Dorsolateral biplane closing radial osteotomy in zero variant cases of Kienböck's disease

The Effect of Radial Inclination on the Stage of Kienbock Disease at the Time of Initial Diagnosis

BACKGROUND

Negative ulnar variance is a widely accepted risk factor for the development of Kienbock disease (KD). Variation in radial inclination has been proposed as a risk factor, but evidence thus far has been inconclusive. We aim to clarify the relationship between radial inclination and KD.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of all KD patients from a single institution from 2007 to 2021 was conducted. Radiographs were reviewed to measure anatomic parameters and stage of disease. An exploratory multinomial regression model was created to examine the association of patient age, radial height, ulnar variance, radial inclination, volar tilt, scapholunate angle, duration of symptoms prior to evaluation, history of wrist trauma, and diagnosis of diabetes with stage of disease.

RESULTS

Fifty-seven cases of KD were identified, with a mean duration of disease of 33.3 months. A history of trauma to the wrist was common (53%) and significantly associated with stage of disease at initial presentation. Twenty-seven cases (47%) were stage IIIB or greater. The average initial radial inclination, radial height, and ulnar variance was 21.9°, 10.7 mm, and -1.23 mm, respectively. A multinominal logistic regression model revealed decreased initial radial inclination is associated with Lichtman stage IIIB or greater at the time of initial patient presentation.

CONCLUSIONS

A correlation exists between decreased radial inclination and more advanced KD at presentation, suggesting this may be a risk factor for disease progression. This correlation is strengthened by our finding of decreased ulnar variance being associated with later stage at presentation, which is one of the most widely accepted proposed risk factors for development and progression of disease.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Novel Descriptions of the Radial Osteotomy in Kienböck's Disease: A Systematic Review

Purpose

Kienböck's disease consists of intrinsic and extrinsic characteristics that coalesce into a pathology with multifactorial etiology. Mechanical, morphological, and vascular factors have been identified as contributory. Radial osteotomy is one of the most commonly used surgical treatment for late-stage Kienböck's disease. Despite its frequent use and reported value, the specifics of radial osteotomy have not been described in aggregate. Our objective was to review the recent literature for descriptions of the radial osteotomy techniques used for treatment of Kienböck's disease.

Methods

The inclusion criteria for the systematic review were as follows: (1) patients aged >18 years, (2) a publication date no older than 2012, and (3) a complete description of the distal radius osteotomy technique, including verbiage that specified numeric dimensions of bony resection or verbiage that detailed a goal in terms of a radiographic parameter that would guide the bony resection.

Results

The studies were grouped according to the stated description of radial osteotomy. This process yielded the following three main groups: (1) studies that used radial shortening, (2) studies that used lateral closing wedge osteotomy or combined lateral closing wedge with radial shortening, and (3) novel osteotomy descriptions.

Conclusions

The Kienböck's disease literature predominantly describes an osteotomy to shorten the radius by 2-3 mm. In some studies, the degree of radial shortening corresponded to the value necessary to achieve near-neutral ulnar variance. The common goal in using lateral closing wedge osteotomy was to achieve a radial inclination of 5° to 15°. Unique wedge resections, some with multiplanar corrections, have been recently described with each purporting specific advantages.

Clinical relevance

Our findings support the premise of mechanical and biologic efficacy for radial osteotomy, with satisfactory results being reported across a wide spectrum of osteotomy techniques.

Dorsolateral Biplane Closing Radial Osteotomy and Lunate Fixation for Stage IIIC Kienböck Disease: A New Surgical Approach

The treatment of advanced-stage Kienböck disease (KD) remains highly controversial. Particularly important is stage IIIC KD, which includes patients with a lunate coronal fracture. The purpose of this paper was to describe a new approach to KD in patients with Lichtman stage IIIC KD, and our results using it. The procedure combines a dorsolateral biplane closing radial osteotomy and lunate fixation. A total of 11 patients from January 2002 through December 2016 with documented KD who underwent this technique were included. The patients were assessed before surgery, then postoperatively at 1 and 10 days, 3 and 6 weeks, 3 and 6 months, and annually. Wrist range of motion, grip and pinch strength, the Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (QuickDASH) score, a Modified Mayo Wrist Score (MMWS), 10-point visual analog scale, radiologic measurements, and data related to consolidation were collected. All statistical analyses were performed using the statistical software package SPSS. Some degree of pain relief, improvements in the QuickDASH score, MMWS score, grip strength, and the degrees of flexion and extension were observed, the results being statistically significant (P<0.05). After surgery, the values for radial and sagittal tilt were statistically different than those measured before surgery. Carpal collapse was not evident either before or after surgery. In conclusion, combining a dorsolateral radial osteotomy and a lunate compression screw may expand the options for patients with Lichtman stage IIIC KD. Our experience indicates that it is a viable option in challenging clinical scenarios.

