Back to the future: middle molecules, high flux membranes, and optimal dialysis

Choices in hemodialysis therapies: variants, personalized therapy and application of evidence-based medicine

The extent of removal of the uremic toxins in hemodialysis (HD) therapies depends primarily on the dialysis membrane characteristics and the solute transport mechanisms involved. While designation of ‘flux’ of membranes as well toxicity of compounds that need to be targeted for removal remain unresolved issues, the relative role, efficiency and utilization of solute removal principles to optimize HD treatment are better delineated. Through the combination and intensity of diffusive and convective removal forces, levels of concentrations of a broad spectrum of uremic toxins can be lowered significantly and successfully. Extended clinical experience as well as data from several clinical trials attest to the benefits of convection-based HD treatment modalities. However, the mode of delivery of HD can further enhance the effectiveness of therapies. Other than treatment time, frequency and location that offer clinical benefits and increase patient well-being, treatment- and patient-specific criteria may be tailored for the therapy delivered: electrolytic composition, dialysate buffer and concentration and choice of anticoagulating agent are crucial for dialysis tolerance and efficacy. Evidence-based medicine (EBM) relies on three tenets, i.e. clinical expertise (i.e. doctor), patient-centered values (i.e. patient) and relevant scientific evidence (i.e. science), that have deviated from their initial aim and summarized to scientific evidence, leading to tyranny of randomized controlled trials. One must recognize that practice patterns as shown by Dialysis Outcomes and Practice Patterns Study and personalization of HD care are the main driving force for improving outcomes. Based on a combination of the three pillars of EBM, and particularly on bedside patient–clinician interaction, we summarize what we have learned over the last 6 decades in terms of best practices to improve outcomes in HD patients. Management of initiation of dialysis, vascular access, preservation of kidney function, selection of biocompatible dialysers and use of dialysis fluids of high microbiological purity to restrict inflammation are just some of the approaches where clinical experience is vital in the absence of definitive scientific evidence. Further, HD adequacy needs to be considered as a broad and multitarget approach covering not just the dose of dialysis provided, but meeting individual patient needs (e.g. fluid volume, acid–base, blood pressure, bone disease metabolism control) through regular assessment—and adjustment—of a series of indicators of treatment efficiency. Finally, in whichever way new technologies (i.e. artificial intelligence, connected health) are embraced in the future to improve the delivery of dialysis, the human dimension of the patient–doctor interaction is irreplaceable. Kidney medicine should remain ‘an art’ and will never be just ‘a science’.

Clinical relevance of abstruse transport phenomena in haemodialysis

Haemodialysis (HD) utilizes the bidirectional properties of semipermeable membranes to remove uraemic toxins from blood while simultaneously replenishing electrolytes and buffers to correct metabolic acidosis. However, the nonspecific size-dependent transport across membranes also means that certain useful plasma constituents may be removed from the patient (together with uraemic toxins), or toxic compounds, e.g. endotoxin fragments, may accompany electrolytes and buffers of the dialysis fluids into blood and elicit severe biological reactions. We describe the mechanisms and implications of these undesirable transport processes that are inherent to all HD therapies and propose approaches to mitigate the effects of such transport. We focus particularly on two undesirable events that are considered to adversely affect HD therapy and possibly impact patient outcomes. Firstly, we describe how loss of albumin (and other essential substances) can occur while striving to eliminate larger uraemic toxins during HD and why hypoalbuminemia is a clinical condition to contend with. Secondly, we describe the origins and mode of transport of biologically active substances (from dialysis fluids with bacterial contamination) into the blood compartment and biological reactions they elicit. Endotoxin fragments activate various proinflammatory pathways to increase the underlying inflammation associated with chronic kidney disease. Both phenomena involve the physical as well as chemical properties of membranes that must be selected judiciously to balance the benefits with potential risks patients may encounter, in both the short and long term.

Potassium control in chronic kidney disease: implications for neuromuscular function

