Nutritional Adequacy of Essential Nutrients in Low Protein Animal-Based and Plant-Based Diets in the United States for Chronic Kidney Disease Patients

Evaluation of protein intake and protein quality in New Zealand vegans

Dietary protein provides indispensable amino acids (IAAs) that the body cannot synthesise. Past assessments of total protein intake from vegan populations in western, developed countries were found to be low but not necessarily below daily requirements. However, plant-sourced proteins generally have lower quantities of digestible IAAs as compared to animal-sourced proteins. Simply accounting for protein intake without considering AA profile and digestibility could overestimate protein adequacy among vegans. This study quantified protein intake and quality, as compared to reference intake values among 193 NZ vegans using a four-day food diary. Protein and IAA composition of all foods were derived from New Zealand FoodFiles and the United States Department of Agriculture and adjusted for True Ileal Digestibility (TID). Mean protein intakes for males and females were 0.98 and 0.80 g/kg/day, respectively with 78.8% of males and 73.0% of females meeting the Estimated Average Requirement for protein. Plant-sourced proteins provided 52.9 mg of leucine and 35.7 mg of lysine per gram of protein and were below the reference scoring patterns (leucine: 59mg/g, lysine: 45mg/g). When adjusted to individual body weight, average IAA intakes were above daily requirements, but lysine just met requirements at 31.0 mg/kg of body weight/day (reference: 30 mg/kg/day). Upon TID adjustment, the percentage of vegans meeting adequacy for protein and IAA decreased and only approximately 50% of the cohort could meet lysine and leucine requirements. Hence, lysine and leucine were the most limiting IAAs in the vegan cohort's diet. Legumes and pulses contributed most to overall protein and lysine intake. An increased proportion of legumes and pulses can potentially increase these intakes but must be considered in the context of the whole diet. AA composition and digestibility are important aspects of protein quality when assessing protein adequacy and is of particular importance in restrictive diets.

Analyzing dietary exposure to critical nutrients on a plant-based diet using the food- and total nutrient index

BACKGROUND

Unfortified plant-based diets are devoid of vitamin B12, and supply low intakes of iodine, zinc, selenium, and calcium. To disentangle the complex interplay between nutritional adequacy and nutrient intakes from supplements and foods in plant-based diets, data from a Germany-based cross-sectional study examining the nutritional status of omnivores, lacto-ovo-vegetarians and vegans was re-analyzed. Special emphasis was put on potentially under-consumed nutrients in plant-based diets, including vitamin A and choline.

METHODS

A novel tool focusing on under-consumed micronutrients was employed to shed a new light on nutrient supply and dietary exposure to critical nutrients in plant-based diets: The Total Nutrient Index (TNI). The TNI extends existing measures of diet quality by considering nutrient intake data from both foods and supplements. The TNI covers calcium, magnesium, potassium, choline and vitamins A, C, D, and E. The TNI was compared between omnivores, vegetarians and vegans, with a special focus on its micronutrient component scores and with regard to dietary supplement contributions.

RESULTS

Data from 108 participants was analyzed. The vegan and the omnivorous diet resulted in similar TNI scores (73.70 ± 19.68 and 72.77 ± 17.88), whereas lacto-ovo-vegetarians scored lower (68.50 ± 17.10). The contribution of supplements to the TNI was higher in vegans and omnivores (median contribution: 12.50 (16.80) and 10.81 (18.23) score points, respectively) as compared to lacto-ovo-vegetarians (3.42 (12.50) score points). High micronutrient component score contributions to the TNI were found for vitamin D supplements (all dietary groups), vitamin C supplements (omnivores and vegans) and magnesium supplements (all groups).

CONCLUSIONS

Supplementation has a profound impact on nutrient supplies in individuals on a plant-based diet. This study reiterates the need to quantitatively assess nutrient intakes from supplements to assess diet quality of plant-based dietary patterns. We posit that defining diet-specific TNI scores is important for a precise evaluation of diet quality, whether in omnivore or in the spectrum of plant-based diets.

