An evaluation of the autopsy following death in a level IV neonatal intensive care unit

Comparison of Clinical Diagnosis and Autopsy Findings of Early Neonatal Deaths: Diagnostic Challenges and the Value of Autopsy in Identifying Rare Pathologies

BACKGROUND

In a non-forensic hospital setting, neonatal death within the first week of life is often related to premature birth and/or lung diseases. Without post-mortem examination, the identification of the cause of death may be challenging. Autopsy can confirm the clinical diagnosis, uncover additional information or change the diagnosis. Our study aimed to assess the correlation between the clinical diagnosis and post-mortem findings in early neonatal deaths.

METHODS

The retrospective study included autopsy cases with neonatal deaths within the first 7 days of life (arbitrary time interval 2006-2021). Discrepancies between clinical and histopathological findings were classified into 3 groups: (i) full agreement, (ii) additional findings discovered by autopsy, or (iii) autopsy changed the diagnosis.

RESULTS

A cohort of 27 cases could be identified and lung pathologies were the most common finding (56%). Additional findings could be discovered in 48% of cases. Major discrepancies which changed the clinical diagnosis could be found in 11% (n = 3/27) of cases.

CONCLUSION

Frequently, post-mortem examinations validate the clinical diagnosis while revealing crucial information in a few cases. In these discrepant cases, autopsy findings can provide information for genetic counselling and quality control of clinical management.

Neonatal autopsy-is it relevant in today's era?

Autopsy of infants can provide vital information about the cause of death and contributes to the detection of diagnostic errors, especially in a low- or middle-income country. To observe the clinicopathological agreement in neonatal deaths in neonatal intensive care units (NICU) and comment on the additional information retrieved by autopsy. A retrospective observational study was conducted in the NICU from January 2020 to December 2022. Neonatal deaths were analyzed, and clinical details and autopsy findings were collected. Both clinical and pathological diagnoses were classified according to the Goldman classification. Twenty-two newborn infants were enrolled. The mean gestational age was 33.5 (±4.38) weeks, and the median birth weight was 1510 (1005-2100) g. There was complete concordance between clinical and pathological diagnosis in 11 (50%) cases. Major diagnostic errors occurred in 41% of cases. Respiratory system disorders (lung infections, airway anomalies) accounted for six (54%) cases of missed diagnosis. Our study showed that the diagnosis was revised after autopsy in about one-third of cases, and newer findings were identified in one-fifth of cases.

Autopsy in a Neonatal Intensive Care Unit: pathological and clinical agreement

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate neonatal autopsy rates at a tertiary hospital in southern Brazil ascertain the level of agreement between premortem and postmortem diagnosis.

METHODS

The authors reviewed all neonatal autopsies performed over a 10-year period and described the percentage of neonates who died and underwent autopsy. The authors tested for agreement between autopsy findings and the cause of death as defined by the neonatologist. Agreement between clinical diagnosis and autopsy findings was classified using the modified Goldman criteria. Additional findings at autopsy were grouped by organ system. Linear regression and multiple comparisons were used for statistical analyses.

RESULTS

During the study period, 382 neonates died at the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU). Consent to perform an autopsy was obtained for 73 (19.1%). The complete agreement between autopsy findings and the neonatologist's premortem diagnosis was found in 48 patients (65.8%). Additional findings were obtained at autopsy in 25 cases (34.2%). In 5 cases (6.9%), the autopsy findings contributed to subsequent genetic counseling. Seven autopsies (9.6%) revealed a diagnosis that would have changed patient management if established premortem. The autopsy rate increased by an average of 1.87% each year.

CONCLUSION

Despite a high level of agreement between clinical diagnosis and pathological findings, autopsies provided relevant data regarding the cause of death, providing additional clinical information to neonatologists and allowing genetic counseling of family members.

Diagnostic errors in the pediatric and neonatal ICU: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

Diagnostic errors lead to preventable hospital morbidity and mortality. ICU patients may be at particularly high risk for misdiagnosis. Little is known about misdiagnosis in pediatrics, including PICU and neonatal ICU. We sought to assess diagnostic errors in PICU and neonatal ICU settings by systematic review.

DATA SOURCES

We searched PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, and Cochrane.

STUDY SELECTION

We identified observational studies reporting autopsy-confirmed diagnostic errors in PICU or neonatal ICU using standard Goldman criteria.

