A novel autoregulation mechanism of fnrN expression in Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae

What determines symbiotic nitrogen fixation efficiency in rhizobium: recent insights into Rhizobium leguminosarum

Symbiotic nitrogen fixation (SNF) by rhizobium, a Gram-negative soil bacterium, is an essential component in the nitrogen cycle and is a sustainable green way to maintain soil fertility without chemical energy consumption. SNF, which results from the processes of nodulation, rhizobial infection, bacteroid differentiation and nitrogen-fixing reaction, requires the expression of various genes from both symbionts with adaptation to the changing environment. To achieve successful nitrogen fixation, rhizobia and their hosts cooperate closely for precise regulation of symbiotic genes, metabolic processes and internal environment homeostasis. Many researches have progressed to reveal the ample information about regulatory aspects of SNF during recent decades, but the major bottlenecks regarding improvement of nitrogen-fixing efficiency has proven to be complex. In this mini-review, we summarize recent advances that have contributed to understanding the rhizobial regulatory aspects that determine SNF efficiency, focusing on the coordinated regulatory mechanism of symbiotic genes, oxygen, carbon metabolism, amino acid metabolism, combined nitrogen, non-coding RNAs and internal environment homeostasis. Unraveling regulatory determinants of SNF in the nitrogen-fixing protagonist rhizobium is expected to promote an improvement of nitrogen-fixing efficiency in crop production.

Multiple sensors provide spatiotemporal oxygen regulation of gene expression in a Rhizobium-legume symbiosis

Regulation by oxygen (O₂) in rhizobia is essential for their symbioses with plants and involves multiple O₂ sensing proteins. Three sensors exist in the pea microsymbiont Rhizobium leguminosarum Rlv3841: hFixL, FnrN and NifA. At low O₂ concentrations (1%) hFixL signals via FxkR to induce expression of the FixK transcription factor, which activates transcription of downstream genes. These include fixNOQP, encoding the high-affinity cbb₃-type terminal oxidase used in symbiosis. In free-living Rlv3841, the hFixL-FxkR-FixK pathway was active at 1% O₂, and confocal microscopy showed hFixL-FxkR-FixK activity in the earliest stages of Rlv3841 differentiation in nodules (zones I and II). Work on Rlv3841 inside and outside nodules showed that the hFixL-FxkR-FixK pathway also induces transcription of fnrN at 1% O₂ and in the earliest stages of Rlv3841 differentiation in nodules. We confirmed past findings suggesting a role for FnrN in fixNOQP expression. However, unlike hFixL-FxkR-FixK, Rlv3841 FnrN was only active in the near-anaerobic zones III and IV of pea nodules. Quantification of fixNOQP expression in nodules showed this was driven primarily by FnrN, with minimal direct hFixL-FxkR-FixK induction. Thus, FnrN is key for full symbiotic expression of fixNOQP. Without FnrN, nitrogen fixation was reduced by 85% in Rlv3841, while eliminating hFixL only reduced fixation by 25%. The hFixL-FxkR-FixK pathway effectively primes the O₂ response by increasing fnrN expression in early differentiation (zones I-II). In zone III of mature nodules, near-anaerobic conditions activate FnrN, which induces fixNOQP transcription to the level required for wild-type nitrogen fixation activity. Modelling and transcriptional analysis indicates that the different O₂ sensitivities of hFixL and FnrN lead to a nuanced spatiotemporal pattern of gene regulation in different nodule zones in response to changing O₂ concentration. Multi-sensor O₂ regulation is prevalent in rhizobia, suggesting the fine-tuned control this enables is common and maximizes the effectiveness of the symbioses.

Rhizobia are soil bacteria that form a symbiosis with legume plants. In exchange for shelter from the plant, rhizobia provide nitrogen fertilizer, produced by nitrogen fixation. Fixation is catalysed by the nitrogenase enzyme, which is inactivated by oxygen. To prevent this, plants house rhizobia in root nodules, which create a low oxygen environment. However, rhizobia need oxygen, and must adapt to survive the low oxygen concentration in the nodule. Key to this is regulating their genes based on oxygen concentration. We studied one Rhizobium species which uses three different protein sensors of oxygen, each turning on at a different oxygen concentration. As the bacteria get deeper inside the plant nodule and the oxygen concentration drops, each sensor switches on in turn. Our results also show that the first sensor to turn on, hFixL, primes the second sensor, FnrN. This prepares the rhizobia for the core region of the nodule where oxygen concentration is lowest and most nitrogen fixation takes place. If both sensors are removed, the bacteria cannot fix nitrogen. Many rhizobia have several oxygen sensing proteins, so using multiple sensors is likely a common strategy enabling rhizobia to adapt to low oxygen precisely and in stages during symbiosis.

