Effects of adenoidectomy on the speech of children with potential velopharyngeal dysfunction

Surgical Treatment for Palatoglossal Arch Cicatrix and Velopharyngeal Insufficiency After Adenotonsillectomy

Postadenotonsillectomy velopharyngeal incompetence/insufficiency/dysfunction (VPI) is an uncommon but potentially surgically challenging problem. We report a child without cleft palate who developed severe palatoglossal arch cicatrix and VPI after adenotonsillectomy, and describe bilateral palatoglossal arch z-plasty to restore palatal function and speech.

Effects of Velopharyngeal Incompetence on Speech

This article begins with a presentation of the author's classification of velopharyngeal disorders. The taxonomy uses the term velopharyngeal inadequacy as generic to all varieties of velopharyngeal function impairments and the classification distinguishes between those impairments of structural etiology (the insufficiencies) and those of primary neuromotor origin (the incompetencies). This introductory material is followed by a discussion of the speech consequences of velopharyngeal inadequacy which includes an indepth presentation of compensatory articulation types and error patterns, and offers pertinent diagnostic guidelines for their assessment. The article concludes with a discussion of the effects of velopharyngeal insufficiency on speech sound learning with specific reference to the type and timing of initial palatoplasty and the role of early speech intervention.

Speech outcomes after tonsillectomy in patients with known velopharyngeal insufficiency

Introduction. Controversy exists over whether tonsillectomy will affect speech in patients with known velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI), particularly in those with cleft palate. Methods. All patients seen at the OHSU Doernbecher Children's Hospital VPI clinic between 1997 and 2010 with VPI who underwent tonsillectomy were reviewed. Speech parameters were assessed before and after tonsillectomy. Wilcoxon rank-sum testing was used to evaluate for significance. Results. A total of 46 patients with VPI underwent tonsillectomy during this period. Twenty-three had pre- and postoperative speech evaluation sufficient for analysis. The majority (87%) had a history of cleft palate. Indications for tonsillectomy included obstructive sleep apnea in 11 (48%) and staged tonsillectomy prior to pharyngoplasty in 10 (43%). There was no significant difference between pre- and postoperative speech intelligibility or velopharyngeal competency in this population. Conclusion. In this study, tonsillectomy in patients with VPI did not significantly alter speech intelligibility or velopharyngeal competence.

Endoscopic partial adenoidectomy for children with submucous cleft palate

OBJECTIVE

Children with submucous cleft palate who suffer from chronic nasal obstruction because of hypertrophic adenoids usually are not subjected to adenoidectomy because of the fear of postoperative velopharyngeal insufficiency. These patients present a therapeutic challenge because we are aware more than ever of the importance of normal nasal breathing and nocturnal respiration, especially during childhood. Our hypothesis was that transnasal endoscopic horizontal limited adenoidectomy may relieve nasal obstruction while preserving the function of the velopharyngeal valve. The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of transnasal endoscopic horizontal partial adenoidectomy in patients with submucous cleft palate and adenoidal hypertrophy.

SETTING

Patients were either referred to the outpatient clinic of the Palate Surgery Unit (seven patients) or were patients referred to the senior author's (Y.F.) private clinic. All the patients had been operated on by this senior author (Y.F.).

PATIENTS

Ten children aged 3.5 to 13 years (six girls and four boys) with submucous cleft palate and hypertrophic adenoids were included in the study. All the patients were hyponasal and suffered nasal obstruction, loud snoring, and episodes of apnea.

INTERVENTIONS

Endoscopic partial adenoidectomy was accomplished to open the lower third of the choanae. Nasal breathing was achieved in all the patients, and only mild snoring remained in two patients. The hyponasality disappeared and speech intelligibility normalized. Mild hypernasality developed in two patients but was still perceived as an overall improvement in speech.

CONCLUSIONS

Transnasal endoscopic horizontal partial adenoidectomy may be an effective surgical method for relief of nasal obstruction while preserving velopharyngeal valve function in patients with submucous cleft palate who suffer from obstructive adenoids.

Furlow palatoplasty to restore velopharyngeal competence following tonsillectomy avulsion of a pharyngeal flap

OBJECTIVE

We report the successful use of a Furlow palatoplasty to salvage velopharyngeal competence following iatrogenic avulsion of a pharyngeal flap that had been previously established to treat velopharyngeal insufficiency associated with a submucous cleft palate.

INTERVENTION

A tonsillectomy, conducted by a surgeon unaffiliated with a cleft palate team, was used to remove enlarged tonsils that had developed after pharyngeal flap surgery and extended into the lateral ports causing nasal obstruction and hypernasality because of mechanical interference with port closure. A posttonsillectomy evaluation revealed avulsion of the pharyngeal flap, which was successfully treated using a Furlow palatoplasty.

