Urological management of cloacal anomalies

Abdominoperineal anoplasty with use of a rectal fistula as a substitute vagina in a cloacal malformation associated with absence of the vagina: short-term follow-up

We report herein a patient with a cloacal malformation and an absent vagina. The patient underwent colostomy on Day 1 of life. At 7 months of age, fistulography of the cloaca showed a common channel >3 cm in length; a vagina was not visible. At the age of 11 months, the patient underwent abdominoperineal anoplasty with the repurposing of her rectal fistula as a substitute vagina. Intraoperative examination revealed a bicornuate uterus and bilateral ovaries. The rectum was resected 7 cm at the confluence of the cloaca. The colonic stump was pulled through a newly created anal canal and an anoplasty was performed. Two months after this procedure, the patient experienced anal prolapse. At the age of 17 months, she underwent partial urogenital mobilization and a modified Delorme operation, and 5 months later the colostomy was closed. At present, this patient is 3 years old and doing well.

Cloacal malformation: A rare case report and review of prenatal imagings

RATIONALE

Cloacal malformation (CM) is a serious type of anorectal and urogenital tract malformation. However, prenatal ultrasound (US) detection of CM is challenging. In this paper, we reported a rare case of CM prenatally diagnosed by US and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), as well as reviewed the prenatal US and MRI characteristics of CM in the literature.

PATIENT CONCERNS

A 30-year-old pregnant woman complained of cystic mass in the fetal abdomen detected by prenatal US.

DIAGNOSIS

Fetus CM.

INTERVENTIONS

The fetus was diagnosed as fetal CM by US and MRI, then the pregnant woman received a drug-induced labor treatment. After the neonate was delivered, the measurement was performed on the weight, length, head circumference, abdomen circumference, and bilateral thigh circumference.

OUTCOMES

A female dead neonate was delivered from the vagina of the gravida, showing congenital anus absence. Prenatal ultrasound demonstrated right kidney duplication, hydronephrosis, and right ureteral dilatation. Meanwhile, prenatal MRI showed a cystic cavity, double collecting systems of right kidney, right ureteral dilatation, and right rectum dilatation. In addition, general parameters are as follows: weight: 2280 g; length: 39 cm; head circumference: 26.3 cm; abdomen circumference: 31 cm; right thigh circumference: 17 cm, and left thigh circumference: 18 cm.

LESSONS

US combined with MRI can not only provide reliable evidence for fetal CM in the third trimester but also offer crucial information to the pregnant women to establish clinic treatment programs as early as possible.

Short-term "double natural orifice catheterization": Nonoperative management of hydrocolpos in persistent cloaca patients - case series

PURPOSE

Management of hydrocolpos in cloaca patients is of clinical importance. We report a nonoperative method for the management of hydrocolpos in the form of initial catheter decompression, followed by an endoscopy with catheters placement into both the bladder and vagina, and leaving these catheters for 9 and 14days respectively.

METHODS

The medical records of six cloaca patients with hydrocolpos in the last 12years were reviewed. The outcomes measured were the renal function, bladder emptying, the presence/resolution of hydronephrosis, and the recurrence of hydrocolpos.

RESULTS

Complete drainage of hydrocolpos was achieved in four out of six cases and partial drainage in two. On common channel endoscopy, in four patients the structures were identified and balloon catheters inserted. After catheter removal, the vagina and urinary tract remained adequately drained through the natural cloacal opening with no post-micturition residual urine, resolution of hydroneprosis within 60days, preserved renal function, and no hydrocolpos reaccumulation.

CONCLUSION

Initial decompression and short time catheterization can be the definite solution for some cloaca patients with hydrocolpos. Our case-series showed a success rate in two-thirds of patients by achieving the three main goals; permanent hydrocolpos derivation, undisturbed voiding, and preservation of renal function.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Study can be classified as a Treatment Study, LEVEL IV Case series with no comparison group.

Urogenital Management in Cloaca: An Alternative Approach

Introduction:

In the management of cloaca, there is concern that dissection of the urogenital sinus in early childhood with the aim of total anatomical correction is hazardous. Avoiding such mobilization and providing mitrofanoff channel, when needed, till peripubertal period reduces complications and is technically easier.

