Modified technique of autologous noncultured epidermal cell transplantation for repigmenting vitiligo: a pilot study

Autologously transplanted dermis-derived cells alleviated monobenzone-induced vitiligo in mouse

Vitiligo is a depigmentation disease which affects skin and hair follicles with a prevalence of 0.5-1% worldwide. In this study, we aimed to investigate treatmental potential of dermis-derived cells in monobenzone (MBEH)-induced mouse vitiligo model with light and electron microscopy. MBEH (40%) cream was topically applied to C57BL/6 mice until depigmentation occured in vitiligo and experimental groups. In experimental groups, dermis-derived cells obtained from back skin biopsy samples before induction of vitiligo, were injected intradermally to vitiligo mice. On day 3 and 15 after cell transplantation to experimental groups, skin biopsies were compared with biopsies of control and vitiligo groups. Dermis-derived cells obtained from back skin biopsy samples of experimental groups showed nestin and versican immunoreactivity. Melanin in hair follicles of control group was detected by histochemical stainings (Hematoxylin&Eosin and Fontana-Masson) whereas sparse melanin granules were observed in hair follicles of vitiligo group. In experimental groups, there was an increase in the number of hair follicles with melanin compared to vitiligo group. We observed MART-1 immunoreactive cells mostly around the hair follicles in control group and within dermis in vitiligo group. Electron microscopic investigation showed presence of melanosomes in hair follicles of control group and lacking in vitiligo group. In experimental groups, both type of hair follicles were observed with electron microscope. Our data suggest that autologously transplanted dermis-derived cells may be effective in vitiligo treatment by contrubuting to melanin production.

Hair Follicle as a Source of Pigment-Producing Cells for Treatment of Vitiligo: An Alternative to Epidermis?

To discuss the advantages and limitations of hair follicle-derived cell transplantation (FCT) in vitiligo, compared to the epidermal cell transplantation (ECT), and the knowledge gap which is required to be bridged. The papers relevant to the purpose was reviewed. Surgical approaches for treating vitiligo are based on the idea of replenishing lost melanocytes. Skin and hair follicles as the main sources of melanocytes have been applied for this purpose transferring the whole tissue or tissue-derived cell suspension to the vitiligo lesions. Considering the differences between hair follicle and epidermis in terms of the constituting cell populations, phenotype and function of melanocytes, and micro-environmental factors, different response of vitiligo patients to treatment with FCT or ECT would be expected theoretically. However, there is currently a lack of evidence on such a difference. However, ECT appears to be a more feasible, less time-consuming, and more comfortable treatment for both physicians and patients. Although the current evidence has not shown a significant difference between ECT and FCT in terms of efficacy, ECT appears to be more feasible specifically in the treatment of large lesions. However, further randomized controlled clinical trials with larger sample sizes and longer follow-up durations are required to be conducted to draw a definite conclusion on comparing FCT with ECT in terms of the safety, efficacy, durability of the therapeutic effects, and indications in vitiligo patients.

Studying the effect of adding growth factors to the autologous melanocyte keratinocyte suspension in segmental vitiligo

Addition of different growth factors to the medium used in autologous melanocyte-keratinocyte transplantation procedure (MKTP) was reported in the literature. The aim of the current study was comparison of response to MKTP in segmental vitiligo (SV) with and without adding growth factors to the suspension medium. Eighteen cases with SV were randomly divided into two groups. In group A: Ham F12 medium was used for suspension and in group B: 5 ng/mL recombinant basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) and 25 mg/500 mL 3'5' cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) were added to the medium. All cases received NB-UVB twice weekly for 24 weeks. The area of vitiligo lesions was measured before and after therapy by point-counting technique and complications were recorded. Excellent response (90%-100% repigmentation) occurred in 5/9 cases (56%) in group A and 7/9 cases (78%) in group B (with growth factors). A significant decrease in the area of treated lesions before and after therapy was found in both groups A and B (P = .0012 and .0004, respectively), however, a higher percentage of reduction in area of vitiligo was seen in group B cases (70% in group A vs 90% in group B; P value: .028). Marginal halo was seen in five cases in group A and six in group B. In conclusion addition of bFGF and cAMP to MKTP medium improved the results of the procedure. It could be considered if economically feasible.

