A history of sympathectomy

Royle's sympathectomy for spastic paralysis: Sorry saga or scientific awakening?

On October 20, 1924, at the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel in New York City, two medical graduates of the University of Sydney delivered the John B. Murphy Oration to the American College of Surgeons on the topic of sympathetic ramisection for the treatment of spastic paralysis. The surgery was regarded as a triumph. The triumph, however, was short-lived, when one of the speakers, John Irvine Hunter, a promising anatomist, died prematurely. Norman Royle, an orthopedic surgeon, continued the research program and continued to perform these operations. Within a few short years, however, the theory of the dual nerve supply of skeletal muscle, which underpinned the procedure, and the results of surgery for spastic paralysis came under question. Nevertheless, Royle's sympathectomy found another indication and became the treatment of choice for peripheral vascular disease for several decades thereafter. Although Hunter and Royle's original work was discredited, their research turned their sorry saga into a scientific awakening of the sympathetic nervous system.

CT-Guided Lumbar Sympathectomy as a Last Option for Chronic Limb-Threatening Ischemia of the Lower Limbs: Evaluation of Technical Factors and Long-Term Outcomes

OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to assess the effects of anatomic and technical factors on the long-term outcome of CT-guided lumbar sympathectomy in patients with chronic limb-threatening ischemia. SUBJECTS AND METHODS. Thirty patients (28 men, two women; mean age, 45.8 years) with chronic limb-threatening ischemia and diffuse tibial arterial disease not amenable to revascularization were included. CT-guided lumbar sympathectomy was performed at the L2-L3 level with a 22-gauge Chiba needle and absolute alcohol. Any periprocedural complication was noted. Numeric pain score (1-10 scale) and skin ulcers were assessed before the procedure and 3 weeks, 3 months, and 1 and 2 years after the procedure. According to spread of alcohol, patients were categorized into those with medial spread and those without medial spread (lateral spread group) with the lateral edge of the vertebral body as the reference point. Treatment results were categorized as improved, unchanged, or worsened on the basis of clinical response. RESULTS. There were 22 (73.3%) patients in the medial spread group and eight (26.7%) in the lateral spread group. The mean volumes of alcohol injected per side were not significantly different (p = .50). One major complication occurred in the group with medial spread. Mean numeric pain scores before the procedure and 3 weeks, 3 months, and 1 and 2 years afterward were 7.31, 2.95, 2.47, 2.10, and 2.04 in the medial spread group and 6.25, 4.13, 4.50, 4.35 and 4.32 in the lateral spread group (p < .001). At 2 years, 16 patients in the medial spread group and two patients in the lateral spread group showed clinical improvement (p < .001), and the limb salvage rates were 100% and 87.5%, respectively. Multivariate analysis showed a trend in improvement with smoking cessation, but the difference was not statistically significant (p = .15). The direction of spread of the neurolytic agent, however, was a major determinant of outcome. CONCLUSION. CT-guided lumbar sympathectomy is a simple, safe, and effective procedure. Ensuring medial spread of the neurolytic agent significantly improves long-term results.

Evaluation of the damage caused by clamping or section of cervical sympathetic nerve in rabbits

PURPOSE

To study the macro and microscopic evaluation of the damage caused by clamping or section of cervical sympathetic nerve in rabbits, quantifying the collagen in the lesions.

METHODS

Twenty rabbits were divided into two groups of ten, doing in group 1 (section) section of the right cervical sympathetic nerve, while in group 2 (clipping) clipping of the nerve. All rabbits were induced to death on the seventh day after surgery. The macroscopic variables were: consequences of nerve lesion, clip appearance, presence of infection and adhesions around the nerve. Microscopy used hematoxylin-eosin staining to evaluate the stages and the degree of inflammation and necrosis, and F3BA Picrosirius red staining to quantify collagen. Mann-Whitney test was used for comparisons of collagen types I and III between groups. Fisher exact test analyzed the macroscopic variables, the degree of inflammation and necrosis.

RESULTS

There was no discontinuity of nerve injury in the clipping group, as well as the clip was closed in all animals. The presence of severe adhesions was significantly higher in the clipping group (p<0.05). There was no significant difference on other variables macroscopically analyzed. There was no significant difference between groups regarding the type of inflammatory process and its intensity, as well as the presence of necrosis and collagen deposition in the nerves.

CONCLUSIONS

In the macroscopic evaluation, the section caused discontinuity, which did not occur in the clamping group; there was no development of local infection; the clipping of the cervical sympathetic nerve was linked to the presence of a greater number of adhesions in comparison to the section group. Microscopically, no difference existed in relation to the type and intensity of inflammation reaction between the groups; occurred predominance of chronic and severe inflammation on the specimens; the necrosis was noticed equally in both groups; there was predominance of type I collagen deposition in relation to type III in both groups.

Cutaneous innervation in man before and after lumbar sympathectomy: evidence for interruption of both sensory and vasomotor nerve fibres

BACKGROUND

Rest pain and severe ischaemia in patients who are unable to be offered (further) surgery to revascularize the lower limb is still problematic. Lumbar sympathectomy has been used for many years but the mechanisms by which this works are not absolutely clear. Both sensory and vasomotor fibres travel in the lumbar sympathetic chain and the effects of lumbar sympathectomy on these nerve types have been investigated in the present paper.

METHODS

Immunohistochemical methods were used to detect neuropeptides contained in sensory and vasomotor nerves in the lower limb skin of (i) patients having amputations for peripheral vascular disease (PVD) after previous (chemical or surgical) sympathectomy; (ii) patients having amputations for PVD without previous (chemical or surgical) sympathectomy; and in control normal skin. The three groups are compared and the results are discussed.

RESULTS

Normal and PVD controls had intact sensory and vasomotor nerves around dermal cutaneous blood vessels, but these were completely or virtually completely lost after lumbar sympathectomy, by either chemical or surgical means.

CONCLUSIONS

Lumbar sympathectomy severs both vasomotor and sensory fibres, suggesting that relief of rest pain may be explained not only by increased cutaneous and muscle blood flow, but also by nociceptive sensory denervation.

Computed tomography fluoroscopy-guided chemical lumbar sympathectomy: simple, safe and effective

Demographic, clinical and laboratory data were retrospectively collected from records of 146 cases of CT fluoroscopy-guided chemical lumbar sympathectomy for the palliation of inoperable peripheral vascular disease (PVD) between January 1997 and August 1999. Of these, 16% had claudication, 39% had rest pain and 44% had ischaemic ulcers or gangrene. Seventy-three percent of elective cases were outpatients. At 3 months, 27 cases were lost to follow up, leaving 119 cases. Within 3 months, improvement, defined as doubling of the walking distance, cessation of rest pain or healing of ulcers, occurred in 30.3% of cases. No change was observed in 45.4% of cases and 24.3% of cases deteriorated. Patients with ulcers or gangrene had significantly poorer results than those without any ischaemic lesions, as only 19% versus 39% of patients improved (P < 0.05). The presence of hypertension, diabetes mellitus, hyperlipidaemia and smoking had no value in predicting clinical outcome (P > 0.05). There were no major complications noted. CT fluoroscopy-guided chemical lumbar sympathectomy is safe and effective, with a complication rate of less than 1%, and efficacy of at least 30% measured within 3 months. It is a simple and minimally invasive procedure, easily performed on an outpatient basis. CT fluoroscopy-guided chemical lumbar sympathectomy should be considered for all patients in the early stages of inoperable PVD.