Materials and Methods:

Forty-three cases of cloaca were managed in the period 2004–2016. Case records and radiology were reviewed retrospectively. The follow-up evaluation was done by looking into voiding history, bowel movements, and menstruation history.

Results:

There were three groups of children, namely, those with no reconstruction done elsewhere except a diverting fecal stoma (Group I, n = 25), those who had undergone anorectal correction elsewhere with no attempt at urogenital reconstruction (Group IIA, n = 13), and those with attempted bowel and genitourinary reconstruction elsewhere (Group IIB, n = 5). The Group I children (one still awaiting reconstruction) underwent early rectal reconstruction followed by expectant management of the urogenital apparatus. The 18 referred cases had multiple problems, chiefly urogenital, of congenital or iatrogenic origin. While urinary reconstruction included bladder augmentation, ileal neobladder, bladder neck closure, and ureteric reimplantation, the foundation of urinary management was intermittent catheterization through mitrofanoff stoma and the avoidance of any dissection of the cloacal common channel. Surgery on the genital tracts included drainage of hydrocolpos, perineal surgery for low vaginae and abdominoperineal vaginoplasty for high vaginae in the peripubertal period with or without bowel supplementation. Spontaneous voiding was maintained in 17 of 25 (68%) Group I girls (including one death later from intestinal complications), 7 of 13 (54%), Group IIA girls, and 1 of 5 (20%) Group IIB girls. Painless menstruation was noted in eight postpubertal girls, three through the cloacal channel (awaiting reconstruction) and five through the reconstructed vagina. Most of the children are on a bowel management program for fecal cleanliness with washouts through the neoanus or Malone's stoma.

Conclusion:

We report a nonconventional approach to cloaca based on avoiding dissection of or around the common channel for urethrovaginal reconstruction, opting for mitrofanoff stoma for intermittent catheterization, when needed, and late vaginal reconstruction. We believe this approach has reduced the overall need for intermittent catheterization.

Long-term urological outcomes in cloacal anomalies

Cloacal anomalies are the most complex and severe form of congenital anorectal malformations (ARM) and urogenital malformations, and it has been well documented that increased severity of ARM leads to worse outcomes. While short-term data on persistent cloaca are available, a paucity of data on long-term outcomes exists, largely because of a lack of uniform terminology, inclusion with other ARM and evolution of the operative technique. On comprehensive review of the published literature on long-term urological outcomes in patients with cloacal anomalies, we found a significant risk of chronic kidney disease and incontinence, however, with improvements in surgical technique, outcomes have improved. Continence often requires intermittent catheterization and in some cases, bladder augmentation. The complexity of cloacal malformations and associated anomalies make long-term multidisciplinary follow-up imperative.

Early urologic considerations in patients with persistent cloaca

Cloacal malformations represent one of the most complex conditions among anorectal malformations. Urologic conditions occur with an increased frequency in cloaca patients compared to patients with other types of ARM. The morbidity of the upper and lower urinary tract dysfunction/malformations at times can be severe; manifested by urinary tract infection, lower urinary tract symptoms, urinary incontinence, chronic kidney disease, and even end stage renal disease. Long-term follow-up of patients with cloaca has described significant chronic kidney disease and end-stage renal disease. Whether this rate of chronic kidney disease is a function of intrinsic renal dysplasia or acquired renal injury from neurogenic bladder is currently unknown. However, it is well known that severe lower urinary tract dysfunction, no matter the etiology, poses significant risk to the upper tracts when untreated. Neonatal assessment of the urinary tract accompanied by early identification of abnormal structure and function is therefore fundamental to minimize the impact of any urologic condition on the child's overall health. Adequate management of any associated bladder dysfunction is essential to preserving renal function, minimizing risk of urinary tract infection, and potentially avoiding need for future reconstructive surgery. This article summarizes our institution's approach to the ongoing early urologic management in patients with cloaca.