CONCLUSIONS

To our knowledge, this is the first report of iatrogenic avulsion of a pharyngeal flap caused by tonsillectomy. Based on a review of the literature and this case experience, we would conclude that tonsillectomy should not be regarded as a routine procedure in patients previously treated with a pharyngeal flap. If required, it should be performed by a skilled otolaryngologist, preferably one affiliated with a multidisciplinary cleft palate team who is familiar with pharyngoplasty surgery. Finally, our experience would suggest that the Furlow palatoplasty is sufficiently robust to be used as a secondary salvage procedure to restore velopharyngeal sufficiency following iatrogenic avulsion of a pharyngeal flap.

Velopharyngeal incompetence after adenotonsillectomy in non-cleft patients

This report discusses 15 non-cleft palate children who developed velopharyngeal incompetence (VPI) after adenotonsillectomy. Eight boys and 7 girls with a mean age of 6.2 years (range 4.3-11 years) were treated between 1970 and 1993. After 2 years conservative management to allow for spontaneous resolution, only (7 children) 47% achieved normal resonance. Speech therapy was employed mainly for those patients with unrelated articulation errors. Fifty-three percent (8 children) required surgery for persistent hypernasality and in 6 a pharyngoplasty was performed and in one child a posterior pharyngeal cartilage graft was inserted. One case is still to have surgical intervention. Half of the non-cleft children who develop VPI after adenotonsillectomy will respond to conservative management.

The functional role of the adenoids in speech

Illustrative cases are presented showing a variety of interrelationships between the adenoids and the activity of the velopharyngeal valve in speech. The cases presented were selected from a group of 1000 patients referred because of suspected velopharyngeal diseases. When appropriate, complete velopharyngeal assessment was made including otolaryngological speech and hearing examination, polysomnography, nasendoscopy, multiview videofluoroscopy and cephalometry. New observations are described which further elucidate the mechanism by which the adenoids may change the mechanism of velopharyngeal valving and consequently speech patterns. In conclusion, procedures involving the adenoids and tonsils and surgical correction of velopharyngeal valve abnormalities to improve respiratory function must be performed in a manner which ensures preservation of normal speech activity. Similarly, surgical correction of velopharyngeal valve abnormalities to improve speech activity must preserve its respiratory function. The velopharyngeal valve and the adeno-tonsils must be considered together whenever diagnosis and a therapeutic intervention of either of them is considered. A clinical method for patient evaluation, patient management and the development of a rational therapeutic approach is presented.

Velopharyngeal incompetence and persistent hypernasality after adenoidectomy in children without palatal defect

Persistent hypernasal speech after adenoidectomy has been reported in children with palatal deficiency. Hypernasality after adenoidectomy can also occur in children with normal palatal function. The aim of the present study was to identify the cause of velopharyngeal incompetence and hypernasality after adenoidectomy in children who did not have palatal defect as a predisposing factor. Sixteen children who developed hypernasality after adenoidectomy were included in the present study. Standard lateral cephalometry, videofluoroscopy, and nasopharyngoscopy were performed to visualize the velopharynx and its function during speech. The results showed that enlarged tonsils and prominent remaining adenoid tissue on the posterior pharyngeal wall were the causes of hypernasality in these children. Incomplete removal of the adenoid tissue should be avoided and enlarged tonsils should be removed at the time of adenoidectomy to prevent the risk for postoperative hypernasality.

Aerodynamic, acoustic, and perceptual changes following adenoidectomy

Fourteen children were seen prior to adenoidectomy and at 1 month, 3 months, and 6 months following surgery. On each visit, nasal airway resistance values, nasal cross-sectional area estimates, nasalance scores, and perceptual ratings of nasality were collected. These data were analyzed to identify changes that were related to the time of the test, and to the primary indication for surgery (nasal airway obstruction or recurrent infection). Results revealed significant reduction in nasal airway resistance and significant changes in nasalance following surgery. Perceptual changes were not significant. Clinical implications of these findings are discussed.

Velopharyngeal insufficiency due to hypertrophic tonsils. A report of two cases

Two children in whom idiopathic hypernasality was diagnosed were referred for investigation of velopharyngeal function. Multiview videofluoroscopic assessments showed the tonsils prolapsing posteriorly during speech, preventing the palate from fully approximating the posterior pharyngeal wall. Tonsillectomy was recommended. Postoperative evaluations found that the hypernasal resonance was eliminated in both children.

Velopharyngeal insufficiency after adenoidectomy: an 8-year review

The characteristics of 137 patients referred to the Speech Clinic at The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Canada during the past 8 years for the investigation of persistent hypernasality after adenoidectomy are reported. Over 30% of the patients had preoperative factors that are thought to increase the risk, such as submucous cleft palate, fluid regurgitation through the nose, a family history of velopharyngeal insufficiency or clefting, or hypernasality. Fifty percent of the patients required pharyngoplasty to correct hypernasality, 37% required speech therapy alone, and 13% improved with no treatment.