A Plant-Dominant Low-Protein Diet in Chronic Kidney Disease Management: A Narrative Review with Considerations for Cyprus

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is a major global health challenge, significantly contributing to morbidity and mortality due to its strong association with cardiovascular complications, metabolic imbalances, and reduced quality of life. Among the various interventions for CKD management, nutrition therapy plays a critical role in slowing disease progression and improving patient outcomes. The Plant-Dominant Low-Protein Diet (PLADO) has emerged as a promising dietary strategy that prioritizes plant-based protein sources while restricting overall protein intake, offering potential renal, cardiovascular, and metabolic benefits. This review evaluates current evidence on the efficacy of PLADO in CKD management, analyzing its impact on renal function, cardiovascular health, and systemic inflammation. Key findings suggest that PLADO can delay CKD progression, reduce dialysis dependence, and mitigate cardiovascular risks through lower dietary acid load, increased fiber intake, and anti-inflammatory properties. Additionally, PLADO has been shown to support gut microbiota diversity and reduce uremic toxin production, offering metabolic advantages beyond kidney health. While PLADO appears nutritionally adequate, concerns remain regarding protein sufficiency, potassium management, and long-term adherence. Its successful implementation requires tailored meal planning, patient education, and regular clinical monitoring to optimize outcomes and mitigate potential risks. This review highlights the importance of integrating PLADO into CKD management as a holistic, patient-centered dietary approach, particularly in regions like Cyprus, where no studies have evaluated its applicability. By synthesizing existing research, this review provides insights for clinicians, dietitians, and researchers to further explore long-term outcomes, adherence strategies, and feasibility across diverse healthcare settings. Future studies should focus on large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to establish PLADO's role in CKD dietary guidelines and clinical practice.

Achieving High Protein Quality Is a Challenge in Vegan Diets: A Narrative Review

The transition toward plant-based (PB) diets has gained attention as a plausible step toward achieving sustainable and healthy dietary goals. However, the complete elimination of all animal-sourced foods from the diet (ie, a vegan diet) may have nutritional ramifications that warrant close examination. Two such concerns are the adequacy and bioavailability of amino acids (AAs) from plant-sourced foods and the consequences for older vegan populations who have elevated AA requirements. This narrative review describes the challenges of achieving high protein quality from vegan diets. Data were synthesized from peer-reviewed research articles and reviews. Plant-sourced proteins provide poorer distribution of indispensable AAs (IAAs) and have poorer digestibility, partly due to their inherent structural components within the food matrix. The review addresses complexities of combinations of varied plant protein sources and why the inclusion of novel PB alternatives adds uncertainty to the achievement of adequate protein adequacy. Meal distribution patterns of protein and the ensuing physiological impacts deserve further research and are outlined in this review. Particular attention is given to describing the challenges of achieving sufficient protein and IAA intakes by aging populations who choose to follow a vegan diet. This review contributes to the emerging discussions of nutritional risks associated with vegan diets and adds perspective to the current dietary shifts toward PB diets.

Protein Intake and Mortality in Older Adults With Chronic Kidney Disease

Importance

Avoiding high protein intake in older adults with chronic kidney disease (CKD) may reduce the risk of kidney function decline, but whether it can be suboptimal for survival is not well known.

Objective

To estimate the associations of total, animal, and plant protein intake with all-cause mortality in older adults with mild or moderate CKD and compare the results to those of older persons without CKD.

Design, Setting, and Participants

Data from 3 cohorts (Study on Cardiovascular Health, Nutrition and Frailty in Older Adults in Spain 1 and 2 and the Swedish National Study on Aging and Care in Kungsholmen [in Sweden]) composed of community-dwelling adults 60 years or older were used. Participants were recruited between March 2001 and June 2017 and followed up for mortality from December 2021 to January 2024. Those with no information on diet or mortality, with CKD stages 4 or 5, or undergoing kidney replacement therapy and kidney transplant recipients were excluded. Data were originally analyzed from June 2023 to February 2024 and reanalyzed in May 2024.

Exposures

Cumulative protein intake, estimated via validated dietary histories and food frequency questionnaires.

Main Outcomes and Measures

The study outcome was 10-year all-cause mortality, ascertained with national death registers. Chronic kidney disease was ascertained according to estimated glomerular filtration rates, urine albumin excretion, and diagnoses from medical records.

