Platelet-Rich Plasma in Sports Medicine: New Treatment for Tendon and Cartilage Lesions

Platelet-rich plasma in orthopedic therapy: a comparative systematic review of clinical and experimental data in equine and human musculoskeletal lesions

BACKGROUND

This systematic review aimed to present and critically appraise the available information on the efficacy of platelet rich plasma (PRP) in equine and human orthopedic therapeutics and to verify the influence of study design and methodology on the assumption of PRP's efficacy. We searched Medline, PubMed, Embase, Bireme and Google Scholar without restrictions until July 2013. Randomized trials, human cohort clinical studies or case series with a control group on the use of PRP in tendons, ligaments or articular lesions were included. Equine clinical studies on the same topics were included independently of their design. Experimental studies relevant to the clarification of PRP's effects and mechanisms of action in tissues of interest, conducted in any animal species, were selected.

RESULTS

This review included 123 studies. PRP's beneficial effects were observed in 46.7% of the clinical studies, while the absence of positive effects was observed in 43.3%. Among experimental studies, 73% yielded positive results, and 7.9% yielded negative results. The most frequent flaws in the clinical trials' designs were the lack of a true placebo group, poor product characterization, insufficient blinding, small sampling, short follow-up periods, and adoption of poor outcome measures. The methods employed for PRP preparation and administration and the selected outcome measures varied greatly. Poor study design was a common feature of equine clinical trials. From studies in which PRP had beneficial effects, 67.8% had an overall high risk of bias. From the studies in which PRP failed to exhibit beneficial effects, 67.8% had an overall low risk of bias.

CONCLUSIONS

Most experimental studies revealed positive effects of PRP. Although the majority of equine clinical studies yielded positive results, the human clinical trials' results failed to corroborate these findings. In both species, beneficial results were more frequently observed in studies with a high risk of bias. The use of PRP in musculoskeletal lesions, although safe and promising, has still not shown strong evidence in clinical scenarios.

Influence of cryopreservation and mechanical stimulation on equine Autologous Conditioned Plasma (ACP®)

OBJECTIVE

To determine the influence of cryopreservation at two different temperatures on platelet concentration, growth factor (GF) levels and platelet activation parameters in equine ACP®; moreover, to determine if adding mechanical ACP® stimulation to freeze-thaw activation amplifies GF release from platelets.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Firstly, blood from five horses was used to prepare ACP®. Platelet, platelet derived growth factor BB (PDGF-BB) and transforming growth factor β1 (TGF-β1) concentrations as well as mean platelet volume (MPV) and mean platelet component (MPC) were determined in fresh and corresponding ACP® samples after 2 months cryopreservation at -20 °C and -80 °C, respectively. Secondly, ACP® was prepared from blood of nine horses. Half of ACP® was activated using one freeze-thaw-cycle at -20 °C, whereas the rest was first vortexed. Their PDGF-BB and TGF-β1 concentrations were subsequently determined.

RESULTS

Platelet concentration significantly decreased after -80 °C cryopreservation. PDGF-BB level augmented significantly after both storage methods, whereas TGF-β1 concentration was not significantly altered. MPV significantly increased after -20 °C cryopreservation. Both storage regimens induced a significant MPC decrease. No significant differences in GF concentrations between the vortexed and non-vortexed samples were detected.

DISCUSSION

Both cryopreservation methods induced platelet activation, but storage at -80 °C apparently harmed the platelets without generating higher GF release than -20 °C. The mechanical stimulation process could not enhance GF release in subsequently frozen-thawed ACP®.

CONCLUSION AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Storage of ACP® at -20 °C could be useful in equine practice, but, before this procedure can be recommended, further qualitative tests are needed. The mechanical stimulation technique should be adjusted in order to increase platelet activation.

Platelet-rich plasma for foot and ankle pathologies: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

The aim of this article is to review systematically all the literature available on the clinical application of PRP for the treatment of foot and ankle pathologies, to understand its potential and best indications for clinical use.

METHODS

A systematic search of the PubMed database was performed. Research criteria were the following: (1) papers in the English language, (2) dealing with the clinical application of PRP for the treatment of orthopedic-related conditions affecting the foot and ankle district, (3) with I to IV level of evidence, and (4) reporting clinical results.

RESULTS

A total of 17 studies fulfilled the inclusion criteria. Nine papers dealt with Achilles tendon management, 2 articles with plantar fasciitis, 3 papers with talar osteochondral lesions, 2 with PRP application in total ankle replacement, and 1 article with PRP in foot and ankle fusions. The overall evaluation of the results reported does not clearly demonstrate the potential of PRP treatment in any of the specific fields of application.

CONCLUSIONS

Considering the literature currently available, no clear indications for using PRP in the foot and ankle district emerged.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, systematic review of Level I, II, III and IV studies.