Differential effects of mutations in the chromophore pocket of recombinant phytochrome on chromoprotein assembly and Pr-to-Pfr photoconversion

MAS NMR on a Red/Far-Red Photochromic Cyanobacteriochrome All2699 from Nostoc

Unlike canonical phytochromes, the GAF domain of cyanobacteriochromes (CBCRs) can bind bilins autonomously and is sufficient for functional photocycles. Despite the astonishing spectral diversity of CBCRs, the GAF1 domain of the three-GAF-domain photoreceptor all2699 from the cyanobacterium Nostoc 7120 is the only CBCR-GAF known that converts from a red-absorbing (Pr) dark state to a far-red-absorbing (Pfr) photoproduct, analogous to the more conservative phytochromes. Here we report a solid-state NMR spectroscopic study of all2699g1 in its Pr state. Conclusive NMR evidence unveils a particular stereochemical heterogeneity at the tetrahedral C3¹ atom, whereas the crystal structure shows exclusively the R-stereochemistry at this chiral center. Additional NMR experiments were performed on a construct comprising the GAF1 and GAF2 domains of all2699, showing a greater precision in the chromophore-protein interactions in the GAF1-2 construct. A 3D Pr structural model of the all2699g1-2 construct predicts a tongue-like region extending from the GAF2 domain (akin to canonical phytochromes) in the direction of the chromophore, shielding it from the solvent. In addition, this stabilizing element allows exclusively the R-stereochemistry for the chromophore-protein linkage. Site-directed mutagenesis performed on three conserved motifs in the hairpin-like tip confirms the interaction of the tongue region with the GAF1-bound chromophore.

Phototransformation of the red light sensor cyanobacterial phytochrome 2 from Synechocystis species depends on its tongue motifs

Phytochromes are photoreceptors using a bilin tetrapyrrole as chromophore, which switch in canonical phytochromes between red (Pr) and far red (Pfr) light-absorbing states. Cph2 from Synechocystis sp., a noncanonical phytochrome, harbors besides a cyanobacteriochrome domain a second photosensory module, a Pr/Pfr-interconverting GAF-GAF bidomain (SynCph2(1-2)). As in the canonical phytochromes, a unique motif of the second GAF domain, the tongue region, seals the bilin-binding site in the GAF1 domain from solvent access. Time-resolved spectroscopy of the SynCph2(1-2) module shows four intermediates during Pr → Pfr phototransformation and three intermediates during Pfr → Pr back-conversion. A mutation in the tongue's conserved PRXSF motif, S385A, affects the formation of late intermediate R3 and of a Pfr-like state but not the back-conversion to Pr via a lumi-F-like state. In contrast, a mutation in the likewise conserved WXE motif, W389A, changes the photocycle at intermediate R2 and causes an alternative red light-adapted state. Here, back-conversion to Pr proceeds via intermediates differing from SynCph2(1-2). Replacement of this tryptophan that is ∼15 Å distant from the chromophore by another aromatic amino acid, W389F, restores native Pr → Pfr phototransformation. These results indicate large scale conformational changes within the tongue region of GAF2 during the final processes of phototransformation. We propose that in early intermediates only the chromophore and its nearest surroundings are altered, whereas late changes during R2 formation depend on the distant WXE motifs of the tongue region. Ser-385 within the PRXSF motif affects only late intermediate R3, when refolding of the tongue and docking to the GAF1 domain are almost completed.

Kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of the light-induced processes in plant and cyanobacterial phytochromes

The light-induced processes of the biological photoreceptor phytochrome (recombinant phyA of oat and recombinant CphA from the cyanobacterium Tolypothrix PCC7601) have been investigated in a time-resolved manner in the temperature range from 0 to 30°C. Both proteins were heterologously expressed and assembled in vitro with phycocyanobilin. The Pr state of plant phytochrome phyA is converted to the Pfr state after formation of four intermediates with an overall quantum yield of ~18%. The reversal reaction (Pfr-to-Pr) shows several intermediates, all of which, even the first detectable one, exhibit already all spectral features of the Pr state. The canonical phytochrome CphA from Tolypothrix showed a similar intermediate sequence as its plant ortholog. Whereas the kinetics for the forward reaction (Pr-to-Pfr) was nearly identical for both proteins, the reverse process (Pr formation) in the cyanobacterial phytochrome was slower by a factor of three. As found for the Pfr-to-Pr intermediates in the plant protein, also in CphA all detectable intermediates showed the spectral features of the Pr form. For both phytochromes, activation parameters for both the forward and the backward reaction pathways were determined.

