Diagnostic telepathology

Telepathology Impacts and Implementation Challenges: A Scoping Review

CONTEXT

Telepathology is a particular form of telemedicine that fundamentally alters the way pathology services are delivered. Prior reviews in this area have mostly focused on 2 themes, namely technical feasibility issues and diagnosis accuracy.

OBJECTIVES

To synthesize the literature on telepathology implementation challenges and broader organizational and societal impacts and to propose a research agenda to guide future efforts in this domain.

DATA SOURCES

Two complementary databases were systematically searched: MEDLINE (PubMed) and ABI/INFORM (ProQuest). Peer-reviewed articles and conference proceedings were considered. The final sample consisted of 159 papers published between 1992 and 2013.

CONCLUSIONS

This review highlights the diversity of telepathology networks and the importance of considering these distinctions when interpreting research findings. Various network structures are associated with different benefits. Although the dominant rationale in single-site projects is financial, larger centralized and decentralized telepathology networks are targeting a more diverse set of benefits, including extending access to pathology to a whole region, achieving substantial economies of scale in workforce and equipment, and improving quality by standardizing care. Importantly, our synthesis reveals that the nature and scale of encountered implementation challenges also varies depending on the network structure. In smaller telepathology networks, organizational concerns are less prominent, and implementers are more focused on usability issues. As the network scope widens, organizational and legal issues gain prominence.

Global manipulation of digital images can lead to variation in cytological diagnosis

Background:

With the adoption of a completely electronic workflow by several journals and the advent of telepathology, digital imaging has become an integral part of every scientific research. However, manipulating digital images is very easy, and it can lead to misinterpretations.

Aim:

To analyse the impact of manipulating digital images on their diagnosis.

Design:

Digital images were obtained from Papanicolaou-stained smears of dysplastic and normal oral epithelium. They were manipulated using GNU Image Manipulation Program (GIMP) to alter their brightness and contrast and color levels. A Power Point presentation composed of slides of these manipulated images along with the unaltered originals arranged randomly was created. The presentation was shown to five observers individually who rated the images as normal, mild, moderate or severe dysplasia. Weighted κ statistics was used to measure and assess the levels of agreement between observers.

Results:

Levels of agreement between manipulated images and original images varied greatly among observers. Variation in diagnosis was in the form of overdiagnosis or under-diagnosis, usually by one grade.

Conclusion:

Global manipulations of digital images of cytological slides can significantly affect their interpretation. Such manipulations should therefore be kept to a minimum, and avoided wherever possible.

Image quality issues in a static image-based telepathology consultation practice

Field selection and image quality have often been identified as impediments in the successful employment of static-image telepathology. One thousand seven hundred fifty-three electronic consultations using static images were performed at the Department of Telemedicine, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology (AFIP) between November 1994 and September 2001, with 98.3% receiving a telepathology diagnosis. In 47.9% of cases, imagery was considered good by AFIP consultants, 38.5% were considered adequate, and 14.6% of cases were considered to have poor-quality imagery. Deficiencies in image quality were recorded for each case. Cases with imagery rated as good averaged significantly fewer deficiencies per case (0.45, range: 0 to 3) than cases with imagery rated adequate (0.95, range: 0 to 6) or poor (2.4, range: 0 to 7). Deficiencies in focus were most commonly identified in this series of cases (28.1%), followed by improper white balancing of the capture device (14.1%) and inadequate resolution (10%). Cases in which images were of inadequate resolution showed an increased likelihood for discordance between the telepathology diagnosis and the diagnosis rendered on follow-up material ("truth diagnosis"). Inadequate field selection, although only cited in 6.7% of cases overall, was seen with a significantly higher frequency in cases in which there was discordance between the telepathology and truth diagnosis. A review of common image deficiencies in static-image telepathology and possible causes is presented.

