Silence of the leukemic clone

Battling the hematological malignancies: the 200 years' war

The delineation of the hematological malignancies began near the end of the first third of the 19th century with the recognition of the similarity among cases with lymph node tumors and an enlarged spleen (Hodgkin's disease). Descriptions of chronic and acute leukemia and myeloma followed thereafter. In the first years of the 20th century the discovery of x-radiation permitted palliative orthovoltage radiation therapy of Hodgkin's disease. Following World War II, legitimate drug therapy for the hematological malignancies was introduced: nitrogen mustard, adrenocorticotropic hormone and cortisone acetate, and anti-folic acid derivatives, initially aminopterin. Today, about 14 classes of drugs (different mechanisms of action) and >50 individual agents are being used, with others under study. Several examples of agents targeting specific transcription factors or oncoproteins have been introduced. Despite remarkable progress, including the ability to cure acute leukemia in about 70% of children, cure several genetic variants of acute myelogenous leukemia in younger adults, cure some cases of lymphoma in children and younger adults, and induce prolonged remission in many affected persons, the majority of patients face an uncertain outcome and shortened life. Thus, we have much to do in the next several decades. The significant hurdles we must overcome include: the apparent infrequency of an exogenous cause that can be avoided, the exponential increase in incidence rates with age and the dramatic negative effect of aging on the results of treatment, the challenge of one trillion or more disseminated cancer cells among which are a smaller population of cancer stem cells, the profound genetic diversity of the hematological malignancies (apparently hundreds of unique genetic primary lesions), the redundant growth and survival pathways defining the cancer phenotype, the decreasing market for pharmaceutical companies as therapy becomes more specific (fewer target patients) and drug development costs become more expensive, and the significant negative long-term effects of current therapy on both children and adults. These challenges will be gradually overcome, if we (a) develop new models of cooperation among academia, industry, and government, (b) continue the growth of international participation in cancer research (more keen minds to the task), and (c) convince the governments of the world, including that of the U.S., that an investment in minimizing the effects of cancer is as important as defending against other threats to the welfare and longevity of their citizens.

Distinctive IGH gene segment usage and minimal residual disease detection in infant acute lymphoblastic leukaemias

Infant acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) represents a rare but unique subset with poor prognosis. We analysed mixed-lineage leukaemia (MLL) gene rearrangements and the sequences of complete and incomplete immunoglobulin heavy chain gene rearrangements (IGH) in 14 infants (age < or = 12 months at diagnosis) enrolled on Dana-Farber Cancer Institute ALL Consortium Protocol 95-01. The dynamics of the leukaemic clone were followed during the course of the disease by quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction of IGH rearrangements. Sixteen sequences were obtained from 13 (93%) of these infants. There was marked over usage of the V(H)6.1 gene segment (64%) in infants compared with older children with ALL (8%), (P < 0.001) and overusage of D(H)6 (P = 0.004) and J(H)1 (P = 0.004). Poor outcome was associated with MLL gene rearrangements rather than any specific V(H)D(H)J(H) gene usage patterns. Levels of minimal residual disease (MRD) at the end of induction appeared to be high in infants with ALL compared with older children, and although the number of infant cases studied was small, there were no differences in MRD levels after induction therapy in infant ALL with or without MLL gene rearrangements (P = 0.41) and quantitative MRD assessment at the early time points may not be predictive of outcome. Novel treatment strategies are required to improve the outcome in this poor prognosis subset of children with ALL.

Minimal residual disease in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia: current status and challenges

The pace of disappearance of leukemic blasts in response to therapy has long been recognized as the most important prognostic factor in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Recent technological advancements enable detection of submicroscopic leukemic cells. The extent of reduction in the level of minimal residual disease (MRD) during the first phase of therapy can be exploited for improved risk classification of children with ALL. Current prospective studies test the hypothesis that tailoring treatment to the level of MRD will improve patients' outcome.

Modeling minimal residual disease (MRD)-testing

There is considerable effort to develop more sensitive methods to detect minimal residual disease (MRD) in bone marrow and blood samples of persons with cancer. Results of MRD-testing are used to predict clinical outcome and determine if more anti-cancer therapy is needed. Mathematical models were developed to assess factors affecting sensitivity and specificity of MRD-testing at diverse cancer cell prevalences. Modeling results and predictions were compared to results of large published studies.Accuracy of MRD-testing depends on cancer cell prevalence and distribution in the blood or bone marrow of the subject, sensitivity and specificity of the MRD-test and sample size. In subjects with low cancer cell prevalences (< or = 10(-4)) results of MRD testing are likely inaccurate. Increasingly sensitive MRD-tests are only marginally useful; the major obstacle to accuracy is inadequate sampling. Increasing sensitivity of methods to detect MRD is unlikely sufficient to increase accuracy of MRD-testing. In contrast, increased sampling (size and frequency) and assigning a high cut-off value (for example, > or = 10(-3)) to declare a MRD-test positive will increase sensitivity and specificity, respectively.

