on the thermal stability of MS2 capsids lacking genomic RNA

The thermal stability of capsids of the bacteriophage MS2, lacking genomic RNA, has been investigated using electron microscopy. Coat protein mutants with amino acid substitutions at residues involved in making contracts at both inter-molecular interfaces and within the coat protein submit are also capable of forming 'empty' capsids of the same size and symmetry as the wild-type protein. Mutations have been characterised which are neutral, deleterious or advantageous in terms of thermal stability. In some cases, the results can be rationalised by reference to the recently refined X-ray crystal structure of the wild-type particle.