Theory and applications of telemedicine

In this study, telemedicine and the use of advanced telemedicine technologies are explained. Telemedicine is the use of modern telecommunications and information technologies for the provision of clinical care to individuals at a distance, and transmission of information to provide that care. Telemedicine can be used for decision making, remote sensing, and collaborative arrangements for the real-time management of patients at a distance. The use of telecommunications and information technologies in providing health services is determined. Telemedicine is described as combination of topics from the fields of telecommunication, medicine, and informatics. The medical systems infrastructure consisting of the equipment and processes used to acquire and present clinical information and to store and retrieve data are explained in details. The challenges existing in telemedicine development in different countries are given. Technological, political, and professional barriers in applications of telemedicine are defined. An investigation of telemedicine applications in various fields is presented, and enormous impact of telemedicine systems on the future of medicine is determined.

Internet teleconferencing method for telepathology consultations from lung and heart transplant patients

Current Internet-based teleconferencing techniques allow a referring pathologist to transmit real-time images from a microscope to a consultant, while maintaining a verbal conversation using Internet telephony. In our study, 50 randomly selected transbronchial biopsies from lung allograft recipients and 58 randomly selected endomyocardial biopsies from heart transplant patients were diagnosed by consultant pathologists using Internet-based teleconferencing methods. The referring pathologists acquired the real-time video images from the biopsies using a light microscope equipped with a phototube adapter and a video camera. The consultant pathologists viewed the processed images on a video monitor at 800 x 600 resolution, using a standard microcomputer equipped with Netmeeting software, and directed the referring pathologist to move the slide under the microscopy and/or change image magnification. The validity of telepathology diagnoses was assessed with kappa coefficients. Consultations were completed in 5 to 15 minutes per case. Sound transmission was unreliable, and in approximately 25% of consultations the referring pathologist needed to "call back" to reestablish verbal communication. In all but 2 transbronchial biopsies there was agreement between the original diagnosis and the diagnosis by telepathology (kappa = 0.92). In 48 of 58 endomyocardial biopsies there was concordance between the 2 diagnoses (kappa = 0.692). Only 3 out of 10 of these discrepancies were clinically significant (kappa = 0.897). Internet-based teleconferencing techniques provide effective and relatively inexpensive tools for real time telepathology consultations. The technology is probably best suited for the study of small specimens from patients that require rapid diagnosis by a consultant.

Clinical evaluation of an international static image-based telepathology service

Telepathology is the use of telecommunications technology as a means to facilitate transfer of image-rich pathology data between remote locations for the purposes of diagnosis, education, and research. Although varying levels of technology exist to accomplish this task, static image--based systems are currently the most widely used around the world. Field selection and image quality have often been identified as major impediments to the successful use of static images for diagnostic telepathology. Between November 1994 and July 1999, the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology (AFIP) performed electronic consultation on over 1,250 static image--based cases, recording a clinically significant concordance rate of 97.3% between telepathology and final diagnosis (in cases in which follow-up material was available). For the same subset of cases, an absolute concordance rate of 73.7% was attained. A review of the case flow and construction of the AFIP telepathology system is presented, as well as factors that have an impact on the diagnostic accuracy of static image-based telepathology sytems in general.

Telemedicine in radiotherapy treatment planning: requirements and applications

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Telemedicine facilitates decentralized radiotherapy services by allowing remote treatment planning and quality assurance of treatment delivery. A prerequisite is digital storage of relevant data and an efficient and reliable telecommunication system between satellite units and the main radiotherapy clinic. The requirements of a telemedicine system in radiotherapy is influenced by the level of support needed. In this paper we differentiate between three categories of telemedicine support in radiotherapy.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Level 1 features video conferencing and display of radiotherapy images and dose plans. Level 2 involves replication of selected data from the radiotherapy database - facilitating remote treatment planning and evaluation. Level 3 includes real-time, remote operations, e.g. target volume delineation and treatment planning performed by the team at the satellite unit under supervision and guidance from more experienced colleagues at the main clinic.

