Global optimization and folding pathways of selected alpha-helical proteins

A Divide-and-Conquer Approach to Nanoparticle Global Optimisation Using Machine Learning

Global optimization of the structure of atomic nanoparticles is often hampered by the presence of many funnels on the potential energy surface. While broad funnels are readily encountered and easily exploited by the search, narrow funnels are more difficult to locate and explore, presenting a problem if the global minimum is situated in such a funnel. Here, a divide-and-conquer approach is applied to overcome the issue posed by the multifunnel effect using a machine learning approach, without using a priori knowledge of the potential energy surface. This approach begins with a truncated exploration to gather coarse-grained knowledge of the potential energy surface. This is then used to train a machine learning Gaussian mixture model to divide up the potential energy surface into separate regions, with each region then being explored in more detail (or conquered) separately. This scheme was tested on a variety of multifunnel systems and yielded significant improvements to the times taken to locate the global minima of Lennard-Jones (LJ) nanoparticles, LJ75 and LJ104, as well as two metallic systems, Au55 and Pd88. However, difficulties were encountered for LJ98, providing insight into how the scheme could be further improved.

Assessing RNA atomistic force fields via energy landscape explorations in implicit solvent

Predicting the structure and dynamics of RNA molecules still proves challenging because of the relative scarcity of experimental RNA structures on which to train models and the very sensitive nature of RNA towards its environment. In the last decade, several atomistic force fields specifically designed for RNA have been proposed and are commonly used for simulations. However, it is not necessarily clear which force field is the most suitable for a given RNA molecule. In this contribution, we propose the use of the computational energy landscape framework to explore the energy landscape of RNA systems as it can bring complementary information to the more standard approaches of enhanced sampling simulations based on molecular dynamics. We apply the EL framework to the study of a small RNA pseudoknot, the Aquifex aeolicus tmRNA pseudoknot PK1, and we compare the results of five different RNA force fields currently available in the AMBER simulation software, in implicit solvent. With this computational approach, we can not only compare the predicted 'native' states for the different force fields, but the method enables us to study metastable states as well. As a result, our comparison not only looks at structural features of low energy folded structures, but provides insight into folding pathways and higher energy excited states, opening to the possibility of assessing the validity of force fields also based on kinetics and experiments providing information on metastable and unfolded states.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12551-024-01202-9.

RNA Modeling with the Computational Energy Landscape Framework

The recent advances in computational abilities, such as the enormous speed-ups provided by GPU computing, allow for large scale computational studies of RNA molecules at an atomic level of detail. As RNA molecules are known to adopt multiple conformations with comparable energies, but different two-dimensional structures, all-atom models are necessary to better describe the structural ensembles for RNA molecules. This point is important because different conformations can exhibit different functions, and their regulation or mis-regulation is linked to a number of diseases. Problematically, the energy barriers between different conformational ensembles are high, resulting in long time scales for interensemble transitions. The computational potential energy landscape framework was designed to overcome this problem of broken ergodicity by use of geometry optimization. Here, we describe the algorithms used in the energy landscape explorations with the OPTIM and PATHSAMPLE programs, and how they are used in biomolecular simulations. We present a recent case study of the 5'-hairpin of RNA 7SK to illustrate how the method can be applied to interpret experimental results, and to obtain a detailed description of molecular properties.

Is the H4 histone tail intrinsically disordered or intrinsically multifunctional?

The structural versatility of histone tails is one of the key elements in the organisation of chromatin, which allows for the compact storage of genomic information. However, this structural diversity also complicates experimental and computational studies. Here, the potential and free energy landscape for the isolated and bound H4 histone tail are explored. The landscapes exhibit a set of distinct structural ensembles separated by high energy barriers, with little difference between isolated and bound tails. This consistency is a desirable feature that facilitates the formation of transient interactions, which are required for the liquid-like chromatin organisation. The existence of multiple, distinct structures on a multifunnel energy landscape is likely to be associated with multifunctionality, i.e. a set of evolved, distinct functions. Contrasting it with previously reported results for other disordered peptides, this type of landscape may be associated with a conformational selection based binding mechanism. Given the similarity to other systems exhibiting similar multifunnel energy landscapes, the disorder in histone tails might be better described in context of multifunctionality.

