Larvicidal toxicity of Japanese Bacillus thuringiensis against the mosquito Anopheles stephensi

Isolation and characterization of native Bacillus thuringiensis strains from Saudi Arabia with enhanced larvicidal toxicity against the mosquito vector Anopheles gambiae (s.l.)

BACKGROUND

Worldwide, mosquito vectors are transmitting several etiological agents of important human diseases, including malaria, causing millions of deaths every year. In Saudi Arabia, as elsewhere, vector-control is based mostly on chemical insecticides which may be toxic and cause environmental deprivation. Here, to support the development of bio-pesticide alternatives, a study was conducted to identify native Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) isolates with improved toxicity against the malaria vector, Anopheles gambiae (s.l.).

METHODS

Sixty-eight Bt isolates were obtained from 300 soil and other samples collected from 16 sites across Saudi Arabia. Bt identification was based on morphological characteristics of colonies, shape of parasporal crystals and biochemical profiles. After characterization of their mosquitocidal activity, larvicidal strains were described through 16S ribosomal DNA gene sequencing, cry, cyt and chi genes PCR-amplification profiles, and SDS-PAGE protein analyses.

RESULTS

Spherical Bt crystals were predominant amongst the 68 isolates (34%), while irregular, bi-pyramidal and spore-attached crystals were found in 32, 13 and 21% of strains, respectively. LC50 and LC90 bioassays showed that 23/68 isolates were larvicidal, with distinct biochemical activity profiles compared to non-larvicidal Bt strains. Eight larvicidal strains showed larvicidal activity up to 3.4-fold higher (LC50 range: 3.90-7.40 μg/ml) than the reference Bti-H14 strain (LC50 = 13.33 μg/ml). Of these, 6 strains had cry and cyt gene profiles similar to Bti-H14 (cry4Aa, cry4Ba, cry10, cry11, cyt1Aa, cyt1Ab, cyt2Aa). The seventh strain (Bt63) displaying the highest larvicidal activity (LC50 = 3.90 μg/ml) missed the cry4Aa and cyt1Ab genes and had SDS-PAGE protein profiles and spore/crystal sizes distinct from Bti-H14. The eight strain (Bt55) with LC50 of 4.11μg/ml had cry and cyt gene profiles similar to Bti-H14 but gave a chi gene PCR product size of 2027bp. No strains harbouring cry2, cry17 + 27, cry24 + 40, cry25, cry29, cry30, or cyt2Ba were detected.

CONCLUSION

This study represents the first report of several Saudi indigenous Bt strains with significantly higher larvicidal efficacy against An. gambiae than the reference Bti-H14 strain. The very high toxicity of the Bt63 strain, combined with distinct cry and cyt genes and SDS-PAGE-protein profiles makes it a promising candidate for future applications in mosquito bio-control.

Extremely high frequency of common flagellar antigens between Bacillus thuringiensis and Bacillus cereus

Bacillus cereus isolates, recovered from natural environments of Japan, were examined for their flagellar (H) antigenicities with the reference H antisera against Bacillus thuringiensis serotypes H1-H55. Of 236 B. cereus isolates tested, 165 (70%) were agglutinated with the reference antisera available. The frequencies of seropositive isolates were: 77% in soils, 68% on phylloplanes, and 60% in animal fecal populations. Among the 45 H serogroups detected, the serovar shandongiensis (H22) was the predominant, followed by the serovars entomocidus (H6), indiana (H16), pakistani (H13), and neoleonensis (H24ab). These five H serovars were commonly distributed in the three populations from different sources.

Specificity of lectin activity of Bacillus thuringiensis parasporal inclusion proteins

Sheep erythrocyte-agglutinating parasporal inclusion proteins from four Bacillus thuringiensis strains (FITC-20, FITC-73, FITC-76 and IBC-1456) were examined for lectin activity against erythrocytes from four mammalian (rabbit, horse, cow and guinea pig) and an avian (chicken) species. Of the five erythrocyte species, only rabbit cells were agglutinated with the protein of the human cancer cell-killing strain IBC-1456. No haemagglutination (HA) activities were shown in other protein-erythrocyte combinations. The lectin activity of the strain IBC-1456 against rabbit cells was strongly inhibited by preincubation with D-galactose. Overall results revealed that the B. thuringiensis lectins have a preference for sheep erythrocytes.

