HPV-induced condylomata acuminata treated by Photodynamic Therapy in comparison with trichloroacetic acid: A randomized clinical trial

OBJECTIVES

This is a randomized controlled clinical trial comparing Photodynamic Therapy (PDT) and the application of trichloracetic acid (TAA) in the treatment of HPV condyloma in the perianal and vulva regions. Design, Randomised controlled, open label, trial. They were allocated to each treatment following randomization by a computer program.

SETTING

Women Health Ambulatory in São Carlos city, São Paulo State in the Brazil.

PARTICIPANTS

36 patients evaluated. 31 patients fulfilled the study requirements.

INTERVENTION

Photodynamic Therapy (PDT) versus trichloracetic acid (TAA). The PDT protocol used the prodrug methyl aminolevulinate incubated for 3 hours and irradiation at 630 nm (100 J/cm²). In the treatment using TAA, warts received a small amount of acid using a cotton swab. Both treatments were repeated weekly until the lesions disappeared completely or until 10 sessions were completed.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Clinical analysis. Follow-up between 12 and 30 months after the complete treatment.

RESULTS

A total of 16 patients were treated with PDT and 15 patients with TAA. A complete response rate of 60% for TAA and 63% for PDT, with a recurrence rate of 33% for TAA and 0% for PDT.

CONCLUSION

PDT appears not only to treat lesions due to physical destruction of condyloma and subclinical lesions, but also to modulate the immune system and/or also to decrease the local viral load, suggesting a lower recurrence compared to the TAA group.

Photodynamic therapy combined with carbon dioxide laser for low-grade vaginal intraepithelial neoplasia: A retrospective analysis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the clinical efficacy and safety of 5-aminolevulinic acid photodynamic therapy (ALA-PDT) combined with a carbon dioxide laser (CO₂ laser + PDT) versus CO₂ laser for the treatment of low-grade vaginal intraepithelial neoplasms (vaginal LSIL).

METHODS

We recruited 40 patients with vaginal LSIL and persistent HR-HPV infection and divided these individuals into two groups. The CO₂ laser + PDT group (20 patients) received one CO₂ laser treatment and three treatments of ALA-PDT over a one-week interval. The CO₂ laser group (20 patients) received up to three CO₂ laser treatments. All patients were followed up at 1 month, 3 month, 6 month and 1 year. Hybrid capture HPV DNA assay and colposcopic biopsy were performed for both groups before treatment and during each of the follow-ups. Adverse effects were also assessed.

RESULTS

The complete remission (CR) rates were 65 % (13/20) in the CO₂ laser group and 85 % (17/20) in the CO₂ laser + PDT group (p > 0.05). HR-HPV remission rates were 25 % (5/20) in the CO₂ laser group and 95 % (19/20) in the CO₂ laser + PDT group (p < 0.05) at one year after treatment. In the CO₂ laser group, one patient experienced severe bleeding during treatment. Twelve patients had varying degrees of adhesions and vaginal scar stenosis. One patient underwent vaginal "dead angle" after repeated CO₂ laser treatment. No severe adverse events or systemic side effects were observed in the CO₂ + PDT group.

CONCLUSION

Topical ALA-PDT combined with CO₂ laser is an effective, safe, and well-tolerated treatment for vaginal LSIL and HR-HPV infections.

Comparative study of photodynamic therapy with 5%, 10% and 20% aminolevulinic acid in the treatment of generalized recalcitrant facial verruca plana: a randomized clinical trial

BACKGROUND

Generalised recalcitrant facial verruca plana responds poorly to current therapeutic options, including cryotherapy, topical drugs and carbon dioxide (CO2 ) laser. Case reports and uncontrolled studies suggested that topical photodynamic therapy (PDT) is effective choice of treatment free from potential complications associated with invasive therapies.

AIMS

To investigate the efficacy and safety of PDT with different concentrations of photosensitiser in the treatment of verruca plana.

MATERIALS & METHODS

The two sides of a subject's face were separately randomized to receive aminolevulinic acid (ALA) of 5%, 10% or 20% concentration. All patients were irradiated with 633-nm red light for 339 J/cm(2) total dose. Complete response (CR) rate was assessed on Week 4, 8, and 16 respectively.

