Nucleotide-binding domain 1 of cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator production of a suitable protein for structural studies

CONSTRUCT: an algorithmic tool for identifying functional or structurally important regions in protein tertiary structure

MOTIVATION

Evolutionary rates in protein-coding genes vary widely, reflecting functional and/or structural constraints. Essential or highly expressed proteins tend to evolve more slowly, and within a protein, different amino acid sites experience distinct selective pressures. Accurately modeling this variation is critical for identifying functional and/or structurally important amino acid sites. Standard methods assume independent substitution rates across sites, and the most conserved ones are widely distributed in protein tertiary structure. This is biologically unrealistic, as functional sites tend to cluster in 3D space.

RESULTS

Here, we developed CONSTRUCT, an improved strategy for detecting functional and structurally important regions in protein tertiary structure. Given a set of orthologous sequences, CONSTRUCT first estimates site-specific substitution rates using the Rate4site model. These rates are then weighted by the rates of neighboring amino acid sites within an optimally defined window size, determined by the strongest spatial correlation. To refine clustering detection, CONSTRUCT can analyze either Cα atoms or the center of mass of amino acid sites, accounting for side chain orientation. Extensive simulations and validation on 14 functionally characterized proteins of diverse sizes, interspecies conservation levels, and taxonomic origins demonstrated the robustness of CONSTRUCT. The results highlight CONSTRUCT as a powerful tool for guiding site-directed mutagenesis experiments aimed at elucidating protein function.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

The CONSTRUCT program and documentation are freely available at https://github.com/Rcoppee/CONSTRUCT.

Expression, purification and structural properties of ABC transporter ABCA4 and its individual domains

ABCA4 is a member of the A subfamily of ATP-binding cassette transporters that consists of large integral membrane proteins implicated in inherited human diseases. ABCA4 assists in the clearance of N-retinylidene-phosphatidylethanolamine, a potentially toxic by-product of the visual cycle formed in photoreceptor cells during light perception. Structural and functional studies of this protein have been hindered by its large size, membrane association, and domain complexity. Although mammalian, insect and bacterial systems have been used for expression of ABCA4 and its individual domains, the structural relevance of resulting proteins to the native transporter has yet to be established. We produced soluble domains of ABCA4 in Escherichia coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the full-length transporter in HEK293 cells. Electron microscopy and size exclusion chromatography were used to assess the conformational homogeneity and structure of these proteins. We found that isolated ABCA4 domains formed large, heterogeneous oligomers cross-linked with non-specific disulphide bonds. Incomplete folding of cytoplasmic domain 2 was proposed based on fluorescence spectroscopy results. In contrast, full-length human ABCA4 produced in mammalian cells was found structurally equivalent to the native protein obtained from bovine photoreceptors. These findings offer recombinantly expressed full-length ABCA4 as an appropriate object for future detailed structural and functional characterization.

Interaction of extracellular domain 2 of the human retina-specific ATP-binding cassette transporter (ABCA4) with all-trans-retinal

The retina-specific ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter, ABCA4, is essential for transport of all-trans-retinal from the rod outer segment discs in the retina and is associated with a broad range of inherited retinal diseases, including Stargardt disease, autosomal recessive cone rod dystrophy, and fundus flavimaculatus. A unique feature of the ABCA subfamily of ABC transporters is the presence of highly conserved, long extracellular loops or domains (ECDs) with unknown function. The high degree of sequence conservation and mapped disease-associated mutations in these domains suggests an important physiological significance. Conformational analysis using CD spectroscopy of purified, recombinant ECD2 protein demonstrated that it has an ordered and stable structure composed of 27 +/- 3% alpha-helix, 20 +/- 3% beta-pleated sheet, and 53 +/- 3% coil. Significant conformational changes were observed in disease-associated mutant proteins. Using intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence emission spectrum of ECD2 polypeptide and fluorescence anisotropy, we have demonstrated that this domain specifically interacts with all-trans-retinal. Furthermore, the retinal interaction appeared preferential for the all-trans-isomer and was directly measurable through fluorescence anisotropy analysis. Our results demonstrate that the three macular degeneration-associated mutations lead to significant changes in the secondary structure of the ECD2 domain of ABCA4, as well as in its interaction with all-trans-retinal.

