Endoscopic endonasal transclival approaches: case series and outcomes for different clival regions

Anatomical Step-by-Step Dissection of Complex Skull Base Approaches for Trainees: Surgical Anatomy of the Endoscopic Endonasal Middle-Inferior Clivectomy, Odontoidectomy, and Far-Medial Approach

Introduction  The clival, paraclival, and craniocervical junction regions are challenging surgical targets. To approach these areas, endoscopic endonasal transclival approaches (EETCAs) and their extensions (far-medial approach and odontoidectomy) have gained popularity as they obviate manipulating and working between neurovascular structures. Although several cadaveric studies have further refined these contemporary approaches, few provide a detailed step-by-step description. Thus, we aim to didactically describe the steps of the EETCAs and their extensions for trainees. Methods  Six formalin-fixed cadaveric head specimens were dissected. All specimens were latex-injected using a six-vessel technique. Endoscopic endonasal middle and inferior clivectomies, far-medial approaches, and odontoidectomy were performed. Results  Using angled endoscopes and surgical instruments, an endoscopic endonasal midclivectomy and partial inferior clivectomy were performed without nasopharyngeal tissue disruption. To complete the inferior clivectomy, far-medial approach, and partially remove the anterior arch of C1 and odontoid process, anteroinferior transposition of the Eustachian-nasopharynx complex was required by transecting pterygosphenoidal fissure tissue, but incision in the nasopharynx was not necessary. Full exposure of the craniocervical junction necessitated bilateral sharp incision and additional inferior mobilization of the posterior nasopharynx. Unobstructed access to neurovascular anatomy of the ventral posterior fossa and craniocervical junction was provided. Conclusion  EETCAs are a powerful tool for the skull-base surgeon as they offer a direct corridor to the ventral posterior fossa and craniocervical junction unobstructed by eloquent neurovasculature. To facilitate easier understanding of the EETCAs and their extensions for trainees, we described the anatomy and surgical nuances in a didactic and step-by-step fashion.

Endoscopic Endonasal Skull Base Surgery Complication Avoidance: A Contemporary Review

The endoscopic endonasal approach (EEA) provides a direct trajectory to ventral skull base lesions, avoidance of brain retraction, and clear visualization of cranial nerves as they exit skull base foramina. Despite these benefits, the EEA is not without complications. Here, we review published literature highlighting complications associated with the EEA including cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak, cranial nerve (CN) dysfunction, pituitary gland dysfunction, internal carotid artery (ICA) injury, infection, and others; we place special emphasis on discussing the prevention of these complications. As widespread adoption of the EEA continues, it becomes critical to educate surgeons regarding potential complications and their prevention while identifying gaps in the current literature to guide future research and advances in clinical care.

Internal Carotid Injury during Skull Base Surgery-Case Report and a Review of the Literature

Iatrogenic injury of the internal carotid artery (ICA) is a rare, and probably underreported, complication of transnasal endoscopic skull base surgery. Although treatment algorithms have been suggested, there is no definite consensus or guideline for the management of this severe complication. We describe a case of ICA injury that occurred during a transsphenoidal biopsy of a tumor in the cavernous sinus and we present a treatment algorithm for managing this complication. We reviewed the articles published from 1998 to 2021, reporting on major vascular injury during transnasal endoscopic skull base surgery and endonasal endoscopic surgery, and we compare the methods and results of ICA injury management reported in the literature with the presented case. The most promising treatment for ICA injury might be packing with a muscle graft initially, then performing an endovascular intervention.

Additive Manufacturing for Personalized Skull Base Reconstruction in Endoscopic Transclival Surgery: A Proof-of-Concept Study

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic transnasal transclival intradural surgery is limited by a high postoperative cerebrospinal fluid leak rate. The aim of this study was to investigate the role of three-dimensional printing to create a personalized, rigid scaffold for clival reconstruction.