RESULTS

The mean overall clearance rate was 74.1%, 68.8%, and 64.6% on Week 4, 8, and 12, respectively, in the 110 treated sides. The CR rate was lower in the 5%-ALA group than in the 10%-ALA group (14.3% vs. 33.3%, p < 0.05) and 20%-ALA group (14.3% vs. 26.3%, p < 0.05) after 12 weeks. The mean severity of pain measured by visual analogue scale (VAS) scoring was 3.8 (range: 2 to 10, depending on the lesion location). The overall recurrence rate was 16.7% (4/24) on Week 12. Hyperpigmentation was observed in 61% (67/110) of all treated sides. On Week 4, 8, and 16, hyperpigmentation was more developed in the 20%-ALA group than in the other two groups (p < 0.05).

DISCUSSION

In terms of complete clearance rate, the 5% ALA-PDT group was significantly inferior to the 10% and 20% ALA-PDT groups at each follow-up. In contrast, the 20% ALA group showed a higher incidence rate of transient hyperpigmentation than the other two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

This randomised clinical trial suggests that PDT with ALA of 10% concentration offers better efficacy and safety than 5% or 20% concentration for generalised recalcitrant facial verruca plana.

Evaluation of photodynamic therapy using topical aminolevulinic acid hydrochloride in the treatment of condylomata acuminata: a comparative, randomized clinical trial

OBJECTIVES

To determine the safety and efficacy of photodynamic therapy (PDT) with topical application of 20% wt/vol aminolevulinic acid hydrochloride (ALA) in the treatment of condylomata acuminata (CA).

STUDY DESIGN

Patients with CA were randomly allocated into the ALA-PDT group and the CO(2) laser group in an allocation ratio of 3 : 1. The treatment was repeated weekly if necessary, but no more than 3 times. The primary efficacy endpoint was the wart clearance rate 1 week after the last treatment. The recurrence rate was evaluated at weeks 4, 8 and 12 after the treatment ended. The clinical response to therapy and adverse effects were recorded.

RESULTS

A total of 91 patients with CA were enrolled in the clinical trial. Of these 90 (98.9%) patients completed the trial (67 in the ALA-PDT group, and 23 in CO(2) laser group). By 1 week after the last treatment, the complete clearance rate was 95.93% in the ALA-PDT group and 100% in CO(2) laser group (P>0.05). The clearance rate of CA at male urethral orifice was 100% in the ALA-PDT group and 100% in the CO(2) laser group (P>0.05). The overall recurrence rate calculated by the end of the entire follow-up period was significantly lower in the ALA-PDT group than that in the CO(2) laser group (9.38% vs 17.39%, P<0.05). Moreover, there was no systemic adverse event in either group. The proportion of patients with adverse effects in the ALA-PDT group (8.82%) was also significantly lower than that in the CO(2) laser group (100%, P<0.05). The side-effects in patients treated with ALA-PDT mainly included mild burning and/or stinging restricted to the illuminated area.

CONCLUSION

The results confirmed that topical application of ALA-PDT is a simpler and as effective therapy with a lower incidence of adverse effects in the treatment of CA compared with conventional CO(2) laser therapy.

Terapia fotodinâmica em dermatologia: princípios básicos e aplicações

A terapia fotodinâmica envolve a administração de uma droga fotossensibilizante e sua ativação subsequente pela luz de comprimento de onda correspondente ao espectro de absorção do fotossensibilizador. Atualmente, a terapia fotodinâmica tópica é aprovada para o tratamento de condições oncológicas cutâneas como queratoses actínicas, doença de Bowen e carcinoma basocelular superficial em diversos países do mundo. Estudos multicêntricos controlados e randomizados demonstram a alta eficácia e resultado cosmético final superior dessa modalidade terapêutica em relação aos tratamentos convencionais. Para condições cutâneas não oncológicas, como acne vulgar, verrugas virais e esclerodermia localizada, há também relatos e série de casos confirmando o potencial terapêutico da terapia fotodinâmica. O desenvolvimento de fotossensibilizantes tópicos, ácido 5-aminolevulínico (ALA) ou seu metiléster (MAL), frente aos derivados da hematoporfirina de aplicação sistêmica, permitiu um grande avanço na popularidade da TFD na dermatologia, uma vez que tanto ALA quanto MAL tópicos não induzem mais fotossensibilidade generalizada prolongada. A produção de intermediários reativos de oxigênio, como oxigênio singlet, depende da concentração, da localização do fotossensibilizante no tecido alvo, assim como da dose de luz utilizada. Tanto as lâmpadas de amplo espectro quanto os LEDs (do inglês light emitting diodes) constituem fontes de luz adequadas para que os efeitos citotóxicos da terapia fotodinâmica resultem na destruição do tumor ou seus efeitos imunomodulatórios atuem melhorando as condições inflamatórias cutâneas.