A 28 kDa protein of the Bacillus thuringiensis serovar shandongiensis isolate 89-T-34-22 induces a human leukemic cell-specific cytotoxicity

A 28 kDa protein that exhibits cytocidal activity specific for human leukemic T (MOLT-4) cells was purified from proteinase K-digested parasporal inclusion of a Bacillus thuringiensis serovar shandongiensis isolate. The N-terminal sequence of the protein was identical with that of the 32 kDa protein, regarded as a protoxin, of the inclusion proteins. The median effective concentration of this protein was 0.23 microg/ml against MOLT-4 cells and its specific activity was 7.9 times greater than that of the whole inclusion proteins. The 28 kDa protein induced necrosis-like cytotoxicity against MOLT-4 cells and the cytopathic effect with the passage of time was characterized by cell swelling, nuclear membrane isolation and chromatin condensation.

Parasporin, a human leukemic cell-recognizing parasporal protein of Bacillus thuringiensis

An unusual property, human leukemic cell-recognizing activity, associated with parasporal inclusions of a noninsecticidal Bacillus thuringiensis soil isolate was investigated, and a protein (named parasporin in this study) responsible for the activity was cloned. The parasporin, encoded by a gene 2,169 bp long, was a polypeptide of 723 amino acid residues with a predicted molecular weight of 81, 045. The sequence of parasporin contained the five conserved blocks commonly found in B. thuringiensis Cry proteins; however, only very low homologies (<25%) between parasporin and the existing classes of Cry and Cyt proteins were detected. Parasporin exhibited cytocidal activity only when degraded by proteases into smaller molecules of 40 to 60 kDa. Trypsin and proteinase K activated parasporin, while chymotrypsin did not. The activated parasporin showed strong cytocidal activity against human leukemic T cells (MOLT-4) and human uterus cervix cancer cells (HeLa) but not against normal T cells.

In vitro cytotoxicity of non-cyt inclusion proteins of a Bacillus thuringiensis isolate against human cells, including cancer cells

A soil isolate designated 90-F-45-14, belonging to Bacillus thuringiensis serovar dakota (H15), was examined for characterization of in vitro cytotoxicity, associated with parasporal inclusion proteins, against human cells. When activated with proteolytic processing, inclusion proteins of the isolate 90-F-45-14 exhibited a moderate cytotoxicity against the human uterus cervix cancer cells (HeLa) with an EC(50) value of 60.8 microg ml(-1), while showing extremely high activities on the human leukaemic T cells (MOLT-4) and the normal T cells with EC(50) values of 0.27 and 0.20 microg ml(-1), respectively. Anti-leukaemic cell activity of the 90-F-45-14 proteins was eight to nine times greater than that of the B. thuringiensis serovar israelensis proteins containing the Cyt1 protein, a broad-spectrum cytolysin. The cytopathy by the 90-F-45-14 proteins was characterized by marked cell-ballooning, while the israelensis proteins induced early breakdown of the cells due to cytolysis. Inclusions of the isolate consisted of five major polypeptides of 170, 103, 73, 40 and 32 kDa. A 100% homology was observed in the sequence of 15 N-terminal amino acids between the proteins of 170 and 103 kDa. There was no N-terminal sequence homology between 90-F-45-14 proteins and the existing Cry/Cyt proteins of B. thuringiensis. Proteolytic processing by proteinase K yielded several proteins with molecular masses ranging from 40 to 28 kDa.

Noninsecticidal parasporal proteins of a Bacillus thuringiensis serovar shandongiensis isolate exhibit a preferential cytotoxicity against human leukemic T cells

A Bacillus thuringiensis isolate, 89-T-34-22, belonging to the serovar shandongiensis (H22) produced noninsecticidal and nonhemolytic proteins crystallizing into irregular-shaped parasporal inclusions. The proteins showed in vitro cytotoxicity to human cells, including cancer cells, only when activated by protease treatment. The human leukemic T (MOLT-4) cells were > 100 times more susceptible than HeLa and normal T cells to the proteins of 89-T-34-22. The cytotoxicity was dose dependent and the median effective concentration for the MOLT-4 was 3.5 microg/ml. The cytopathy induced by the 89-T-34-22 proteins was characterized by remarkable condensation of the nucleus and cell-ballooning. Five major parasporal proteins of 89-T-34-22, with molecular masses in the range of 16-160 kDa, shared no similarity with the previously reported proteins in terms of the N-terminal sequence.