METHODS

Two different types of clivectomy were performed in 5 specimens with the aid of neuronavigation, and 11 clival reconstructions were simulated. They were repaired with polylactide, three-dimensional-printed scaffolds that were manually designed in a computer-aided environment based either on the real or on the predicted defect. Scaffolds were printed with a fused filament fabrication technique and different offsets. They were positioned and fixed either following the gasket seal technique or with screws. Postdissection radiological evaluation of scaffold position was performed in all cases. In 3 specimens, the cerebrospinal fluid leak pressure point was measured immediately after reconstruction.

RESULTS

The production process took approximately 30 hours. The designed scaffolds were satisfactory when no offset was added. Wings were added during the design to allow for screw positioning, but broke in 30% of cases. Radiological assessment documented maximal accuracy of scaffold positioning when the scaffold was created on the real defect; accuracy was satisfactory when the predicted clivectomy was performed under neuronavigation guidance. The cerebrospinal fluid leak pressure point was significantly higher when the scaffold was fixed with screws compared with the gasket technique.

CONCLUSIONS

In this preclinical setting, additive manufacturing allows the creation of customized scaffolds that are effective in reconstructing even large and geometrically complex clival defects.

ICAR: endoscopic skull-base surgery

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic skull-base surgery (ESBS) is employed in the management of diverse skull-base pathologies. Paralleling the increased utilization of ESBS, the literature in this field has expanded rapidly. However, the rarity of these diseases, the inherent challenges of surgical studies, and the continued learning curve in ESBS have resulted in significant variability in the quality of the literature. To consolidate and critically appraise the available literature, experts in skull-base surgery have produced the International Consensus Statement on Endoscopic Skull-Base Surgery (ICAR:ESBS).

METHODS

Using previously described methodology, topics spanning the breadth of ESBS were identified and assigned a literature review, evidence-based review or evidence-based review with recommendations format. Subsequently, each topic was written and then reviewed by skull-base surgeons in both neurosurgery and otolaryngology. Following this iterative review process, the ICAR:ESBS document was synthesized and reviewed by all authors for consensus.

RESULTS

The ICAR:ESBS document addresses the role of ESBS in primary cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) rhinorrhea, intradural tumors, benign skull-base and orbital pathology, sinonasal malignancies, and clival lesions. Additionally, specific challenges in ESBS including endoscopic reconstruction and complication management were evaluated.

CONCLUSION

A critical review of the literature in ESBS demonstrates at least the equivalency of ESBS with alternative approaches in pathologies such as CSF rhinorrhea and pituitary adenoma as well as improved reconstructive techniques in reducing CSF leaks. Evidence-based recommendations are limited in other pathologies and these significant knowledge gaps call upon the skull-base community to embrace these opportunities and collaboratively address these shortcomings.

Transclival approaches for intradural pathologies: historical overview and present scenario

Recently, endoscopic transsphenoidal transclival approaches have been developed and their role is widely accepted for extradural pathologies. Their application to intradural pathologies is still debated, but is undoubtedly increasing. In the past five decades, different authors have reported various extracranial, anterior transclival approaches for intradural pathologies. The aim of this review is to provide a historical overview of transclival approaches applied to intradural pathologies. PubMed was searched in October 2018 using the terms transcliv*, cliv* intradural, transsphenoidal transcliv*, transoral transcliv*, transcervical transcliv*, transsphenoidal brainstem, and transoral brainstem. Exclusion criteria included not reporting reconstruction technique, anatomical studies, reviews without new data, and transcranial approaches. Ninety-one studies were included in the systematic review. Since 1966, transcervical, transoral, transsphenoidal microsurgical, and, recently, endoscopic routes have been used as a corridor for transclival approaches to treat intradural pathologies. Each approach presents a curve that follows Scott's parabola, with evident phases of enthusiasm that quickly faded, possibly due to high post-operative CSF leak rates and other complications. It is evident that the introduction of the endoscope has led to a significant increase in reports of transclival approaches for intradural pathologies. Various reconstruction techniques and materials have been used, although rates of CSF leak remain relatively high. Transclival approaches for intradural pathologies have a long history. We are now in a new era of interest, but achieving effective dural and skull base reconstruction must still be definitively addressed, possibly with the use of newly available technologies.