Genital warts treated by photodynamic therapy

The patient, a 30-year-old man with numerous genital condylomata acuminata (CA), has had unsuccessful treatment with liquid nitrogen, 20% podophyllin, and repeated 0.5% podophyllotoxin solution with 5% imiquimod (Figure 1). Before the appearance of CA, he experienced acute orchiepididimitis and a Candida infection. The patient was immunologically examined, and the lower level of lymphocytes, slightly reduced level of IgM, and C4 complement were revealed. Results from a human immunodeficiency virus examination were negative. After the therapeutic failure mentioned above, photodynamic therapy (PDT) was initiated using 20% aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA) in a gel. The photosensitizer was applied to lesions and 10 mm of surrounding skin in a 1-mm-thick layer under occlusive dressing for 3 hours and then removed with saline and nonwoven gauze. The site was immediately irradiated with noncoherent red light with an emission spectrum of 580 to 680 nm wavelength (Medeikonos PDT-Model 200, Medeikonos AB, Sweden). The total light dose was 50 J/cm(2); light intensity ranged from 70 to 90 mW/cm(2). Because of persistent fluorescence during photodynamic therapy, the treatment was repeated 10 times in 2-week intervals with a follow-up of 1, 3, and 6 months after its completion. After the last PDT treatment, the persistent fluorescence disappeared completely. The absence of fluorescence corresponded with a healed clinical finding without scarring and pigmentation (Figure 2). The period from the initiation of PDT to the consolidation of CA was 22 weeks. During PDT treatment, the patient felt only mild burning, which disappeared after the illumination stopped. Six months after the therapy, there were no signs of recurrent disease.

Study of Protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) Pharmacokinetics After Topical Application of 5-Aminolevulinic Acid in Urethral Condylomata Acuminata

The pharmacokinetics of 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA)-induced protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) in lesions of urethral condylomata acuminata were investigated. Sixty patients (20 to 60 years old, 48 male and 12 female) were divided randomly into five groups and received topic application of different concentrations of ALA solution (0.5%, 1%, 3%, 5% or 10%). Biopsy was performed between 1 and 7 h and specimens were subjected to histological, PpIX fluorescence and human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA typing analyses. Fluorescence examination confirmed that ALA-induced PpIX fluorescence was dominantly distributed in the HPV-infected epidermis. In contrast, only a minimal amount of PpIX fluorescence was detected in the dermis. The maximal fluorescence intensity was detected at 5 h incubation. Higher ALA concentration (e.g. 5% and 10%) produced a stronger intensity. These results suggest that the topical application of 5-10% ALA solution for 3-5 h is the optimal condition for the photodynamic therapy of urethral condylomata acuminata. The selective damage of the condylomata acuminata lesions in the epidermis without damaging the dermis ensures a better control of recurrence and side effects such as ulceration or scarring. DNA typing showed that all patients were positive for low risk-HPV DNA and among them 18.3% of patients harbored high risk-HPV DNA.

Comparative study of photodynamic therapy vs. CO2laser vaporization in treatment of condylomata acuminata, a randomized clinical trial

BACKGROUND

Most conventional therapies for condylomata acuminata (CA) are traumatic and have high recurrence rates.

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the efficacy and safety of topical application of 5-aminolaevulinic acid (ALA) photodynamic therapy (PDT) for the treatment of CA.

METHODS

Sixty-five patients with CA were allocated into the treatment (ALA-PDT) group and treated with 20% ALA solution under occlusive dressing for 3 h followed by irradiation with the helium-neon laser at a dose of 100 J cm(-2) and a power of 100 mW. Another 21 CA patients were allocated into the control group and treated with the CO(2) laser. The treatment was to be repeated 1 week later if the lesion was not completely removed after the first treatment.

RESULTS

After one treatment, the complete removal rate was 95% in the ALA-PDT group and 100% in the control group. After two treatments with ALA-PDT, the complete removal rate in the treatment group was 100%. The recurrence rate for ALA-PDT group was 6.3% which was significantly lower than that in control group (19.1%, P < 0.05). Moreover, the proportion of patients with adverse effects in the ALA-PDT group (13.9%) was also significantly lower than that in control group (100%, P < 0.05). The side-effects in patients treated with ALA-PDT mainly included mild burning and/or stinging restricted to the illuminated area.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study shows that topical application of ALA-PDT is a simpler, more effective and safer therapy with a lower recurrence for treatment of CA compared with conventional CO(2) laser therapy.