DATA EXTRACTION

We abstracted patient characteristics, diagnostic error description, rates and error classes using standard Goldman criteria for autopsy misdiagnoses and calculated descriptive statistics.

DATA SYNTHESIS

We screened 329 citations, examined 79 full-text articles, and included 13 studies (seven PICU; six neonatal ICU). The PICU studies examined a total of 1,063 deaths and 498 autopsies. Neonatal ICU studies examined a total of 2,124 neonatal deaths and 1,259 autopsies. Major diagnostic errors were found in 19.6% of autopsied PICU and neonatal ICU deaths (class I, 4.5%; class II, 15.1%). Class I (potentially lethal) misdiagnoses in the PICU (43% infections, 37% vascular) and neonatal ICU (62% infections, 21% congenital/metabolic) differed slightly. Although missed infections were most common in both settings, missed vascular events were more common in the PICU and missed congenital conditions in the neonatal ICU.

CONCLUSION

Diagnostic errors in PICU/neonatal ICU populations are most commonly due to infection. Further research is needed to better quantify pediatric intensive care-related misdiagnosis and to define potential strategies to reduce their frequency or mitigate misdiagnosis-related harm.

The value of neonatal autopsy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Neonatal autopsy rates were in decline internationally at the end of the last century. Our objective was to assess the current value of neonatal autopsy in providing additional information to families and healthcare professionals.

METHODS

We conducted a review of neonatal autopsies performed in a tertiary perinatal centre over an 11-year period. Primary outcomes measured were the annual neonatal autopsy rates and concordance rates between clinical and autopsy diagnoses of the primary cause of death. Secondary outcomes were the clinical, genetic and audit value of the examinations. Findings were used to inform the consent process, and the effect this had on institutional post-mortem rates was assessed over the subsequent 5-year period.

RESULTS

There was a marked decline in the annual neonatal autopsy rate from 73% in 1994 to 48% in 2004. 164 cases met the inclusion criteria for review. Complete concordance for cause of death was reached in 91% of cases. Previously unsuspected or unconfirmed clinical conditions, other than the primary cause of death, were uncovered at autopsy in 85 cases. Detailed information on inheritable conditions was obtained in 45 cases. Findings with perceived 'audit value' for clinical practice were identified in 29 cases. The dissemination of this information to staff and families contributed to the stabilisation of the consent rate in the following 5-year period.

CONCLUSION

Neonatal autopsy remains a valuable diagnostic tool as it provides critical clinical and audit information for healthcare professionals and families.

Noninvasive investigation of asymmetrically conjoined tripus twins with features of rachipagus, parapagus dicephalus, and cephalopagus

A hypothetical mechanism for conjoined twinning postulated by Spencer ([2003] Developmental Malformations and Clinical Implications, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, p 1-476) suggests that, after separation, monovular twins fuse in one of eight predictable homologous sites. The tripus fetal specimen under study embodies characteristics of three types therefore preventing it from classification into a simple variant of any one of the eight twin types described by Spencer. The aim of this study was to reveal internal structural anomalies of the fetal specimen by using magnetic resonance imaging and computerized tomography. Dorsally appended to the primary twin is a secondary head mass (brain tissue and ocular globe) and two spinal columns converging at T4/T5, suggesting rachipagus twinning. The ventral orientation of the secondary twin's (right lateral) lower limb suggests parapagus twinning. The caudal divergence of the spinal columns and the presence of a secondary hemipelvis, separate from the primary pelvis, suggest cephalopagus twinning. Measurements of the long bones indicate a gestational age of ∼20-23 weeks. Secondary malformations of the primary fetal body include anencephaly, cleft palate, renal agenesis, decreased left ventricular outflow, and a prematurely terminating descending aorta. This study demonstrates the possibility of using current imaging techniques to study very old, formalin-preserved human material for documentation and scientific discussion without destroying the specimen, thus keeping it intact for posterity.

Diagnosis and cause of death in a neonatal intensive care unit--how important is autopsy?

OBJECTIVES

To characterize mortality in a tertiary referral Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) in Portugal and evaluate the concordance between ante-mortem and post-mortem diagnoses.

METHODS

Retrospective review of the clinical and pathological records of infants who died in five consecutive years was done. Pathological findings and clinical diagnoses were compared and classified according to general concordance and to modified Goldman classification.