Formulation of a Highly Effective Inoculant for Common Bean Based on an Autochthonous Elite Strain of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli, and Genomic-Based Insights Into Its Agronomic Performance

Common bean is a poor symbiotic N-fixer, with a low response to inoculation owing to its promiscuous nodulation with competitive but inefficient resident rhizobia. Consequently, farmers prefer to fertilize them rather than rely on their capacity for Biological Nitrogen Fixation (BNF). However, when rhizobial inoculants are based on autochthonous strains, they often have superior BNF performance in the field due to their genetic adaptations to the local environment. Nevertheless, there is scant information at the genomic level explaining their superiority or on how their genomes may influence the inoculant performance. This information is especially important in technologically advanced agri-systems like Europe, where environmental concerns and increasingly stringent fertilizer regulations are encouraging a return to the use of rhizobial inoculants, but based upon strains that have been thoroughly characterized in terms of their symbiotic performance and their genetics. The aim of this study was to design an inoculant formulation based on a superior autochthonous strain, Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli LCS0306, to assess its performance in the field, and to determine the genomic features contributing to the high effectiveness of its symbiosis with common bean. Plants inoculated with the autochthonous strain LCS0306 fixed significantly more nitrogen than those with the allochthonous strains R. phaseoli ATCC 14482^T and R. etli CFN42^T, and had grain yield similar to the nitrogen-fertilized controls. Inoculation with LCS0306 was particularly efficacious when formulated with a carrier based upon a mixture of perlite and biochar. Whole genome comparisons revealed no differences in the classical symbiotic genes of strain LCS0306 within the symbiovar phaseoli. However, its symbiotic superior performance might be due to its genomic versatility, as it harbors a large assortment of genes contributing to fitness and competitiveness. It is concluded that inoculation with elite rhizobia formulated with perlite-biochar carriers might constitute a step-change in the sustainable cultivation of common bean in Spanish soils.

Oxygen regulatory mechanisms of nitrogen fixation in rhizobia

Rhizobia are α- and β-proteobacteria that form a symbiotic partnership with legumes, fixing atmospheric dinitrogen to ammonia and providing it to the plant. Oxygen regulation is key in this symbiosis. Fixation is performed by an oxygen-intolerant nitrogenase enzyme but requires respiration to meet its high energy demands. To satisfy these opposing constraints the symbiotic partners cooperate intimately, employing a variety of mechanisms to regulate and respond to oxygen concentration. During symbiosis rhizobia undergo significant changes in gene expression to differentiate into nitrogen-fixing bacteroids. Legumes host these bacteroids in specialized root organs called nodules. These generate a near-anoxic environment using an oxygen diffusion barrier, oxygen-binding leghemoglobin and control of mitochondria localization. Rhizobia sense oxygen using multiple interconnected systems which enable a finely-tuned response to the wide range of oxygen concentrations they experience when transitioning from soil to nodules. The oxygen-sensing FixL-FixJ and hybrid FixL-FxkR two-component systems activate at relatively high oxygen concentration and regulate fixK transcription. FixK activates the fixNOQP and fixGHIS operons producing a high-affinity terminal oxidase required for bacterial respiration in the microaerobic nodule. Additionally or alternatively, some rhizobia regulate expression of these operons by FnrN, an FNR-like oxygen-sensing protein. The final stage of symbiotic establishment is activated by the NifA protein, regulated by oxygen at both the transcriptional and protein level. A cross-species comparison of these systems highlights differences in their roles and interconnections but reveals common regulatory patterns and themes. Future work is needed to establish the complete regulon of these systems and identify other regulatory signals.

Complete genome of Rhizobium leguminosarum Norway, an ineffective Lotus micro-symbiont

Rhizobia bacteria engage in nitrogen-fixing root nodule symbiosis, a mutualistic interaction with legume plants in which a bidirectional nutrient exchange takes place. Occasionally, this interaction is suboptimal resulting in the formation of ineffective nodules in which little or no atmospheric nitrogen fixation occurs. Rhizobium leguminosarum Norway induces ineffective nodules in a wide range of Lotus hosts. To investigate the basis of this phenotype, we sequenced the complete genome of Rl Norway and compared it to the genome of the closely related strain R. leguminosarum bv. viciae 3841. The genome comprises 7,788,085 bp, distributed on a circular chromosome containing 63% of the genomic information and five large circular plasmids. The functionally classified bacterial gene set is distributed evenly among all replicons. All symbiotic genes (nod, fix, nif) are located on the pRLN3 plasmid. Whole genome comparisons revealed differences in the metabolic repertoire and in protein secretion systems, but not in classical symbiotic genes.

