Bidirectional modulation of visual plasticity by cholinergic receptor subtypes in the frog optic tectum

A potential cost of evolving epibatidine resistance in poison frogs

BACKGROUND

Some dendrobatid poison frogs sequester the toxin epibatidine as a defense against predators. We previously identified an amino acid substitution (S108C) at a highly conserved site in a nicotinic acetylcholine receptor β2 subunit of dendrobatid frogs that decreases sensitivity to epibatidine in the brain-expressing α4β2 receptor. Introduction of S108C to the orthologous high-sensitivity human receptor similarly decreased sensitivity to epibatidine but also decreased sensitivity to acetylcholine, a potential cost if this were to occur in dendrobatids. This decrease in the acetylcholine sensitivity manifested as a biphasic acetylcholine concentration-response curve consistent with the addition of low-sensitivity receptors. Surprisingly, the addition of the β2 S108C into the α4β2 receptor of the dendrobatid Epipedobates anthonyi did not change acetylcholine sensitivity, appearing cost-free. We proposed that toxin-bearing dendrobatids may have additional amino acid substitutions protecting their receptors from alterations in acetylcholine sensitivity. To test this, in the current study, we compared the dendrobatid receptor to its homologs from two non-dendrobatid frogs.

RESULTS

The introduction of S108C into the α4β2 receptors of two non-dendrobatid frogs also does not affect acetylcholine sensitivity suggesting no additional dendrobatid-specific substitutions. However, S108C decreased the magnitude of neurotransmitter-induced currents in Epipedobates and the non-dendrobatid frogs. We confirmed that decreased current resulted from fewer receptors in the plasma membrane in Epipedobates using radiolabeled antibodies against the receptors. To test whether S108C alteration of acetylcholine sensitivity in the human receptor was due to (1) adding low-sensitivity binding sites by changing stoichiometry or (2) converting existing high- to low-sensitivity binding sites with no stoichiometric alteration, we made concatenated α4β2 receptors in stoichiometry with only high-sensitivity sites. S108C substitutions decreased maximal current and number of immunolabeled receptors but no longer altered acetylcholine sensitivity.

CONCLUSIONS

The most parsimonious explanation of our current and previous work is that the S108C substitution renders the β2 subunit less efficient in assembling/trafficking, thereby decreasing the number of receptors in the plasma membrane. Thus, while β2 S108C protects dendrobatids against sequestered epibatidine, it incurs a potential physiological cost of disrupted α4β2 receptor function.

A potential cost of evolving epibatidine resistance in poison frogs

Background

Some poison arrow frogs sequester the toxin epibatidine as a defense against predators. We previously identified a single amino acid substitution (S108C) at a highly conserved site in a neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) ß2 subunit that prevents epibatidine from binding to this receptor. When placed in a homologous mammalian nAChR this substitution minimized epibatidine binding but also perturbed acetylcholine binding, a clear cost. However, in the nAChRs of poison arrow frogs, this substitution appeared to have no detrimental effect on acetylcholine binding and, thus, appeared cost-free.

Results

The introduction of S108C into the α4β2 nAChRs of non-dendrobatid frogs also does not affect ACh sensitivity, when these receptors are expressed in Xenopus laevis oocytes. However, α4β2 nAChRs with C108 had a decreased magnitude of neurotransmitter-induced currents in all species tested ( Epipedobates anthonyi , non-dendrobatid frogs, as well as human), compared with α4β2 nAChRs with the conserved S108. Immunolabeling of frog or human α4β2 nAChRs in the plasma membrane using radiolabeled antibody against the β2 nAChR subunit shows that C108 significantly decreased the number of cell-surface α4β2 nAChRs, compared with S108.

Conclusions

While S108C protects these species against sequestered epibatidine, it incurs a potential physiological cost of disrupted α4β2 nAChR function. These results may explain the high conservation of a serine at this site in vertebrates, as well as provide an example of a tradeoff between beneficial and deleterious effects of an evolutionary change. They also provide important clues for future work on assembly and trafficking of this important neurotransmitter receptor.

Retinal co-mediator acetylcholine evokes muscarinic inhibition of recurrent excitation in frog tectum column

Acetylcholine receptors contribute to the control of neuronal and neuronal network activity from insects to humans. We have investigated the action of acetylcholine receptors in the optic tectum of Rana temporaria (common frog). Our previous studies have demonstrated that acetylcholine activates presynaptic nicotinic receptors, when released into the frog optic tectum as a co-mediator during firing of a single retinal ganglion cell, and causes: a) potentiation of retinotectal synaptic transmission, and b) facilitation of transition of the tectum column to a higher level of activity. In the present study we have shown that endogenous acetylcholine also activates muscarinic receptors, leading to a delayed inhibition of recurrent excitatory synaptic transmission in the tectum column. The delay of muscarinic inhibition was evaluated to be of ∼80ms, with an extent of inhibition of ∼2 times. The inhibition of the recurrent excitation determines transition of the tectum column back to its resting state, giving a functional sense for the inhibition.

Smoking, nicotine and visual plasticity: does what you know, tell you what you can see?

Nicotine exposure alters activity-dependent synaptic plasticity processes. Effects on learning and memory outcomes, and the synaptic changes that underlie them, are well-documented. Parallels in hippocampal and visual system pharmacology suggest that nicotine has the potential to alter activity-dependent structural organization in visual areas. Such alterations may contribute to deficits in visual performance reported in smoking exposed individuals.