Risk-adapted treatment according to minimal residual disease in adult ALL

The evaluation of minimal residual disease (MRD) is a new diagnostic method which is applicable in various malignant disorders. Acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) is a somewhat ideal disease in this respect because >90% of the patients show individual clonal markers and because several methods for MRD evaluation are already established. Futhermore, it was demonstrated that level and course of MRD are significantly correlated with relapse risk in childhood and in adult ALL. In clinical practice MRD evaluation may serve for several purposes such as follow-up of individual course of disease, identification of new prognostic factors or evaluation of single treatment elements. We discuss these options as well as general considerations for MRD-based risk stratification and treatment options for risk groups. Practical applications are analysed because prospective MRD-based clinical trials have been recently started. Finally, future options for application of MRD evaluation and also limitations and pitfalls of this method are reviewed.

Chimerism testing and detection of minimal residual disease after allogeneic hematopoietic transplantation using the bioView (Duet) combined morphological and cytogenetical analysis

Recurrent disease remains a major obstacle to cure after allogeneic transplantation. Various methods have been developed to detect minimal residual disease (MRD) after transplantation to identify patients at risk for relapse. Chimerism tests differentiate recipient and donor cells and are used to identify MRD when there are no other disease-specific markers. The detection of MRD does not always correlate with relapse risk. Chimerism testing may also identify normal hematopoietic cells or other cells not contributing to relapse. In this study we report our initial experience with a novel system that provides combined morphological and cytogenetical analysis on the same cells. This system allows rapid automatic scanning of a large number of cells, thus increasing the sensitivity of detection of small recipient population. The clinical significance of MRD detection is improved by identifying the morphology of recipient cells. Identification of recipient characteristics within blasts predicts overt relapse in leukemia patients and precedes it by a few weeks to months. Identification within mature hematopoietic cells may not be closely associated with relapse. The system also allows chimerism testing after sex-mismatched transplants, within cellular subsets, with no need for sorting of cells. The system merits further study in larger scale trials.

Minimal residual disease in Brazilian children with acute lymphoid leukemia: comparison of three detection methods by PCR

The minimal residual disease (MRD) detection by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia has been pointed to be an adverse prognostic factor. Detection methods based on this technique using clone-specific primers are cumbersome and time consuming. The detection of monoclonal gene rearrangements of gamma T-cell receptors (TCRgamma) is a simpler although less sensitive method. In the present study, we analyzed the presence of MRD during four different phases of treatment (week 4; 3-6, 12-24 months, and end of treatment) in 34 Brazilian children with lymphoid leukemia by three detection methods based on the PCR technique: (1) using consensus primers for the detection of a clonal population for TCRgamma; (2) clone-specific primers for the junctional region of TCRgamma; and (3) a semi-nested reaction with an initial cycle with consensus primers followed by a second cycle with clone-specific primers. MRD presence was associated with a shorter event-free survival and was the major independent prognostic factor in most of the phases analyzed. The use of consensus primers for the detection of TCRgamma clonality, although less sensitive, proved to be a simpler, faster and less costly method whose positivity was associated with more than 90% relapse rates during all phases analyzed.

Studies of minimal residual disease in acute lymphocytic leukemia

During the past 2 decades, there has been considerable progress made in the treatment of childhood and adult lymphocytic leukemia (ALL). Currently, 70% to 90% of adults achieve a complete remission, and 25% to 50% of these patients may experience prolonged disease-free survival and may be cured of their disease. Unfortunately, most adults with ALL will ultimately experience a recurrence and die of their leukemia. Although most children with ALL may now be cured with current therapeutic regimens, the ability to distinguish good-risk patients from those who are likely to relapse has important clinical implications. Relapse, in most pediatric and adult cases, is thought to result from residual leukemia cells that remain following achievement of "complete" remission but are below the limits of detection using conventional morphologic assessment of the bone marrow. Sensitive techniques are now available to detect subclinical levels of residual leukemia, termed minimal residual disease.

Minimal residual disease in hematologic disorders

In almost no other area of medical oncology has the introduction of new drugs, combinations of chemotherapeutic agents, and novel biologic treatments caused such dramatic responses as it has in the treatment of malignant hematologic disorders. However, despite some therapeutic success, many patients relapse and die from recurrence of their disease. The implications of minimal residual disease (MRD), a term referring to disease that is undetectable by conventional morphologic methods, have therefore attracted increasing attention in recent years. New and powerful laboratory tools such as polymerase chain reaction assays have extraordinary sensitivity and provide exciting new insights into the detection, nature, quantification, and kinetics of MRD. This article summarizes methods used in the identification of MRD and its importance as exemplified in the case of acute leukemias and chronic myelogenous leukemia.