Photodynamic therapy of genital condylomata in men

Current treatments for genital condylomata are not completely satisfactory, as they fail to clear lesions in a proportion of patients, and relapses after successful treatment are frequently seen. Photodynamic therapy (PDT) using topical 5-aminolaevulinic acid (5-ALA) has been suggested as a novel treatment option. We performed a small open study using topical 5-ALA and red light (630 nm) in nine men with genital condylomata and a history of at least one previous unsuccessful conventional treatment. Complete cure was achieved in three patients, one of whom experienced a relapse after 3 weeks. Three patients showed partial responses, and three showed no response. Based on the currently available evidence, PDT is a viable treatment option for selected cases that fail to respond to other therapies.

In vivo fluorescence kinetics and photodynamic therapy in condylomata acuminata

BACKGROUND

Topical application of 5-aminolaevulinic acid (ALA) to condylomata acuminata leads to accumulation of protoporphyrin IX (PpIX); therefore ALA-induced photodynamic therapy (ALA-PDT) appears to be a potential treatment.

OBJECTIVES

To investigate in vivo the PpIX fluorescence time course after topical application of ALA in order to determine the optimal time for irradiation, and to assess the efficacy of subsequently performed ALA-PDT.

METHODS

Fluorescence kinetics was studied in 12 male patients with condylomata acuminata. Confirmation of diagnosis was established with conventional histology and polymerase chain reaction. Lesions were treated with 20% ALA and irradiated at the optimal time with a dose of 70 J cm-2 or 100 J cm-2 light. An additional session with 100 J cm-2 was administered 1 week later to lesions that persisted.

RESULTS

The in vivo study of fluorescence kinetics indicated that the optimal time for irradiation varied among patients from 6 to 11 h. The overall cure rate was 72.9%, 12 months after treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Topical ALA-PDT is a potentially effective treatment for condylomata acuminata.

Topical 5-aminolaevulinic acid photodynamic therapy for the treatment of skin conditions other than non-melanoma skin cancer

Topical 5-aminolaevulinic acid (ALA) photodynamic therapy (PDT) is used increasingly for superficial non-melanoma skin cancer (NMSC) and dysplasia. However, the relative accumulation of the photosensitizer protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) in diseased tissue is not specific for neoplastic disease, and has been shown after the application of ALA to benign proliferative skin conditions such as viral warts and psoriasis. This review appraises the quality of evidence available for the use of topical ALA-PDT in the treatment of skin conditions other than NMSC. The diseases that have been studied in most detail are recalcitrant viral warts, acne, psoriasis and cutaneous T-cell lymphoma. Publications relating to the treatment of other diseases by topical PDT are restricted to small case series or case reports. The relevant literature will be discussed and the potential for topical PDT in the treatment of several skin diseases is highlighted, although more detailed studies are required to clarify the role of PDT beyond the treatment of NMSC.

Photodynamic Therapy for Bowen's Disease (Squamous Cell Carcinoma in situ) of the Digit

BACKGROUND

Surgical excision is the preferred method of eradicating Bowen's disease (BD). However, when BD occurs on the digit, surgical intervention can sometimes lead to scar contracture and loss of function of the digit.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effectiveness of photodynamic therapy (PDT) in eradicating BD of the digit while preserving the full function of the digit.

METHODS

Four patients of chronic arsenism with biopsy-proven BD on the digit were treated with PDT by using a newly designed light-emitting diode (LED) array with a peak wavelength of 630 nm (630 +/- 40 nm; 40 mW/cm2 at skin surface). After partial removal of the thickened horny layer and 16 hours of occlusion with a 2% aminolevulinic acid (ALA) solution, each lesion was irradiated with 240 J/cm2 in two fractions with a 90-minute interval.

RESULTS

All patients experienced a significant burning, tingling sensation that was tolerable during the procedure except one who needed local anesthesia. All treated digits healed without scarring in 2 weeks. Posttreatment biopsy in one patient showed normal epidermis and a slight fibrosis in the papillary dermis. Three patients remained free of recurrence (75%) at 15-17 months (average 16 months) after one treatment. One patient's BD recurred at 8 months, but was successfully treated without recurrence after 20 months.

CONCLUSION

Our preliminary study suggests that PDT using 2% 5-ALA solution and an LED array is an effective, noninvasive method to treat digital BD with the benefit of scar-free contracture and loss of digital function. Among the various factors that would affect the results of PDT, we feel that partial removal of the thickened horny layer is the most important step to achieve sufficient therapeutic effect in digital BDs.