Nicotine exposure refines visual map topography through an NMDA receptor-mediated pathway

The precise mapping of one surface onto another is fundamental to visual system organization and depends upon adequate stimulation of postsynaptic targets to stabilize correctly placed synapses. As exogenous nicotine alters neuronal activity, we investigated whether it would affect the visual map created by retinal ganglion cell terminals in the frog optic tectum. Chronic exposure of the tectum to nicotine decreased the retinal area from which cells project to a given tectal site. This map refinement was also produced by exposure to either the alpha-bungarotoxin sensitive nicotinic receptor agonist, anatoxin-a or the alpha-bungarotoxin-insensitive nicotinic receptor agonist epiboxidine. Immunocytochemical studies using mAb306 and mAb22 demonstrated that alpha-bungarotoxin-sensitive and -insensitive nicotinic receptors, respectively, occupied different tectal sites. Choline acetyltransferase immunoreactivity overlapped with mAb306, but not mAb22, staining. The developing optic tectum was more sensitive to nicotine than the adult tectum and nicotine induced both map refinements and map disruptions in a concentration-dependent manner. Blockade of the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor with D(-)-2-amino-5-phosphonopentanoic acid (D-APV) prevented nicotine from refining the map in the adult tectum. Exposure to the use-dependent NMDA antagonist MK801 alone had no effect on retinotectal topography but in combination with either NMDA or nicotine it disrupted the map. Exposure to NMDA alone produced refinement. We conclude that the map refinement induced by chronic nicotine treatment has as its basis an increase in the level of NMDA receptor activity. The data are consistent with a model whereby map topography can be bidirectionally affected by either increasing or decreasing NMDA receptor activity.

Non-NMDA and NMDA receptors are involved in suprathreshold excitation of network of frog tectal neurons by a single retinal ganglion cell

NMDA receptors play an important functional role in the neuron excitability and plasticity. The conditions and consequences of their activation are of interest for many neuroscientists. This investigation was designed to explore an activation of the NMDA receptors of frog tectal neurons in vivo by a burst of spikes of individual retinotectal fiber. We show that: (1) the NMDA receptors of tectal neurons can be activated by an intense burst discharge of an individual ganglion cell (likely darkness detector) at physiological conditions. (2) Activation of the NMDA receptors is achieved, primarily, due to temporal summation and frequency facilitation of the fast non-NMDA synaptic potentials. However, it is very likely that spatial summation of the fast retinotectal synaptic potentials with excitatory synaptic potentials of recurrent connections contributes to elicit the NMDA response. (3) The activation of NMDA receptors causes a higher level of activity of tectal neuron network. The suprathreshold excitation of efferent tectal neurons is characteristic for this level. Therefore, the burst discharge of only single retinal ganglion cell can activate the tectobulbospinal tract and lead to the motor reaction.

Chronic melatonin and binocular plasticity in Xenopus frogs

The topographic binocular maps in the optic tectum of Xenopus frogs are notable both for their dramatic plasticity during development and for the high expression of melatonin receptors in the circuitry contributing to those binocular maps. The goal of this study was to determine whether melatonin contributes to the control of binocular tectal plasticity. During development, rotation of one eye leads to compensatory rewiring of ipsilateral maps. The effect of 3-4 months of chronic 20 or 200 nM melatonin on this rewiring was tested by electrophysiological mapping. No decrease in plasticity was observed. In adult Xenopus, rotation of one eye normally does not lead to rewiring of the ipsilateral projection, although adults can exhibit plasticity if they have been dark-reared or have been treated as adults with NMDA. We tested whether exposure to 20-200 nM melatonin during and after the normal critical period would similarly extend plasticity. Eye rotation in adults that had been treated with melatonin did not demonstrate retained plasticity. These results show that melatonin does not reduce the normally high plasticity characteristic of young Xenopus nor does it increase the normally low plasticity of adult Xenopus.

Abnormal functional organization in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus of mice lacking the beta 2 subunit of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

Spontaneous activity patterns in the developing retina appear important for the functional organization of the visual system. We show here that an absence of early retinal waves in mice lacking the beta2 subunit of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) is associated with both gain and loss of functional organization in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN). Anatomical studies show normal gross retinotopy in the beta2(-/-) dLGN but suggest reduced topographic precision in the retinogeniculate projection. Physiological recordings reveal normal topography in the dorsoventral visual axis but a lack of fine-scale mapping in the nasotemporal visual plane. In contrast, unlike wild-type mice, on- and off-center cells in the beta2(-/-) dLGN are spatially segregated. The presence of the beta2 subunit of the nAChR in the CNS is therefore important for normal functional organization in the retinogeniculate projection.

Retinotopic map refinement requires spontaneous retinal waves during a brief critical period of development

During retinocollicular map development, spontaneous waves of action potentials spread across the retina, correlating activity among neighboring retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). To address the role of retinal waves in topographic map development, we examined wave dynamics and retinocollicular projections in mice lacking the beta2 subunit of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. beta2(-/-) mice lack waves during the first postnatal week, but RGCs have high levels of uncorrelated firing. By P8, the wild-type retinocollicular projection remodels into a refined map characterized by axons of neighboring RGCs forming focal termination zones (TZs) of overlapping arbors. In contrast, in P8 beta2(-/-) mice, neighboring RGC axons form large TZs characterized by broadly distributed arbors. At P8, glutamatergic retinal waves appear in beta2(-/-) mice, and later, visually patterned activity appears, but the diffuse TZs fail to remodel. Thus, spontaneous retinal waves that correlate RGC activity are required for retinotopic map remodeling during a brief early critical period.