New surgical approach to advanced Kienböck disease: lunate replacement with pedicled vascularized scaphoid graft and radioscaphoidal partial arthrodesis

Reconstructive procedures such as proximal row carpectomy or partial arthrodesis have been commonly proposed for advanced Kienböck disease (Lichtmann IIIB to IV). The purpose of this study is to evaluate an alternative surgical technique to advanced Kienböck disease: lunate excision and replacement with pedicled vascularized scaphoid graft and partial radioscaphoidal arthrodesis. The main advantage of the proposed intervention is to preserve mobility while not jeopardizing prime clinical outcomes such as pain. By replacing the devitalized lunate we aim at maintaining midcarpal range of motion, and preventing disease progression with carpal collapse and osteoarthritis of the wrist. Between 2002 and 2008, 13 patients of mean age 41 years (range, 25 to 57 y) were operated using this technique. The surgical act included 3 key steps. First, we excised the lunate, then, filled the generated gap with the rotated scaphoid, using it as a pedicled vascularized autograft. Finally, we performed a partial radioscaphoid arthrodesis. At the final follow-up, none of the intervened patients had pain at rest, and 6 patients could perform nonrestricted daily activities. The average postoperative range of motion in flexion/extension was 70 degrees (range, 55 to 90 degrees), 44% (range, 38% to 54%) of what could be achieved by the contralateral arm, and only 16% (range, 14% to 19%) or 25 degrees (range, 18 to 30 degrees) less than the preoperative range of motion of the same wrist. Grip strength improved by more than 30% (range, 24% to 36%). At an average follow-up of 4 years after surgery, 12 of 13 patients had no radiographic evidence of osteoarthritis or collapse of subchondral bone at the level of the new scaphocapitate joint. At follow-up evaluation, the average DASH score was 14 points (range, 6 to 20). The patients experienced a significant improvement in their functional abilities, achieving good results compared with the conventional techniques. The absence of carpal collapse and good functional results are encouraging.

Osteotomy of the radius without shortening for Kienböck disease: a 10-year follow-up

PURPOSE

To determine the long-term effect of distal radius osteotomy without modifying the radial length or inclination for Kienböck disease.

METHODS

Over 9 years, 14 patients underwent osteotomy of the distal radius without altering radial length or inclination. A total of 11 of these patients were available for follow-up after 10 or more years. We assessed pain, range of wrist motion, and grip strength preoperatively and postoperatively in all cases, as well as preoperative and postoperative posteroanterior and lateral x-rays.

RESULTS

The osteotomy healed in all cases. All 11 patients had decreased pain and showed improvement in wrist motion and grip strength. Radiographically, there were no measurable changes in ulnar variance and there was minimal loss of carpal height. In some patients, the lunate showed increased sclerosis or fragmentation.

CONCLUSIONS

An osteotomy of the distal radius without altering radial length or inclination was effective in decreasing pain and improving grip strength and wrist motion regardless of ulnar variance.

Systematic review of the treatment of Kienböck's disease in its early and late stages

PURPOSE

To perform a systematic review of the treatment of Kienböck's disease to test the hypothesis that none of the reported treatments for Kienböck's disease is superior with respect to outcomes of pain, motion, grip strength, and radiographic measures.

METHODS

We searched PubMed, Medline, and the Cochrane Review for articles published between 1998 and 2008 reporting outcomes of treatment for Kienböck's disease. Patients were grouped by stage of disease. Early stages were defined as Lichtman stage I, II, and IIIa, and 'late' stages as IIIb and IV. The groups were then analyzed on the basis of treatment; procedures performed on subjects in the early group included vascularized bone grafting (VBG), metaphyseal core decompression, and radial osteotomy, whereas the procedures performed on subjects in the late group included VBG, radial osteotomy, partial arthrodesis, proximal row carpectomy, tendon ball arthroplasty, and nonsurgical treatment.

RESULTS

We found no statistically significant difference between any of the treatment groups for subjective pain outcomes. In terms of objective measures, statistically significant improvement (p<.05) was seen in range of motion after radial osteotomy and VBG in early-stage patients and after all interventions, except partial arthrodesis and nonsurgical treatment, for late-stage patients. Grip strength was significantly improved in early-stage patients after radial osteotomy and VBG and for all late-stage patients, except among those managed nonsurgically. Changes in Stahl and carpal height index scores were not statistically significant regardless of intervention, except after radial osteotomy in the early group, where they statistically worsened.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on retrospective data from uncontrolled studies, no active treatment is superior in the treatment of Kienböck's disease and there are insufficient data to determine whether the outcomes of any intervention are superior to placebo or the natural history of the disease.

