Non-surgical biliary drainage: endoscopic conversion of percutaneous transhepatic into endoprosthetic drainage

Usefulness of combined percutaneous-endoscopic rendezvous techniques after failed therapeutic endoscopic retrograde cholangiography in the era of endoscopic ultrasound guided rendezvous

The rendezvous approach is a salvage technique after failure of endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (ERC). In certain circumstances, percutaneous-endoscopic rendezvous (PE-RV) is preferred, and endoscopic ultrasound-guided rendezvous (EUS-RV) is difficult to perform. We aimed to evaluate PE-RV outcomes, describe the PE-RV techniques, and identify potential indications for PE-RV over EUS-RV.Retrospective analysis was conducted of a prospectively designed ERC database between January 2005 and December 2016 at a tertiary referral center including cases where PE-RV was used as a salvage procedure after ERC failure.During the study period, PE-RV was performed in 42 cases after failed therapeutic ERC; 15 had a surgically altered enteric anatomy. The technical success rate of PE-RV was 92.9% (39/42), with a therapeutic success rate of 88.1% (37/42). Potential indications for PE-RV over EUS-RV were identified in 23 cases, and either PE-RV or EUS-RV could have effectively been used in 19 cases. Endoscopic bile duct access was successfully achieved with PE-RV in 39 cases with accessible biliary orifice using one of PE-RV cannulation techniques (classic, n = 11; parallel, n = 19; and adjunctive maneuvers, n = 9).PE-RV uses a unique technology and has clinical indications that distinguish it from EUS-RV. Therefore, PE-RV can still be considered a useful salvage technique for the treatment of biliary obstruction after ERC failure.

The rendezvous technique for the treatment of choledocholithiasis

BACKGROUND

The rendezvous technique combines endoscopy with percutaneous transhepatic cholangiography to facilitate cannulation of the bile duct when previous attempts have failed.

METHODS

Over a 7-year period, a total of 1753 ERCPs were performed. Twelve of these patients with a diagnosis of choledocholithiasis were poor candidates for surgery. Percutaneous transhepatic cholangiography as well as ERCP with precut papillotomy failed to resolve biliary obstruction. In a further 2 cases the percutaneous approach was used by means of a T-tube positioned at a prior cholecystectomy.

OBSERVATIONS

The combined procedure was successful in 13 patients (93%). It was unsuccessful in 1 patient because of a stone lodged distally near the papilla. There was only 1 complication (7%), a retroperitoneal perforation that occurred during papillotomy; no mortality was directly attributable to the technique.

CONCLUSIONS

The rendezvous technique is recommended for patients who are not eligible for surgery when ERCP is unsuccessful and when it is impossible to resolve biliary obstruction by percutaneous transhepatic cholangiography.

Combined transhepatic and endoscopic procedures in the biliary system

Endoscopic biliary procedures are 89-97% successful in skilled hands. The commonest causes of failure are inability to cannulate the papilla of Vater due to difficult anatomy or tortuosity of the distal common bile duct and failure to cross a rigid biliary stricture. In nearly all of these cases, successful endoscopic procedures can be completed after percutaneous antegrade placement of a small catheter or guidewire to the duodenum. In 44 such combined procedures on 42 patients, the success rate was 43 (98%). There were two severe and eight mild complications. Combined procedures overcome the difficulties caused by tortuous biliary ducts and rigid strictures while obviating the need for more extensive percutaneous procedures and transhepatic tract dilatation.

A new balloon-expandable tantalum stent (Strecker-Stent) for the biliary system: preliminary experience

Placement of a balloon-expandable metallic stent (Strecker-Stent) for biliary drainage has been attempted in 30 patients. The stent was successfully implanted in 22 patients; in the remaining 8 patients, dilatation of the biliary stricture prior to stent placement was inadequate and delivery of the Strecker-Stent was, therefore, not possible. Insufficient balloon dilatation was related to the rigid nature of the stricture and to pain experienced during dilatation. During 2-9 months follow-up, 3 of 21 patients (14%) presented with reocclusion of the stented bile ducts. In all other patients, biliary drainage remains adequate. No major complications related to stent placement were observed.

Percutaneous-endoscopic biliary stenting in patients with occluded surgical bypass

PURPOSE

The purpose of this investigation was to test the feasibility of using a recently developed technique of placing internalized biliary stents into patients who have had reobstruction after initial surgical bypass.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Seven men and three women, 46 to 85 years of age (eight with pancreatic carcinoma, one with metastatic colon, and one with metastatic ovarian carcinoma), all had reobstruction after initial surgical bypass palliation. Subsequent attempts to place stents via endoscope failed in five patients; a pair of 7-Fr stents placed in one patient failed to drain well. Endoscopic stenting in four patients was not even attempted because of severely distorted anatomy. Nine of the 10 patients then had successful internal stent placement by a combined percutaneous-transhepatic and peroral-endoscopically guided technique.

RESULTS

One of these nine placeable stents failed to drain well and the patient died 8 days later with massive tumor. Seven showed a significant decrease in bilirubin levels and improved quality of life. Two of these had sepsis that responded to antibiotics. Life span ranged between 11 days and 10 months, with one patient still alive; no deaths were directly due to stents.

CONCLUSION

A combined transhepatic-peroral technique of placing internalized biliary stents can be expected to result in repalliation in a majority of patients with reobstruction after earlier surgical bypass and in whom subsequent attempts at endoscopic placement of stents have failed or in whom tumor growth prevents undertaking the endoscopic approach.

The needle knife: a valuable tool in diagnostic and therapeutic ERCP

Using monopolar electrocautery technique, we have used both an electrified guide wire and a needle-tipped sphincterotome to successfully enter the common bile duct, subsequently image it, and perform therapeutic procedures when by virtue of the patient's anatomy, or because of tumor, this had not been possible using conventional ERCP catheters. In an initial group of 45 patients using the needle-tipped sphincterotome, clinically significant complications occurred in 3 patients but were not of a serious nature. The technique was an effective method for achieving both diagnostic ERCP and therapeutic maneuvers in 43 of 45 patients. We stress that this technique should only be attempted by those with long experience in ERCP and related procedures.

Palliation of obstructive jaundice with a biliary endoprosthesis. Comparison of insertion by the percutaneous-transhepatic and the combined percutaneous-endoscopic routes

Thirty-eight patients with obstructive jaundice due to inoperable malignancy were referred for insertion of an endoprosthesis. In 19 this was performed by the percutaneous-transhepatic route, and in 19 by a combined percutaneous-endoscopic approach. Satisfactory bile drainage was achieved in 15 patients after combined percutaneous-endoscopic insertion and in 11 after percutaneous-transhepatic prosthesis insertion. Cholangitis occurred after the combined approach in five patients and after percutaneous-transhepatic insertion in nine. None of these differences were significant. Thirty-day mortality rates and mean survival times were similar for each approach (26% and 10 weeks after combined insertion, 21% and 9 weeks after percutaneous-transhepatic). Prostheses inserted by the combined route were easily replaced when they occluded. This was not possible after percutaneous insertion. The combined percutaneous-endoscopic approach appeared to be better tolerated by the patients and is suggested as the method of choice in strictures which can not be intubated by the endoscopic route alone.

Combined endoscopic and percutaneous stent insertion to overcome a problem of percutaneous stent insertion

Non-operative stent insertion is a well-accepted means of palliating malignant biliary obstruction. The endoscopic approach is often considered the procedure of choice, with the percutaneous technique reserved for endoscopy failures. We recently encountered a patient in whom both techniques proved unsuccessful initially, and in whom palliation was finally achieved by means of a combined endoscopic and percutaneous transhepatic procedure.