Mutation scanning and genotyping by high-resolution DNA melting analysis in olive germplasm

The application of high-resolution melting (HRM) analysis of DNA is reported for scanning and genotyping Olea europaea germplasm. To test the sensitivity of the method, a functional gene marker, phytochrome A (phyA), was used, since this gene is correlated with important traits for the ecology of the species. We have designed a set of oligos able to produce amplicons of 307 bp to scan for the presence of single polymorphic mutations in a specific phyA fragment encompassing the chromophore attachment site (Cys323). The presence of mutations for substitution, either homozygous or heterozygous, was easily detected by melting curve analysis in a high-resolution melter. It has been established that the sensitivity of the HRM analysis can be significantly improved designing specific primers very close to the mutation sites. All SNPs found were confirmed by sequence analyses and ARMS-PCR. The method has also been confirmed to be very powerful for the visualization of microsatellite (SSR) length polymorphisms. HRM analysis has a very high reproducibility and sensitivity for detecting SNPs and SSRs, allowing olive cultivar genotyping and resulting in an informative, easy, and low-cost method able to greatly reduce the operating time.

Domain interaction in cyanobacterial phytochromes as a prerequisite for spectral integrity

Two phytochromes, CphA and CphB, from the cyanobacterium Calothrix PCC7601, with similar size (768 and 766 amino acids) and domain structure, were investigated for the essential length of their protein moiety required to maintain the spectral integrity. Both proteins fold into PAS-, GAF-, PHY-, and Histidine-kinase (HK) domains. CphA binds a phycocyanobilin (PCB) chromophore at a "canonical" cysteine within the GAF domain, identically as in plant phytochromes. CphB binds biliverdin IXalpha at cysteine24, positioned in the N-terminal PAS domain. The C-terminally located HK and PHY domains, present in both proteins, were removed subsequently by introducing stop-codons at the corresponding DNA positions. The spectral properties of the resulting proteins were investigated. The full-length proteins absorb at (CphA) 663 and 707 nm (red-, far red-absorbing P (r) and P (fr) forms of phytochromes) and at (CphB) 704 and 750 nm. Removal of the HK domains had no effect on the absorbance maxima of the resulting PAS-GAF-PHY constructs (CphA: 663/707 nm, CphB: 704/750 nm, P (r)/P (fr), respectively). Further deletion of the "PHY" domains caused a blue-shift of the P (r) and P (fr) absorption of CphA (lambda (max): 658/698 nm) and increased the amount of unproperly folded apoprotein, seen by a reduced capability to bind the chromophore in photoconvertible manner. In CphB, however, it practically impaired the formation of P (fr), i.e., showing a very low oscillator strength absorption band, whereas the P (r) form remains unchanged (702 nm). This finding clearly indicates a different interaction between domains in the "typical", PCB binding and in the biliverdin-binding phytochromes, and demonstrates a loss of oscillator strength for the latter, most probably due to a strong conformational distortion of the chromophore in the CphB P (fr) form.

Homologous expression of a bacterial phytochrome. The cyanobacterium Fremyella diplosiphon incorporates biliverdin as a genuine, functional chromophore

