Differences in the levels of TSH-binding inhibitor immunoglobulins in goitrous and agoitrous autoimmune thyroiditis after twelve months of L-thyroxine therapy

Sphingolipids in thyroid eye disease

Graves' disease (GD) is caused by an autoimmune formation of autoantibodies and autoreactive T-cells against the thyroid stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR). The autoimmune reaction does not only lead to overstimulation of the thyroid gland, but very often also to an immune reaction against antigens within the orbital tissue leading to thyroid eye disease, which is characterized by activation of orbital fibroblasts, orbital generation of adipocytes and myofibroblasts and increased hyaluronan production in the orbit. Thyroid eye disease is the most common extra-thyroidal manifestation of the autoimmune Graves' disease. Several studies indicate an important role of sphingolipids, in particular the acid sphingomyelinase/ceramide system and sphingosine 1-phosphate in thyroid eye disease. Here, we discuss how the biophysical properties of sphingolipids contribute to cell signaling, in particular in the context of thyroid eye disease. We further review the role of the acid sphingomyelinase/ceramide system in autoimmune diseases and its function in T lymphocytes to provide some novel hypotheses for the pathogenesis of thyroid eye disease and potentially allowing the development of novel treatments.

TSH-receptor autoantibodies in patients with chronic thyroiditis and hypothyroidism

OBJECTIVES

The reported prevalence of TSH-receptor (TSHR) autoantibodies (TRAb) in patients with chronic thyroiditis (CT) range from 0 to 48%. The objective was to study the prevalence of TRAb in patients with CT and hypothyroidism and to correlate it with gender, age, thyroid dimensions, TSH levels, and autoimmune diseases.

METHODS

The study comprised 245 patients with CT and hypothyroidism (median age 42 years, 193 females, 52 males) and 123 Italian healthy subjects matched for sex and age as controls. TRAb were tested with ELISA using a >2.5 IU/L cut off for positivity. TSHR blocking (TBAb) and TSHR stimulating autoantibodies (TSAb) were measured in 12 TRAb-positive patients using bioassays with Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells expressing wild-type or R255D-mutated TSHR.

RESULTS

TRAb positivity was found in 32/245 (13.1%) patients and significantly correlated (p<0.05) with TSH levels. TRAb positivity was significantly higher in males vs. females (p=0.034), in females 16-45 years of age vs. >45 years of age (p<0.05) and in patients with reduced vs. normal/increased thyroid dimensions (p<0.05). Linear regression analysis showed a correlation between TRAb concentrations with age (p<0.05) and TRAb concentrations with TSH (p<0.01). In bioassay with TSHR-R255D all 12 patients tested were TBAb-positive while 33% were also TSAb-positive suggesting the presence of a mixture of TRAbs with different biological activities in some patients.

CONCLUSIONS

TRAb have been found in patients with CT and hypothyroidism. A mixture of TBAb and TSAb was found in some patients and this may contribute to the pathogenesis of thyroid dysfunction during the course of the disease.

Thyrotropin-blocking autoantibodies and thyroid-stimulating autoantibodies: potential mechanisms involved in the pendulum swinging from hypothyroidism to hyperthyroidism or vice versa

BACKGROUND

Thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) antibodies that stimulate the thyroid (TSAb) cause Graves' hyperthyroidism and TSHR antibodies which block thyrotropin action (TBAb) are occasionally responsible for hypothyroidism. Unusual patients switch from TSAb to TBAb (or vice versa) with concomitant thyroid function changes. We have examined case reports to obtain insight into the basis for "switching."

SUMMARY

TBAb to TSAb switching occurs in patients treated with levothyroxine (LT4); the reverse switch (TBAb to TSAb) occurs after anti-thyroid drug therapy; TSAb/TBAb alterations may occur during pregnancy and are well recognized in transient neonatal thyroid dysfunction. Factors that may impact the shift include: (i) LT4 treatment, usually associated with decreased thyroid autoantibodies, in unusual patients induces or enhances thyroid autoantibody levels; (ii) antithyroid drug treatment decreases thyroid autoantibody levels; (iii) hyperthyroidism can polarize antigen-presenting cells, leading to impaired development of regulatory T cells, thereby compromising control of autoimmunity; (iv) immune-suppression/hemodilution reduces thyroid autoantibodies during pregnancy and rebounds postpartum; (v) maternally transferred IgG transiently impacts thyroid function in neonates until metabolized; (vi) a Graves' disease model involving immunizing TSHR-knockout mice with mouse TSHR-adenovirus and transfer of TSHR antibody-secreting splenocytes to athymic mice demonstrates the TSAb to TBAb shift, paralleling the outcome of maternally transferred "term limited" TSHR antibodies in neonates. Finally, perhaps most important, as illustrated by dilution analyses of patients' sera in vitro, TSHR antibody concentrations and affinities play a critical role in switching TSAb and TBAb functional activities in vivo.