Experiences of surgical continence management approaches for cloacal anomalies: a qualitative analysis based on 6 women

STUDY OBJECTIVE

The aim of this qualitative study was to gain insight into health care experiences of young women diagnosed with cloacal anomalies, with a special focus on continence management.

DESIGN

Qualitative analysis of one-to-one interviews.

SETTING

A tertiary center for congenital anomalies of the urogenital tract in London.

PARTICIPANTS

Six women aged 16 to 24 with cloacal anomalies.

INTERVENTIONS

Tape-recorded one-to-one semi-stuctured interviews with a skilled interviewer.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

The taped interviews were transcribed and analyzed verbatim using interpretative phenomenological analysis according to the research question. Organizing themes across all of the accounts were identified.

RESULTS

Two organizing themes concerning our research interests are summarized. The first theme Personal Agency in the Hands of Experts focuses on the interviewees' appreciation of their life-saving surgical care and their involvement in treatment decisions. The second theme Compromises and Trade-Offs focuses on what it was like to live with the more traditional versus the more advanced continence methods. Reliability emerged as a key priority in terms of continence treatment outcome. Gratitude may have interfered with the women's honest communications during treatment decision and evaluation consultations.

CONCLUSIONS

A more developed approach to communication about the complex interventions proposed, founded on a nuanced understanding of users perspectives, can enhance informed decision making about continence management approaches. Despite these specific gaps, the interviewees were appreciative of their care and optimistic about life.

Endoscopic surgery as an adjuvant treatment modality before or after definitive correction of cloacal anomalies

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effectiveness of endoscopic surgery before or after definitive correction in patients with a persistent cloaca.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The medical records of 16 patients diagnosed with persistent urogenital sinus at our institution were retrospectively reviewed. Of these 16 patients, five underwent endoscopic surgery, such as visual internal urethrotomy or transurethral incision by a single surgeon at the time of or after colostomy formation or corrective surgery.

RESULTS

All patients underwent colostomy 1-2 days after birth. Three patients were treated by endoscopic procedures before corrective surgery owing to voiding difficulty, urinary tract infection, or hydrocolpos, at a median age of 1 month. Another two patients underwent endoscopic surgery after definitive correction of the cloaca owing to urethral stricture or urinary incontinence. After endoscopic surgery, all patients voided well without residual urine or were catheterised easily without incontinence. Endoscopic modality played a substantial role in managing complications or resolving the anatomical barrier to decompress the genitourinary tract in patients with a common urogenital sinus length of <3 cm.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic surgery for a cloacal anomaly is a minimally invasive adjuvant technique for bladder neck obstruction, urethral stricture, and hydrocolpos with a thickened vaginal septum.

Fetal MRI clues to diagnose cloacal malformations

BACKGROUND

Prenatal US detection of cloacal malformations is challenging and rarely confirms this diagnosis.

OBJECTIVE

To define the prenatal MRI findings in cloacal malformations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We performed a retrospective study of patients with cloacal malformations who had pre- and post-natal assessment at our institution. Fetal MRI was obtained in six singleton pregnancies between 26 and 32 weeks of gestation. Imaging analysis was focused on the distal bowel, the urinary system and the genital tract and compared with postnatal clinical, radiological and surgical diagnoses.

RESULTS

The distal bowel was dilated and did not extend below the bladder in five fetuses. They had a long common cloacal channel (3.5-6 cm) and a rectum located over the bladder base. Only one fetus with a posterior cloacal variant had a normal rectum. Three fetuses had increased T2 signal in the bowel and two increased T1/decreased T2 signal bladder content. All had renal anomalies, four had abnormal bladders and two had hydrocolpos.

CONCLUSION

Assessment of the anorectal signal and pelvic anatomy during the third trimester helps to detect cloacal malformations in the fetus. The specificity for this diagnosis was highly increased when bowel fluid or bladder meconium content was identified.

Therapeutic strategy for persistent cloaca: the efficacy of antegrade continent enema as a salvage surgery

PURPOSE

The aim of this study is to evaluate our therapeutic strategy for persistent cloaca from the viewpoint of long-term functional outcome.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study covers 17 cases of persistent cloaca treated at our institution and followed for more than 3 years. As a definitive repair for anorectal and urogenital systems, simultaneous surgery with posterior sagittal approach or anorecto-urethrovagino-plasty (PSARUVP) was performed. The length of the common channel and the shape of the vagina determined the vaginoplasty methods. Fecal function was assessed with the scoring system of the Japan Study Group of Anorectal Anomalies.

