Volar Scaphoid Plating for Nonunion: A Multicenter Case Series Study

Comparative analysis of cancellous graft and cortico-cancellous graft in osteosynthesis of scaphoid pseudoarthrosis with plate

INTRODUCTION

Scaphoid is the most fractured carpal bone, with a 5-10% nonunion rate. Treatment challenges include choosing the implant and graft that best corrects humpback deformity and carpal malalignment with higher chances of bony healing.

OBJECTIVE

Compare cortico-cancellous and cancellous grafts between two groups of patients treating scaphoid nonunion with locking plates using autologous bone graft and evaluate bone healing rates and radiographic, tomographic, and functional parameters before and after surgery.

METHODS

Non-randomized prospective study including 20 cases of scaphoid nonunion. Groups were divided into Group A (ten patients treated with cortico-cancellous iliac graft) and Group B (ten patients treated with cancellous iliac graft). Patients underwent pre- and postoperative radiographs, computed tomography, and functional evaluation.

RESULTS

In postoperative analysis, Group A showed a statistically significant difference in intrascaphoid angle (p = 0.002) and scapholunate angle (p = 0.011) correction when comparing the pre- and postoperative periods. Group B showed a statistically significant difference in intrascaphoid angle (p = 0.002) and scapholunate angle correction (p = 0.0018), grip strength (p = 0.002), and tip pinch strength (p = 0.001) when comparing the pre- and postoperative periods. By comparing both groups, Group B showed a statistically significant difference in intrascaphoid angle correction (p = 0.002), grip strength (p = 0.002), tip pinch strength (p = 0.002), and radial deviation (p = 0.0003). There was no statistical difference when comparing bony healing between groups.

CONCLUSION

Scaphoid nonunion treatment with a locking plate was effective, showing a high bony healing rate and improved carpal alignment in imaging tests for both graft types. However, results for intrascaphoid angle correction, grip strength, tip pinch strength, and radial deviation were better in Group B.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, case series.

Scaphoid Plate Osteosynthesis in Complex Fractures and Wrist Trauma: A Case Series

Introduction Treatment of scaphoid fracture is challenging due to its unique blood supply and geometry. Traditionally, a headless compression screw is the standard treatment for unstable scaphoid fracture. Some fractures are complex, for example, comminution with bone loss. A scaphoid plate is an option in these difficult fractures providing adequate rotational stability. Aim To share our experience in using scaphoid plates in complex wrist trauma and comminuted fractures. Method and material Complex wrist trauma involving scaphoid fractures that were comminuted and multi-fragmentary fractures treated with plate osteosynthesis were retrospectively reviewed between July 2019 and September 2021. Patient demographic data, preoperative radiographs, CT scans, pain, wrist range of motion, and fracture union rate to union were reviewed. Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (QuickDASH®) score was recorded at 1-year postoperative follow-up.  Results Nine patients associated with complex wrist trauma were included in this case series. The mean follow-up was 2.5 years (13-30 months). The union rate was 100%. The mean arc of motion was 105° (95-110°). QuickDASH® score was 19.96 at 1-year postoperative follow-up. Four patients had good outcomes, four satisfactory, and one poor outcome. One hardware complication was observed which was the impingement of the plate proximally over the articular surface of the distal radius. Conclusion A scaphoid plate is a reliable option for treating complex and difficult fractures. It provides adequate stability, especially in comminution, bone loss, or multi-fragmentary fractures which are not amendable using other fixation methods. We recommend the expansion of plate osteosynthesis beyond scaphoid nonunion into complex wrist trauma.

Volar Plating of Scaphoid Fractures: A Retrospective Case Series

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the rate of union of scaphoid fractures managed with volar plating and assess postoperative complications.

METHODS

Retrospective consecutive case series of 28 patients with scaphoid fractures, 9 acute and 19 chronic nonunions, undergoing surgical fixation with volar scaphoid plating by a single surgeon between 2013 and 2019. Patients were followed up for a minimum of 3 months with scaphoid bony union being confirmed on radiograph or computed tomography. Postoperative complications and need for plate removal were recorded.

RESULTS

Overall union rate of 96% with all 19 chronic nonunions demonstrating radiological union and 1 of 9 acute fractures not uniting and requiring revision surgery. The only postoperative complication identified was symptomatic plate impingement which necessitated plate removal in 57% of cases.

CONCLUSIONS

This case series demonstrates volar plating of scaphoid fractures can be used as an alternative technique to achieve union.

