Ultra-low friction in soft contact lenses: Analysis of dynamic free responses measured by the dynamic oscillating tribometer

Friction coefficient is considered as a measurement for clinical comfort of soft contact lenses. One of the main challenges in the tribology field is to evaluate the friction in soft materials such as soft contact lenses. In this work, we aim to evaluate the friction at the eyelid-lens contact using a new technique. This technique is based on a single-degree-of-freedom (SDOF) mass-spring system having a sliding contact. The experimental technique measures the free responses of the mechanical system. The friction is then evaluated from the damped free responses with a high accuracy. A variety of soft contact lenses are tested with some lubricants under many physiological conditions. The results are discussed and compared with those in the literature.

Impact of the physical properties of contact lens materials on the discomfort: role of the coefficient of friction

Contact Lens Discomfort (CLD) is the main cause in contact lens (CLs) discontinuation, referred in literature as drop-out phenomenon. Despite such evidence was reported in several clinical studies, a relationship between physico-chemical properties of CLs and CLD is not still totally understood. In this regard, the friction of CLs surfaces seems to be related to discomfort feeling events, probably due to an alteration of the lubricate function of the tear film after the CL placement inside the ocular environment. In the last years, many studies have been finalized to the friction measurements of CLs surface, finding conflicting data due to a lack in standardized protocol. The aim of this review is primarily to show evident relationships between CLs surface properties (i.e. wettability, tear evaporation, tear film quality, etc.) and the coefficient of friction (CoF), resulting therefore the most relevant physical quantity in the CLs characterization. In addition, we reported the most recent studies in CLs tribology, which highlight that the introduction of a standard protocol in CoF measurements is necessary to obtain reproducible results, considering the aim to evaluate in a more precise way the relationship between this material surface property and comfort in CLs users.

Evaluation of the Lubricating Effect of Hyaluronic Acid on Contact Lenses Using a Pendulum-Type Friction Tester Under Mimicking Physiological Conditions

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the lubricating effect of hyaluronic acid (HA) on soft contact lenses (SCLs) measured using a pendulum-type friction tester.

METHODS

We measured the coefficient of friction (CoF) of narafilcon A, delefilcon A, and etafilcon A with polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), daily disposable SCL material, using a modified pendulum-type friction tester. Sample SCLs were set on an acrylic plastic half-ball and placed into the polyethylene terephthalate hemisphere cup filled with 0.4 mL of test lubricants that included saline and 0.05%, 0.1%, 0.2%, 0.3%, 0.4%, and 0.5% (wt/vol) HA (molecular weight, 850 kDa). The viscosities of saline and HA were measured using an Ubbelohde viscometer.

RESULTS

The CoF of the SCL under a low concentration (0.05%) of HA was the lowest and significantly lower than saline in narafilcon A and delefilcon A (P<0.05, Steel multiple comparison test). Under higher HA concentrations (0.3%, 0.4%, and 0.5%), the CoF was significantly higher than that of saline (P<0.01, Steel' multiple comparison test) in all three SCLs. There were no significant differences of CoF among three SCLs in saline and all concentrations of HA. The HA viscosities increased exponentially with the concentration (Y=1.2829e9.286X).

CONCLUSION

The viscosity of a high concentration of HA may increase the friction of SCLs, which may have a deleterious effect on the ocular surface.