Outcome of Repeated Use of Donor Site for Noncultured Epidermal Cellular Grafting in Stable Vitiligo: A Retrospective Study

Background

Noncultured epidermal suspension (NCES) is a surgical technique which employs cellular grafting onto depigmented lesions. However, scarring and dyschromia at the donor site often occurs.

Objective

To assess the outcome of reusing the same donor site in subsequent sessions of NCES procedures.

Methods

Electronic records of vitiligo patients who had undergone two sessions of NCES procedures were retrospectively reviewed. Information on the first and second NCES was retrieved for analyses.

Results

A total of 30 patients (female 19 and male 11) were included. The majority of patients had nonsegmental vitiligo (66.7%). The median donor-to-recipient ratios were 1 : 3 (1 : 1–1 : 20) for the first session and 1 : 3 (1 : 1–1 : 13.5) for the second session (p=0.661). The mean melanocyte count was 220.7 ± 65.5 cells/mm² vs. 242.4 ± 55.3 cells/mm² on the first and second sessions, respectively (p=0.440). The mean repigmentation rate was 84.2% (±21.1%) and 82.3 (±22.1%) for the first and second NCESs, respectively (p=0.645). The frequency of color mismatch and pigment loss were similar between both sessions (p=0.706 and p=1.000).

Conclusions

Repeated use of donor sites in subsequent NCES sessions gave comparable repigmentation.

Vitiligo surgery: A journey from tissues via cells to the stems!

Depigmented patches in vitiligo, a common dermatosis, cause a great psychological distress to the patients. Hence, apart from halting the disease process, the strategies to impart normal skin colour to these white patches carry an important role in the management of vitiligo. Surgical procedures are often required for stable vitiligo lesions not responding to medical therapies. It involves "shuffling" of melanocytes from the pigmented skin to the depigmented areas. During the last fifty years, the vitiligo surgery has evolved from tissue transplantation via cellular transplantation to reach a stage where the use of stem cells or immunomodulatory cells is contemplating. We would like to depict this wonderful journey of vitiligo surgery through this viewpoint.

Autologous non-cultured melanocyte-keratinocyte transplantation in the treatment of vitiligo: patient selection and perspectives

Autologous non-cultured melanocyte–keratinocyte transplantation procedure (MKTP) is one of the simplest cellular grafting techniques. Various modifications were done over the years to make the technique easier and more economical which led to its great popularity among dermatologists. Proper patient selection and good technical skills are essential for achieving success with this technique. In this review, different patient-related and procedure-related factors that affect the outcome are discussed. This review may guide dermatologists to select suitable candidates, and explains what to expect in each case and indicates different techniques which can be used. The expected complications and stability of acquired pigmentation, which are an essential part of the pretreatment patient counseling, are also discussed.

High correlation between skin color based on CIELAB color space, epidermal melanocyte ratio, and melanocyte melanin content

Background

To treat skin color disorders, such as vitiligo or burns, melanocytes are transplanted for tissue regeneration. However, melanocyte distribution in the human body varies with age and location, making it difficult to select the optimal donor skin to achieve a desired color match. Determining the correlations with the desired skin color measurement based on CIELAB color, epidermal melanocyte numbers, and melanin content of individual melanocytes is critical for clinical application.

Method

Fifteen foreskin samples from Asian young adults were analyzed for skin color, melanocyte ratio (melanocyte proportion in the epidermis), and melanin concentration. Furthermore, an equation was developed based on CIELAB color with melanocyte ratio, melanin concentration, and the product of melanocyte ratio and melanin concentration. The equation was validated by seeding different ratios of keratinocytes and melanocytes in tissue-engineered skin substitutes, and the degree of fitness in expected skin color was confirmed.

Results

Linear regression analysis revealed a significant strong negative correlation (r =  − 0.847, R² = 0.717) between CIELAB L* value and the product of the epidermal melanocyte ratio and cell-based melanin concentration. Furthermore, the results showed that an optimal skin color match was achieved by the formula.

Discussion

We found that L* value was correlated with the value obtained from multiplying the epidermal melanocyte ratio (R) and melanin content (M) and that this correlation was more significant than either L* vs M or L* vs R. This suggests that more accurate prediction of skin color can be achieved by considering both R and M. Therefore, precise skin color match in treating vitiligo or burn patients would be potentially achievable based on extensive collection of skin data from people of Asian descent.

