A comparison of some variational formulas for the free energy as applied to hard-sphere crystals

Renormalized phonons in nonlinear lattices: A variational approach

We propose a variational approach to study renormalized phonons in momentum-conserving nonlinear lattices with either symmetric or asymmetric potentials. To investigate the influence of pressure for phonon properties, we derive an inequality which provides both the lower and upper bound of the Gibbs free energy as the associated variational principle. This inequality is a direct extension to the Gibbs-Bogoliubov inequality. Taking the symmetry effect into account, the reference system for the variational approach is chosen to be harmonic with an asymmetric quadratic potential which contains variational parameters. We demonstrate the power of this approach by applying it to one-dimensional nonlinear lattices with a symmetric or asymmetric Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-type potential. For a system with a symmetric potential and zero pressure, we recover existing results. For other systems which are beyond the scope of existing theories, including those having symmetric potential and pressure and those having the asymmetric potential with or without pressure, we also obtain accurate sound velocity.