Results of artificial inflammation in scarless foetal wound healing: an experimental study in foetal lambs

Molecular Diagnostics and In Utero Therapeutics for Orofacial Clefts

Orofacial clefts and their management impose a substantial burden on patients, on their families, and on the health system. Under the current standard of care, affected patients are subjected to a lifelong journey of corrective surgeries and multidisciplinary management to replace bone and soft tissues, as well as restore esthetics and physiologic functions while restoring self-esteem and psychological health. Hence, a better understanding of the dynamic interplay of molecular signaling pathways at critical phases of palate development is necessary to pioneer novel prenatal interventions. Such pathways include transforming growth factor-β (Tgfβ), sonic hedgehog (Shh), wingless-integrated site (Wnt)/β-catenin, bone morphogenetic protein (Bmp), and fibroblast growth factor (Fgf) and its associated receptors, among others. Here, we summarize commonly used surgical methods used to correct cleft defects postnatally. We also review the advances made in prenatal diagnostics of clefts through imaging and genomics and the various in utero surgical corrections that have been attempted thus far. An overview of how key mediators of signaling that drive palatogenesis are emphasized in the context of the framework and rationale for the development and testing of therapeutics in animal model systems and in humans is provided. The pros and cons of in utero therapies that can potentially restore molecular homeostasis needed for the proper growth and fusion of palatal shelves are presented. The theme advanced throughout this review is the need to develop preclinical molecular therapies that could ultimately be translated into human trials that can correct orofacial clefts at earlier stages of development.

Fetal Cleft Lip/Palate Surgery: End of a Dream?

Recognition that a fetus can scarlessly heal in intrauterine life led to various animal studies in the mid 1980s exploring the possibility of fetal cleft lip/palate surgery. The idea of scarless cleft repair seemed like a possible dream after the promising results from the early animal studies. In this review, we analyze the progress made in the 30 years since our first experience with animal models.

A Comparative Analysis of Gene Expression Profiles during Skin Regeneration in Mus and Acomys

The African spiny mouse (Acomys spp.) can heal full thickness excisional skin wounds in a scar-free manner with regeneration of all dermal components including hair and associated structures. Comparing Acomys scar-free healing from Mus scarring identifies gene expression differences that discriminate these processes. We have performed an extensive comparison of gene expression profiles in response to 8mm full-thickness excisional wounds at days 3, 5, 7 and 14 post-wounding between Acomys and Mus to characterize differences in wound healing, and identify mechanisms involved in scar-free healing. We also identify similarities with scar-free healing observed in fetal wounds. While wounding in Mus elicits a strong inflammatory response, wounding in Acomys produces a moderated immune response and little to no increase in expression for most cytokines and chemokines assayed. We also identified differences in the ECM profiles of the Acomys wounds, which appear to have a collagen profile more similar to fetal wounds, with larger increases in expression of collagen types III and V. In contrast, Mus wounds have very high levels of collagen XII. This data suggests that an overall lack of induction of cytokines and chemokines, coupled with an ECM profile more similar to fetal wounds, may underlie scar-free wound healing in Acomys skin. These data identify candidate genes for further testing in order to elucidate the causal mechanisms of scar-free healing.

The number of immune cells is lower in healthy oral mucosa compared to skin and does not increase after scarring

OBJECTIVE

Depending on the location of injury, wounds can heal with different outcomes. In addition foetal wounds heal fast without scar formation, while scars are a common feature of regular skin repair. Since inflammation is very limited in these wounds reduced numbers or even absence of immune cells might be responsible for scarless foetal wound healing. It is thought that various immune cells, such as macrophages, neutrophils and T-cells, play a role in aberrant wound healing and the fibrotic process seen in scar formation in the adult skin. Similar to the foetus, oral wounds show comparable healing properties by means of accelerated reepithelialization and negligible scar formation. It is possible that reduced inflammatory reaction as a result of lower numbers of immune cells are present in oral wounds compared to skin wounds.

DESIGN

Here we investigated the presence of various immune cells in human skin and oral mucosa, with or without scars. The presence or absence of these cells may play a role in the different modes of healing observed between the two types of tissue. Mast cells, neutrophils, M1/M2 macrophages, T-cells and blood vessels were localized in healthy and scarred skin and oral mucosa (scars>1 year old).

RESULTS

Oral mucosa had significantly fewer neutrophils, macrophages, mannose receptor-positive M2 macrophages, but more blood vessels. Scars contained similar numbers of immune cells compared to healthy tissues.

CONCLUSIONS

Less immune cells in the healthy oral mucosa may induce a diminished immune reaction when wounding occurs, and could explain the better healing capacity of the oral mucosa.