Bacteriophytochromes constitute a light-sensing subgroup of sensory kinases with a chromophore-binding motif in the N-terminal half and a C-terminally located histidine kinase activity. The cyanobacterium Fremyella diplosiphon (also designated Calothrix sp.) expresses two sequentially very similar bacteriophytochromes, cyanobacterial phytochrome A (CphA) and cyanobacterial phytochrome B (CphB). Cyanobacterial phytochrome A has the canonical cysteine residue, by which covalent chromophore attachment is accomplished in the same manner as in plant phytochromes; however, its paralog cyanobacterial phytochrome B carries a leucine residue at that position. On the basis of in vitro experiments that showed, for both cyanobacterial phytochrome A and cyanobacterial phytochrome B, light-induced autophosphorylation and phosphate transfer to their cognate response regulator proteins RcpA and RcpB [Hübschmann T, Jorissen HJMM, Börner T, Gärtner W & deMarsac NT (2001) Eur J Biochem268, 3383-3389], we aimed at the identification of a chromophore that is incorporated in vivo into cyanobacterial phytochrome B within the cyanobacterial cell. The approach was based on the introduction of a copy of cphB into the cyanobacterium via triparental conjugation. The His-tagged purified, recombinant protein (CphBcy) showed photoreversible absorption bands similar to those of plant and bacterial phytochromes, but with remarkably red-shifted maxima [lambda(max) 700 and 748 nm, red-absorbing (P(r)) and far red-absorbing (P(fr)) forms of phytochrome, respectively]. A comparison of the absorption maxima with those of the heterologously generated apoprotein, assembled with phycocyanobilin (lambda(max) 686 and 734 nm) or with biliverdin IXalpha (lambda(max) 700 and 750 +/- 2 nm), shows biliverdin IXalpha to be a genuine chromophore. The kinase activity of CphBcy and phosphotransfer to its cognate response regulator was found to be strictly P(r)-dependent. As an N-terminally located cysteine was found as an alternative covalent binding site for several bacteriophytochrome photoreceptors that bind biliverdin and lack the canonical cysteine residue (e.g. Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Deinococcus radiodurans), this corresponding residue in heterologously expressed cyanobacterial phytochrome B was mutated into a serine (C24S); however, there was no change in its spectral properties. On the other hand, the mutation of His267, which is located directly after the canonical cysteine, into alanine (H267A), caused complete loss of the capability of cyanobacterial phytochrome B to form a chromoprotein.

Functional and Biochemical Analysis of the N-terminal Domain of Phytochrome A

Phytochrome A (phyA) is a versatile plant photoreceptor that mediates responses to brief light exposures (very low fluence responses, VLFR) as well as to prolonged irradiation (high irradiance responses, HIR). We identified the phyA-303 mutant allele of Arabidopsis thaliana bearing an R384K substitution in the GAF subdomain of the N-terminal half of phyA. phyA-303 showed reduced phyA spectral activity, almost normal VLFR, and severely impaired HIR. Recombinant N-terminal half oat of PHYA bearing the phyA-303 mutation showed poor incorporation of chromophore in vitro, despite the predicted relatively long distance (>13 A) between the mutation and the closest ring of the chromophore. Fusion proteins bearing the N-terminal domain of oat phyA, beta-glucuronidase, green fluorescent protein, and a nuclear localization signal showed physiological activity in darkness and mediated VLFR but not HIR. At equal protein levels, the phyA-303 mutation caused slightly less activity than the fusions containing the wild-type sequence. Taken together, these studies highlight the role of the N-terminal domain of phyA in signaling and of distant residues of the GAF subdomain in the regulation of phytochrome bilin-lyase activity.

Probing protein-chromophore interactions in Cph1 phytochrome by mutagenesis

We have investigated mutants of phytochrome Cph1 from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC6803 in order to study chromophore-protein interactions. Cph1Delta2, the 514-residue N-terminal sensor module produced as a recombinant His6-tagged apoprotein in Escherichia coli, autoassembles in vitro to form a holoprotein photochemically indistinguishable from the full-length product. We generated 12 site-directed mutants of Cph1Delta2, focusing on conserved residues which might be involved in chromophore-protein autoassembly and photoconversion. Folding, phycocyanobilin-binding and Pr-->Pfr photoconversion were analysed using CD and UV-visible spectroscopy. MALDI-TOF-MS confirmed C259 as the chromophore attachment site. C259L is unable to attach the chromophore covalently but still autoassembles to form a red-shifted photochromic holoprotein. H260Q shows UV-visible properties similar to the wild-type at pH 7.0 but both Pr and Pfr (reversibly) bleach at pH 9.0, indicating that the imidazole side chain buffers chromophore protonation. Mutations at E189 disturbed folding but the residue is not essential for chromophore-protein autoassembly. In D207A, whereas red irradiation of the ground state leads to bleaching of the red Pr band as in the wild-type, a Pfr-like peak does not arise, implicating D207 as a proton donor for a deprotonated intermediate prior to Pfr. UV-Vis spectra of both H260Q under alkaline conditions and D207A point to a particular significance of protonation in the Pfr state, possibly implying proton migration (release and re-uptake) during Pr-->Pfr photoconversion. The findings are discussed in relation to the recently published 3D structure of a bacteriophytochrome fragment.

