The analysis of ancestry with small-scale forensic panels of genetic markers

Comparative evaluation of the MAPlex, Precision ID Ancestry Panel, and VISAGE Basic Tool for biogeographical ancestry inference

Biogeographical ancestry (BGA) inference from ancestry-informative markers (AIMs) has strong potential to support forensic investigations. Over the past two decades, several forensic panels composed of AIMs have been developed to predict ancestry at a continental scale. These panels typically comprise fewer than 200 AIMs and have been designed and tested with a limited set of populations. How well these panels recover patterns of genetic diversity relative to larger sets of markers, and how accurately they infer ancestry of individuals and populations not included in their design remains poorly understood. The lack of comparative studies addressing these aspects makes the selection of appropriate panels for forensic laboratories difficult. In this study, the model-based genetic clustering tool STRUCTURE was used to compare three popular forensic BGA panels: MAPlex, Precision ID Ancestry Panel (PIDAP), and VISAGE Basic Tool (VISAGE BT) relative to a genome-wide reference set of 10k SNPs. The genotypes for all these markers were obtained for a comprehensive set of 3957 individuals from 228 worldwide human populations. Our results indicate that at the broad continental scale (K=6) typically examined in forensic studies, all forensic panels produced similar genetic structure patterns compared to the reference set (G'≈90%) and had high classification performance across all regions (average AUC-PR > 97%). However, at K= 7 and K= 8, the forensic panels displayed some region-specific clustering deviations from the reference set, particularly in Europe and the region of East and South-East Asia, which may be attributed to differences in the design of the respective panels. Overall, the panel with the most consistent performance in all regions was VISAGE BT with an average weighted AUC̅_W score of 96.26% across the three scales of geographical resolution investigated.

Challenges in the recovery of the genetic data from human remains found on the Western Balkan migration route

Traditional DNA-based identification of human remains relies on the system of matching STR profile of the deceased with the family references or antemortem samples. In forensic cases without any available samples for the comparison, the body remains unidentified. The aim of this study was to assess the applicability of massively parallel sequencing (MPS) approach in the forensic cases of five drowned individuals recovered on the Western Balkan migration route. Besides capillary electrophoresis (CE)-based genetic profiling (aSTR, Y STR, and mitochondrial control region sequencing) of postmortem samples, we applied ForenSeq DNA Signature Prep Kit/Primer Mix B on MiSeqFGx platform and concomitant ForenSeq Universal Analysis (UAS) software. The assay showed high reproducibility and complete concordance with CE-based data except in locus DYF387S1. Allele and locus drop was evident in 2.9% of total SNPs that slightly reduced the completeness of the data. We endeavored to predict the phenotype of the tested samples and accurate biogeographical ancestry of European individual. UAS was less informative for the remaining samples assigned to Admixed American cluster. Nevertheless, the application of FROG-kb and Snipper tools along with admixture analysis in STRUCTURE and lineage markers revealed likely Middle Eastern and North African ancestry. We conclude that the combination of the phenotype and biogeographical ancestry predictions, including paternal and maternal genetic ancestry, represent a promising tool for humanitarian identification of dead migrants. Nevertheless, the data interpretation remains a challenging task.

Development and Performance Evaluation of a Novel Ancestry Informative DIP Panel for Continental Origin Inference

Ancestry informative markers (AIMs) are useful to infer individual biogeographical ancestry and to estimate admixture proportions of admixed populations or individuals. Although a growing number of AIM panels for forensic ancestry origin analyses were developed, they may not efficiently infer the ancestry origins of most populations in China. In this study, a set of 52 ancestry informative deletion/insertion polymorphisms (AIDIPs) were selected with the aim of effectively differentiate continental and partial Chinese populations. All of the selected markers were successfully incorporated into a single multiplex PCR panel, which could be conveniently and efficiently detected on capillary electrophoresis platforms. Genetic distributions of the same 50 AIDIPs in different continental populations revealed that most loci showed high genetic differentiations between East Asian populations and other continental populations. Population genetic analyses of different continental populations indicated that these 50 AIDIPs could clearly discriminate East Asian, European, and African populations. In addition, the 52 AIDIPs also exhibited relatively high cumulative discrimination power in the Eastern Han population, which could be used as a supplementary tool for forensic investigation. Furthermore, the Eastern Han population showed close genetic relationships with East Asian populations and high ancestral components from East Asian populations. In the future, we need to investigate genetic distributions of these 52 AIDIPs in Chinese Han populations in different regions and other ethnic groups, and further evaluate the power of these loci to differentiate different Chinese populations.

Cold cases and ancient trade routes: DNA phenotyping and isotope analysis extend forensic science into new domains

New technologies in forensic science often find other scientific and commercial applications beyond assisting criminal investigators.