The clinical experience for treating post-burn depigmentation with tiny epidermal particles graft

The critical problem of post-burn depigmentation is the lacking normal melanocytes. Auto-skin grafting and autologous non-cultured epidermal cell suspension have been used to improve the appearance. However, a large amount of skin graft is required of donor sites in the former method, while the latter method is thought to be complicated and costly. This study is designed to generalise the experience of tiny epidermal particles graft (TEPG) for treating post-burn depigmentation. From 2012 to 2013, 30 consecutive patients with depigmentation caused by burn injuries were divided into I and II group. I group: 15 cases (11 males and 4 females) were treated by the TEPG. II group: 15 patients (10 males and 5 females) were treated by suction blister epidermal skin graft (SBEG). Imagine-Pro Plus software was used to evaluate the size of repigmentation (RP) 12 months post-surgery. SPSS software 13.0 was used to evaluate the data. The optimum rate of RP was defined as more than 75% (RP > 75%) when excellent RP was defined as more than 90% (>90%). All patients were followed up for 12 months. The mean size of RP in two groups demonstrated that there were statistically significant differences in pigmentation between the two groups (P = 0·002), while there was no significant difference in the other factors (gender, site and age). No infection occurred in the recipient site. Pathological result showed that melanocytes existed at the basal layer of resurfacing skin. Optimum RP (RP > 75%) was seen in 12 patients in I group and 9 patients in II group. Excellent RP was achieved in 14 cases in I group and 10 patients in II group. Excellent RP can be obtained by the abovementioned two surgical techniques. In contrast to SBEG, TEPG is less traumatic, and definite effects can be guaranteed. It is a preferred treatment, especially for those patients who suffer from large depigmented lesions.

Four compartment method: a simplified and cost-effective method of noncultured epidermal cell suspension for the treatment of vitiligo

BACKGROUND

Despite continued progress towards an elucidation of pathogenetic pathways in vitiligo, a definitive cure remains elusive. Noncultured epidermal cell suspension (NCECS) is emerging as the treatment of choice for surgical management of both stable and segmental vitiligo. NCECS is very effective in repigmenting stable vitiligo, but the technique requires an expert and the support of a laboratory facility.

OBJECTIVES

To investigate a simplified and more cost-effective method for NCECS.

METHODS

We simplified the conventional NCECS method and made it more cost-effective and simple enough to be performed in the clinic without laboratory equipment. We named this the four compartment (FC) method. Six patients with vitiligo were treated with this FC method.

RESULTS

The FC method for NCECS is highly cost-effective and simple. Six patients with vitiligo were treated and the results showed marked to complete repigmentation in four patients and > 50% repigmentation in two patients in 3 months.

CONCLUSIONS

The FC method is a cost-effective and simple procedure to prepare epidermal cell suspensions. In this modified method we showed that there is no need for pipette, tips, centrifuge tube and most importantly a centrifuge machine or any other expensive laboratory equipment.

Grafting in vitiligo: how to get better results and how to avoid complications

Grafting procedures in vitiligo have become quite popular over the last one or two decades especially in India. Starting with the simplest punch grafting we have now a multitude of different grafting techniques available in vitiligo. All of these grafting procedures are associated with certain complications. In addition there are certain factors and surgical pearls that can go a long way in improving the cosmetic results achieved with any of these grafting techniques. This paper will try to address these specific factors and complications associated with these grafting techniques and the ways and means to avoid them.

Comparison of intradermal injection of autologous epidermal cell suspension vs. spraying of these cells on dermabraded surface of skin of patients with post-burn hypopigmentation

Introduction:

One of the most important complications after burning is hypo/depigmentation. This study was designed to compare two methods of cell spray and intradermal injection of epidermal cell suspension for treatment of burn induced hypopigmentation.