Wound healing in mammals and amphibians: toward limb regeneration in mammals

Mammalian fetal skin regenerates perfectly, but adult skin repairs by the formation of scar tissue. The cause of this imperfect repair by adult skin is not understood. In contrast, wounded adult amphibian (urodeles and anurans) skin is like mammalian fetal skin in that it repairs by regeneration, not scarring. Scar-free wound repair in adult Xenopus is associated with expression of the paired homeobox transcription factor Prx1 by mesenchymal cells of the wound, a feature shared by mesenchymal cells of the regeneration blastema of the axolotl limb. Furthermore, mesenchymal cells of Xenopus skin wounds that harbor the mouse Prx1-limb-enhancer as a transgene exhibit activation of the enhancer despite the fact that they are Xenopus cells, suggesting that the mouse Prx1 enhancer possesses all elements required for its activation in skin wound healing, even though activation of the same enhancer in the mouse is not seen in the wounded skin of an adult mouse. Elucidation of the role of the Prx1 gene in amphibian skin wound healing will help to clarify the molecular mechanisms of scarless wound healing. Shifting the molecular mechanism of wound repair in mammals to that of amphibians, including reactivation of the Prx1-limb-enhancer, will be an important clue to stimulate scarless wound repair in mammalian adult skin. Finding or creating Prx1-positive stem cells in adult mammal skin by activating the Prx1-limb-enhancer may be a fast and reliable way to provide for scarless skin wound repair, and even directly lead to limb regeneration in mammals.

A review of fetal scarless healing

Wound healing is a complex process involving a number of processes. Fetal regeneration has been shown to have a number of differences compared to scar-forming healing. This review discusses the number of differences identified in fetal regeneration. Understanding these differences may result in new therapeutic targets which may reduce or even prevent scarring in adult healing.

In utero surgery--current state of the art--part II

Background

Fetal surgery, also referred to as in utero, prenatal or intrauterine surgery, consists of treatment of congenital malformations during the fetal period. The idea of treating malformations diagnosed in the course of intrauterine life dates back to 1963, when Lilly performed the first blood transfusion in a fetus. Since then it has been introduced as a treatment option in a series of lethal malformations. Efforts are being made to treat nonlethal malformations by means of fetal surgery.

Material/Methods

A comprehensive search of the literature using MEDLINE and PubMed between 1925 and February 2009 was performed. Search terms for MEDLINE and PubMed were: fetal surgery, foetal surgery, in utero surgery, prenatal surgery, and in utero treatment. In addition, information was obtained at Web sites of the International Medicine and Surgery Society and the University of California Fetal Treatment Centre.

Results

Authors’ attention focused on the survey of indications to intrauterine operations. We outline potential directions of its development, quoting the groundwork of the most experienced researchers and clinicians. Moreover, owing to the authors’ interest in plastic surgery, some remarks on the role of intrauterine medicine and surgery in this branch of medicine are made.

Conclusions

In utero surgery may be regarded as an efficient tool of preventive medicine. It offers some advantages that no other branch of medicine may offer. However, its implementation is more troublesome than in the past, therefore only selected cases may benefit from its advantages. Nevertheless, current tendencies are to include, after thorough evaluation of benefit-risk ratio, some new indications for fetal surgery.

Matrix metalloproteinase 9 (MMP-9) is upregulated during scarless wound healing in athymic nude mice

Cutaneous wound healing is associated with migratory and remodeling events that require the action of matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and their tissue inhibitors (TIMPs). Differences in their expressions were observed during scar-forming and scar-free skin wound healing. We previously found that athymic nude mice are exceptional among mature mammals in their ability to heal injured skin scarlessly. The present study was undertaken to determine whether the modulation of MMP-2 and MMP-9 expression during scarless healing in nude mice was different from scar-forming animals. Full thickness skin wounds were made into the back of nude, wild-type controls (C57BL/6J), immunodeficient SCID and Rag, thymectomized neonates and adults, and cyclosporin A treated mice. Post-injured skin tissues were harvested at Day 7 and 24 after injury. Quantitative RT-PCR, Western blot, gelatin zymography and immunohistochemical assays were performed. Our results show that MMP-2 protein was high but similarly expressed in all post-injured animals on Day 7 after injury. Late phase (Day 24) of wound repair was characterized by a decrease in mRNA and protein expression and a decrease in gelatinolytic activity of MMP-2 in all post-injured samples. On the contrary, high (p < 0.001) levels of mRNA expression, prominent pro-and active forms of MMP-9 and cells immunopositive for MMP-9 were present exclusively in the post-injured tissues from nude mice on Day 24 after wounding. This data suggest that MMP-9 expression in the remodeling phase of wound healing in nude mice could be a major component of their ability for scar-free healing.