Genomic Diversity in the Endosymbiotic Bacterium Rhizobium leguminosarum

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae is a soil α-proteobacterium that establishes a diazotrophic symbiosis with different legumes of the Fabeae tribe. The number of genome sequences from rhizobial strains available in public databases is constantly increasing, although complete, fully annotated genome structures from rhizobial genomes are scarce. In this work, we report and analyse the complete genome of R. leguminosarum bv. viciae UPM791. Whole genome sequencing can provide new insights into the genetic features contributing to symbiotically relevant processes such as bacterial adaptation to the rhizosphere, mechanisms for efficient competition with other bacteria, and the ability to establish a complex signalling dialogue with legumes, to enter the root without triggering plant defenses, and, ultimately, to fix nitrogen within the host. Comparison of the complete genome sequences of two strains of R. leguminosarum bv. viciae, 3841 and UPM791, highlights the existence of different symbiotic plasmids and a common core chromosome. Specific genomic traits, such as plasmid content or a distinctive regulation, define differential physiological capabilities of these endosymbionts. Among them, strain UPM791 presents unique adaptations for recycling the hydrogen generated in the nitrogen fixation process.

What determines the efficiency of N(2)-fixing Rhizobium-legume symbioses?

Biological nitrogen fixation is vital to nutrient cycling in the biosphere and is the major route by which atmospheric dinitrogen (N(2)) is reduced to ammonia. The largest single contribution to biological N(2) fixation is carried out by rhizobia, which include a large group of both alpha and beta-proteobacteria, almost exclusively in association with legumes. Rhizobia must compete to infect roots of legumes and initiate a signaling dialog with host plants that leads to nodule formation. The most common form of infection involves the growth of rhizobia down infection threads which are laid down by the host plant. Legumes form either indeterminate or determinate types of nodules, with these groups differing widely in nodule morphology and often in the developmental program by which rhizobia form N(2) fixing bacteroids. In particular, indeterminate legumes from the inverted repeat-lacking clade (IRLC) (e.g., peas, vetch, alfalfa, medics) produce a cocktail of antimicrobial peptides which cause endoreduplication of the bacterial genome and force rhizobia into a nongrowing state. Bacteroids often become dependent on the plant for provision of key cofactors, such as homocitrate needed for nitrogenase activity or for branched chain amino acids. This has led to the suggestion that bacteroids at least from the IRLC can be considered as ammoniaplasts, where they are effectively facultative plant organelles. A low O(2) tension is critical both to induction of genes needed for N(2) fixation and to the subsequent exchange of nutrient between plants and bacteroids. To achieve high rates of N(2) fixation, the legume host and Rhizobium must be closely matched not only for infection, but for optimum development, nutrient exchange, and N(2) fixation. In this review, we consider the multiple steps of selection and bacteroid development and how these alter the overall efficiency of N(2) fixation.

The C-terminal receiver domain of the Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae FixL protein is required for free-living microaerobic induction of the fnrN promoter

The Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae VF39 FixL protein belongs to a distinct group of hybrid regulatory sensor proteins that bear a covalently linked C-terminal receiver domain. FixL has an unorthodox histidine kinase domain, which is shared with many other hybrid regulators. The purified FixL protein had autophosphorylation activity. A truncated protein, lacking the receiver domain, had a much-reduced autophosphorylation activity. However, this truncated protein still efficiently phosphorylated the purified receiver domain in trans. This indicates that, in the full-length FixL protein, the conserved histidine residue in the kinase domain is phosphorylated only transiently and that most of the phosphoryl label accumulates in the C-terminal receiver domain. Gene-fusion studies showed that the fixL gene is required for free-living microaerobic induction of the fnrN promoter. The presence of a functional fixK gene is not required. An R. leguminosarum strain lacking fixL could not be complemented with a truncated copy of the gene lacking the receiver domain. This indicates that the C-terminal receiver domain is an intermediate in the signal transduction pathway that links oxygen limitation to induction of the fnrN promoter in R. leguminosarum bv. viciae VF39.