[Extended endoscopic endonasal posterior (transclival) approach to tumors of the clival region and ventral posterior cranial fossa. Part 2. Topographic and anatomical aspects and surgical technique]

PURPOSE

to present the main topographic and anatomical features of the clivus and adjacent structures for improving and optimizing the extended endoscopic transnasal posterior (transclival) approach in removal of clival and ventral posterior cranial fossa lesions.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We performed a topographic and anatomical study of 25 cadaver heads, the vascular bed of which was filled with colored silicone using the original technique for visualizing the bed features and individual variability.

RESULTS

We present the main anatomical landmarks necessary for performing the extended endoscopic endonasal posterior approach. Superior, medial, and inferior transclival approaches provide access to the anterior surface of the upper, middle, and lower neurovascular complexes of the posterior cranial fossa.

CONCLUSION

The endoscopic transclival approach can be used to reach ventral posterior cranial fossa lesions. The endoscopic transnasal transclival approach is an alternative to transcranial approaches to clival lesions.

Transnasal Endoscopic and Lateral Approaches to the Clivus: A Quantitative Anatomic Study

BACKGROUND

Transnasal endoscopic approaches to the clivus have been established recently. Comparative analyses with classic lateral approaches are limited. In this study, we compared transnasal endoscopic and lateral approaches to the clivus, quantifying the exposure and working volume of each approach in the anatomy laboratory.

METHODS

High-resolution computed tomography scans were performed on 5 injected specimens (10 sides). In each specimen, transnasal endoscopic approaches (i.e., paraseptal, transrostral, extended transrostral, transethmoidal, and extended transclival without and with intradural hypophysiopexy) and lateral approaches (i.e., retrosigmoid, far-lateral, presigmoid retrolabyrinthine and translabyrinthine) to the clivus were performed. An optic neuronavigation system and dedicated software (ApproachViewer; Guided Therapeutics Program, University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada) were used to quantify the working volume and exposed clival area of each approach. Statistical evaluation was performed with the Kruskal-Wallis test and Steel-Dwass-Critchlow-Fligner post hoc test.

RESULTS

Endoscopic transnasal transclival approaches showed higher working volume and larger clival exposure compared with lateral approaches. Incremental volumetric values were evident for transnasal approaches; presigmoid approaches provided less working volume than retrosigmoid approaches. A transnasal transclival approach with hypophysiopexy provided significant exposure of the upper clivus (84.4%). The transrostral approach was the first transnasal approach providing satisfactory access to the midclivus (66%); retrosigmoid and far-lateral approaches provided exposure of approximately one half of the midclivus. The lower clivus was optimally exposed with endoscopic transclival approaches (83%), whereas access to this region was limited with lateral approaches.

CONCLUSIONS

This quantitative anatomic study shows that endoscopic transnasal approaches to the clivus provide a larger working volume and wider exposure of the clivus compared with lateral approaches.

The use of a three-dimensional endoscope for different skull base tumors: results of a preliminary extended endonasal surgical series

BACKGROUND

The evolution of skull base surgery over the past decade has been influenced by advancement in visualization technology. Recently, as a result of such improvements, three-dimensional (3-D) scopes have been widely used during endoscopic endonasal approaches. In the present study, we describe the use of 3-D stereoscopic endoscope for the treatment of a variety of skull base lesions.

METHODS

From January 2010 to June 2015, a 3-D endoscopic endonasal approach (4 and 4.9 mm, 0°, and 30° rigid endoscopes) was performed in 70 patients with the following lesions: 42 large extrasellar pituitary macroadenomas, seven tuberculum sellae meningiomas, seven clivus chordomas, five craniopharyngiomas, three fibrous dysplasia of the clivus, three sinonasal malignancies, one orbital lymphangioma, one trigeminal neurinoma, one primary suprasellar lymphoma.