Energy Landscapes of Deoxyxylo- and Xylo-Nucleic Acid Octamers

Artificial analogues of the natural nucleic acids have attracted interest as a diverse class of information storage molecules capable of self-replication. In this study, we use the computational potential energy landscape framework to investigate the structural and dynamical properties of xylo- and deoxyxylo-nucleic acids (XyNA and dXyNA), which are derived from their respective RNA and DNA analogues by inversion of a single chiral center in the sugar moiety of the nucleotides. For an octameric XyNA sequence and the analogue dXyNA, we observe facile conformational transitions between a left-handed helix, which is the free energy global minimum, and a ladder-type structure with approximately zero helicity. The competing ensembles are better separated in the dXyNA, making it a more suitable candidate for a molecular switch, whereas the XyNA exhibits additional flexibility. Both energy landscapes exhibit greater frustration than we observe in RNA or DNA, in agreement with the higher degree of optimization expected from the principle of minimal frustration in evolved biomolecules.

Energy Landscapes of a Pair of Adsorbed Peptides

The wide relevance of peptide adsorption in natural and synthetic contexts means it has attracted much attention. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation has been widely used in these endeavors. Much of this has focused on single peptides due to the computational effort required to capture the rare events that characterize their adsorption. This focus is, however, of limited practical relevance as in reality, most systems of interest operate in the nondilute regime where peptides will interact with other adsorbed peptides. As an alternative to MD simulation, we have used energy landscape mapping (ELM) to investigate two met-enkephalin molecules adsorbed at a gas/graphite interface. Major conformations of the adsorbed peptides and the connecting transition states are elucidated along with the associated energy barriers and rates of exchange. The last of these makes clear that MD simulations are currently of limited use in probing the co-adsorption of two peptides, let alone more. The constant volume heat capacity as a function of temperature is also presented. Overall, this study represents a significant step toward characterizing peptide adsorption beyond the dilute limit.

Energy Landscapes of Mini-Dumbbell DNA Octanucleotides

Single-stranded DNA structures play a significant role in biological systems, in particular during replication, translation, and DNA repair. Tracts of simple repetitive DNA are associated with slipped-strand mispairing, which can lead to genetic diseases. Recent NMR studies of TTTA and CCTG repeats have shown that these sequences form mini-dumbbells (MDBs), leading to frameshift mutations. Here we explore the energy landscapes of (CCTG)₂ and (TTTA)₂, which are currently the smallest known molecules to form MDBs. While (CCTG)₂ MDBs are stable, (TTTA)₂ exhibits numerous other structures with lower energies. A key factor identified in the stabilization of MDB structures is the bonding strength between residues 1 and 4, and 5 and 8.

Energy Landscapes for the Aggregation of Aβ17-42

The aggregation of the Aβ peptide (Aβ_1-42) to form fibrils is a key feature of Alzheimer's disease. The mechanism is thought to be a nucleation stage followed by an elongation process. The elongation stage involves the consecutive addition of monomers to one end of the growing fibril. The aggregation process proceeds in a stop-and-go fashion and may involve off-pathway aggregates, complicating experimental and computational studies. Here we present exploration of a well-defined region in the free and potential energy landscapes for the Aβ_17-42 pentamer. We find that the ideal aggregation process agrees with the previously reported dock-lock mechanism. We also analyze a large number of additional stable structures located on the multifunnel energy landscape, which constitute kinetic traps. The key contributors to the formation of such traps are misaligned strong interactions, for example the stacking of F19 and F20, as well as entropic contributions. Our results suggest that folding templates for aggregation are a necessity and that aggregation studies could employ such species to obtain a more detailed description of the process.

Segmenting Proteins into Tripeptides to Enhance Conformational Sampling with Monte Carlo Methods

This paper presents an approach to enhance conformational sampling of proteins employing stochastic algorithms such as Monte Carlo (MC) methods. The approach is based on a mechanistic representation of proteins and on the application of methods originating from robotics. We outline the general ideas of our approach and detail how it can be applied to construct several MC move classes, all operating on a shared representation of the molecule and using a single mathematical solver. We showcase these sampling techniques on several types of proteins. Results show that combining several move classes, which can be easily implemented thanks to the proposed approach, significantly improves sampling efficiency.

Markov state modeling and dynamical coarse-graining via discrete relaxation path sampling

A method is derived to coarse-grain the dynamics of complex molecular systems to a Markov jump process (MJP) describing how the system jumps between cells that fully partition its state space. The main inputs are relaxation times for each pair of cells, which are shown to be robust with respect to positioning of the cell boundaries. These relaxation times can be calculated via molecular dynamics simulations performed in each cell separately and are used in an efficient estimator for the rate matrix of the MJP. The method is illustrated through applications to Sinai billiards and a cluster of Lennard-Jones discs.