NMR and EPR studies of membrane transporters

In order to fulfill their function, membrane transport proteins have to cycle through a number of conformational and/or energetic states. Thus, understanding the role of conformational dynamics seems to be the key for elucidation of the functional mechanism of these proteins. However, membrane proteins in general are often difficult to express heterologously and in sufficient amounts for structural studies. It is especially challenging to trap a stable energy minimum, e.g., for crystallographic analysis. Furthermore, crystallization is often only possible by subjecting the protein to conditions that do not resemble its native environment and crystals can only be snapshots of selected conformational states. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy are complementary methods that offer unique possibilities for studying membrane proteins in their natural membrane environment and for investigating functional conformational changes, lipid interactions, substrate-lipid and substrate-protein interactions, oligomerization states and overall dynamics of membrane transporters. Here, we review recent progress in the field including studies from primary and secondary active transporters.

CFTR (ABCC7) is a hydrolyzable-ligand-gated channel

As the product of the gene mutated in cystic fibrosis, the most common genetic disease of Caucasians, CFTR is an atypical ABC protein. From an evolutionary perspective, it is apparently a relatively young member of the ABC family, present only in metazoans where it plays a critical role in epithelial salt and fluid homeostasis. Functionally, the membrane translocation process it mediates, the passive bidirectional diffusion of small inorganic anions, is simpler than the vectorial transport of larger more complex substrates ("allocrites") by most ABC transporters. However, the control of the permeation pathway which cannot go unchecked is necessarily more stringent than in the case of the transporters. There is tight regulation by the phosphorylation/dephosphorylation of the unique CFTR R domain superimposed on the basic ABC regulation mode of ATP binding and hydrolysis at the dual nucleotide binding sites. As with other ABCC subfamily members, only the second of these sites is hydrolytic in CFTR. The phosphorylation and ATP binding/hydrolysis events do not strongly influence each other; rather, R domain phosphorylation appears to enable transduction of the nucleotide binding allosteric signal to the responding channel gate. ATP hydrolysis is not required for either the opening or closing gating transitions but efficiently clears the ligand-binding site enabling a new gating cycle to be initiated.

A phosphatidic acid-binding protein of the chloroplast inner envelope membrane involved in lipid trafficking

The biogenesis of the photosynthetic thylakoid membranes inside plant chloroplasts requires enzymes at the plastid envelope and the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Extensive lipid trafficking is required for thylakoid lipid biosynthesis. Here the trigalactosyldiacylglycerol2 (tgd2) mutant of Arabidopsis is described. To the extent tested, tgd2 showed a complex lipid phenotype identical to the previously described tgd1 mutant. The aberrant accumulation of oligogalactolipids and triacylglycerols and the reduction of molecular species of galactolipids derived from the ER are consistent with a disruption of the import of ER-derived lipids into the plastid. The TGD1 protein is a permease-like component of an ABC transporter located in the chloroplast inner envelope membrane. The TGD2 gene encodes a phosphatidic acid-binding protein with a predicted mycobacterial cell entry domain. It is tethered to the inner chloroplast envelope membrane facing the outer envelope membrane. Presumed bacterial orthologs of TGD1 and TGD2 in Gram-negative bacteria are typically organized in transcriptional units, suggesting their involvement in a common biological process. Expression of the tgd2-1 mutant cDNA caused a dominant-negative effect replicating the tgd2 mutant phenotype. This result is interpreted as the interference of the mutant protein with its native protein complex. It is proposed that TGD2 represents the substrate-binding or regulatory component of a phosphatidic acid/lipid transport complex in the chloroplast inner envelope membrane.

