V/Q SPECT and Computed Tomographic Pulmonary Angiography

Head-to-head comparison of ventilation/perfusion single photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography and multidetector computed tomography angiography for the detection of acute pulmonary embolism in clinical practice

INTRODUCTION

Computed tomography angiography (CTA) and ventilation/perfusion (V/Q) single photon emission computed tomography/CT (SPECT/CT) images have been widely used to detect PE, but few studies have performed a direct comparison between them. We aimed to evaluate the performance of these tests in the same group of patients, selected from the routine practice of a general hospital.

METHODS

Patients with suspected acute PE were prospectively submitted to CTA and V/Q SPECT/CT. General radiologists and nuclear physicians, respectively, interpreted the images. Data regarding age, sex, time between examinations, symptoms, and Wells score were also recorded. The final diagnosis was decided through a consensus among the clinicians, taking into account clinical, laboratory, follow-up, and all imaging procedures data.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight patients (15 male, 13 female, and median age of 51.5 years) were studied. Median duration of the onset of symptoms was 4 (1-14) days, and the median Wells score was 3.5 (1.5-6). Sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, and accuracy were 84.6%, 80.0%, 78.6%, 85.7%, and 82.1% for V/Q SPECT/CT, and 46.1%, 100%, 100%, 68.2%, and 75.0% for CTA. The overall agreement between the methods was 57.1%. Of the 22 patients with negative CTA, 10 (45.4%) had positives V/Q SPECT/CT and seven of them classified as true positives.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that V/Q SPECT/CT is more sensitive and accurate than CTA when interpreted by general radiologists and nuclear medicine physicians.

V/Q SPECT and SPECT/CT in Pulmonary Embolism

Ventilation and perfusion (V/Q) lung scintigraphy has been used in the assessment of patients with suspected pulmonary embolism for more than 50 y. Advances in imaging technology make SPECT and SPECT/CT feasible. This article will examine the application and technical considerations associated with performing 3-dimensional V/Q SPECT and the contribution of a coacquired CT scan. The literature tends to be mixed and contradictory in terms of appropriate investigation algorithms for pulmonary embolism. V/Q SPECT and SPECT/CT offer significant advantages over planar V/Q, with or without the advantages of Technegas ventilation, and if available should be the preferred option in the evaluation of patients with suspected pulmonary embolism.

Mismatched Perfusion Defects on Routine Ventilation-Perfusion Scans after Lung Transplantation

BACKGROUND

Incidental pulmonary embolism (PE) is a challenging entity with unclear treatment implications. Our program performs routine ventilation-perfusion (VQ) scans at 3-months post-transplant to establish airway and vascular function. We sought to determine the prevalence and prognostic implications of mismatched perfusion defects (MMPD) found on these studies, hypothesizing they would be associated with a benign prognosis.

METHODS

We studied VQ scans obtained routinely at 3-months post-transplant from double lung transplant recipients 2005-2016 for studies with MMPD interpreted as high or intermediate probability for PE. We tested the relationship between MMPD and 1-year survival via chi square testing, overall survival via Kaplan Meier analysis with log rank testing and peak forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV1) percent predicted via t-testing.

RESULTS

373 patients met inclusion criteria, of whom 35 (9%) had VQ scans with MMPDs interpreted by radiologists as high or intermediate probability for PE. Baseline recipient and donor characteristics were similar between groups. 7 patients (20%) in the MMPD group were treated with therapeutic anticoagulation. Patients with MMPD had similar 1-year survival (100% vs. 98%, p = 1.00), overall survival (log rank p = 0.90) and peak FEV1% predicted (94% [SD 20%] vs. 92% [SD 21%]; p = 0.58). Anticoagulation did not affect these relationships.

CONCLUSION

Mismatched perfusion defects on routine post-transplant VQ scan were not associated with a difference in survival or lung function. A conservative approach to these changes may be a viable option in the absence of other anticoagulation indications. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Comparison of V/Q SPECT and CT Angiography for the Diagnosis of Chronic Thromboembolic Pulmonary Hypertension