Protofold II: Enhanced Model and Implementation for Kinetostatic Protein Folding1

A reliable prediction of three-dimensional (3D) protein structures from sequence data remains a big challenge due to both theoretical and computational difficulties. We have previously shown that our kinetostatic compliance method (KCM) implemented into the Protofold package can overcome some of the key difficulties faced by other de novo structure prediction methods, such as the very small time steps required by the molecular dynamics (MD) approaches or the very large number of samples needed by the Monte Carlo (MC) sampling techniques. In this paper, we improve the free energy formulation used in Protofold by including the typically underrated entropic effects, imparted due to differences in hydrophobicity of the chemical groups, which dominate the folding of most water-soluble proteins. In addition to the model enhancement, we revisit the numerical implementation by redesigning the algorithms and introducing efficient data structures that reduce the expected complexity from quadratic to linear. Moreover, we develop and optimize parallel implementations of the algorithms on both central and graphics processing units (CPU/GPU) achieving speed-ups up to two orders of magnitude on the GPU. Our simulations are consistent with the general behavior observed in the folding process in aqueous solvent, confirming the effectiveness of model improvements. We report on the folding process at multiple levels, namely, the formation of secondary structural elements and tertiary interactions between secondary elements or across larger domains. We also observe significant enhancements in running times that make the folding simulation tractable for large molecules.

Conformational Interconversions of Amino Acid Derivatives

Exhaustive conformational interconversions including transition structure analyses of N-acetyl-l-glycine-N-methylamide as well as its alanine, serine, and cysteine analogues have been investigated at the MP2/6-31G** level, yielding a total of 142 transition states. Improved estimates of relative energies were obtained by separately extrapolating the Hartree-Fock and MP2 energies to the basis set limit and adding the difference between CCSD(T) and MP2 results with the cc-pVDZ basis set to the extrapolated MP2 results. The performance of eight empirical force fields (AMBER94, AMBER14SB, MM2, MM3, MMFFs, CHARMM22_CMAP, OPLS_2005, and AMOEBAPRO13) in reproducing ab initio energies of transition states was tested. Our results indicate that commonly used class I force fields employing a fixed partial charge model for the electrostatic interaction provide mean errors in the ∼10 kJ/mol range for energies of conformational transition states for amino acid conformers. Modern reparametrized versions, such as CHARMM22_CMAP, and polarizable force fields, such as AMOEBAPRO13, have slightly lower mean errors, but maximal errors are still in the 35 kJ/mol range. There are differences between the force fields in their ability for reproducing conformational transitions classified according to backbone/side-chain or regions in the Ramachandran angles, but the data set is likely too small to draw any general conclusions. Errors in conformational interconversion barriers by ∼10 kJ/mol suggest that the commonly used force field may bias certain types of transitions by several orders of magnitude in rate and thus lead to incorrect dynamics in simulations. It is therefore suggested that information for conformational transition states should be included in parametrizations of new force fields.

Energy landscapes of a hairpin peptide including NMR chemical shift restraints

Methods recently introduced to improve the efficiency of protein structure prediction simulations by adding a restraint potential to a molecular mechanics force field introduce additional input parameters that can affect the performance. Here we investigate the changes in the energy landscape as the relative weight of the two contributions, force field and restraint potential, is systematically altered, for restraint functions constructed from calculated nuclear magnetic resonance chemical shifts. Benchmarking calculations were performed on a 12-residue peptide, tryptophan zipper 1, which features both secondary structure (a β-hairpin) and specific packing of tryptophan sidechains. Basin-hopping global optimization was performed to assess the efficiency with which lowest-energy structures are located, and the discrete path sampling approach was employed to survey the energy landscapes between unfolded and folded structures. We find that inclusion of the chemical shift restraints improves the efficiency of structure prediction because the energy landscape becomes more funnelled and the proportion of local minima classified as native increases. However, the funnelling nature of the landscape is reduced as the relative contribution of the chemical shift restraint potential is increased past an optimal value.