Improving accuracy in the grading of renal cell carcinoma by combining the quantitative description of chromatin pattern with the quantitative determination of cell kinetic parameters

The determination of grade and stage in renal cell carcinomas (RCCs) often fails to predict the actual clinical outcome for individual patients. The aim of the present work was to investigate whether it is possible to significantly improve the prognostic accuracy of the grading system by using the combination of two independent computer-assisted microscopy techniques. The first technique relates to the quantitative description of morphonuclear and nuclear DNA content features by means of the image analysis of Feulgen-stained cell nuclei, and the second quantitatively characterizes tumor growth by means of different cell kinetic parameters. These parameters consist of a duplication of a time-related parameter determined by means of the technique of using silver-stained proteins in interphase nucleolar organizer regions (AgNOR), a proliferation index determined by means of MIB-1 immunohistochemistry, and an apoptotic index determined by means of the terminal dUTP nick end labeling technique. The prognostic value of these quantitative features was investigated in a series of 60 RCCs. The quantitative analysis of Feulgen-stained nuclei made it possible to identify subgroups of patients with significantly different prognoses in both grade II and grade III RCCs. We labeled the RCCs associated with the most favorable prognoses as grade II- and III- and those with the least favorable ones as grade II+ and III+. The two most important kinetic variables to identify patients with different clinical outcomes were the MIB-1 index and the mean AgNOR area in the MIB-1-positive cells. Three significantly different survival curves were obtained for the 53 grade II and III RCC patients. Our results show that conventional RCC grading can be significantly improved by the quantitative analysis of Feulgen-stained nuclei, by cell kinetic parameter determination, and, more importantly, by combining the proliferation index with the mean AgNOR area parameter.

Laboratory medicine in the United Kingdom: 1948-1998 and beyond

The National Health Service in the United Kingdom was created in 1948, effectively becoming the main provider of healthcare and funded by the government from taxation. By the late 1970's, and despite many achievements, it was seen to be approaching a financial crisis. Radical reforms were introduced in the early 1990's bringing in general management, a split between purchaser and provider, and competition. Whilst there has been a change of government more recently several of these initiatives have been retained, with the exception of competition (the internal market) which has been abandoned. There is now a much greater focus on the quality of care with increased clinical and financial accountability. Laboratory medicine (generally termed pathology in the United Kingdom) has evolved to meet the demands of more patients, reducing turnaround times, a greater repertoire of investigations and a continuing improvement in productivity. There is an increasing focus on improved dialogue between the laboratory and the clinician covering interpretation of results, audit of services and outcomes, research and development and continuous education in the pursuit of a high quality service. The major challenges for the future focus on alternative modes of delivery, on issues relating to staffing and on quality of service, in the face of an ever increasing demand.

Image sampling in static telepathology for frozen section diagnosis

BACKGROUND

A frozen section diagnostic service is often not directly available in small rural or mountain hospitals. In these cases, it could be possible to provide frozen section diagnosis through telepathology systems. Telepathology is based on two main methods: static and dynamic. The former is less expensive, but involves the crucial problem of image sampling.

AIMS

To characterise the differences in image sampling for static telepathology when undertaken by pathologists with different experience.

METHODS

As a test field, a previously studied telepathology method based on multimedia email was adopted. Using this method, three pathologists with different levels of experience sampled images from 155 routine frozen sections and sent them to a distant pathology institute, where diagnoses were made on digital images. After the telepathology diagnoses, the glass slides of both the frozen sections and the definitive sections were sent to the remote pathologists for review.

RESULTS

Four of 155 transmissions were considered inadequate by the remote pathologist. In the remaining 151 cases, the telepathology diagnosis agreed with the gold standard in 146 (96.7%). There was no significant divergence between the three pathologists in their sampling of the images. Each case comprised five images on average, acquired in four minutes. The overall time for transmission was about 19 minutes.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that in routine frozen section diagnosis an inexperienced pathologist can sample images sufficiently well to permit remote diagnosis. However, as expected, the internet is too unreliable for such a time dependent task. An improvement in the system would involve integrated real time features, so that there could be interaction between the two pathologists.

Interactive television and the NHS: too much television could be bad for your health

Images