Background Accurate methods for identifying obstructions in both large and small vessels are crucial for diagnosis and treatment of chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension (CTEPH). Purpose To compare the performance of ventilation-perfusion (V/Q) scanning, V/Q SPECT, and CT pulmonary angiography (PA) in CTEPH by using digital subtraction PA as the reference standard. Materials and Methods This prospective study was conducted from January 2016 to January 2018. A total of 229 participants suspected of having CTEPH were evaluated with V/Q SPECT, V/Q planar scintigraphy, CT PA, and digital subtraction PA. Participants underwent all four procedures within 1 week. Differences in the diagnostic performance of V/Q SPECT, V/Q planar scintigraphy, and CT PA were evaluated with areas under the curve receiver operator curve, the McNemar test, and generalized estimating equations analysis. Results A total of 150 participants (mean age, 42 years ± 15 [standard deviation]; 99 women) were enrolled. Digital subtraction PA assessments confirmed CTEPH in 51 participants and indicated that 602 of 1020 lung segments (20 segments per participant) were obstructed. The three imaging methods showed high sensitivity (V/Q SPECT, 98%; V/Q planar scintigraphy, 98%; CT PA, 94%) and specificity (V/Q SPECT, 89%; V/Q planar scintigraphy, 91%; CT PA, 96%) (all P > .05). However, both V/Q scanning techniques were more sensitive (V/Q SPECT: 85%, P < .001 vs CT PA: 67%; V/Q planar scintigraphy: 83%, P < .001 vs CT PA: 67%), and less specific (V/Q planar scintigraphy: 51%, P = .03 vs CT PA: 60%; V/Q SPECT: 42%, P < .01 vs CT PA: 60%) than was CT PA for segmental analysis. Areas under the curve for CT PA, V/Q planar scintigraphy, and V/Q SPECT were 0.95, 0.95, and 0.94, respectively (all P > .05), for individual analysis, and 0.64, 0.67, and 0.64, respectively, by segment (V/Q planar scintigraphy vs V/Q SPECT, P = .02; V/Q planar scintigraphy vs CT PA, P = .08; V/Q SPECT vs CT PA, P = .94). Conclusion Ventilation-perfusion scanning was more sensitive and less specific than was CT pulmonary angiography for detecting vascular obstructions at the segmental pulmonary arterial level. © RSNA, 2020 See also the editorial by Swift and Rajaram in this issue.

The Economic Value of Hybrid Single-photon Emission Computed Tomography With Computed Tomography Imaging in Pulmonary Embolism Diagnosis

Objective

The objective was to quantify the potential economic value of single‐photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) with computed tomography (CT; SPECT/CT) versus CT pulmonary angiography (CTPA), ventilation–perfusion (V/Q) planar scintigraphy, and V/Q SPECT imaging modalities for diagnosing suspected pulmonary embolism (PE) patients in an emergency setting.

Methods

An Excel‐based simulation model was developed to compare SPECT/CT versus the alternate scanning technologies from a payer's perspective. Clinical endpoints (diagnosis, treatment, complications, and mortality) and their corresponding cost data (2016 USD) were obtained by performing a best evidence review of the published literature. Studies were pooled and parameters were weighted by sample size. Outcomes measured included differences in 1) excess costs, 2) total costs, and 3) lives lost per annum between SPECT/CT and the other imaging modalities. One‐way (±25%) sensitivity and three scenario analyses were performed to gauge the robustness of the results.

Results

For every 1,000 suspected PE patients undergoing imaging, expected annual economic burden by modality was found to be 3.2 million (SPECT/CT), 3.8 million (CTPA), 5.8 million (planar), and 3.6 million (SPECT) USD, with a switch to SPECT/CT technology yielding per‐patient‐per‐month cost savings of $51.80 (vs. CTPA), $213.80 (vs. planar), and $36.30 (vs. SPECT), respectively. The model calculated that the incremental number of lives saved with SPECT/CT was six (vs. CTPA) and three (vs. planar). Utilizing SPECT/CT as the initial imaging modality for workup of acute PE was also expected to save $994,777 (vs. CTPA), $2,852,014 (vs. planar), and $435,038 (vs. SPECT) in “potentially avoidable”’ excess costs per annum for a payer or health plan.

Conclusion

Compared to the currently available scanning technologies for diagnosing suspected PE, SPECT/CT appears to confer superior economic value, primarily via improved sensitivity and specificity and low nondiagnostic rates. In turn, the improved diagnostic accuracy accords this modality the lowest ratio of expenses attributable to potentially avoidable complications, misdiagnosis, and underdiagnosis.

Texture analysis of pulmonary parenchymateous changes related to pulmonary thromboembolism in dogs - a novel approach using quantitative methods

Background

Diagnosis of pulmonary thromboembolism (PTE) in dogs relies on computed tomography pulmonary angiography (CTPA), but detailed interpretation of CTPA images is demanding for the radiologist and only large vessels may be evaluated. New approaches for better detection of smaller thrombi include dual energy computed tomography (DECT) as well as computer assisted diagnosis (CAD) techniques. The purpose of this study was to investigate the performance of quantitative texture analysis for detecting dogs with PTE using grey-level co-occurrence matrices (GLCM) and multivariate statistical classification analyses.