RESULTS

During the referred period, 1938 patients were admitted to the NICU, with a mortality rate of 5.7% (110 patients). The median of age at death was 10.5 days and the most frequent causes of death were congenital malformations and prematurity with its complications. Autopsy was performed in 53 patients resulting in a 48.2% overall autopsy rate. There was complete agreement between pathological and clinical diagnoses in 18 cases (34%) and additional findings were identified in 22 cases; in 13 cases (24.5%), the diagnosis was revised or established by pathology. Five autopsies revealed information relevant for genetic counseling.

CONCLUSION

Despite the high agreement rate between clinical and pathological diagnoses, autopsy frequently added important data, including several cases in which it established the diagnosis or provided information relevant for parental counseling regarding future pregnancies.

Perinatal perimortem and postmortem examination: obligations and considerations for perinatal, neonatal, and pediatric clinicians

Clinicians are called upon to participate in a variety of clinical scenarios in which babies will die. A number of factors have caused the most appropriate method of evaluating cause(s) of death, namely autopsy, to fall to record low numbers during the past decade. Because of obligations unique to the stillborn fetus, dead or dying infant or child, and family and siblings, it is important for clinicians to understand the importance and utility of postmortem examination. Postmortem examination is of multidisciplinary importance to determine the cause of death and contributing and related diagnoses. This article summarizes some of what is known about postmortem examination and provides a list of guidelines available on the Internet and in the medical literature for the systematic assessment of perinatal death and the provision of appropriate testing. Clinicians are encouraged to use their leadership roles to improve rates of postmortem examination and to participate in research and education to improve its occurrence.

Neonatal death after hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy: does a postmortem add to the final diagnoses?

BACKGROUND

Case review after fatal perinatal asphyxia may have medicolegal implications. Accurate diagnosis of cause of death is therefore essential.

OBJECTIVE

To determine consent rate and utility of autopsy after fatal grade III hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy (HIE) presumed to be secondary to birth asphyxia.

DESIGN

A retrospective clinical review from January 1995 to December 2002.

SETTING

Regional tertiary referral neonatal unit, Wellington, New Zealand.

POPULATION

Inclusion criteria were gestation >/=37 weeks, resuscitation after delivery and clinical course of grade III HIE. Exclusions were a recognised major lethal malformation.

METHODS

Review of clinical records including the autopsy report.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Consent for autopsy, change in diagnosis after autopsy.

RESULTS

Twenty-three infants died during the time period with a major diagnosis of grade III HIE. Three did not meet inclusion criteria. Of the remaining 20, 11 were female. Median gestation at birth was 40 weeks (range 38-42 weeks) and median birth weight was 3568 g (range 2140-4475 g). In 8/17 of the infants for whom length and head measurements were available, the Ponderal Index suggested intrauterine growth retardation. The 16/20 infants had an autopsy. Four of these were Coroner's cases giving an autopsy rate of 80% with a rate by consent of 60%. In 10 (62.5%) infants, significant new information was added to the clinical diagnoses.

CONCLUSIONS

Neonatal HIE is a symptom rather than a final clinical diagnosis. A full autopsy is required to fully explore the reasons for fatal neonatal HIE and may provide information that is important medicolegally.

How the pediatric autopsy yields valuable information in a vertically integrated health care system

CONTEXT

Although autopsy rates have declined significantly in recent decades, studies continue to validate the autopsy as an important source of clinically relevant information, a teaching tool, and a quality assurance measure. A recent review of autopsy series showed a decline in the number of serious errors likely to have affected clinical outcome detected at autopsy during the past 46 years, with a current major error rate of 8.4% to 24.4%.

OBJECTIVE

Our hypothesis was that the pediatric autopsy would uncover a significant number of major unexpected findings at the high end of the spectrum predicted by a recent review. This study assesses the unexpected findings at a pediatric hospital whose autopsy service handles both in-house (tertiary care) and referral (mostly perinatal) cases for a vertically integrated health care system.

DESIGN

Data were analyzed from an autopsy effectiveness report completed for all autopsies performed in 2000. The data from this series include concordance of premortem and postmortem diagnoses, with the autopsy considered the criterion standard. The autopsy effectiveness report also provided logistic information, such as problems with consents, medical records, specimen identification, and prosection.

SETTING

Pediatric autopsies were performed by members of the Pediatric Pathology Division in a freestanding children's hospital in the Intermountain West of the United States with a large rural catchment area. This hospital is part of a large health maintenance organization serving the surrounding urban and rural areas.