RESULTS

Anorectoplasty was performed with the posterior sagittal approach in 15 cases and with the perineal approach in two. Vaginoplasty was performed with total urogenital mobilization in nine cases, rectal interposition in four, vaginal flap in two and with other methods. Fecal function was classified as good in three cases, moderate in ten, and poor in four. In the poor cases, Malone's antegrade continence enema (MACE) was performed, which improved fecal function significantly.

CONCLUSION

PSARUVP might be the optimal surgery for persistent cloaca at present; however, satisfactory fecal function could not be achieved in those cases with a longer common channel. MACE effectively compensated for the poor outcome and was especially successful at eliminating incontinence.

Congenital vaginal obstruction in neonates and infants: recognition and management

BACKGROUND

Congenital vaginal obstruction commonly presents after puberty and presentation in infancy is uncommon. Due to lack of awareness, diagnosis may be missed in infants, sometimes with disastrous consequences.

METHOD

A retrospective review of 9 neonates and infants treated for congenital vaginal obstruction in 16 years.

RESULTS

The patients were aged 2 days to 4 months (median 28 days) at presentation. The main presenting feature was a lower abdominal mass, producing intestinal and urinary obstruction in 7 patients. In 2 patients, other conditions were suspected and diagnosis made only intraoperatively and in one patient, diagnosis was incidental during treatment for another condition. The cause of vaginal obstruction were low transverse vaginal septum 6, imperforate hymen 2, high transverse vaginal septum one. Associated anomalies were present in 5 patients (persistent cloaca 3, Hirschsprung disease 1, polydactyly 1). Low vaginal septum was treated by incision and drainage of hydrometrocolpos, imperforate hymen by hymenotomy and drainage of hydrometrocolpos and high vaginal septum by excision. There was recurrence of hydrometrocolpos in one patient who had low vaginal septum, requiring repeat surgery. One patient, in whom diagnosis was missed, died from overwhelming infection. Short term follow-up was good.

CONCLUSION

Congenital vaginal obstruction is an uncommon presentation in this setting. Missing the diagnosis can lead to disastrous consequences. A high index of suspicion is required for prompt recognition and treatment.

Prenatal diagnosis of cloacal malformations

INTRODUCTION

Prenatal diagnosis of anorectal malformations currently occurs in 0-15.9% of screened cases. In cloacas, these numbers are unknown. We speculate that some images from prenatal ultrasound studies may suggest the diagnosis of cloaca, but are not recognized because of a lack of suspicion for this diagnosis.

METHODS

A retrospective review of the medical records of 489 patients born with cloaca was performed; 95 of them had prenatal ultrasound reports that represent the material analyzed for this study. A literature review was performed, finding 31 publications, with 68 cloaca patients detected by prenatal images. The abnormal findings of our patients were compared with those described in the literature to determine the most common abnormal prenatal images found in patients with cloaca.

RESULTS

The 95 ultrasound reports found in our patients described 270 abnormalities, the most frequent were: abdominal/pelvic cystic/mass (39), hydronephrosis (36), oligohydramnios (23), distended bowel/bowel obstruction (19), ascites (15), 2 vessel cord (14), dilated bladder (14), dilated ureter (14), polyhydramnios (10), echogenic bowel (8), multicystic kidney (8), "ambiguous genitalia" (7), hydrops fetalis (7), hydrocolpos (4), absent kidney (3), abnormal spine (3), and anorectal atresia (3). In spite of these findings, the radiologists who interpreted the studies only suspected a cloaca in 6 cases (6%). The literature review showed 212 abnormalities in 68 demonstrated cloaca patients. The most frequent were: abdominal/pelvic cystic/mass (46), hydronephrosis (44), ascites (21), oligohydramnios (20), distended bowel (11), multicystic dysplastic kidney (7), ambiguous genitalia (6), non-visualization of the bladder (6), two-vessel cord (5), dilated bladder (5), intraabdominal calcification (4), polyhydramnios (4), enterolithiasis (4), hydrometrocolpos (3), and dilated ureter (3).