RcaE is a complementary chromatic adaptation photoreceptor required for green and red light responsiveness

The recent discovery of large numbers of phytochrome photoreceptor genes in both photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic prokaryotes has led to efforts to understand their physiological roles in environmental acclimation. One receptor in this class, RcaE, is involved in controlling complementary chromatic adaptation, a process that regulates the transcription of operons encoding light-harvesting proteins in cyanobacteria. Although all previously identified phytochrome responses are maximally sensitive to red and far red light, complementary chromatic adaptation is unique in that it is responsive to green and red light. Here, we present biochemical and genetic evidence demonstrating that RcaE is a photoreceptor and that it requires the cysteine at position 198 to ligate an open chain tetrapyrrole covalently in a manner analogous to chromophore attachment in plant phytochromes. Furthermore, although the wild-type rcaE gene can rescue red and green light photoresponses of an rcaE null mutant, a gene in which the codon for cysteine 198 is converted to an alanine codon rescues the red light but not the green light response. Thus, RcaE is a photoreceptor that is required for both green and red light responsiveness during complementary chromatic adaptation and is the first identified phytochrome class sensor that is involved in sensing and responding to green and red light rather than red and far red light.

The Biliverdin Chromophore Binds Covalently to a Conserved Cysteine Residue in the N-Terminus ofAgrobacteriumPhytochrome Agp1†

Phytochromes are widely distributed biliprotein photoreceptors. Typically, the chromophore becomes covalently linked to the protein during an autocatalytic lyase reaction. Plant and cyanobacterial phytochromes incorporate bilins with a ring A ethylidene side chain, whereas other bacterial phytochromes utilize biliverdin as chromophore, which has a vinyl ring A side chain. For Agrobacterium phytochrome Agp1, site-directed mutagenesis provided evidence that biliverdin is bound to cysteine 20. This cysteine is highly conserved within bacterial homologues, but its role as attachment site has as yet not been proven. We therefore performed mass spectrometry studies on proteolytic holopeptide fragments. For that purpose, an Agp1 expression vector was re-engineered to produce a protein with an N-terminal affinity tag. Following proteolysis, the chromophore co-purified with a ca. 5 kDa fragment during affinity chromatography, showing that the attachment site is located close to the N-terminus. Mass spectrometry analyses performed with the purified chromopeptide confirmed the role of the cysteine 20 as biliverdin attachment site. We also analyzed the role of the highly conserved histidine 250 by site-directed mutagenesis. The homologous amino acid plays an important but yet undefined role in plant phytochromes and has been proposed as chromophore attachment site of Deinococcus phytochrome. We found that in Agp1, this amino acid is dispensable for covalent attachment, but required for tight chromophore-protein interaction.

Chromophore selectivity in bacterial phytochromes

Bacterial phytochromes (Bphs) are ancestors of the well characterized plant photoreceptors. Whereas plant phytochromes perform their photoisomerization exclusively via a covalently bound bilin chromophore, Bphs are variable in their chromophore selection. This is demonstrated in the cyanobacterium Calothrix PCC7601 that expresses two Bphs, CphA and CphB. CphA binds phycocyanobilin (PCB) covalently, whereas CphB, lacking the covalently binding cysteine of the plant phytochromes, carries biliverdin IXalpha (BV) as the chromophore. Our experiments elucidate the different modes of chromophore-protein interaction in CphA and CphB and offer a rationale for their chromophore selectivity. The tight binding of BV by CphB prevents PCB from competing for the binding cavity. Even when the chromophore-binding cysteine has been inserted (CphB-mutant L266C), PCB replaces BV very slowly, indicating the tight, but not irreversible binding of BV. The mutant CphB L266C showed a redox-sensitivity with respect to its PCB binding mode: under reducing conditions, the chromoprotein assembly leads to spectra indicative for a covalent binding, whereas absence of dithiothreitol or its removal prior to assembly causes spectra indicative for noncovalent binding. Regarding the CphB-type Bphs lacking the covalently binding cysteine, our results support the involvement of the succeeding histidine residue in chromophore fixation via a Schiff base-like bond between the bilin A-ring carbonyl and the histidine imidazole group. The assembly process and the stability of the holo-proteins were strongly influenced by the concentration of added imidazole (mimicking the histidine side-chain), making the attachment of the chromophore via the histidine more likely than via another cysteine of the protein.