Epidemiology, aetiology and management of abnormal scarring: a review of the literature

Keloid and hypertrophic scars are the result of abnormal processes in scar formation. This paper reviews the literature and the many debates concerning the processes that cause abnormal scarring.

Modulation of scar tissue formation using different dermal regeneration templates in the treatment of experimental full-thickness wounds

The recovery of skin function is the goal of each burn surgeon. Split-skin graft treatment of full-thickness skin defects leads to scar formation, which is often vulnerable and instable. Therefore, the aim of this study was to analyze wound healing and scar tissue formation in acute full-thickness wounds treated with clinically available biopolymer dermal regeneration templates. Full-thickness wounds (3 x 3 cm) on both flanks of Gottingen mini pigs (n= 3) were treated with split-thickness skin graft alone or in combination with a 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)-carbodiimide (EDC) cross-linked-collagen scaffold, Integra, or a polyethyleneglycol terephthalate-polybutylene terephthalate (PEGT/PBT) scaffold. The wounds (n= 12 per group) were examined weekly for six weeks to evaluate graft take, contraction (planimetry), and cosmetic appearance. Histologic samples taken after one and six weeks were used to assess scaffold angiogenesis, biocompatibility, and scar tissue quality. In all wounds, one week postwounding graft take was between 93 and 100 percent. The control wound, treated with split-skin graft, showed little granulation tissue formation, whereas the EDC-collagen treated wounds showed two to three times more granulation tissue formation. The collagen scaffold was completely degraded within one week. The Integra and PEGT/PBT scaffolds showed angiogenesis only through two-thirds of the scaffold, which resulted in loss of integrity of the epidermis. Only basal cells survived, proliferated, and regenerated a fully differentiated epidermis within three weeks. Granulation thickness was comparable to collagen scaffold-treated wounds. After six weeks, control wounds showed a wound contraction of 27.2 +/- 6.1 percent, Integra-treated wounds 34.6 +/- 6.4 percent, collagen scaffold-treated wounds 38.1 +/- 5.0 percent, and PEGT/PBT scaffold-treated wounds 54.5 +/- 3.9 percent. The latter wounds had significantly more contraction than wounds of other treatment groups. Microscopically, the control and collagen scaffold-treated wounds showed an immature scar tissue that was two times thicker in the EDC-collagen treated wounds. The Integra-treated wounds showed nondegraded collagen scaffold fibers with partly de novo dermal tissue formation and partly areas with giant cells and other inflammatory cells. The PEGT/PBT scaffold was almost completely degraded. Scaffold particles were phagocytosized and degraded intracellularly by clusters of macrophages. The scar tissue was in the early phase of ECM remodeling. In conclusion, this study showed that the rate of dermal tissue formation and scarring is influenced by the rate of scaffold angiogenesis, degradation, and host response induced by the scaffold materials.

Comparison of Membranous Bone Healing Characteristics in Fetal and Postnatal Periods: An Experimental Study

In this experimental study, the postnatal and fetal membranous bone healing were investigated radiologically, histologically and levels of growth factors. Sixteen sheep fetuses and 16 sheep were included in this study. In the fetal group, 5 mm diameter ostectomy, and a 10 mm osteotomy were created in 90th gestational day. In the postnatal group, similar ostectomy and osteotomies were created. In the early period, radiologically similar radiolucencies in the ostectomy areas were seen in both groups. Histologically, fetal bone healing was decreased in the early postoperative period. However, it was accelerated in further time points. Histomorphometric analyses revealed accelerated fetal bone healing. TGF-beta1 levels were higher and then lower in early and late postoperative periods respectively in the fetal group. In the postnatal group, the levels of TGF-beta1 were lower and the differences between two groups were statistically significant in all time points (p < 0.05). The FGF and PDGF levels in both areas were higher in early postoperative period whereas lower in the late period in both groups. However, the fetal FGF levels were higher compared to the postnatal group (p < 0.05). The fetal PDGF levels were lower compared to the postnatal ones (p < 0.05). In conclusion, the calvarial bone gap model at the end of the second trimester of gestation in the fetal sheep model proved useful in examining the membranous bone healing. Histologically, the process of fetal bone healing seems similar to that of postnatal healing, albeit at an accelerated rate. Histomorphometric evaluation is a valuable tool in the evaluation of bone formation and gives more objective information about the ratio of bone formation.