CONCLUSION

We conclude that it is possible to suspect the diagnosis of cloaca, prenatally, more frequently than what currently occurs, looking at the same images but with an increased index of suspicion for cystic abdominal masses and a combination of gastrointestinal and urological abnormalities.

Hydrocolpos in cloacal malformations

INTRODUCTION

Hydrocolpos is a condition rarely mentioned in the literature. The purpose of this report is to increase the index of suspicion for hydrocolpos in patients with cloaca and to describe our approach for its treatment with the hope that errors in the management of hydrocolpos can be avoided.

METHODS

We reviewed 411 medical records of patients diagnosed with cloaca and managed at our Center during the last 26 years. Emphasis was placed on evaluating for the presence of hydrocolpos, type of drainage, and complications related to the persistence of the hydrocolpos.

RESULTS

One hundred seventeen cloaca patients had an associated hydrocolpos (28.4%). Forty-two cases (36%) were initially managed at other institutions at which the hydrocolpos was not drained. Complications experienced by this group included: multiple urinary tract infections (8), hydrocolpos infection (7), sepsis (7), failure to thrive (6), ruptured hydrocolpos (4), and development of hydronephrosis in previously normal kidneys (2). Forty-one patients (35%) had other modalities of treatment, aimed to drain the hydrocolpos, including vesicostomy (26), intermittent perineal catheterization (8), single aspiration (6), or plasty of the perineal orifice (1). In all of these cases, the hydrocolpos persisted or reaccumulated. Thirty-four patients (29%) underwent an effective drainage of the hydrocolpos at birth; 29 at other institutions, 15 with a tube vaginostomy, 13 with a tubeless vaginostomy, and 1 with a catheter placed and left in the vagina through cystoscopy. Five cases had a tube vaginostomy done by us. In all these cases, the vagina remained adequately drained as demonstrated radiologically. Proper drainage of the hydrocolpos alone, with no urologic intervention, dramatically improved the hydronephrosis in 13 cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Hydrocolpos in patients with cloacas must be diagnosed and treated early in life. Our preferred approach is a transabdominal indwelling vaginostomy tube. The drainage of the hydrocolpos alone may dramatically improve the hydronephrosis, and therefore, we suggest that only after the hydrocolpos is drained should a urological intervention be contemplated. Failure to drain the hydrocolpos can result in serious complications.

Postoperative cystolithiasis in a case of cloacal malformation treated using an endoscopic pneumatic lithotripter through a combination of percutaneous and transurethral approaches

Long-term management of patients with cloacal malformation is still challenging to pediatric surgeons and urologists. Recently, we experienced postoperative cystolithiasis in a case of cloacal malformation. All stones were removed successfully by using an endoscopic pneumatic lithotripter through a combined approach from the cystostomy and the narrow reconstructed urethra. To the best of our knowledge, this was the first time for this combined approach to be applied in a patient with cloacal malformation. It has a particular appeal because it is simple, safe, and minimally invasive.

Urinary control after the definitive reconstruction of cloacal anomaly

PURPOSE

Urinary control after definitive repair of a cloacal anomaly is difficult to achieve. The present report aims to describe the clinical course of urinary control, and the need for the management of bladder dysfunction after reconstruction.

METHODS

The present consecutive series consisted of 11 girls who underwent definitive repair of cloacal anomalies over a period of 11 years. Eight patients were associated with hydrocolpos. Radiological examination included a plain X-ray radiograph of the lumbosacral spine and a voiding cystourethrography with or without a urodynamic study.