CONCLUSIONS

Switching between TBAb and TSAb (or vice versa) occurs in unusual patients after LT4 therapy for hypothyroidism or anti-thyroid drug treatment for Graves' disease. These changes involve differences in TSAb versus TBAb concentrations, affinities and/or potencies in individual patients. Thus, anti-thyroid drugs or suppression/hemodilution in pregnancy reduce initially low TSAb levels even further, leading to TBAb dominance. In contrast, TSAb emergence after LT4 administration may be sufficient to counteract TBAb inhibition. The occurrence of "switching" emphasizes the need for careful patient monitoring and management. Finally, whole genome screening of relatively rare "switch" patients and appropriate Graves' and Hashimoto's controls could provide unexpected and valuable information regarding the basis for thyroid autoimmunity.

Cysteine 390 mutation of the TSH receptor modulates its ectodomain as an inverse agonist on the serpentine domain with decrease in basal constitutive activity

Mutations of individual cysteine residues at codon 301, 390, 398 and 408 of the thyrotropin receptor (TSHr) to serine resulted in cell surface expression of only C301S and C390S mutants. C390S mutation was a silencing mutation with decreased basal constitutive activity. Although the C301S and C390S mutants did not show any significant TSH binding, they generated cyclic AMP upon TSH stimulation. These mutants were also able to interact with stimulating and blocking anti-TSHr antibodies. In fact, C390S receptor is a more sensitive tool for blocking antibody detection than wild type receptor. Introduction of C390S to activating mutations in the ectodomain (S281N), exloop (I486F) and transmembrane (D633H) segments could not mute/nullify receptor activation. These data indicate that the C390S ectodomain behaves as a more effective inverse agonist on the noisy transmembrane segment and suggest that the basal and activated states of the receptor operate through two independent pathways.

Antibodies to TSH-receptor in thyroid autoimmune disease interact with monoclonal antibodies whose epitopes are broadly distributed on the receptor

The hyperthyroidism of Graves' disease (GD) is caused by TSH-receptor (TSH-R) stimulating autoantibodies (TSAb), leading to overproduction of thyroid hormones. We present evidence for TSAb interaction with three distinct regions of the TSH-R, one in immediate vicinity of the carboxy terminal serpentine. Three murine monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs 28.1, A9 and 31.7) directed to amino acids 36-40, 147-228 and 382-415 were labelled and tested for their binding to human recombinant TSH-R on solid phase. All MoAbs bound to TSH-R with a K(d) of 8-12 nm and showed no competition among themselves. We tested 114 sera from euthyroid controls, 118 TBII positive sera from patients with GD (containing TSAb confirmed by bioassays), 16 TBII positive sera from patients with autoimmune thyroid disease (AIT), who were hypothyroid and had TSH blocking antibodies (TBAb), and 20 patients with AIT, who were hypothyroid but negative for all TRAb. Mid-regional MoAb A9 tracer achieved the highest sensitivity in the GD group (72.0%), whereas C-terminal MoAb 31.7 found most sera positive in the AIT group (87.5%). Surprisingly, the N-terminal MoAb 28.1 had the lowest sensitivity in the GD (10.4%) and AIT group (43.8%). Using a mixture of all three tracer MoAbs did not increase the sensitivity in the GD or AIT group, compared to the best single MoAb alone. Median inhibition of MoAb A9 was significantly (P < 0.001) higher than inhibition of MoAbs 28.1 or 31.7 in the group of GD patients but not in other groups. Almost all patient sera with positive reactivity in the MoAb tracer assays had TBII values in the higher range. However, there were many highly TBII positive sera, which did not show a displacement of the MoAb tracers. We conclude that, contrary to some reports, the binding of TSAb and TBAb to the TSH-R is not restricted to distinct and distant epitopes. The middle part of the TSH-R seems to be more relevant for TSAb binding than the N-terminal part, while a proportion of TSAb autoantibodies also binds to a C-terminal epitope of the TSH-R. The method described here is a TSH independent competitive assay for the detection of TSH-R autoantibodies.

Thyroid autoantibody profiles in ophthalmic dominant and thyroid dominant Graves' disease differ and suggest ophthalmopathy is a multiantigenic disease

BACKGROUND

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) occurs in 25-50% of patients with Graves' disease (GD) and is occasionally seen in hypothyroid Hashimoto's disease or euthyroid individuals. The link between TAO and hyperthyroidism remains unclear. We hypothesized that qualitative or quantitative differences in thyroid antibodies might determine individual predisposition to these features.