RESULTS

Total tumor removal was obtained in 50 patients (71.4 %) while in 14 (20 %), subtotal removal was possible in six (8.6 %) only partial removal was achieved. Overall complications included diabetes insipidus in eight patients (11.4 %), hypopituitarism in seven patients (10 %), CSF leak in five patients (7.1 %), cranial nerve injury in two patients (2.8 %), panhypopituitarism in two patients (2.8 %), meningitis in one (1.4 %) and one postoperative central retinal artery occlusion (1.4 %). There was no mortality in the series. The mean follow-up time was 39 months (range, 6-72 months).

CONCLUSIONS

In our experience, the 3-D endoscope represents a critical development in visualization, thus enabling improved hand-eye coordination and depth perception, which are mandatory for the management of complex intradural neurovascular structures during tumor removal surgery.

Skull Base Surgery Training and Practice Patterns among Recent Otolaryngology Fellowship Graduates

OBJECTIVE

To collect data on skull base surgery training experiences and practice patterns of otolaryngologists that recently completed fellowship training.

DESIGN

A 24-item survey was disseminated to physicians who completed otolaryngology fellowships in rhinology, head and neck oncology, or neurotology between 2010 and 2014.

RESULTS

During a typical year, 50% of rhinologists performed more than 20 endoscopic anterior skull base cases, 83% performed fewer than 20 open cases, and were more confident performing advanced transplanum (p = 0.02) and transclival (p = 0.03) endoscopic approaches than head and neck surgeons. Head and neck surgeons performed fewer than 20 endoscopic and fewer than 20 open cases in 100% of respondents and were more confident with open approaches than rhinologists (p = 0.02). Neurotologists performed more than 20 lateral skull base cases in 45% of respondents during a typical year, fewer than 20 endoscopic ear cases in 95%, and were very comfortable performing lateral skull base approaches.

CONCLUSION

Many recent otolaryngology fellowship graduates are integrating skull base surgery into their practices. Respondents reported high confidence levels performing a range of cranial base approaches. Exposure to endoscopic ear techniques is minimal in neurotology training, and rhinology training appears to offer increased exposure to skull base surgery compared with head and neck training.

Internal carotid artery injury in endoscopic endonasal surgery: A systematic review

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

Internal carotid artery (ICA) injury during endoscopic endonasal surgery (EES) is a known and feared complication of paranasal sinus and skull base procedures. These ICA injuries can result in stroke, cranial nerve palsies, and death. This review examines the setting of injury along with the treatment approaches, and patient outcomes.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review using PubMed/MEDLINE and EMBASE.

METHODS

The databases were searched for articles reporting cases of ICA injury during EES. Variables analyzed included patient demographics, operative approach, preoperative diagnosis, setting of injury, repair method, imaging studies, patient outcomes, and follow-up.

RESULTS

Twenty-five articles with 50 cases were included in this review. The EES approach was used for skull base procedures in 34 cases and for inflammatory disease in 16 cases. The most commonly injured ICA segment was the cavernous (34 cases), followed by the ophthalmic (three cases). Injuries occurred more commonly on the left (1.3:1). Injury occurred in the setting of various steps during EES with instruments. Stereotactic image guidance was reported in two cases. Initial hemostasis was achieved with packing in 35 cases, endoscopic clip sacrifice in four cases, bipolar coagulation with the intent to seal defect in three cases, and bipolar coagulation with the intent to sacrifice the ICA in one case. Intraoperative or immediate postoperative angiography was reported in 27 cases.

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of reported cases of ICA injury during EES remains low. Left-sided injuries to the cavernous segment of the ICA occurred more frequently than injuries on the right.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 126:582-590, 2016.