Mechanism of Cph1 Phytochrome Assembly from Stopped-Flow Kinetics and Circular Dichroism

The kinetics and mechanism of the autocatalytic assembly of holo-Cph1 phytochrome (from Synechocystis) from the apoprotein and the bilin chromophores phycocyanobilin (PCB) and phycoerythrobilin (PEB) were investigated by stopped flow and circular dichroism. At 1:1 stoichiometry, pH 7.9, and 10 degrees C, SVD analysis of the kinetic data for PCB revealed three spectral components involving three transitions with time constants tau(1) approximately 150 ms, tau(2) approximately 2.5 s, and tau(3) approximately 50 s. Tau(1) was associated with a major red shift and transfer of oscillator strength from the Soret region to the 680 nm region. When the sulfhydryl group of cysteine 259 was blocked with iodoacetamide, preventing the formation of a covalent adduct, a noncovalent red-shifted complex (680 nm) was formed with a time constant of 200 ms. Tau(1) could thus be assigned to the formation of a noncovalent complex. The absorption changes during tau(1) are due to the formation of the extended conformation of the linear tetrapyrrole and to its protonation in the binding pocket. From the concentration and pH dependence of the kinetics we obtained a value of 1.5 microM for the K(D) of this noncovalent complex and a value of 8.4 for the pK(a) of the proton donor. The tau(2) component was associated with a blue shift of about 25 nm and was attributed to the formation of the covalent bond (P(r)), accompanied with the loss of the 3-3' double bond to ring A. Tau(3) was due to photoconversion to P(fr). For PEB, which is not photochromic, the formation of the noncovalent complex is faster (tau(1) = 70 ms), but the covalent bond formation is about 80 times slower (tau(2) = 200 s) than with the natural chromophore PCB. The CD spectra of the PCB adduct in the 250-800 nm range show that the chromophore geometries in P(r) and P(fr) are similar to those in plant phytochrome. The opposite rotational strengths of P(r) and P(fr) in the longest wavelength band suggest that the photoisomerization induces a reversal of the chirality. The Cph1 complex with noncovalently bound PCB was still photochromic when cysteine 259 was blocked with IAA or with the bulkier IAF. The covalent linkage to cysteine 259 is thus not required for photoconversion. The CD spectra of the noncovalently bound PCB in P(r)- and P(fr)-like states are qualitatively similar to those of the covalent adducts, suggesting analogous structures in the binding pocket. The noncovalent interactions with the binding pocket are apparently sufficient to hold the chromophore in the appropriate geometry for photoisomerization.

Two independent, light-sensing two-component systems in a filamentous cyanobacterium

Two ORFs, cphA and cphB, encoding proteins CphA and CphB with strong similarities to plant phytochromes and to the cyanobacterial phytochrome Cph1 of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 have been identified in the filamentous cyanobacterium Calothrix sp. PCC7601. While CphA carries a cysteine within a highly conserved amino-acid sequence motif, to which the chromophore phytochromobilin is covalently bound in plant phytochromes, in CphB this position is changed into a leucine. Both ORFs are followed by rcpA and rcpB genes encoding response regulator proteins similar to those known from the bacterial two-component signal transduction. In Calothrix, all four genes are expressed under white light irradiation conditions, albeit in low amounts. For heterologous expression and convenient purification, the cloned genes were furnished with His-tag encoding sequences at their 3' end and expressed in Escherichia coli. The two recombinant apoproteins CphA and CphB bound the chromophore phycocyanobilin (PCB) in a covalent and a noncovalent manner, respectively, and underwent photochromic absorption changes reminiscent of the P(r) and P(fr) forms (red and far-red absorbing forms, respectively) of the plant phytochromes and Cph1. A red shift in the absorption maxima of the CphB/PCB complex (lambda(max) = 685 and 735 nm for P(r) and P(fr), respectively) is indicative for a noncovalent incorporation of the chromophore (lambda(max) of P(r), P(fr) of CphA: 663, 700 nm). A CphB mutant generated at the chromophore-binding position (Leu246-->Cys) bound the chromophore covalently and showed absorption spectra very similar to its paralog CphA, indicating the noncovalent binding to be the only cause for the unexpected absorption properties of CphB. The kinetics of the light-induced P(fr) formation of the CphA-PCB chromoprotein, though similar to that of its ortholog from Synechocystis, showed differences in the kinetics of the P(fr) formation. The kinetics were not influenced by ATP (probing for autophosphorylation) or by the response regulator. In contrast, the light-induced kinetics of the CphB-PCB complex was markedly different, clearly due to the noncovalently bound chromophore.