Material and Methods:

In this study, 28 patients with post burn hypo/depigmentation were selected and divided in 2 groups. A small skin biopsy was taken from normal skin of patients in operation room and epidermal cell suspension was prepared using NaBr 4N and trypsin. In the first group, the epidermal cell suspension was sprayed on the wound surface and then the area was dressed with amniotic membrane and gauze. In the second group, the cell suspension was injected in intradermal manner in the hypopigmented area. The patients were followed up and to evaluate the effect of the cells, photos were taken from the area before operation and also at follow-up. Clinical evaluation was done by the surgeon and a clinical score between “0” to “4” was used to demonstrate the clinical status from poor to excellent pigmentation. Skin biopsies were taken from depigmented area before and after interventions. Melanocytes were stained using anti S100 antibody and were counted in ×400 magnification fields.

Results:

Eighteen patients were in cell spray and 10 were in cell injection groups. Mean change of pigmentation in two group showed that there was no statistical significant differences in pigmentation between two groups, (P value = 0.52) although a limited improvement in pigmentation status was observed in both groups. Regarding melanocyte numbers per field, there was not a significant difference between two groups and also before and after interventions, but melanocyte number increased after treatment in both groups.

Conclusion:

We did not find noticeable differences between cell spray and intradermal injection methods. Although both methods showed a limited effect on pigmentation of depigmented skin, the clinical results were not satisfactorily for both patients and clinicians.

A Review of Non-cultured Epidermal Cellular Grafting in Vitiligo

Non-cultured epidermal cellular grafting is an innovative surgical technique that can be used for the treatment of stabilized leucoderma, including vitiligo. Many reports have been published since its introduction in 1992, including several modifications and simplification of the original technique. This systematic review gives an overview of the literature.

Non-cultured melanocyte-keratinocyte transplantation for the treatment of vitiligo: a clinical trial in an Iranian population

BACKGROUND

Non-cultured cellular grafting as a surgical procedure is indicated to treat stable vitiligo, refractory to medical treatment, and is gaining wider acceptance among dermatologists.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of non-cultured melanocyte-keratinocyte transplantation (MKT) for the treatment of generalized vitiligo in Iranian patients.

METHODS

In this clinical trial, a total of 14 vitiligo patches in eight patients were treated; eight patches with non-cultured MKT and six patches dermabraded alone without application of keratinocyte-melanocyte suspension. Repigmentation was compared at about 4 months post-transplantation.

RESULTS

Of the eight lesions treated with non-cultured MKT, four lesions showed 96-100% repigmentation, one lesion 65-95% and three lesions 0-25%. Of the patients who showed excellent results, only one showed a post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation in recipient and control areas. Of the six control lesions, five showed failed repigmentation and one showed post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation.

CONCLUSION

Non-cultured MKT is an effective method to treat stable vitiligo. Studies on larger series of vitiligo patients are required to confirm its efficacy.

Cellular grafts in management of leucoderma

Cellular grafting methods constitute important advances in the surgical management of leucoderma. Different methods such as noncultured epidermal suspensions, melanocyte cultures, and melanocyte-keratinocyte cultures have all been shown to be effective. This article reviews these methods.

Treatment of vitiligo lesions by ReCell vs. conventional melanocyte-keratinocyte transplantation: a pilot study

BACKGROUND

Surgical procedures are indicated to treat stable vitiligo, refractory to medical treatment. In addition to conventional surgical techniques, noncultured cellular grafting is gaining wider acceptance among dermatologists.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the efficacy of the ReCell kit (Clinical Cell Culture, Cambridge, U.K.) and to compare it with conventional melanocyte-keratinocyte transplantation (MKT) for the treatment of vitiligo.

METHODS

Ten lesions in five patients at the same anatomical localization (left vs. right, or two separate lesions at the same anatomical location) were treated with ReCell and conventional MKT and repigmentation compared at 4 months post-transplantation.

RESULTS

Of the five lesions treated with ReCell two lesions showed 100%, one 65% and one 40% repigmentation, and one lesion failed to repigment. Of the five lesions treated by conventional MKT three showed 100% and one 30% repigmentation and one failed to repigment.

CONCLUSIONS

ReCell may be an effective method to treat vitiligo. Studies on larger series of patients are required to confirm its efficacy. Further research is required to establish the effective dilution of the cell suspension.