CT images from healthy (n = 6) and diseased (n = 29) dogs with and without PTE confirmed on CTPA were segmented so that only tissue with CT numbers between −1024 and −250 Houndsfield Units (HU) was preserved. GLCM analysis and subsequent multivariate classification analyses were performed on texture parameters extracted from these images.

Results

Leave-one-dog-out cross validation and receiver operator characteristic (ROC) showed that the models generated from the texture analysis were able to predict healthy dogs with optimal levels of performance. Partial Least Square Discriminant Analysis (PLS-DA) obtained a sensitivity of 94% and a specificity of 96%, while Support Vector Machines (SVM) yielded a sensitivity of 99% and a specificity of 100%. The models, however, performed worse in classifying the type of disease in the diseased dog group: In diseased dogs with PTE sensitivities were 30% (PLS-DA) and 38% (SVM), and specificities were 80% (PLS-DA) and 89% (SVM). In diseased dogs without PTE the sensitivities of the models were 59% (PLS-DA) and 79% (SVM) and specificities were 79% (PLS-DA) and 82% (SVM).

Conclusion

The results indicate that texture analysis of CTPA images using GLCM is an effective tool for distinguishing healthy from abnormal lung. Furthermore the texture of pulmonary parenchyma in dogs with PTE is altered, when compared to the texture of pulmonary parenchyma of healthy dogs. The models’ poorer performance in classifying dogs within the diseased group, may be related to the low number of dogs compared to texture variables, a lack of balanced number of dogs within each group or a real lack of difference in the texture features among the diseased dogs.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12917-017-1117-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

First in vivo magnetic particle imaging of lung perfusion in rats

Pulmonary embolism (PE), along with the closely related condition of deep vein thrombosis, affect an estimated 600 000 patients in the US per year. Untreated, PE carries a mortality rate of 30%. Because many patients experience mild or non-specific symptoms, imaging studies are necessary for definitive diagnosis of PE. Iodinated CT pulmonary angiography is recommended for most patients, while nuclear medicine-based ventilation/perfusion (V/Q) scans are reserved for patients in whom the use of iodine is contraindicated. Magnetic particle imaging (MPI) is an emerging tracer imaging modality with high image contrast (no tissue background signal) and sensitivity to superparamagnetic iron oxide (SPIO) tracer. Importantly, unlike CT or nuclear medicine, MPI uses no ionizing radiation. Further, MPI is not derived from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI); MPI directly images SPIO tracers via their strong electronic magnetization, enabling deep imaging of anatomy including within the lungs, which is very challenging with MRI. Here, the first high-contrast in vivo MPI lung perfusion images of rats are shown using a novel lung perfusion agent, MAA-SPIOs.

Factors determining altered perfusion after acute pulmonary embolism assessed by quantified single-photon emission computed tomography-perfusion scan

AIM OF THE STUDY:

The aim of the study was to analyze the evolution of perfusion (Q)-defects in patients treated for acute pulmonary embolism (PE), correlation with baseline parameters and evaluation of recurrence risk.

METHODS:

This is a single-center prospective observational cohort study in symptomatic normotensive PE. Comparison of the ventilation/perfusion single-photon emission computed tomography (V/Q-SPECT) acquired at baseline with a quantified SPECT (Q-SPECT) repeated at 1 week and 6 months. The Q-defect extent (percentage of total lung volume affected) was measured semiquantitatively. Data collected at baseline were age, gender, body mass index (BMI), history of previous venous thromboembolism (HVTE), Charlson's Comorbidity Score (CcS), plasma troponin-T and D-dimer levels, PE Severity Index, and tricuspid regurgitation jet (TRJ) velocity.

RESULTS:

Forty-six patients (22 men/24 women, mean age 61.7 years (± standard deviation 16.3)) completed the study. At 1 week, 13/46 (28.3 %) and at 6 months 22/46 (47.8%) patients had completely normalized Q-SPECT. Persistence of Q-defects was more frequent in female patients in univariate and multivariate analysis. We found no correlation between the persistence of Q-defects on Q-SPECT and HVTE, BMI, plasma troponin-T, and CcS. However, lower TRJ and younger age were statistically significantly linked to normalization of Q-scans after 6 months of treatment only in univariate analysis. There is no difference in the frequency of recurrent PE in relation to the persistence of Q-defects.

CONCLUSION:

Acute PE patients of female, older age, and higher TRJ in univariate analysis and patients of female in multivariate analysis seem to have a higher risk of persistent Q-defects after 6 months treatment. The presence of residual Q-abnormalities at 6 months was not associated with an increased risk for recurrent PE.