In Australia, approximately 1.7 million adults have evidence of chronic kidney disease (CKD). This complex disease can result in a multitude of complications, including hyperkalaemia, which is common and well recognised. The advent of new therapeutics aimed at lowering serum potassium has raised the possibility of optimising potassium control to enable greater use of renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system inhibitors in the management of CKD. Recent studies suggest that hyperkalaemia also has implications for peripheral neuropathy in CKD, a complication that substantially contributes to patient morbidity. This review examines evidence of the relationship between potassium and peripheral neuropathy, with a discussion of clinical implications. We searched PubMed for original and review articles using pre-specified key words, clinical guidelines and population data. The major findings were that contemporary CKD cohorts demonstrate a high prevalence of peripheral neuropathy, even in stage 3-4 CKD, including those without diabetes. The severity of the problem has been emphasised by an ominous rise in foot complications and amputation rates in dialysis patients, highlighting the need for increased awareness of the condition in earlier stages of CKD and targeted treatment strategies. It is likely that the pathophysiology of peripheral neuropathy in CKD is multifaceted, with potential influences from potassium, vascular abnormalities, diabetes, inflammation and unknown middle molecules. Despite these complexities, the relationship between potassium and nerve function in dialysis has been well established, and recent research in stage 3-4 CKD suggests that assertive potassium control may improve neuromuscular outcomes in CKD. These small studies should be confirmed in large, multicentre settings.

Levels of cystatin C in low- and high-flux hemodialysis in children with end-stage renal disease

BACKGROUND

Cystatin-C (CyC) is a middle molecule that is freely filtered at the glomerulus and almost completely reabsorbed by the proximal tubules. The aim of this study was to evaluate serum CyC and its reduction ratio as a biomarker for assessing the adequacy of the hemodialysis (HD) sessions in children with end-stage renal disease on maintenance HD. We also compared levels of CyC in patients on low-flux HD (LFH) and high-flux HD (HFH).

METHODS

Forty patients were included in the study and divided into two groups, with one group (16 patients) receiving HFH and the other group receiving LFH (24 patients) (high-flux and low-flux polysulfone filters, respectively). Before and after each dialysis session serum CyC and beta-2-microglobulin (B2M) levels were measured using an ELISA technique, and routine laboratory tests were performed for each patient.

RESULTS

Pre-dialytic levels of CyC were significantly lower in the patients receiving HFH than in those receiving LFH (7.33 ± 1.35 vs. 9.73 ± 0.93, respectively; p < 0.0001). In the HFH group, post-dialytic levels of serum CyC were significantly lower than pre-dialytic levels (4.49 ± 0.71 vs. 7.33 ± 1.35, respectively; p < 0.0001). The reduction ratio (RR) of CyC was significantly higher in the HFH group than in the LFH group (38.2 ± 3.91 vs. -6.49 ± 5.05, respectively; p < 0.0001). Serum CyC level significantly correlated with B2M, urea and creatinine levels in both the LFH and HFH groups, whereas its RR significantly correlated with the RRs of urea, creatinine, and B2M in the HFH group.

CONCLUSION

The results of our study emphasize the role of CyC as a good marker for assessing the adequacy of HD sessions in children on HFH and show that the CyC RR may be used as an index of middle-molecule toxin clearance following HFH sessions.

Hemodialysis clearance of iosimenol, a novel iso-osmolar radiographic contrast medium

BACKGROUND

Iodinated contrast media (CM) have molecular and pharmacokinetic properties likely to make them highly dialyzable. Controlled clinical studies allowing for comparisons of hemodialysis clearance between different test substances and in multiple hemodialysis filters are, however, complex and not always practically feasible. A miniaturized in vitro method was therefore developed to evaluate the dialyzability of a new CM.

PURPOSE

To evaluate hemodialysis clearance of iosimenol, a novel iso-osmolar contrast medium (CM), in a select variety of hemodialysis filters and in comparison to commercially available CM.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Three different high-flux and one low-flux membrane were used in miniaturized dialyzers to evaluate the in vitro blood clearance of iosimenol. Commercially available CM (iodixanol and iohexol) served as control substances. In vitro dialysis parameters were then used to predict clinical hemodialysis clearances. Residual ratios of endogenous substances (inorganic phosphate, urea nitrogen, creatinine, total bilirubin, and albumin) were used as proof of reliability of the in vitro dialysis system.

RESULTS

Dialyzable small endogenous molecules were readily eliminated in all membranes. The removal ratios of iosimenol were generally similar to that of iodixanol in all membranes except the high-flux polysulfone but were consistently lower than that of iohexol. The blood clearance of iosimenol during clinical hemodialysis was predicted as, on average, approximately 85 mL/min with the high-flux membranes and 47 mL/min with the low-flux membrane.

CONCLUSION

The dialyzability of iosimenol was evaluated using a newly developed in vitro dialysis system, and iosimenol was readily cleared from blood with all four tested membranes. And it is suggested that the dialysis parameters can predict clinical hemodialysis clearance of CM.

