[Arthroscopic labral reconstruction for anterior shoulder instability. Failure analysis in 187 patients]

Does the immediate repair of Bankart lesion following first dislocation reduce the chances of recurrence after arthroscopic repair in soldiers?

PURPOSE

The study attempted to compare the effects of immediate and delayed arthroscopic Bankart repair on the shoulder dislocation recurrence.

METHODS

In total, 465 soldiers with first-time anterior shoulder dislocation were included in the study. Of the total, 285 soldiers underwent a quick arthroscopic Bankart repair procedure, whether 180 soldiers underwent a delayed repair procedure. The initial dislocation was traumatic in both groups and operated using the standard arthroscopic suture anchor repair technique. Patient's age, repair time since the first dislocation, number of dislocations before surgery, number of suture anchors used during the repair, duration of surgical procedure, duration from surgery to return to work, and recurrence of dislocation after surgery were recorded. Rowe score, Constant score, and American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score were used for clinical assessment.

RESULTS

The operating time and recurrence rate were higher in the group subjected to delayed repair procedure than in the group subjected to immediate repair procedure. Repair timing was found to be crucial for a successful outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings suggest that Bankart repair must be performed immediately to minimize recurrence and other degenerative changes, which may require an additional surgical procedure for satisfactory repair. More studies are required to reach a definitive conclusion.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Mid-term to long-term results of primary arthroscopic Bankart repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability: a retrospective study

Background

The arthroscopic method offers a less invasive technique of Bankart repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability. The aim of the study is to determine the mid−/long-term functional outcome, failure rates and predictors of failure after primary arthroscopic Bankart repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability.

Methods

A total of 100 patients were primarily operated using arthroscopic Bankart repair after traumatic anterior shoulder instability. Medical records were retrospectively reviewed, and patients were assessed using postal questionnaire after a mean follow-up of 8.3 years [3–14]. Clinical assessment was performed using Constant score, Rowe score, and American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score.

Results

The overall recurrence rate was 22%. The Kaplan-Meier failure-free survival estimates.

were 80% at 5 years and 70% at 10 years. Nearly half (54.5%) of recurrences occurred at 2 years postoperative. Compared with normal shoulder, there were statistical differences in all 3 scores. Failure rate was significantly affected by age at the time of surgery with 86% of recurrence cases observed in patients aged 30 years or younger. Nevertheless, Younger age at the time of surgery (P = 0.007) as well age at the time of initial instability (P = 0.03) was found to correlate negatively with early recurrence within 2 years of surgery. Among those with recurrent instability, recurrence rate was found to be higher if there had been more than 5 instability episodes preoperatively (P = 0.01). Return to the preinjury sport and occupational level was possible in 41 and 78%, respectively.

Conclusion

Failure-free survival rates dropped dramatically over time. Alternative reconstruction techniques should be considered in those aged ≤30 years due to the high recurrence rate.

Risk factors for early failure after thermal capsulorrhaphy

Thermal capsular shrinkage has rapidly become a common procedure for a variety of shoulder conditions usually associated with instability, although clinical data on outcomes are limited. The objective of this study was to identify risk factors for poor outcome after thermal capsulorrhaphy. Of 106 patients who underwent thermal shrinkage, 15 patients with treatment failures were identified. The mean time to failure after the procedure was 6.3 months (range, 1 to 16). Previous operations and multiple recurrent dislocations were associated with poor outcome at a highly significant level. Multidirectional instability and participation in contact sports did not attain statistical significance as risk factors. However, statistical power in these two comparisons was insufficient to exclude them as potential risk factors. A concomitant procedure at the time of thermal capsulorrhaphy was not associated with poor outcome. The data from early treatment failures can be useful in guiding patient selection for thermal capsulorrhaphy. This procedure may be of limited value for patients who have had prior operations or have a history of multiple dislocations. The data also suggest that thermal capsulorrhaphy should be used cautiously in patients with multidirectional instability or in those who are involved in contact sports.