Pulmonary ventilation/perfusion single photon emission tomography--Initial experience of a Nuclear Medicine Department

INTRODUCTION

Lung ventilation/perfusion scintigraphy with planar images (V/QS-planar) is very useful for the diagnosis and follow-up of pulmonary thromboembolism (PTE). Acquiring tomographic images (V/QS-SPECT) is a recent development with potential to increase the technique's accuracy. The purpose of this work is to evaluate the added benefits of V/QS-SPECT studies as opposed to traditional planar imaging.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We prospectively revised 53 V/QS-planar and V/QS-SPECT exams, performed according to the European Association of Nuclear Medicine guidelines. We evaluated the exams independently, by consensus of two Nuclear Medicine physicians. For both methods, we gave each lung a score expressing the dimension and extension of perfusion defects with normal ventilation. For each lung, we compared the scores with the paired Wilcoxon test, estimating the 95% confidence interval (95 CI) for the respective difference.

RESULTS

We performed V/QS-SPECT exams without technical difficulties. The paired Wilcoxon test estimated the score difference to be -0.75 (95 CI of -1.0 to -0.5; p-value=9.6 × 10(-7)), expressing a statistically significant difference of about 1 subsegmental defect between both methods, with V/QS-SPECT detecting more defects.

DISCUSSION

The results demonstrate that V/QS-SPECT identifies a slightly larger number of perfusion defects than V/QS-planar, suggesting a higher sensitivity of this technique. However, more studies are necessary to evaluate the clinical meaning of this fact.

CONCLUSION

V/QS-SPECT demonstrates a higher capability to identify perfusion defects. This method looks promising, allowing for a greater role of this exam in pulmonary thromboembolism diagnosis and follow-up.

Pulmonary Scintigraphy for the Diagnosis of Acute Pulmonary Embolism: A Survey of Current Practices in Australia, Canada, and France

There are currently no data published regarding the proportion of nuclear medicine centers using SPECT or SPECT/CT rather than planar ventilation/perfusion (V/Q) imaging in patients with suspected acute pulmonary embolism (PE). Furthermore, the reporting criteria used for interpretation of both planar and SPECT V/Q scans are variable and data are lacking regarding which criteria are commonly used in various centers. The aim of this study was to assess current practices regarding the performance and interpretation of lung scintigraphy across 3 different countries.

METHODS

A short online survey composed of simple multiple-choice questions was distributed to nuclear medicine departments in Australia, Canada, and France during the period April to December 2014. The survey covered image acquisition, interpretation criteria for SPECT and planar images, and use of pseudoplanar images and radiopharmaceuticals. Information was initially solicited by 2 sets of e-mails, which pointed to the survey internet link. Departments were subsequently contacted by telephone. A single response per department was consolidated.

RESULTS

Three hundred thirty-one responses were collected (Australia, 74; Canada, 48; and France, 209). Twenty-eight percent of centers indicated use of V/Q planar imaging alone whereas 72% of centers included some form of SPECT in their acquisition protocol for evaluation of PE, specifically V/Q SPECT in 36%, V/Q SPECT/CT in 29%, Q SPECT/CT in 2%, and both V/Q planar and SPECT in 5%, with a strong variability among countries. The most commonly used criteria for SPECT interpretation were the those of the European Association of Nuclear Medicine (60%). Criteria used for planar interpretation were heterogeneous (European Association of Nuclear Medicine criteria, 35%; Prospective Investigation of Pulmonary Embolism Diagnosis study, 29%; no standardized criteria, 21%). Sixty-three percent of departments used pseudoplanar images in addition to SPECT images.

CONCLUSION

In the 3 countries surveyed, SPECT has largely replaced planar imaging for evaluation of PE, with almost half of the SPECT studies incorporating a CT acquisition. Criteria used for interpretation are inconsistent, especially for planar imaging.

Multimodality molecular imaging of the lung

Lung diseases cause significant morbidity and mortality and lead to high healthcare utilization. However, few lung disease-specific biomarkers are available to accurately monitor disease activity for the purposes of clinical management or drug development. Advances in cross-modal imaging technologies, such as combined positron emission tomography (PET) and magnetic resonance (MR) imaging scanners and PET or single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) combined with computed tomography (CT), may aid in the development of noninvasive, molecular-based biomarkers for lung disease. However, the lungs pose particular challenges in obtaining accurate quantification of imaging data due to the low density of the organ and breathing motion. This review covers the basic physics underlying PET, SPECT, CT, and MR lung imaging and presents technical considerations for multimodal imaging with regard to PET and SPECT quantification. It also includes a brief review of the current and potential clinical applications for these hybrid imaging technologies.