PATIENTS

A sample of all in-house and referral autopsies for the year 2000 was examined.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

The percentage of cases with a major or minor diagnostic discrepancy or unexpected pathologic finding using the autopsy as the criterion standard.

RESULTS

The overall autopsy rate was 40% (39 hospital autopsies and 15 forensic autopsies per 135 total deaths) and was 32% excluding forensic cases. Twenty-two additional referral autopsies from outside institutions were performed. Of 61 autopsies, 12 (20%) revealed a major diagnostic discrepancy or unexpected pathologic finding, 17 (28%) had a minor unexpected finding or additional diagnosis, 41 (67%) clarified the differential diagnosis, 46 (75%) confirmed or verified a major diagnosis, and 21 (34%) provided information regarding treatment effects. Additionally, 3 (5%) had problems with identification, and 12 (20%) had problems with consent, all of which were resolved prior to initiation of the autopsy.

CONCLUSIONS

These data confirm the value of the pediatric autopsy in a children's hospital and a vertically integrated health care system. It is an important medical and quality assurance procedure for assessing the accuracy of diagnoses, clarifying differential diagnoses, yielding unexpected findings, and providing feedback regarding therapeutic outcomes.

Magnetic resonance imaging: an alternative to autopsy in neonatal death?

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) represents a non-invasive alternative to full autopsy in neonatal death if parents refuse classical full autopsy. MRI offers high resolution images of the entire neonate without disrupting the integrity of the child. Neonatal malformations or pathologies that are responsible for the death of the neonate can be identified. A major disadvantage of MR-autopsy is the lack of tissue sampling. Chromosomal, histological or microbiological analyses are consequently missing. MR-autopsy has proven to be especially helpful in the evaluation of the central nervous system but is limited in complex cardiac malformations. The limitations and possibilities of MR-autopsy are discussed.

Value of the perinatal autopsy: critique

In consenting to a perinatal autopsy, the primary motive of parents may be to find the exact cause of death. A critical review on the value of perinatal autopsies was performed to see whether parents could be counseled regarding their main motive. A literature search was performed in MEDLINE, EXCERPTA MEDICA, and the Cochrane library. We evaluated the value of the autopsy by comparing the clinical and autopsy diagnoses in stillbirths, neonatal deaths, and therapeutic terminations. Clinicopathologic concordance was divided into four categories: (1) change in diagnosis, (2) additional findings, (3) complete confirmation, and (4) inconclusive. We sought information on factors that may influence the value of perinatal autopsies: the type and definitions of perinatal loss; autopsy rate; level of hospital; expertise of pathologists; autopsy protocol used; whether patients were inborn or referred; and antenatal diagnosis. From the 27 articles that met our review criteria, the autopsy revealed a change in diagnosis or additional findings in 22% to 76% of cases. If confirmation of clinical findings is included, then the value of the perinatal autopsy was as high as up to 100%. Factors that could influence this rate were reported variably by investigators. When centers report their experience of the value of the perinatal autopsy, information on the factors that may influence their reports should be provided as well. Clinicians can confidently advise parents of the usefulness of the perinatal autopsy in ascertaining the cause of death or for counseling their future pregnancies.

Why is the placenta being ignored?

The relationship between the frequency of published recommended indications for placental pathological examination and the frequency of requests for such examination in a population-based study of term newborn encephalopathy was examined. Only 11.2% of placentas among 276 case infants and 0.7% of placentas among 564 term control infants were examined. Using the criteria set out in a consensus statement by the American College of Pathologists, all 276 cases fulfilled multiple maternal, fetal and placental indications for placental examination. Furthermore 43.3% of control infants fulfilled at least one criterion. Of the 25 case placentas that underwent pathological review, 16 were reported as having no diagnostic abnormality Six cases (24%) showed clinically important findings: four had evidence of infection, one had multiple chorangiomata and one had thrombosis and rupture of the umbilical vein. Of the three remaining placentas, one showed funisitis, one showed minor lymphohistiocytic villitis and one was from monochorionic twins. To our knowledge there are no agreed Australian guidelines for when a placenta should be submitted for pathological examination. We suggest that until guidelines based on properly designed studies are developed it may be appropriate to store all placentas for at least 72 hours. If the infant develops neurological symptoms or requires unexpected admission to a neonatal intensive care unit then placental examination may reveal important aetiological diagnostic and prognostic information.