FTIR studies of phytochrome photoreactions reveal the C=O bands of the chromophore: consequences for its protonation states, conformation, and protein interaction

The molecular changes of phytochrome during red --> far-red and reverse photoreactions have been monitored by static infrared difference spectroscopy using the recombinant 65 kDa N-terminal fragment assembled with a chromophore chemically modified at ring D or with a chromophore isotopically labeled with (18)O at the carbonyl group of ring A. This allows the identification of the C=O stretching vibrations of rings D and A. We exclude the formation of an iminoether in Pfr. The positions of both these modes show that the chromophore always remains protonated. The upshift of the C=O stretch of ring D in the first photoproducts is explained by a twisted methine bridge connecting rings C and D. The changes in the vibrational pattern during the red --> far-red conversion show that the backreaction is not just the reversal of the forward reaction. The infrared difference spectra of the fragment deviate very little from those of the full-length protein. The differences which are related to the lack of the C-terminal half of the protein constituting the signaling domain are possibly important for the understanding of the signaling mechanism.

In vitro assembly of phytochrome B apoprotein with synthetic analogs of the phytochrome chromophore

Phytochrome B (PhyB), one of the major photosensory chromoproteins in plants, mediates a variety of light-responsive developmental processes in a photoreversible manner. To analyze the structural requirements of the chromophore for the spectral properties of PhyB, we have designed and chemically synthesized 20 analogs of the linear tetrapyrrole (bilin) chromophore and reconstituted them with PhyB apoprotein (PHYB). The A-ring acts mainly as the anchor for ligation to PHYB, because the modification of the side chains at the C2 and C3 positions did not significantly influence the formation or difference spectra of adducts. In contrast, the side chains of the B- and C-rings are crucial to position the chromophore properly in the chromophore pocket of PHYB and for photoreversible spectral changes. The side-chain structure of the D-ring is required for the photoreversible spectral change of the adducts. When methyl and ethyl groups at the C17 and C18 positions are replaced with an n-propyl, n-pentyl, or n-octyl group, respectively, the photoreversible spectral change of the adducts depends on the length of the side chains. From these studies, we conclude that each pyrrole ring of the linear tetrapyrrole chromophore plays a different role in chromophore assembly and the photochromic properties of PhyB.

Defining the bilin lyase domain: lessons from the extended phytochrome superfamily

Through pattern searches of genomic databases, new members of the growing family of phytochrome-related genes were identified and used to construct a 130-180 amino acid motif that delimits the bilin lyase domain, a subdomain of the extended phytochrome family that is sufficient for covalent attachment of linear tetrapyrroles (bilins). To test this hypothesis, portions of locus sll0821, a novel phytochrome-related gene from Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 that encodes a large protein with two potential bilin binding sites, were amplified, and the recombinant apoproteins were tested for bilin binding and phytochrome photoactivity. Our experiments indicated that both sites of this protein, termed Cph2 for cyanobacterial phytochrome 2, possessed bilin lyase activity, revealing two distinct classes of bilin lyase domains--those whose bilin adducts are red, far-red reversible and a second class whose bilin adducts are nonphotochromic. Spectroscopic analysis of photochromic phycocyanobilin and fluorescent phycoerythrobilin adducts of a 24-kDa fragment of Cph2 definitively established that the motif identified by pattern searches represents a bona fide bilin lyase domain. Site-directed mutagenesis of highly conserved charged residues within bilin lyase domains of nearly all members of the extended phytochrome superfamily has identified a glutamate residue critical for bilin binding.