METHODS

In a prospective study over 3 years, thyroid antibody levels were measured in all patients diagnosed at the Singapore National Eye Centre to have GD. These patients had no known history of thyroid disease, presented with eye complaints and diagnosis was made by an ophthalmologist. A total of 31 patients were identified. Antibody levels were compared against 71 consecutive patients referred to a thyroid clinic (TC) for thyrotoxic symptoms in whom the diagnosis of GD was confirmed by a thyroidologist.

FINDINGS

Thyroid autoantibody profiles of patients diagnosed at the ophthalmology centre (OC) and TC differed markedly. OC patients had significantly higher TSI (P = 0.003) but lower TPOAb (P = 0.008) and TgAb levels (P < 0.001). In contrast, TC patients had higher free T4 (P = 0.048) and higher TBII levels (P < 0.001). Antibody levels were correlated with four parameters of ophthalmopathy--chronic lid retraction, lid swelling, proptosis and extraocular myopathy (EOM). On univariate logistic regression analysis, TSI was a positive predictor and TPOAb and TgAb negative predictors of all four features. In the absence of TgAb, the odds ratios for individual TAO features ranged from 2.8 to 7.9, with corresponding values of 3.9-10.2 when TPOAb was absent. In stepwise logistic regression analysis, TSI was the strongest independent predictor of all aspects studied: lid fullness P = 0.001, proptosis P = 0.001, lid retraction P = 0.008, EOM P = 0.009. Among smokers, TPOAb were significantly lower (P = 0.044) but no association between smoking and the other antibodies was observed.

INTERPRETATION

The study demonstrates markedly different thyroid autoantibody profiles in newly diagnosed GD patients with ophthalmic dominant as opposed to thyroid dominant features. It suggests differing antibody patterns are associated with predisposition to hyperthyroidism and orbitopathy. In addition, an association between smoking and low TPOAb levels was noted.

A coated tube assay for the detection of blocking thyrotropin receptor autoantibodies

We developed a coated tube assay to discriminate TSH-receptor-stimulating autoantibodies [thyroid-stimulating antibodies (TSAb)] from those autoantibodies blocking TSH binding without intrinsic activation [thyroid-blocking antibodies (TBAb)]. The wild-type TSH receptor in the TSH binding-inhibitory assay was exchanged for a chimeric receptor where a TSAb epitope (amino acids 8-165) was replaced by comparable LH-R residues. Binding of (125)I-labeled TSH to this chimera could be inhibited by sera containing TBAb up to 95%. Sera from 316 patients with Graves' disease and 17 with autoimmune thyroid disease were grouped according to their bioassay activity. At the decision threshold, the chimera A assay had a sensitivity of 78.0% for TBAb with a specificity of 90.2%. In detail, 19 of 22 (86.4%) TBAb sera and 15 of 23 (65.2%) TSAb/TBAb sera were positive but only 32 of 216 (14.0%) TSAb sera and 5 of 72 (6.9%) bioassay negative sera. There was a weak but significant positive correlation (r = 0.46) between the chimera assay and the bioassay for TBAb. This is the first report of a coated tube assay for the determination of TBAb employing an adaptation of the TSH binding-inhibitory format, which could be a useful alternative to the bioassay.

Affinity purification and diagnostic use of TSH receptor autoantibodies from human serum

Purification of TSH receptor autoantibodies (TRAb) from the serum of patients with Graves' disease (GD) might help to elucidate the nature of these disease causing autoantibodies. We describe here for the first time the successful affinity purification of human TRAb. Affinity purification was performed in a four step procedure with human recombinant TSH receptor (TSH-R) expressed in K562 cells. Purification from six different serum pools from patients with GD and two individual sera (one with only thyroid stimulating antibodies (TSAb) one with only thyroid blocking antibodies (TBAb)) resulted in a purity of 39.2+/-3.8 IU/mg TRAb or 25.7+/-2.1 microg IgG/IU (about 3.5-13.7 microg TRAb/ml serum). The average enrichment based on the respective original serum was 3420-fold (range 1200-10,000). The kDa of the purified TRAb were in the range of 0.7-2.6 x 10(-10)M. All purified TRAb (except from the TBAb serum which showed blocking activity) showed a more than 1000-fold stronger stimulation in the TSAb bioassay based on the IgG content than the original serum, and similar stimulation based on international units (IU/l) TRAb. When labelled purified TRAb were used in a competitive assay as tracer instead of bovine TSH, their binding to the human recombinant TSH-R on tubes was displaced by 99 of 100 GD sera (selected for TBII activity). Correlation to the standard TSH tracer was r=0.92. Interestingly, the use of TRAb tracer derived from a patient with TSAb and a patient with TBAb gave virtually identical results (r=0.93) with these patients, suggesting similar if not identical binding sites for both TRAb subtypes. In conclusion, this is the first report on the purification of human TRAb from the serum of patients with GD. The purified TRAb are of low concentration with high affinity, strong TBII and TSAb activity. Further characterisation may allow new insights in TRAb epitope localisation, the pathology of GD and the differences between TSAb and TBAb. Also, their use as tracer in a competitive assay is the first report on a completely homogenous assay with high sensitivity for TSH-R autoantibodies.