RESULTS

Reconstruction of the cloaca was performed on patients aged between 1 and 3 years using a posterior sagittal approach. Vaginal reconstruction was carried out 13 times in 11 patients using tubularized vaginal flap, distal rectal segment, perineal skin flap, or total urogenital sinus mobilization. Cystostomy or vesicostomy was carried out in four newborns/infants. Another seven patients could void spontaneously but incompletely with residual urine. Occult spinal dysraphism was found in five patients and hemisacrum in two patients. After definitive reconstruction, most patients acquired an adequate to normal bladder volume for 1-year-olds. Normal detrusor-sphincter function was seen in three patients. Detrusor areflexia was seen in two patients who underwent in utero vesico-amniotic shunt. Detrusor underactivity was observed in six patients. Bladder compliance was good in all patients except for one. No patients in the present series showed persistent urinary incontinence from the bladder neck or urethral dysfunction.

CONCLUSION

It is postulated that wetting after definitive repair may be the result of overflow incontinence and poor bladder contractility rather than sphincter injury. The main clinical characteristic of bladder dysfunction was a failure to empty. We could not define the exact etiology, but iatrogenic injury from extensive dissection can lead to the higher risks of peripheral nerve damage. Accomplishment of definitive repair involves not only anatomical reconstruction, but also postoperative urinary control, including the initiation of clean intermittent catheterizations under repeated urodynamic evaluations.

Outcomes from the correction of anorectal malformations

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Anorectal malformations have been recognized and managed since antiquity, with surgical treatment evolving to maximize anatomic reconstruction, avoid complications, and understand mechanisms of incontinence, ultimately leading to improved quality of life for patients. This review describes recent advances in the management of anorectal malformations, including prenatal diagnosis, newborn treatment, surgical correction, and postoperative care.

RECENT FINDINGS

Surgical treatment has improved with better understanding and exposure of anatomy and appreciation of the intimate relation between rectum and urinary tract. Repair of cloacal malformations has evolved to include the total urogenital mobilization and an appreciation of the complex associated Mullerian anomalies. The importance of associated urologic, gynecologic, neurologic, and orthopedic malformations has been recognized. Addition of a bowel management program to patients' postoperative care has increased dramatically the number of children who are clean and dry.

SUMMARY

Management of anorectal malformations requires an accurate clinical diagnosis, proper newborn treatment, meticulous anatomic reconstruction, and comprehensive postoperative care with the goal of having a child who is clean and dry, with an excellent quality of life, because they either have the capacity for continence or can be kept artificially clean with a comprehensive bowel management program.

Pitfalls in the management of newborn cloacas

Clinicians caring for newborns with persistent cloaca face significant challenges in the newborn period. Avoiding key pitfalls during this time can have dramatic implications. We reviewed the medical records of 361 patients with cloaca operated on at our institution and analyzed sequelae that resulted from incorrect management in the newborn period. Of 361 patients, 282 underwent primary operations at our institution, and 79 patients were referred to us after a failed repair at other institutions. Pitfalls in management during the newborn period included the following: (1) Failure to recognize and manage hydrocolpos, which occurred in 46 patients. Of these, three patients developed pyocolpos (two progressed to vaginal perforation), and 43 suffered from persistent bilateral hydronephrosis, megaureters, recurrent urinary tract infections, persistent acidosis, or failure to thrive due to undrained hydrocolpos. They underwent unnecessary urinary drainage procedures (nephrostomy, ureterostomy, cystostomy, or vesicostomy) in the newborn period. When the vagina was finally decompressed, all of these symptoms disappeared. (2) Colostomy or vesicostomy problems, which occurred in 50 patients. These included incorrect placement of the colostomy (too distal, which interfered with the pull-through) in 24 and colostomy prolapse in 23. Incompletely diverting loop colostomies led to urinary tract infections in 49 patients. Vesicostomy prolapse occurred in three patients. (3) Clinical misdiagnosis, which occurred in 42 patients. Six were incorrectly diagnosed as "intersex" and 36 as "rectovaginal fistula." In this group only the rectum was repaired, and the patients were left with a urogenital sinus that required reoperation. Proper management of a newborn with cloaca includes drainage of a hydrocolpos, which avoids unnecessary urinary diversions and pyocolpos. Our preferred colostomy is one with separated stomas, adequate distal bowel for the pull-through, and use of a proper technique to avoid prolapse. Correct clinical diagnosis of cloaca avoids problems during the definitive repair.