Dermatosurgical techniques for repigmentation of vitiligo

There are a number of dermatosurgery techniques available to achieve repigmentation of vitiligo, such as suction blister grafting, split-thickness skin grafting, punch grafting, follicular grafting, cultured-melanocytes transplantation, and noncultured-melanocytes transplantation. Each method has advantages and disadvantages. As there are no specific data available from the prospective studies in this field it is uneasy to recommend which surgical approach to vitiligo offers the best result. According to a systematic review by Njoo et al.,(17) suction blister and split-thickness skin grafting have the highest rates of success (87%), while the average success rates for other methods varied from 13% to 53%. Punch grafting has the highest rate of adverse effects, including cobblestoning appearance (27%) and scar formation (40%) in the donor site. Accordingly, it is also mandatory to appropriately select vitiligo patients in order to achieve a complete and permanent repigmentation.

Efficacy of autologous transplantation of noncultured epidermal suspension in two different dilutions in the treatment of vitiligo

BACKGROUND

Previous reports have shown the effectiveness of a basal layer cell suspension in the treatment of stable vitiligo; however, there has been no mention in the literature until now of the optimal number of melanocytes required in an autologous noncultured epidermal suspension for transplantation to obtain early and acceptable results.

METHODS

In this randomized prospective study, we compared the efficacy of two different dilutions to determine the optimum density of melanocytes required for transplantation to achieve early and cosmetically acceptable results. We enrolled 20 patients with stable vitiligo with a body surface area involvement of< 10%.

RESULTS

Fifty per cent of patients in Group A (where the recipient area transplanted was approximately three times the size of the donor area, and the density of melanocytes transplanted per square millimeter was approximately 231.60+/- 27.03) showed marked (> 75%), 20% moderate, 10% mild, and 20% minimal repigmentation (or no response). In Group B (where the recipient area was increased to five-fold the donor area), none of the patients showed marked, 10% showed moderate, 20% showed mild, and 70% showed either minimal or no repigmentation. The density of melanocytes transplanted in this group was 154.90+/- 27.65/mm(2). The extent of repigmentation was significantly greater (P< 0.05) in Group A than in Group B, and the density of melanocytes in the suspension was also significantly greater (P< 0.01) in Group A than in Group B.

CONCLUSION

We contend that the minimum number of melanocytes required to produce satisfactory repigmentation is probably in the range of 210-250/mm(2).

Autografts and cultured epidermis in the treatment of vitiligo

Skin transplants can be a useful and efficacious method to treat vitiligo. The aim is to repopulate areas lacking melanocytes with functional cells taken from normally pigmented areas. Several procedures have been devised and tested: some consist in the simple transfer of epidermis sampled and implanted as is, whereas others are based on the transplantation of disaggregated and manipulated cells. The therapeutic success of the former methods is partly determined by the ability and experience of the surgeon performing the operation, whereas the results of the latter methods mainly depend on the laboratory facilities and abilities of the personnel who manipulate the cells to be transplanted. The transplantation of cultured cells is the most fascinating and promising procedure but requires the observance of still not completely predictable procedures. The use of biological material of animal origin and the use of factors to stimulate cell proliferation, such as growth factors and promoting agents, are other points that require attention.

A chemically defined surface for the co-culture of melanocytes and keratinocytes

Patients with stable vitiligo can be helped surgically using transplantation of autologous cultured melanocytes, but there is a need for a culture methodology that is free from xenobiotic agents and for a simple way of delivering cultured melanocytes to the patient to achieve pigmentation with good wound healing. The aim of this study was to develop a chemically defined surface, suitable for the co-culture of melanocytes and keratinocytes which could be used in the future for the treatment vitiligo patients to achieve both restoration of pigmentation and good wound healing. Two keratinocyte growth media and two melanocyte growth media were compared; two of these were serum free. Cells were seeded on a range of chemically defined substrates (produced by plasma polymerisation of acrylic acid, allylamine or a mixture of these monomers) either as mono- or co-cultures. Melanocytes and keratinocytes attached and proliferated on both acid and amine substrates (without significant preferences), and co-cultures of cells proliferated more successfully than individual cultures. One media, M2, which is serum free, supported expansion of melanocytes and to a lesser extent keratinocytes on several plasma polymer substrates. In conclusion, these data indicate that a combination of a chemically defined substrate with M2 media allows serum-free co-culture of melanocytes and keratinocytes.