Positive co-operative activity and dimerization of the isolated ABC ATPase domain of HlyB from Escherichia coli

The ATPase activity of the ABC (ATP-binding cassette) ATPase domain of the HlyB (haemolysin B) transporter is required for secretion of Escherichia coli haemolysin via the type I pathway. Although ABC transporters are generally presumed to function as dimers, the precise role of dimerization remains unclear. In the present study, we have analysed the HlyB ABC domain, purified separately from the membrane domain, with respect to its activity and capacity to form physically detectable dimers. The ATPase activity of the isolated ABC domain clearly demonstrated positive co-operativity, with a Hill coefficient of 1.7. Furthermore, the activity is (reversibly) inhibited by salt concentrations in the physiological range accompanied by proportionately decreased binding of 8-azido-ATP. Inhibition of activity with increasing salt concentration resulted in a change in flexibility as detected by intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence. Finally, ATPase activity was sensitive towards orthovanadate, with an IC50 of 16 microM, consistent with the presence of transient dimers during ATP hydrolysis. Nevertheless, over a wide range of protein or of NaCl or KCl concentrations, the ABC ATPase was only detected as a monomer, as measured by ultracentrifugation or gel filtration. In contrast, in the absence of salt, the sedimentation velocity determined by analytical ultracentrifugation suggested a rapid equilibrium between monomers and dimers. Small amounts of dimers, but apparently only when stabilized by 8-azido-ATP, were also detected by gel filtration, even in the presence of salt. These data are consistent with the fact that monomers can interact at least transiently and are the important species during ATP hydrolysis.

A heteromeric complex of the two nucleotide binding domains of cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) mediates ATPase activity

The cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein is a member of the ABC superfamily of transporter proteins. Recently, crystal structures of intact, prokaryotic members of this family have been described. These structures suggested that ATP binding and hydrolysis occurs at two sites formed at the interface between their nucleotide binding domains (NBDs). In contrast to the prokaryotic family members, the NBDs of CFTR are asymmetric (both structurally and functionally), and previous to the present studies, it was not clear whether both NBDs are required for ATP hydrolysis. In order to assess the relative roles of the two NBDs of human CFTR, we purified and reconstituted NBD1 and NBD2, separately and together. We found that NBD1 and NBD2 by themselves exhibited relatively low ATPase activity. Co-assembly of NBD1 and NBD2 exhibited a 2-3-fold enhancement in catalytic activity relative to the isolated domains and this increase reflected enhanced ATP turnover (V(max)). These data provide the first direct evidence that heterodimerization of the NBD1 and NBD2 domains of CFTR is required to generate optimal catalytic activity.

Expression and activity of the nucleotide-binding domains of the human ABCA1 transporter

The aim of this study was the expression and production in Escherichia coli of the nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) of the human ABCA1 transporter, in a soluble, non-denatured form. To increase the protein solubility, and avoid expression in E. coli inclusion bodies, we extended the length of the expressed NBD domains, to include proximal domains. The corresponding cDNA constructs were used to express the N-terminal His-tagged WT and mutant proteins, which were purified by Ni(2+)-affinity chromatography. Optimal expression of soluble proteins was obtained for constructs including the NBD, the downstream 80-residue domain, and about 20 upstream residues. The size homogeneity of WT and mutant NBDs was determined by Dynamic Light Scattering, and ATP-binding constants and ATPase activities were measured. The NBD1 and NBD2 domains bound ATP with comparable affinity. The ATPase activity of WT His-NBD1 was about three times higher than that of NBD2 and amounted to 5913 compared to 1979 nmol Pi/micromol NBD/min for WT His-NBD2. All engineered mutants had comparable ATPase activity to the corresponding WT protein. The optimisation of the length of the expressed proteins, based upon the boundary prediction of NBDs and neighbour domains, enables the expression and purification of soluble ABCA1 NBDs, with high ATPase activity. This approach should prove useful for the study of the structural and functional properties of the NBDs and other domains of the ABC transporters.