Dialysis membrane: from convection to adsorption

Although patients undergoing dialysis have a complex illness, there are compelling reasons to believe that the inadequate removal of organic waste is an important contributing factor to the illness itself. This paper focuses on the transport phenomena that occur within a dialyser. An attempt is made to clarify how transport phenomena are related to the performance of a dialysis session and how they depend on the membrane characteristics. Our study offers some discussion points on the complex issue of defining what the best parameters could be in comparing the efficiency of different membranes. The new high-flux dialysers have improved larger-molecule clearance and biocompatibility. Membrane performance is a very hard process to evaluate, and different membranes can only be compared by establishing adequate points of comparison. At the same time, the points of comparison themselves may change depending on the type of co-morbidities of the specific patient who is considered for membrane selection. This editorial (together with all the papers presented in this issue) seeks to focus on the membrane's own merits in improving the dialysis therapy.

Hemodialysis in children: general practical guidelines

Over the past 20 years children have benefited from major improvements in both technology and clinical management of dialysis. Morbidity during dialysis sessions has decreased with seizures being exceptional and hypotensive episodes rare. Pain and discomfort have been reduced with the use of chronic internal jugular venous catheters and anesthetic creams for fistula puncture. Non-invasive technologies to assess patient target dry weight and access flow can significantly reduce patient morbidity and health care costs. The development of urea kinetic modeling enables calculation of the dialysis dose delivery, Kt/V, and an indirect assessment of the intake. Nutritional assessment and support are of major importance for the growing child. Even if the validity of these "urea only" data is questioned, their analysis provides information useful for follow-up. Newer machines provide more precise control of ultrafiltration by volumetric assessment and continuous blood volume monitoring during dialysis sessions. Buffered bicarbonate solutions are now standard and more biocompatible synthetic membranes and specific small size material dialyzers and tubing have been developed for young infants. More recently, the concept of "ultrapure" dialysate, i.e. free from microbiological contamination and endotoxins, has developed. This will enable the use of hemodiafiltration, especially with the on-line option, which has many theoretical advantages and should be considered in the case of maximum/optimum dialysis need. Although the optimum dialysis dose requirement for children remains uncertain, reports of longer duration and/or daily dialysis show they are more effective for phosphate control than conventional hemodialysis and should be considered at least for some high-risk patients with cardiovascular impairment. In children hemodialysis has to be individualized and viewed as an "integrated therapy" considering their long-term exposure to chronic renal failure treatment. Dialysis is seen only as a temporary measure for children compared with renal transplantation because this enables the best chance of rehabilitation in terms of educational and psychosocial functioning. In long term chronic dialysis, however, the highest standards should be applied to these children to preserve their future "cardiovascular life" which might include more dialysis time and on-line hemodiafiltration with synthetic high flux membranes if we are able to improve on the rather restricted concept of small-solute urea dialysis clearance.

Hemodialysis in children: general practical guidelines

Over the past 20 years children have benefited from major improvements in both technology and clinical management of dialysis. Morbidity during dialysis sessions has decreased with seizures being exceptional and hypotensive episodes rare. Pain and discomfort have been reduced with the use of chronic internal jugular venous catheters and anesthetic creams for fistula puncture. Non-invasive technologies to assess patient target dry weight and access flow can significantly reduce patient morbidity and health care costs. The development of urea kinetic modeling enables calculation of the dialysis dose delivery, Kt/V, and an indirect assessment of the intake. Nutritional assessment and support are of major importance for the growing child. Even if the validity of these "urea only" data is questioned, their analysis provides information useful for follow-up. Newer machines provide more precise control of ultrafiltration by volumetric assessment and continuous blood volume monitoring during dialysis sessions. Buffered bicarbonate solutions are now standard and more biocompatible synthetic membranes and specific small size material dialyzers and tubing have been developed for young infants. More recently, the concept of "ultrapure" dialysate, i.e. free from microbiological contamination and endotoxins, has developed. This will enable the use of hemodiafiltration, especially with the on-line option, which has many theoretical advantages and should be considered in the case of maximum/optimum dialysis need. Although the optimum dialysis dose requirement for children remains uncertain, reports of longer duration and/or daily dialysis show they are more effective for phosphate control than conventional hemodialysis and should be considered at least for some high-risk patients with cardiovascular impairment. In children hemodialysis has to be individualized and viewed as an "integrated therapy" considering their long-term exposure to chronic renal failure treatment. Dialysis is seen only as a temporary measure for children compared with renal transplantation because this enables the best chance of rehabilitation in terms of educational and psychosocial functioning. In long term chronic dialysis, however, the highest standards should be applied to these children to preserve their future "cardiovascular life" which might include more dialysis time and on-line hemodiafiltration with synthetic high flux membranes if we are able to improve on the rather restricted concept of small-solute urea dialysis clearance.