Results

The study sample consisted of 8543 participants and 14 399 observations. Of the 4789 observations with CKD stages 1 to 3, 2726 (56.9%) corresponded to female sex, and mean (SD) age was 78.0 (7.2) years. During the follow-up period, 1468 deaths were recorded. Higher total protein intake was associated with lower mortality among participants with CKD; adjusted hazard ratio (HR) for 1.00 vs 0.80 g/kg/d was 0.88 (95% CI, 0.79-0.98); for 1.20 vs 0.80 g/kg/d, 0.79 (95% CI, 0.66-0.95); and for 1.40 vs 0.80 g/kg/d, 0.73 (95% CI, 0.57-0.92). Associations with mortality were comparable for plant and animal protein (HRs, 0.80 [95% CI, 0.65-0.98] and 0.88 [95% CI, 0.81-0.95] per 0.20-g/kg/d increment, respectively) and for total protein intake in participants younger than 75 years vs 75 years or older (HRs, 0.94 [95% CI, 0.85-1.04] and 0.91 [95% CI, 0.85-0.98] per 0.20-g/kg/d increment in total protein intake, respectively). However, the hazards were lower among participants without CKD than in those with CKD (HRs, 0.85 [95% CI, 0.79-0.92] and 0.92 [95% CI, 0.86-0.98] per 0.20-g/kg/d increment, respectively; P = .02 for interaction).

Conclusions and Relevance

In this multicohort study of older adults, higher intake of total, animal, and plant protein was associated with lower mortality in participants with CKD. Associations were stronger in those without CKD, suggesting that the benefits of proteins may outweigh the downsides in older adults with mild or moderate CKD.

A Therapeutic Approach in the Management of Chronic Kidney Disease: Plant-Based Dietary Models and Associated Parameters

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Chronic kidney disease is one of the leading causes of death worldwide today. Nutrition and nutrition-related factors have a very important role in both the prevention and management of the disease. Plant-based dietary practices are one of the promising approaches to chronic kidney disease. This review aims to examine the potential benefits and risks of plant-based diet models on symptoms and indices used in diet quality in chronic kidney disease.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recently, a growing body of evidence has shown that, unlike animal-based diets, diets rich in plant-based nutrients may play an active role in the incidence of chronic kidney disease in many ways and the management of common symptoms, such as metabolic acidosis, uremic toxicity, and hyperphosphatemia. Implementation of existing plant-based dietary patterns in patients with chronic kidney disease may increase the efficacy of the diet and improve patients' quality of life by expanding their food choices. While there are concerns about creatine deficiency, dietary adequacy, and accessibility regarding plant-based diets, available information is limited.

Dieta de la Milpa: A Culturally-Concordant Plant-Based Dietary Pattern for Hispanic/Latine People with Chronic Kidney Disease

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) disproportionately affects minorities in the United States, including the Hispanic/Latine population, and is a public health concern in Latin American countries. An emphasis on healthy dietary patterns, including the Mediterranean and the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) diets, has been suggested as they are associated with a lower incidence of CKD, slower CKD progression, and lower mortality in kidney failure. However, their applicability may be limited in people from Latin America. The Dieta de la Milpa (Diet of the Cornfield) was recently described as the dietary pattern of choice for people from Mesoamerica (Central Mexico and Central America). This dietary pattern highlights the intake of four plant-based staple foods from this geographical region, corn/maize, common beans, pumpkins/squashes, and chilies, complemented with seasonal and local intake of plant-based foods and a lower intake of animal-based foods, collectively classified into ten food groups. Limited preclinical and clinical studies suggest several health benefits, including cardiometabolic health, but there is currently no data concerning CKD. In this narrative review, we describe and highlight the potential benefits of the Dieta de la Milpa in CKD, including acid-base balance, protein source, potassium and phosphorus management, impact on the gut microbiota, inflammation, and cultural appropriateness. Despite these potential benefits, this dietary pattern has not been tested in people with CKD. Therefore, we suggest key research questions targeting measurement of adherence, feasibility, and effectiveness of the Dieta de la Milpa in people with CKD.