Kienböck’s disease

Kienböck’s disease is a form of osteonecrosis affecting the lunate. Its aetiology remains unknown. Morphological variations, such as negative ulnar variance, high uncovering of the lunate, abnormal radial inclination and/or a trapezoidal shape of the lunate and the particular pattern of its vascularity may be predisposing factors. A history of trauma is common. The diagnosis is made on plain radiographs, but MRI can be helpful early in the disease. A CT scan is useful to demonstrate fracture or fragmentation of the lunate. Lichtman classified Kienböck disease into five stages. The natural history of the condition is not well known, and the symptoms do not correlate well with the changes in shape of the lunate and the degree of carpal collapse. There is no strong evidence to support any particular form of treatment. Many patients are improved by temporary immobilisation of the wrist, which does not stop the progression of carpal collapse. Radial shortening may be the treatment of choice in young symptomatic patients presenting with stages I to III-A of Kienböck’s disease and negative ulnar variance. Many other forms of surgical treatment have been described.

The anatomy and vascularity of the lunate: considerations applied to Kienböck’s disease

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to assess the anatomy and vascularity of the lunate. The genesis of lunatomalacia requires some combination of vascular risk and mechanical predisposition. The findings will be correlated with the major existing theories of the cause of Kienböck's disease.

METHODS

We studied 27 cadaver upper limbs using latex injection and the Spalteholz technique. We investigated the blood supply to the lunate. In 24 wrists we evaluated the incidence and distribution of anatomic features, arthrosis, and soft tissue lesions. We correlated the lunate morphology and ligaments disruptions with the arthritic changes.

RESULTS

The lunate morphology results as classified by Antuña-Zapico were five type I (20.8%), 18 type II (75%) and one type III (4.2%). The lunate was found to have a separate facet for the hamate in 11 cases (45.8%). The most common size of the facet was found to be 3 mm (range, 3-6 mm). Arthrosis was identified with most frequency in the radius (88.2%) and lunate (94.1%). The triangular fibrocartilage complex was found torn in 58.3%, the lunotriquetral interosseous ligament was torn in 20.8% and the scapholunate interosseous ligament (SLIL) was torn in 54.2% of the wrists. There was a correlation between the presence of arthrosis at the hamate and the presence of a lunate facet (P=0.027) and a correlation between the presence of a tear in the SLIL and arthrosis in the scaphoid (P=0.002). The nutrient vessels entered the lunate through the dorsal and volar poles in all the specimens. The dorsal intercarpal and radiocarpal arches supply blood to the lunate from a plexus of vessels located directly over the lunate's dorsal pole. Vessels entered the dorsal aspect of the lunate through one to three foramina. One to five nutrient vessels were observed entering the volar pole through various ligament insertions, including the ligament of Testut-Kuentz (radio-scapho-lunate (RSL) ligament) and the radiolunate triquetrum ligament (or dorsoradial carpal ligament) and ulnar lunate triquetral ligament.

CONCLUSIONS

The lunate had consistent dorsal and palmar arteries entering the bone in all the specimens. The blood supply and foramina number is greater in the volar pole of the lunate than the dorsal pole. The lunate blood supply comes from different ligaments. In the etiopathogeny of Kienböck's disease it is possible that an acute or chronic, traumatic or non-traumatic injury of the vessel bearing ligaments, particularly because of their structure and the location of the RSL ligament, may have an important role in the appearance of lunate necrosis.

Stage 3 Kienböck's disease: reconstruction of the fractured lunate using a free vascularized iliac bone graft and external fixation

Eighteen patients with stage 3 Kienböck's disease were treated by débridement of the necrotic core of the lunate and implantation of a free vascularized corticocancellous iliac bone. The wrist was stabilized with an external fixator during healing. The efficiency of the procedure for restoring the structure of the fractured lunate, preventing carpal collapse and improving the clinical outcome was assessed at a mean follow-up of 5 years. The graft became incorporated in the lunate in 16 of the 18 patients and no fracture of the reconstructed lunate or carpal collapse occurred in these cases. The graft did not integrate and was resorbed in the other two patients.

Radial closing wedge osteotomy for Kienböck's disease: an over 10 year clinical and radiographic follow-up

Thirteen patients with Kienböck's disease who had undergone a radial closing wedge osteotomy were reviewed clinically and radiologically at a follow-up mean of 14 years. Good long-term results were obtained in all patients. Their levels of pain were improved, and significant increases were seen in the range of motion and grip strength. Radiographic stage, as assessed by Lichtman's classification, improved in one, did not change in four, and advanced in eight patients. The radial inclination angle significantly decreased and the carpal-ulnar distance and lunate covering ratios both increased, demonstrating that radial shift in the alignment of the carpal bones occurs and that the joint contact area of the lunate increases in proportion to the decrease in radial inclination. The preoperative radiolunate and radioscaphoid angles, which were significantly larger than those of the unaffected wrist, did not change postoperatively which shows that this technique was not able to correct the flexion deformity of the lunate and the scaphoid.

Lunatomalacia in association with congenital synostosis between the capitate and the hamate

This report describes a case of lunatomalacia associated with congenital synostosis between the capitate and the hamate, an association not previously reported. The case was examined in detail, and compared to the findings in the literature including observation regarding prognosis of lunatomalacia.