Double screw versus angular stable plate fixation of scaphoid waist nonunions in combination with intraoperative extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT)

INTRODUCTION

Over the past years, different fixation techniques focused on rotational stability in order to increase stability and stimulate union rates. Additionally, extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT) has gained importance in the treatment of delayed and nonunions. Purpose of this study was to compare the radiological and clinical outcome of two headless compression screws (HCS) and plate fixation in scaphoid nonunions, in combination with intraoperative high energy ESWT.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty-eight patients with scaphoid nonunions were treated by using a nonvascularized bone graft from the iliac crest and stabilization with either two HCS or a volar angular stable scaphoid plate. All patients received one ESWT session with 3000 impulses and energy flux per pulse of 0.41 mJ/mm² intraoperatively. Clinical assessment included range of motion (ROM), pain according to the Visual Analog Scale (VAS), grip strength, disability of the Arm Shoulder and Hand Score, Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation Score, Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire and modified Green O'Brien (Mayo) Wrist Score. To confirm union, a CT scan of the wrist was performed.

RESULTS

Thirty-two patients returned for clinical and radiological examination. Out of these, 29 (91%) showed bony union. All patients treated with two HCS compared to 16 out of 19 (84%) patients treated by plate showed bony union on the CT scans. The difference was not statistically significant. However, at a mean follow-up interval of 34 months, no significant differences could be found in ROM, pain, grip strength and patient-reported outcome measurements between the two HCS and plate group. Height-to-length ratio and capitolunate angle improved significantly in both groups compared to preoperative.

CONCLUSIONS

Scaphoid nonunion stabilization by using two HCS or angular stable volar plate fixation and intraoperative ESWT results in comparable high union rates and good functional outcome. Due to the higher rate for a secondary intervention (plate removal), HCS might be preferable as first choice, whereas the scaphoid plate fixation should be reserved for recalcitrant (substantial bone loss, humpback deformity or failed prior surgical intervention) scaphoid nonunions.

Plate fixation in challenging traumatic carpal scaphoid lesions

BACKGROUND

Complex fractures of the carpal scaphoid with poles fragmentation, edges comminution, bone loss and non-union of fractures previously treated by screw fixation remain challenging for hand surgeons. The authors present the indications, advantages and results of scaphoid plating, underlining the importance of correct plate positioning well shaped onto the bone.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study includes 11 patients presenting acute fracture with distal pole fragmentation, acute fracture with comminution and non-union after prior failure of screw fixation. All patients were treated with volar locked plate fixation, adding a cortical bone graft in cases of non-union.

RESULTS

Bone consolidation was achieved in all cases; excellent outcomes in fracture healing and relevant improvement in symptoms and functions were obtained in non-union group that are consistent with the literature. Only one patient underwent early further surgery (first row carpectomy) with poor results.

CONCLUSION

The treatment of the selected scaphoid lesions with volar locked plate is a surely efficient technique. The plate can be easily adjusted to the shape of the scaphoid and can achieve an adequate correction of bone deformity and high degree of stability both in non-union and fractures.

Predictors of Failure for Vascularized and Nonvascularized Bone Grafting of Scaphoid Nonunions: A Systematic Review

Objective This article compares predictors of failure for vascularized (VBG) and nonvascularized bone grafting (NVBG) of scaphoid nonunions.

Methods We conducted a systematic literature review of outcomes after VBG and NVBG of scaphoid nonunion. Fifty-one VBG studies (N = 1,419 patients) and 81 NVBG studies (N = 3,019 patients) met the inclusion criteria. Data were collected on surgical technique, type of fixation, time from injury to surgery, fracture location, abnormal carpal posture (humpback deformity and/or dorsal intercalated segmental instability [DISI]), radiographic parameters of carpal alignment, prior failed surgery, smoking status, and avascular necrosis (AVN) as defined by punctate bleeding, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with contrast, MRI without contrast, X-ray, and histology. Meta-analysis of proportions was conducted with Freeman–Tukey double arcsine transformation. Multilevel mixed-effects analyses were performed with univariable and multivariable Poisson regression to identify confounders and evaluate predictors of failure.

Results The pooled failure incidence effect size was comparable between VBG and NVBG (0.09 [95% confidence interval [CI] 0.05–0.13] and 0.08 [95% CI 0.06–0.11], respectively). Humpback deformity and/or DISI (incidence-rate radios [IRRs] 1.57, CI: 1.04–2.36) and lateral intrascaphoid angle (IRR 1.21, CI: 1.08–1.37) were significantly associated with an increased VBG failure incidence. Time from injury to surgery (IRR 1.09, CI: 1.06–1.12) and height-to-length (H/L) ratio (IRR 53.98, CI: 1.16–2,504.24) were significantly associated with an increased NVBG failure incidence, though H/L ratio demonstrated a wide CI. Decreased proximal fragment contrast uptake on MRI was a statistically significant predictor of increased failure incidence for both VBG (IRR 2.03 CI: 1.13–3.66) and NVBG (IRR 1.39, CI: 1.16–1.66). Punctate bleeding or radiographic AVN, scapholunate angle, radiolunate angle, and prior failed surgery were not associated with failure incidence for either bone graft type (p > 0.05).

Conclusion Humpback deformity and/or DISI and increasing lateral intrascaphoid angle may be predictors of VBG failure. Time from injury to surgery may be a predictor of NVBG failure. AVN as defined by decreased contrast uptake on MRI may be a marker of increased failure risk for both bone graft types.