[Ultrasound morphologic criteria in evaluating meniscus changes--an experimental study]

The Value of Ultrasound Diagnostic Imaging of Meniscal Knee Injuries Verified by Experimental and Arthroscopic Investigations

(1) Introduction: Meniscal knee injuries may develop as the result of trauma or overloading. Ultrasound imaging is an observer-dependent modality, meaning that the assessment of structural damage depends on the investigator's experience.. None of the published papers provides a standardized method for ultrasound examination of knee menisci. The main goal of this study is to realize and standardize ultrasound imaging diagnostics of meniscal knee injuries based on individual features of ultrasound presentation and to evaluate the applicability of this modality in clinical practice. (2) Material and methods: This study consisted of two anatomical parts, including a clinical part that started with clinical examination of 50 patients with suspected meniscal knee injuries. After this we performed ultrasound examinations in patients with positive clinical test results, using sonographic confirmation for inclusion in the next stage. Finally, knee arthroscopy by two physicians in an operating room was performed, with procedures documented through photographs and video recordings, and analytic material obtained from patients in the control group documented similarly. (3) Results: In the clinical part of the study, arthroscopic examination revealed 13 longitudinal injuries (corresponding to 36% of all injuries in the group), 14 multidirectional injuries (corresponding to 28% of all injuries), 3 radial injuries (corresponding to 6% of all injuries), and 20 oblique injuries (corresponding to 40% of all injuries). The analysis of the sensitivity and specificity of the diagnostic test in terms of recognizing actual meniscal injuries on the basis of full-thickness or partial-thickness delamination, meniscal cyst oedema, and articular space stenosis revealed that the presence of at least two of these three characteristics was associated with the sensitivity of 88% and the specificity of 86% relative to the number of actual meniscal injuries as seen in arthroscopic examination. (4) Conclusions: Research results confirm that clinical examination combined with ultrasound imaging is a very efficient tool for evaluation of meniscal injuries.

[Meniscal degeneration score and NITEGE expression : immunohistochemical detection of NITEGE in advanced meniscal degeneration]

BACKGROUND

Meniscal degeneration (MD) is a structural change of fibrous cartilage that is common in orthopaedic diagnostics and relevant for health insurance matters. So far, there has been neither a standardised scoring system nor an immunohistochemical marker for MD.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

In this retrospective trial, the meniscal tissue of 60 patients was assessed immunohistochemically for NITEGE (G1 fragment of the proteoglycan aggrecan) expression. NITEGE expression was correlated with defined grades of MD: little (grade 0/1), medium (grade 2), or severe (grade 3).

RESULTS

Detection of extracellular NITEGE deposits in grade 2 or 3 MD had a positive predictive value and specificity of 100%, whereas no deposits were found in grade 0/1 MD. Sensitivity in advanced MD was 55%. Detection of extracellular NITEGE correlated positively with the grade of degeneration, as did patient age and the grade of degeneration. The patient age of those with grade 0/1 MD was significantly lower than for grade 3 (p<0.0001).

CONCLUSION

The thoroughly defined degeneration score (grade 1 - grade 3 MD) is suitable to assess the severity of degeneration. Extracellular NITEGE deposits can be regarded as an immunohistochemical marker for advanced (grades 2 and 3) MD.

Accuracy of hand-held ultrasound scanning in detecting meniscal tears

The diagnosis of a meniscal tear may require MRI, which is costly. Ultrasonography has been used to image the meniscus, but there are no reliable data on its accuracy. We performed a prospective study investigating the sensitivity and specificity of ultrasonography in comparison with MRI; the final outcome was determined at arthroscopy. The study included 35 patients with a mean age of 47 years (14 to 73).

There was a sensitivity of 86.4% (95% confidence interval (CI) 75 to 97.7), a specificity of 69.2% (95% CI 53.7 to 84.7), a positive predictive value of 82.6% (95% CI 70 to 95.2) and a negative predictive value of 75% (95% CI 60.7 to 81.1) for ultrasonography. This compared favourably with a sensitivity of 86.4% (95% CI 75 to 97.7), a specificity of 100.0%, a positive predictive value of 100.0% and a negative predictive value of 81.3% (95% CI 74.7 to 87.9) for MRI.