The effect of thyrotropin-receptor blocking antibodies on stimulating autoantibodies from patients with Graves' disease

The hyperthyroidism of Graves' disease (GD) is caused by thyrotropin-receptor (TSHR) stimulating autoantibodies (TSAb), which lead to overproduction of thyroid hormones. In this study we tried to block the stimulatory effect of patients' TSAb to the TSHR with monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and sera from hypothyroid patients. Two groups of blocking mAbs raised by different methods from two independent groups were tested for their ability to inhibit TSH binding to the TSHR, and also the binding of TSAb from the serum of patients with GD. Group 1 mAbs (7E3, 3H10, 4C1, 1B1, 4E9) bind to amino acids 378-387 and group 2 mAbs (23.1 and 31.7) to amino acids 382-415 of the human TSHR. These results were compared to the TSH- and TSAb-inhibiting effect of sera from hypothyroid patients containing bona fide thyroid blocking antibodies (TBAb) without agonistic activity. All studies were done in a conventional cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) or a modified luciferase reporter gene bioassay. TSH-induced cAMP/luciferase signal was reduced (> 70% inhibition) by all 7 mAbs, verifying the blocking nature. Comparable results (82.2%-96.3% inhibition) were seen when cells were preincubated with 8 TBAb sera. These TBAb sera also inhibited cAMP/luciferase induction of TSAb-positive sera from patients with GD (median of 27 experiments 62.2% inhibition; range, 26.8%-93.9%), and maintained inhibition greater than 20% even when diluted 1:150. However, when mAbs were incubated with these sera, results were heterogeneous: 17 of 30 sera (57%) incubated with mAb 31.7 caused reduced cAMP production compared to incubation with the control antibody, as did 18 of 34 sera (53%) incubated with mAb 7E3, 17 of 33 sera (52%) incubated with mAb 3H10, and 16 of 31 (52%) with mAb 23.1. Mixing all four mAbs did not enhance the cAMP-reductive effect (16/27 sera; 59% inhibited). Inhibition was less pronounced than with TBAb sera (0%-76% of a control antibody) and only present at antibody concentrations greater than 10 microg/mL. We conclude that despite the strong TBAb activity of the mAbs, their effect on TSAb-induced TSHR activation of sera from patients with GD was weaker than that of human TBAb autoantibodies. Thus, the latter are not only strong inhibitors of TSH activity, but also block the stimulatory effect of autoantibodies from patients with GD. However, this effect could not be reproduced by experimental mAbs to the same extent, because it may be the result of a broader spectrum of antibodies present in the TBAb sera, interacting with or in the vicinity of TSAb epitopes. Also of interest, when a TBAb serum was added to a TSAb serum, the TBAb effect was predominant even at high dilutions.

Prevalence of gestational thyrotoxicosis in Asian women evaluated in the 8th to 14th weeks of pregnancy: correlations with total and free beta human chorionic gonadotrophin

OBJECTIVES

The prevalence of gestational transient thyrotoxicosis (GTT) in Europeans evaluated during the 8th to 14th weeks of pregnancy is 2-3%. However, there is evidence that GTT may be more common in some Asian populations. The aims of this study were to evaluate the prevalence of thyroid hormone abnormalities in Asian women in their 8th to 14th weeks of pregnancy using highly sensitive free T4 and TSH assays and to correlate these with total and free beta-hCG levels.

DESIGN AND PATIENTS

One hundred and eighty-four consecutive unselected Asian (Singaporean) pregnant women seen at ante-natal clinics for the first time and who were in their 8th to 14th weeks of pregnancy were tested.