Structure of nucleotide-binding domain 1 of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator

Cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) is an ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter that functions as a chloride channel. Nucleotide-binding domain 1 (NBD1), one of two ABC domains in CFTR, also contains sites for the predominant CF-causing mutation and, potentially, for regulatory phosphorylation. We have determined crystal structures for mouse NBD1 in unliganded, ADP- and ATP-bound states, with and without phosphorylation. This NBD1 differs from typical ABC domains in having added regulatory segments, a foreshortened subdomain interconnection, and an unusual nucleotide conformation. Moreover, isolated NBD1 has undetectable ATPase activity and its structure is essentially the same independent of ligand state. Phe508, which is commonly deleted in CF, is exposed at a putative NBD1-transmembrane interface. Our results are consistent with a CFTR mechanism, whereby channel gating occurs through ATP binding in an NBD1-NBD2 nucleotide sandwich that forms upon displacement of NBD1 regulatory segments.

Definition of the domain boundaries is critical to the expression of the nucleotide-binding domains of P-glycoprotein

Heterologous expression of domains of eukaryotic proteins is frequently associated with formation of inclusion bodies, consisting of aggregated mis-folded protein. This phenomenon has proved a significant barrier to the characterization of domains of eukaryotic ATP binding cassette (ABC) transporters. We hypothesized that the solubility of heterologously expressed nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) of ABC transporters is dependent on the definition of the domain boundaries. In this paper we have defined a core NBD, and tested the effect of extensions to and deletions of this core domain on protein expression. Of 10 NBDs constructed, only one was expressed as a soluble protein in Escherichia coli, with expression of the remaining NBDs being associated with inclusion body formation. The soluble NBD protein we have obtained corresponds to residues 386-632 of P-glycoprotein and represents an optimally defined domain. The NBD has been isolated and purified to 95% homogeneity by a two-step purification protocol, involving affinity chromatography and gel filtration. Although showing no detectable ATP hydrolysis, the protein retains specific ATP binding and has a secondary structure compatible with X-ray crystallographic data on bacterial NBDs. We have interpreted our results in terms of homology models, which suggest that the N-terminal NBD of P-glycoprotein can be produced as a stable, correctly folded, isolate domain with judicious design of the expression construct.

Functional analysis of genetic mutations in nucleotide binding domain 2 of the human retina specific ABC transporter

The rod outer segment (ROS) ABC transporter (ABCR) plays an important role in the outer segment of retinal rod cells, where it functions as a transporter of all-trans retinal, most probably as the complex lipid, retinylidene-phosphatidyl-ethanolamine. We report here a quantitative analysis of the structural and functional effects of genetic mutations, associated with several macular degenerations, in the second nucleotide-binding domain of ABCR (NBD2). We have analyzed the ATP binding, kinetics of ATP hydrolysis, and structural changes. The results of these multifaceted analyses were correlated with the disease severity and prognosis. Results presented here demonstrated that, in wild type NBD2, distinct conformational changes accompany nucleotide (ATP and ADP) binding. Upon ATP binding, NBD2 protein changed to a relaxed conformation where tryptophans became more solvent-exposed, while ADP binding reverses this process and leads back to a taut conformation that is also observed with the unbound protein. This sequence of conformational change appears to be important in the energetics of the ATP hydrolysis and may have important structural consequences in the ability of the NBD2 domain to act as a regulator of the nucleotide-binding domain 1. Some of the mutant proteins displayed strikingly different patterns of conformational changes upon nucleotide binding that pointed to unique structural consequences of these genetic mutations. The ABCR dysfunctions, associated with various retinopathies, are multifaceted in nature and include alterations in protein structure as well as the attenuation of ATPase activity and nucleotide binding.