Given that the sensitivity matched that of MRI we feel that ultrasonography can reasonably be applied to confirm the clinical diagnosis before undertaking arthroscopy. However, the lower specificity suggests that there is still a need to improve the technique to reduce the number of false-positive diagnoses and thus to avoid unnecessary arthroscopy.

C4d deposits mark sites of meniscal tissue disintegration

Although the frequent occurrence of meniscal degeneration is a well-known fact and its consequences include rupture and even loss of the meniscus, the pathogenetic factors are established insufficiently. Because complement factors and leukocytes are present in synovial fluid, we tried to detect complement deposits and macrophages in menisci, which displayed degenerative changes. We therefore performed a retrospective analysis by immunohistochemical staining of C4d and CD68 in meniscal tissue derived from patients (n=15) who underwent meniscectomy because of meniscal tears and from three autopsy cases (n=3). In this study, focal C4d deposits in the meniscal extracellular matrix in areas of mucoid degeneration or fibrillation were demonstrated for the first time, while no C4d deposits in the avascular zone of menisci without signs of degeneration or injury could be detected. In addition, colocalization of C4d and CD68+ cells was found at sites of meniscal tissue disintegration in five cases. These results represent the first evidence for an involvement of complement and macrophages in meniscal tissue disintegration, indicating a complement mediated reaction at the site of tissue alteration.

The value of sonography with micro convex probes in diagnosing meniscal tears compared with arthroscopy

OBJECTIVE

Meniscal tears are common in knee injuries. Sonography has been used in the knee to evaluate meniscal tears. Linear probes with high resolution have been used, and the overall accuracy of sonography has been more than 70% in many studies. In this study, we used a 6.5-MHz micro convex probe to evaluate meniscal tears, and the results were compared with arthroscopic findings.

METHODS

Four hundred six knee joints with knee pain and a clinical indication for arthroscopy were examined from the popliteal fossa with the 6.5-MHz micro convex probe. Those patients with positive sonographic findings who had an arthroscopic examination (100 patients) were included in our study, and the results were compared. The results were statistically analyzed by the Fisher exact test.

RESULTS

One hundred knees with sonographic examinations underwent arthroscopic evaluation. Three age groups were included in the study (20-30, 30-40, and >40 years). Comparison of the results between the two methods showed sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 95% for sonography in detecting meniscal tears. The positive predictive value for the medial meniscus was 95%, and the negative predictive value was 100%; these values for the lateral meniscus were 93% and 100%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Meniscal tears are common in all age groups. The use of sonography allows rapid, low-cost, and noninvasive exploration of meniscal tears as a first-line diagnostic method. We recommend high-resolution micro convex probes, which better fit the anatomic concavity of the popliteal fossa, as efficient investigation tools.

Is there a role for sonography in the diagnosis of tears of the knee menisci?

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to investigate the usefulness of sonography in diagnosing tears of the knee menisci.

METHODS

In this retrospective study, we reviewed the sonographic examinations of the knees of 321 patients diagnosed with a torn meniscus on the basis of clinical findings. Of the 321 knees imaged, 216 were also examined using MRI or CT. Arthroscopic meniscectomy was performed on 126 knees.

RESULTS

MRI or CT did not confirm 48% (71 cases) of the positive sonographic diagnoses (ie, false positives) and 72% (50 cases) of the negative sonographic diagnoses (ie, false negatives). Thus, the sonographic diagnosis was correct in 95 cases (44%) and incorrect in 121 cases (56%), yielding low rates of sensitivity (60%) and specificity (21%). Among the 126 cases in which arthroscopic meniscectomy was performed, arthroscopy confirmed 100% of the MRI or CT diagnoses of meniscal tears.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that sonography is not accurate enough to be used as the only imaging modality for diagnosing tears of the knee menisci.