MEASUREMENTS

Serum free T4, free T3, TSH, total beta-hCG and free beta-HCG levels were measured on the Vitros ECi system (Johnson & Johnson Ortho-Clinical Diagnostics, Amersham, UK) which employs chemiluminescent immunochemical technology. This free T4 assay is free of biases related to serum binding capacity. The TSH assay used was a third generation assay. Thyrotrophin-receptor antibody (TRAb) levels were measured using LUMItest TRAK (BRAHMS Diagnostica, Berlin, Germany).

RESULTS

Two subjects (1.1%) were found to have Graves' disease. Elevated free T4, free T3, total T3 and suppressed TSH were seen in 14.8%, 3.3%, 26.4% and 33.0% of the remaining 182 pregnant women, respectively. Total and free beta-hCG correlated negatively with TSH (r = -0.30, P < 0.0001 and r = -0.29, P < 0.0001, respectively), positively with fT4 (r = 0.283, P < 0.001 and r = 0.253, P < 0.001) and fT3 (r = 0.273, P < 0.001 and r = 0.204, P < 0.01). 11.0% of cases had gestational thyrotoxicosis (GT) defined as elevated free T4 (> 19.1 pmol/l), suppressed TSH (< 0.36 mIU/l) and TRAb levels within the reference interval (0-0.9 U/l). The prevalence of GT was significantly higher in patients tested at 8-11 weeks compared to those evaluated at 12-14 weeks (14.4% vs. 4.7%, P < 0.05). Total beta-hCG (P = 0.0002), free beta-hCG (P < 0.0001) and free T4 (P = 0.02) levels were higher and TSH levels (P = 0.01) lower in patients tested at 8-11 weeks. Significant positive correlations between both total and free beta-hCG with free T4 were seen at 8-11 weeks but not in patients tested at 12 weeks or later. TT3 levels were similar in the two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Using sensitive assays, the prevalence of gestational thyrotoxicosis in Asian women was found to be 11.0% and was significantly higher in subjects at 8-11 weeks of gestation than at 12-14 weeks. The positive correlation between hCG and free T4 seen in patients tested at 8-11 weeks was absent in patients tested at later stages of the first trimester. Future studies investigating the entity of gestational thyrotoxicosis, at least in Asian patients, should focus on patients at earlier stages of gestation than currently practised.

A luminescent bioassay for thyroid blocking antibodies

OBJECTIVE

Thyroid blocking antibodies (TBAb) have a role in the development of hypothyroidism and in the neonate are responsible for transient hypothyroidism. Specific measurement of TBAb requires a bioassay, but current methods are lengthy and cumbersome. We describe a rapid luciferase-based method for the detection of TBAb using the lulu* cell line which is suitable for the provision of a clinical service

PATIENTS AND MEASUREMENTS

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were transfected with human TSH-R together with G418 resistance and a cAMP responsive luciferase construct. Stable pools of transfected cells were selected and clones identified by limiting dilution. Clone lulu* gave the best response to stimulation by TSH and was used to develop a bioassay for TBAb. The luminescent bioassay conditions have been optimized and validated using 12 serum samples from patients found to be TBAb positive in a bioassay using an established method quantifying cAMP by radioimmunoassay (RIA). The effect of thyroid stimulating antibodies (TSAb) on the calculation of Inhibition Index (InI) using two previously described formulae have been investigated and we have used serum containing both TSAb and TBAb to investigate detection of TBAb in samples containing more than one type of activity.

RESULTS

Lulu* displays a dose dependent increase in luciferase expression in response to stimulation with bovine (b) TSH which is more effective in serum free medium than in salt free buffer. TSH stimulated luciferase expression can be inhibited by TBAb in either serum or an immunoglobulin preparation. Using optimized assay conditions, challenging 10% serum against 1 U/l bTSH in culture medium, we have tested 31 euthyroid sera to determine a reference range: InI values >23% were considered positive. Twelve samples previously shown to contain TBAb by an established method quantifying cAMP by RIA were positive by the luciferase-based assay. Of control sera, 20/20 systemic lupus erythematosus, 13/14 rheumatoid arthritis, 12/12 multinodular goitre were negative. We demonstrated that if more complex formulae are used to calculate InI, false positive TBAb results can be obtained in samples containing only TSAb. Finally, when sera contain both TSAb and TBAb, the net activity of stimulating and blocking antibodies is detected in the bioassay. Where TSAb are also present, analysis of serum may be required at several dilutions to detect TBAb.

CONCLUSIONS

We describe the production of a new cell line, lulu*, and its use to develop a luminescent bioassay for TBAb suitable for clinical use. Comparing two established methods of calculating TBAb, we found that they do not give identical results. In light of this, the high prevalence reported for TBAb in some studies has to be considered with caution.