Regulatory role of Rhizobium etli CNPAF512 fnrN during symbiosis

The Rhizobium etli CNPAF512 fnrN gene was identified in the fixABCX rpoN(2) region. The corresponding protein contains the hallmark residues characteristic of proteins belonging to the class IB group of Fnr-related proteins. The expression of R. etli fnrN is highly induced under free-living microaerobic conditions and during symbiosis. This microaerobic and symbiotic induction of fnrN is not controlled by the sigma factor RpoN and the symbiotic regulator nifA or fixLJ, but it is due to positive autoregulation. Inoculation of Phaseolus vulgaris with an R. etli fnrN mutant strain resulted in a severe reduction in the bacteroid nitrogen fixation capacity compared to the wild-type capacity, confirming the importance of FnrN during symbiosis. The expression of the R. etli fixN, fixG, and arcA genes is strictly controlled by fnrN under free-living microaerobic conditions and in bacteroids during symbiosis with the host. However, there is an additional level of regulation of fixN and fixG under symbiotic conditions. A phylogenetic analysis of the available rhizobial FnrN and FixK proteins grouped the proteins in three different clusters.

Characterization of a new internal promoter (P3) for Rhizobium leguminosarum hydrogenase accessory genes hupGHIJ

Synthesis of the Rhizobium leguminosarum [NiFe] hydrogenase requires the participation of 16 accessory genes (hupCDEFGHIJKhypABFCDEX) besides the genes encoding the structural proteins (hupSL). Transcription of hupSL is controlled by a -24/-12-type promoter (P(1)), located upstream of hupS and regulated by NifA. In this work, a second -24/-12-type promoter (P(3)), located upstream of the hupG gene and transcribing hupGHIJ genes in R. leguminosarum pea (Pisum sativum L.) bacteroids, has been identified in the hup gene cluster. Promoter P(3) was also active in R. leguminosarum free-living cells, as evidenced by genetic complementation of hydrogenase mutants. Both NifA and NtrC activated P(3) expression in the heterologous host Klebsiella pneumoniae. Also, P(3) activity was highly stimulated by K. pneumoniae NifA in Escherichia coli. This NifA activation of P(3) expression only required the sigma(54)-binding site, and it was independent of any cis-acting element upstream of the sigma(54) box, which suggests a direct interaction of free NifA with the RNA polymerase holoenzyme. P(3)-dependent hupGHIJ expression in pea nodules started in interzone II/III, spanned through nitrogen-fixing zone III, and was coincident with the NifA-dependent nifH expression pattern. However, P(3) was dispensable for hupGHIJ transcription and hydrogenase activity in pea bacteroids due to transcription initiated at P(1). This fact and the lack of an activator recruitment system suggest that P(3) plays a secondary role in symbiotic hupGHIJ expression.

Phylogeny of the bacterial superfamily of Crp-Fnr transcription regulators: exploiting the metabolic spectrum by controlling alternative gene programs

The Crp-Fnr regulators, named after the first two identified members, are DNA-binding proteins which predominantly function as positive transcription factors, though roles of repressors are also important. Among over 1200 proteins with an N-terminally located nucleotide-binding domain similar to the cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) receptor protein, the distinctive additional trait of the Crp-Fnr superfamily is a C-terminally located helix-turn-helix motif for DNA binding. From a curated database of 369 family members exhibiting both features, we provide a protein tree of Crp-Fnr proteins according to their phylogenetic relationships. This results in the assembly of the regulators ArcR, CooA, CprK, Crp, Dnr, FixK, Flp, Fnr, FnrN, MalR, NnrR, NtcA, PrfA, and YeiL and their homologs in distinct clusters. Lead members and representatives of these groups are described, placing emphasis on the less well-known regulators and target processes. Several more groups consist of sequence-derived proteins of unknown physiological roles; some of them are tight clusters of highly similar members. The Crp-Fnr regulators stand out in responding to a broad spectrum of intracellular and exogenous signals such as cAMP, anoxia, the redox state, oxidative and nitrosative stress, nitric oxide, carbon monoxide, 2-oxoglutarate, or temperature. To accomplish their roles, Crp-Fnr members have intrinsic sensory modules allowing the binding of allosteric effector molecules, or have prosthetic groups for the interaction with the signal. The regulatory adaptability and structural flexibility represented in the Crp-Fnr scaffold has led to the evolution of an important group of physiologically versatile transcription factors.