Prolonged nonhydrolytic interaction of nucleotide with CFTR's NH2-terminal nucleotide binding domain and its role in channel gating

CFTR, the protein defective in cystic fibrosis, functions as a Cl- channel regulated by cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA). CFTR is also an ATPase, comprising two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) thought to bind and hydrolyze ATP. In hydrolyzable nucleoside triphosphates, PKA-phosphorylated CFTR channels open into bursts, lasting on the order of a second, from closed (interburst) intervals of a second or more. To investigate nucleotide interactions underlying channel gating, we examined photolabeling by [alpha32P]8-N3ATP or [gamma32P]8-N3ATP of intact CFTR channels expressed in HEK293T cells or Xenopus oocytes. We also exploited split CFTR channels to distinguish photolabeling at NBD1 from that at NBD2. To examine simple binding of nucleotide in the absence of hydrolysis and gating reactions, we photolabeled after incubation at 0 degrees C with no washing. Nucleotide interactions under gating conditions were probed by photolabeling after incubation at 30 degrees C, with extensive washing, also at 30 degrees C. Phosphorylation of CFTR by PKA only slightly influenced photolabeling after either protocol. Strikingly, at 30 degrees C nucleotide remained tightly bound at NBD1 for many minutes, in the form of nonhydrolyzed nucleoside triphosphate. As nucleotide-dependent gating of CFTR channels occurred on the time scale of seconds under comparable conditions, this suggests that the nucleotide interactions, including hydrolysis, that time CFTR channel opening and closing occur predominantly at NBD2. Vanadate also appeared to act at NBD2, presumably interrupting its hydrolytic cycle, and markedly delayed termination of channel open bursts. Vanadate somewhat increased the magnitude, but did not alter the rate, of the slow loss of nucleotide tightly bound at NBD1. Kinetic analysis of channel gating in Mg8-N3ATP or MgATP reveals that the rate-limiting step for CFTR channel opening at saturating [nucleotide] follows nucleotide binding to both NBDs. We propose that ATP remains tightly bound or occluded at CFTR's NBD1 for long periods, that binding of ATP at NBD2 leads to channel opening wherupon its hydrolysis prompts channel closing, and that phosphorylation acts like an automobile clutch that engages the NBD events to drive gating of the transmembrane ion pore.

Cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator: the NBF1+R (nucleotide-binding fold 1 and regulatory domain) segment acting alone catalyses a Co2+/Mn2+/Mg2+-ATPase activity markedly inhibited by both Cd2+ and the transition-state analogue orthovanadate

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is caused by mutations in the gene encoding CFTR (cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator), a regulated anion channel and member of the ATP-binding-cassette transporter (ABC transporter) superfamily. Of CFTR's five domains, the first nucleotide-binding fold (NBF1) has been of greatest interest both because it is the major 'hotspot' for mutations that cause CF, and because it is connected to a unique regulatory domain (R). However, attempts have failed to obtain a catalytically active NBF1+R protein in the absence of a fusion partner. Here, we report that such a protein can be obtained following its overexpression in bacteria. The pure NBF1+R protein exhibits significant ATPase activity [catalytic-centre activity (turnover number) 6.7 min(-1)] and an apparent affinity for ATP ( K (m), 8.7 microM) higher than reported previously for CFTR or segments thereof. As predicted, the ATPase activity is inhibited by mutations in the Walker A motif. It is also inhibited by vanadate, a transition-state analogue. Surprisingly, however, the best divalent metal activator is Co(2+), followed by Mn(2+) and Mg(2+). In contrast, Ca(2+) is ineffective and Cd(2+) is a potent inhibitor. These novel studies, while demonstrating clearly that CFTR's NBF1+R segment can act independently as an active, vanadate-sensitive ATPase, also identify its unique cation activators and a new inhibitor, thus providing insight into the nature of its active site.

Functional analysis of the C-terminal boundary of the second nucleotide binding domain of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator and structural implications

The cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) contains two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) or ATP-binding cassettes (ABCs) that characterize a large family of membrane transporters. Although the three-dimensional structures of these domains from several ABC proteins have been determined, this is not the case for CFTR, and hence the domains are defined simply on the basis of sequence alignment. The functional C-terminal boundary of NBD1 of CFTR was located by analysis of chloride channel function [Chan, Csanady, Seto-Young, Nairn and Gadsby (2000) J. Gen. Physiol. 116, 163-180]. However, the boundary between the C-terminal end of NBD2 and sequences further downstream in the whole protein, that are important for its cellular localization and endocytotic turnover, has not been defined. We have now done this by assaying the influence of progressive C-terminal truncations on photolabelling of NBD2 by 8-azido-ATP, which reflects hydrolysis, as well as binding, at that domain, and on NBD2-dependent channel gating itself. The boundary defined in this way is between residues 1420 and 1424, which corresponds to the final beta-strand in aligned NBDs whose structures have been determined. Utilization of this information should facilitate the generation of monodisperse NBD2 polypeptides for structural analysis, which until now has not been possible. The established boundary includes within NBD2 a hydrophobic patch of four residues (1413-1416) previously shown to be essential for CFTR maturation and stability [Gentzsch and Riordan (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 1291-1298]. This hydrophobic cluster is conserved in most ABC proteins, and on alignment with ones of known structure constitutes the penultimate beta-strand of the domain which is likely to participate in essential structure-stabilizing beta-sheet formation.

Distinct Mg(2+)-dependent steps rate limit opening and closing of a single CFTR Cl(-) channel

The roles played by ATP binding and hydrolysis in the complex mechanisms that open and close cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) Cl(-) channels remain controversial. In this work, the contributions made by ATP and Mg(2+) ions to the gating of phosphorylated cardiac CFTR channels were evaluated separately by measuring the rates of opening and closing of single channels in excised patches exposed to solutions in which [ATP] and [Mg(2+)] were varied independently. Channel opening was found to be rate-limited not by the binding of ATP alone, but by a Mg(2+)-dependent step that followed binding of both ATP and Mg(2+). Once a channel had opened, sudden withdrawal of all Mg(2+) and ATP could prevent it from closing for tens of seconds. But subsequent exposure of such an open channel to Mg(2+) ions alone could close it, and the closing rate increased with [Mg(2+)] over the micromolar range (half maximal at approximately 50 microM [Mg(2+)]). A simple interpretation is that channel closing is stoichiometrically coupled to hydrolysis of an ATP molecule that remains tightly associated with the open CFTR channel despite continuous washing. If correct, that ATP molecule appears able to reside for over a minute in the catalytic site that controls channel closing, implying that the site must entrap, or have an intrinsically high apparent affinity for, ATP, even without a Mg(2+) ion. Such stabilization of the open-channel conformation of CFTR by tight binding, or occlusion, of an ATP molecule echoes the stabilization of the active conformation of a G protein by GTP.

The First Nucleotide Binding Domain of Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator Is a Site of Stable Nucleotide Interaction, whereas the Second Is a Site of Rapid Turnover

As in other adenine nucleotide binding cassette (ABC) proteins the nucleotide binding domains of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) bind and hydrolyze ATP and in some manner regulate CFTR ion channel gating. Unlike some other ABC proteins, however, there are preliminary indications that the two domains of CFTR are nonequivalent in their nucleotide interactions (Szabo, K., Szakacs, G., Hegeds, T., and Sarkadi, B. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 12209-12212; Aleksandrov, L., Mengos, A., Chang, X., Aleksandrov, A., and Riordan, J. R. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 12918-12923). We have now characterized the interactions of the 8-azido-photoactive analogues of ATP, ADP, and 5'-adenyl-beta,gamma-imidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP) with the two domains of functional membrane-bound CFTR. The results show that the two domains appear to act independently in the binding and hydrolysis of 8-azido-ATP. At NBD1 binding does not require a divalent cation. This binding is followed by minimal Mg(2+)-dependent hydrolysis and retention of the hydrolysis product, 8-azido-ADP, but not as a vanadate stabilized post-hydrolysis transition state complex. In contrast, at NBD2, MgN(3)ATP is hydrolyzed as rapidly as it is bound and the nucleoside diphosphate hydrolysis product dissociates immediately. Confirming this characterization of NBD1 as a site of more stable nucleotide interaction and NBD2 as a site of fast turnover, the non-hydrolyzable N(3)AMP-PNP bound preferentially to NBD1. This demonstration of NBD2 as the rapid nucleotide turnover site is consistent with the strong effect on channel gating kinetics of inactivation of this domain by mutagenesis.