The Use of the 308-nm Excimer Laser for the Treatment of Vitiligo

BACKGROUND

Recent reports show that 308-nm excimer laser may be an effective and safe method for the treatment of vitiligo, which is usually resistant to other available treatment methods.

OBJECTIVE

The objective was to study the effectiveness of the new 308-nm excimer laser for the treatment of vitiligo.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review of thirty-two patients with 55 spots of vitiligo were enrolled; a population-based sample was studied that included men and women, adults and children, with different ethnic backgrounds. The treatment was started with the lowest dose, which is 100 mJ/cm(2) (comparable to one minimal erythema dose value and one multiplier). Depending on Fitzpatrick skin type, the dose was raised gradually in a stepwise fashion. In skin types I to II, the same does was repeated twice before going up to avoid burns. Patients were treated for 30 sessions, or 75% repigmentation, whichever comes first.

RESULTS

Overall 55 spots were treated: 29 (52.8%) had 75% pigmentation or greater, and 35 (63.7%) had 50% pigmentation or greater. The best results were on the face: of the 21 spots treated 15 (71.5%) had 75% pigmentation, and 16 (76.2%) had 50% pigmentation or greater. Other areas (neck, extremities, trunk, and genitals) had moderate response in comparison to the face. The least response was on the hands and feet; of the 5 spots treated only 20% showed 50% pigmentation or more.

CONCLUSION

Slightly more than 50% of the patients tested showed 75% or more pigmentation of their lesions, after 30 treatments or less; most of the responders had Fitzpatrick skin type III and above. All the untreated patches (controls) remained unchanged. This demonstrates that the 308-nm excimer laser is an effective method of treatment for vitiligo.

Melanocyte-keratinocyte cell transplantation for stable vitiligo

BACKGROUND

Vitiligo is a common disorder with a worldwide prevalence of 1-2%. In India the psychological and social impact of the disease is significant and is detrimental to patients.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the usefulness of epidermal cell transplantation in the treatment of vitiligo.

METHODS

A simpler and modified method based on that of Olsson and Juhlin has been used. It utilizes a shave biopsy skin sample of up to one-tenth the size of the recipient area. The skin sample is incubated, the cells mechanically separated using trypsin EDTA solution, and then centrifuged to prepare a suspension. The cell suspension is then applied to the derm-abraded depigmented skin area and collagen dressing is applied to keep it in place.

RESULTS

One hundred and twenty-two patients with generalized vitiligo, 43 with segmental and 19 with focal vitiligo were treated and observed for a period of 1 year. In the generalized vitiligo group 65 (53%) showed excellent pigmentation, 10 (8%) showed good pigmentation, 11 (9%) showed fair pigmentation and 28 (23%) patients showed poor pigmentation. Eight (7%) patients did not follow up. Thirty-six (84%), five (12%) and two (4%) patients showed excellent, good and poor pigmentation, respectively, in the segmental vitiligo group. Thirteen (69%) and five (26%) patients showed excellent and poor results, respectively, in the focal vitiligo group. One (5%) patient did not appear for follow up. Recurrence was observed in 15 patents.

CONCLUSION

This surgical treatment gives its best results in segmental and focal vitiligo, even with large affected areas, and in at least 50% of patients with generalized vitiligo, thus improving their appearance.

Photo(chemo) therapy for vitiligo

Vitiligo has always been difficult to treat. Several modes of treatment are available, but the therapeutic effect varies greatly, and rarely does one achieve complete repigmentation. One of the most efficient treatment methods is photo(chemo) therapy. Already in ancient Egypt, vitiligo lesions were treated with extracts of the Ammi maius plant followed by exposure to the sun. This principle is at the basis of the photochemotherapy or PUVA therapy, whereby UVA irradiations are given 2 h after administration of 8-methoxypsoralen, a photosensitizer. Another efficient treatment form is UVB phototherapy, particularly narrow-band UVB. This not only gives good therapeutic results but also has the advantage of eliminating the need for a photosensitizer. All these treatments must be applied for many months to be efficient. They can also be combined with various surgical skin-grafting techniques. A newer approach is targeted UVB phototherapy, whereby xenon-chloride lasers or monochromatic excimer light is used.