Larval susceptibility of the diamondback moth, Plutella xylostella (Lepidoptera: Plutellidae), to Bacillus thuringiensis H serovars isolated in Japan

A total of 1700 Japanese strains of Bacillus thuringiensis, belonging to at least 47 H serogroups, were examined for insecticidal activity against larvae of the diamondback moth, Plutella xylostella. The high-level toxicity was associated with 612 isolates (36.0%). Of these, 608 isolates (99.3%) fell into 13 H serogroups belonging to the low-numbered H serotypes, H1-H10. Conversely, most isolates belonging to the high-numbered serotypes (>H10) had little or no larvicidal activity; only one isolate of the serovar japonensis H23 was active. P xylostella larvae were susceptible to 89.8% of the serovar morrisoni H8a:8b strains and 85.7% of galleriae H5a:5b strains. High values of 60-80% were also obtained in six serovars (thuringiensis H1, alesti H3a:3c, kurstaki H3a:3b:3c, kenyae H4a:4c, aizawai H7, and tolworhi H9), while relatively low values of <60% in two other common serovars, sotto H4a:4b and darmstadiensis H10a:10b. Five selected isolates, belonging to H serovars other than kurstaki and aizawai, were 10-60 times less toxic than the reference strain HD-1 (serovar kurstaki). Parasporal inclusion proteins of these strains were immunologically unrelated to those of the strain HD-1 and the aizawai type strain.

Lectin activity of Bacillus thuringiensis parasporal inclusion proteins

Parasporal inclusion proteins from a total of 151 Bacillus thuringiensis strains, consisting of 139 Japanese isolates and the type strains of 12 H serovars, were screened for haemagglutination (HA) activity against sheep erythrocytes. Of 58 B. thuringiensis strains with HA activity, nine strains exhibited high activity and the remaining 49 strains were moderately active. The strains with high HA activity were derived from phylloplanes and soils of five geographically different localities, and belonged to H serovars kurstaki and other undefined serotype(s). The HA activities in the four selected strains were generated only when alkali-solubilised parasporal inclusion proteins were proteolytically processed. Furthermore, the lectin activity of the four strains was strongly inhibited by preincubation with N-acetylgalactosamine. The lectin-producing B. thuringiensis strains were heterogeneous in other biological activities of parasporal inclusions: insecticidal activity and cytocidal action on human leukaemia T cells.

Unique activity associated with non-insecticidal Bacillus thuringiensis parasporal inclusions: in vitro cell-killing action on human cancer cells

Parasporal inclusion proteins from a total of 1744 Bacillus thuringiensis strains, consisting of 1700 Japanese isolates and 44 reference type strains of existing H serovars, were screened for cytocidal activity against human leukaemia T cells and haemolytic activity against sheep erythrocytes. Of 1684 B. thuringiensis strains having no haemolytic activity, 42 exhibited in vitro cytotoxicity against leukaemia T cells. These non-haemolytic but leukaemia cell-toxic strains belonged to several H-serovars including dakota, neoleonensis, shandongiensis, coreanensis and other unidentified serogroups. Purified parasporal inclusions of the three selected strains, designated 84-HS-1-11, 89-T-26-17 and 90-F-45-14, exhibited no haemolytic activity and no insecticidal activity against dipteran and lepidopteran insects, but were highly cytocidal against leukaemia T cells and other human cancer cells, showing different toxicity spectra and varied activity levels. Furthermore, the proteins from 84-HS-1-11 and 89-T-26-17 were able to discriminate between leukaemia and normal T cells, specifically killing the former cells. These findings may lead to the use of B. thuringiensis inclusion proteins for medical purposes.