Improved visualization of perfusion defects by respiratory-gated SPECT: a phantom simulation study

OBJECTIVES

Single-photon emission computed tomography ventilation/perfusion (SPECT V/Q) imaging is recommended both by the Society of Nuclear Medicine and by the European Association of Nuclear Medicine for the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism. However, respiratory motion produces image blurring and degradation of detail in the lungs. We have investigated respiratory gating of SPECT images, correcting for motion to reduce blur and improve image definition.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Wedge-shaped defects of different sizes ranging from 15 to 4 mm were fixed in the lung cavities of an anthropomorphic lung phantom to simulate perfusion defects. Gated and nongated SPECT images were obtained using a double-headed SPECT system. Three-dimensional movement was introduced using a purpose-built moving platform with two motion frequencies of 10 and 20 cycles/min. Motion was tracked with a respiratory-gating system. Gated SPECT data were acquired in 16 discrete data bins in synchronization with the breathing cycle. The images were reconstructed using ordered-subset expectation maximization algorithms and corrected for rigid motion. Contrast and contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRs) were measured to quantify any improvement in the gated motion-corrected images. Visualization of defects in the reconstructed images was performed by seven observers and analyzed using alternative free-response receiver operating characteristic analysis.

RESULTS

Assessment of gated and nongated SPECT phantom images demonstrated that motion adversely affected the detectability of defects. Quantification of data demonstrated that, in the controlled simulation, image quality, defect definition, observer confidence, contrast, and CNR were increased after applying motion correction. Improvement in CNRs was found to be significant using alternative free-response receiver operating characteristic analysis (P=0.0002).

CONCLUSION

Respiratory-gated motion-corrected SPECT images enhanced the visualization of defects compared with matched moving/nongated images in a realistic moving phantom. This approach may be particularly valuable for SPECT V/Q imaging and may improve the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism.

V/Q scanning using SPECT and SPECT/CT

Planar ventilation-perfusion (V/Q) scanning is often used to investigate pulmonary embolism; however, it has well-recognized limitations. SPECT overcomes many of these through its ability to generate 3-dimensional imaging data. V/Q SPECT has higher sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy than planar imaging and a lower indeterminate rate. SPECT allows for new ways to display and analyze data, such as parametric V/Q ratio images. Compared with CT pulmonary angiography, SPECT has higher sensitivity, a lower radiation dose, fewer technically suboptimal studies, and no contrast-related complications. Any nuclear medicine department equipped with a modern hybrid scanner can now perform combined V/Q SPECT with CT (using low-dose protocols) to further enhance diagnostic accuracy. V/Q SPECT (with or without CT) has application in other pulmonary conditions and in research.

Risk-benefit analysis of pulmonary CT angiography in patients with suspected pulmonary embolus

OBJECTIVE

The objective of our study was to estimate the mortality benefit-to-risk ratio of pulmonary CT angiography (CTA) by setting (ambulatory [emergency department or outpatient] or inpatient), age, and sex.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective evaluation of 1424 consecutive pulmonary CTA examinations was performed and the following information was recorded: examination setting, patient age, patient sex, pulmonary CTA interpretation for pulmonary embolus (PE), and CT radiation exposure (dose-length product). We estimated mortality benefit of pulmonary CTA by multiplying the rate of positive pulmonary CTA examinations by published estimates of mortality of untreated PE in ambulatory and inpatient settings. We estimated the lifetime attributable risk of cancer mortality due to radiation from pulmonary CTA by calculating the estimated effective dose and using sex-specific polynomial equations derived from the Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation VII report. We calculated benefit-to-risk ratios by dividing the mortality benefit of preventing a fatal PE by the mortality risk of a radiation-induced cancer.

RESULTS

Pulmonary CTA diagnosed PE in 188 of 1424 patients (13.2%). Both inpatients (101/723, 14.0%) and emergency department patients (74/509, 14.5%) had significantly higher rates of PE than outpatients (13/192 [6.8%]). Males received significantly (p = 0.02451) higher radiation dose (9.7 mSv) than females (8.4 mSv), but males had a significantly (p < 0.0001) lower lifetime attributable risk of cancer mortality than females. Assuming an untreated PE mortality rate of 5% for ambulatory patients and 30% for inpatients, the benefit-to-risk ratio ranged from 25 for ambulatory patients to 187 for inpatients. Ambulatory women had the lowest benefit-to-risk ratio.

CONCLUSION

The benefit-to-risk ratio of pulmonary CTA in patients with suspected PE ranges from 25 to 187 and can be increased by optimizing the radiation dose.