Regulation of gene expression in response to oxygen in Rhizobium etli: role of FnrN in fixNOQP expression and in symbiotic nitrogen fixation

Previously, we reported finding duplicated fixNOQP operons in Rhizobium etli CFN42. One of these duplicated operons is located in the symbiotic plasmid (fixNOQPd), while the other is located in a cryptic plasmid (fixNOQPf). Although a novel FixL-FixKf regulatory cascade participates in microaerobic expression of both fixNOQP duplicated operons, we found that a mutation in fixL eliminates fixNOQPf expression but has only a moderate effect on expression of fixNOQPd. This suggests that there are differential regulatory controls. Interestingly, only the fixNOQPd operon was essential for symbiotic nitrogen fixation (L. Girard, S. Brom, A. Dávalos, O. Lopez, M. Soberón, and D. Romero, Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 13:1283-1292, 2000). Searching for potential candidates responsible for the differential expression, we characterized two fnrN homologs (encoding transcriptional activators of the cyclic AMP receptor protein [CRP]-Fnr family) in R. etli CFN42. One of these genes (fnrNd) is located on the symbiotic plasmid, while the other (fnrNchr) is located on the chromosome. Analysis of the expression of the fnrN genes using transcriptional fusions with lacZ showed that the two fnrN genes are differentially regulated, since only fnrNd is expressed in microaerobic cultures of the wild-type strain while fnrNchr is negatively controlled by FixL. Mutagenesis of the two fnrN genes showed that both genes participate, in conjunction with FixL-FixKf, in the microaerobic induction of the fixNOQPd operon. Participation of these genes is also seen during the symbiotic process, in which mutations in fnrNd and fnrNchr, either singly or in combination, lead to reductions in nitrogen fixation. Therefore, R. etli employs a regulatory circuit for induction of the fixNOQPd operon that involves at least three transcriptional regulators of the CRP-Fnr family. This regulatory circuit may be important for ensuring optimal production of the cbb(3), terminal oxidase during symbiosis.

A novel promoter architecture for microaerobic activation by the anaerobic transcription factor FNR

The yfiD gene of Escherichia coli has an unusual promoter architecture in which an FNR dimer located at -93.5 inhibits transcription activation mediated by another FNR dimer bound at the typical class II position (-40.5). In vitro transcription from the yfiD promoter indicated that FNR alone can downregulate yfiD expression. Analysis of yfiD::lac reporters showed that five turns of the DNA helix between FNR sites was optimal for downregulation. FNR heterodimers, in which one subunit carried a defective repression surface, revealed that the upstream subunit of the -40.5 dimer and the downstream subunit of the -93.5 dimer were most important for downregulating yfiD expression. Deletion of the C-terminal domain of the alpha-subunit of RNA polymerase (RNAP) did not affect FNR-mediated repression, suggesting that repression is mediated through FNR-FNR and not FNR-RNAP interactions. Maximum yfiD::lac expression was observed in cultures exposed to 10 microM oxygen. More or less oxygen reduced expression dramatically. This pattern of response was dependent on the combination of a high-affinity site at the activating class II position and a lower affinity site at the upstream position.

Generation of new hydrogen-recycling Rhizobiaceae strains by introduction of a novel hup minitransposon

Hydrogen evolution by nitrogenase is a source of inefficiency for the nitrogen fixation process by the Rhizobium-legume symbiosis. To develop a strategy to generate rhizobial strains with H(2)-recycling ability, we have constructed a Tn5 derivative minitransposon (TnHB100) that contains the ca. 18-kb H(2) uptake (hup) gene cluster from Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae UPM791. Bacteroids from TnHB100-containing strains of R. leguminosarum bv. viciae PRE, Bradyrhizobium japonicum, R. etli, and Mesorhizobium loti expressed high levels of hydrogenase activity that resulted in full recycling of the hydrogen evolved by nitrogenase in nodules. Efficient processing of the hydrogenase large subunit (HupL) in these strains was shown by immunoblot analysis of bacteroid extracts. In contrast, Sinorhizobium meliloti, M. ciceri, and R. leguminosarum bv. viciae UML2 strains showed poor expression of the hup system that resulted in H(2)-evolving nodules. For the latter group of strains, no immunoreactive material was detected in bacteroid extracts using anti-HupL antiserum, suggesting a low level of transcription of hup genes or HupL instability. A general procedure for the characterization of the minitransposon insertion site and removal of antibiotic resistance gene included in TnHB100 has been developed and used to generate engineered strains suitable for field release.