Detection of minimal residual disease: methods and relationship to outcome in T-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukemia

The molecular basis of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) of both B-cell and T-cell lineages seems better understood using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) methods. The analysis of clone-specific junctional regions of rearranged genes for both Immunoglobulin (Ig H) and T-cell receptor (TcR) is the most sensitive tool for detection of minimal residual disease (MRD) in ALL. Because of the heterogeneity of all ALL patients examined in several studies, the detection of MRD at different times of treatment has not as yet been correlated with disease outcome. In contrast, T-ALL is a homogeneous disease characterized by expansion of a single clone showing a specific Rearranged junctional region of TcR delta and/or gamma genes. The use of a clone-specific probe allows detection of residual leukemia throughout treatment. However, 60 % of patients with T-ALL relapse during treatment or towards the end of therapy, with resurgence of the original leukemic clone. It is possible that the detection of MRD at a specific time-point after diagnosis, as well as at the beginning of maintenance, may help to identify a group of T-ALL patients at high risk of relapse. The correlation between detection of MRD and treatment phase may be used in the future to evaluate whether treatment regimens can be improved allowing for stratification, based on PCR-mediated detection of MRD.

Molecular diagnosis of B- and T-cell lymphomas: fundamental principles and clinical applications

Molecular diagnostic assays have become routine in the evaluation of lymphoid malignancies. Both Southern transfer and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technologies are used to assess for B- and T-cell clonality, the presence of rearrangements involving protooncogenes such as bcl-1 and bcl-2, and the monitoring of minimal residual disease. We review the fundamentals of B- and T-cell ontogeny as well as the basic principles of the Southern transfer and PCR assays and their applications to the diagnosis of lymphoid malignancies.

Myelodysplasia and the leukemias

The armistice after World War II marked the beginning of an era that was to last to the end of the present century. It was an era in which many changes in medicine and nursing combined to alter the entire philosophy of managing malignant disease. More specifically, the fluid-phase tumors, which comprise myelodysplasia and the leukemias, were singled out for special attention. First there was the ease with which blood and bone marrow could be sampled, making serial investigations simple and practical. Second, cytotoxic drugs became available ranging from nitrogen mustard through cytosine arabinoside, the anthracycline antibiotics, and the epi-podophyllotoxins. Although cytomorphology of the hematopoietic tissue had been exquisitely defined with the use of Romanowsky stains coupled with electron microscopy, the diagnosis of leukemia was, before 1945, a death sentence for want of effective therapy. This changed dramatically with the introduction of the folate antagonists, and progress was unremitting as the range of new products expanded. Suddenly responses could be obtained with single agents, and fairly rapidly combinations were developed for cumulative antitumor effect. Many agents had undesirable toxicity among different organs. Although slightly different for myeloblastic or lymphoblastic variants, this approach produced apparent disease eradication. The concept of complete remission, both clinical and hematologic, was born. Some of our early enthusiasm has had to be tempered with the somber appreciation that not all patients can improve and many others experience relapses. Where then do we stand? Leukemic cells themselves seldom kill. It is the relentless and uncontrolled expansion of a neoplastic clone that leads to bone marrow failure, albeit at different rates in the various subtypes. In the acute forms, the common presentation remains symptomatic anemia, neutropenic sepsis, and thrombocytopenic bleeding. Differentiation from marrow aplasia may not be possible at first on clinical grounds, although bone tenderness, gingival hypertrophy, and skin infiltration are among the general useful differential signs. Findings in the circulation and the marrow are of cardinal importance in diagnosis; they provide the basis for classification. Improved accuracy has followed the introduction of cytochemical stains, and a widening range of monoclonal antibodies, and greater recourse to karyotyping, have enhanced diagnostic acumen. Treatment decisions rest on many variables or prognostic factors that include age, performance status, comorbidity, and disease category, with an ever increasing regard for the part played by cellular and molecular genetics. Despite skillful utilization of this wealth of information for optimal management, outcome often leaves much to be desired. Myelodysplasia encompasses a number of different syndromes in which the refractory anemias are indolent, whereas those with excess blasts progress toward overt leukemia. Considerable judgment is necessary in selecting patients for whom supportive therapy alone is appropriate and recognizing others, up to one third of patients for whom use growth factors that include erythropoietin, granulocyte or granulocyte monocyte-colony stimulating factors, and thrombopoietin can be justified. The often unfavorable result has been a stimulus to current investigations that examine the value of intensive chemotherapy or the more innovative bone marrow transplantation and its peripheral blood equivalent. Autografting is a newer alternative that does not have proved potential. Acute leukemia, whether myeloblastic or lymphoblastic, has been managed with mixed success. Remission rates have steadily increased and, notably among children, moved toward 100% in certain groupings. The downside of nonspecific drug regimens is that some patients simply may not respond, whereas others experience remissions and then relapses. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)