Equilibration of Protein States: A Time Dependent Free-Energy Disconnectivity Graph

The process of equilibration of protein states in a three-stranded antiparallel β-sheet miniprotein is studied using a time-dependent free energy disconnectivity graph. To determine the rates of transitions, the molecular dynamics simulation results of a recent work (Kalgin, I. V.; J. Phys. Chem. B 2013, 117, 6092) are employed. The vertices of the graph are the free energies of characteristic states of the protein, and the edges are the transition state free energies. To determine the latter, the "complete" partition function (Eyring, 1935) is used, which includes the translational partition function corresponding to the ballistic motion of the system along the reaction coordinate. The distance along the reaction coordinate that enters the translational partition function is taken to be proportional to the observation time and thus measures the number of representative points that cross the transition state surface during given time. As the time increases, the free energy barriers between the clusters of characteristic conformations (native-like, helical, and β-sheet conformations of different degree of organization) decrease and (local) equilibrium between the clusters is established. With time, these clusters are grouped into larger clusters, extending the equilibrium to a larger portion of protein states.

Analysis of the Contrasting Pathogenicities Induced by the D222G Mutation in 1918 and 2009 Pandemic Influenza A Viruses

In 2009, the D222G mutation in the hemagglutinin (HA) glycoprotein of pandemic H1N1 influenza A virus was found to correlate with fatal and severe human infections. Previous static structural analysis suggested that, unlike the H1N1 viruses prevalent in 1918, the mutation did not compromise binding to human α2,6-linked glycan receptors, allowing it to transmit efficiently. Here we investigate the interconversion mechanism between two predicted binding modes in both 2009 and 1918 HAs, introducing a highly parallel intermediate network search scheme to construct kinetically relevant pathways efficiently. Accumulated mutations at positions 183 and 224 that alter the size of the binding pocket are identified with the fitness of the 2009 pandemic virus carrying the D222G mutation. This result suggests that the pandemic H1N1 viruses could gain binding affinity to the α2,3-linked glycan receptors in the lungs, usually associated with highly pathogenic avian influenza, without compromising viability.

The role of binding site on the mechanical unfolding mechanism of ubiquitin

We apply novel atomistic simulations based on potential energy surface exploration to investigate the constant force-induced unfolding of ubiquitin. At the experimentally-studied force clamping level of 100 pN, we find a new unfolding mechanism starting with the detachment between β₅ and β₃ involving the binding site of ubiquitin, the Ile44 residue. This new unfolding pathway leads to the discovery of new intermediate configurations, which correspond to the end-to-end extensions previously seen experimentally. More importantly, it demonstrates the novel finding that the binding site of ubiquitin can be responsible not only for its biological functions, but also its unfolding dynamics. We also report in contrast to previous single molecule constant force experiments that when the clamping force becomes smaller than about 300 pN, the number of intermediate configurations increases dramatically, where almost all unfolding events at 100 pN involve an intermediate configuration. By directly calculating the life times of the intermediate configurations from the height of the barriers that were crossed on the potential energy surface, we demonstrate that these intermediate states were likely not observed experimentally due to their lifetimes typically being about two orders of magnitude smaller than the experimental temporal resolution.

Protein structure prediction: assembly of secondary structure elements by basin-hopping

The prediction of protein tertiary structure from primary structure remains a challenging task. One possible approach to this problem is the application of basin-hopping global optimization combined with an all-atom force field. In this work, the efficiency of basin-hopping is improved by introducing an approach that derives tertiary structures from the secondary structure assignments of individual residues. This approach is termed secondary-to-tertiary basin-hopping and benchmarked for three miniproteins: trpzip, trp-cage and ER-10. For each of the three miniproteins, the secondary-to-tertiary basin-hopping approach successfully and reliably predicts their three-dimensional structure. When it is applied to larger proteins, correctly folded structures are obtained. It can be concluded that the assembly of secondary structure elements using basin-hopping is a promising tool for de novo protein structure prediction.

Graph representation of protein free energy landscape

The thermodynamics and kinetics of protein folding and protein conformational changes are governed by the underlying free energy landscape. However, the multidimensional nature of the free energy landscape makes it difficult to describe. We propose to use a weighted-graph approach to depict the free energy landscape with the nodes on the graph representing the conformational states and the edge weights reflecting the free energy barriers between the states. Our graph is constructed from a molecular dynamics trajectory and does not involve projecting the multi-dimensional free energy landscape onto a low-dimensional space defined by a few order parameters. The calculation of free energy barriers was based on transition-path theory using the MSMBuilder2 package. We compare our graph with the widely used transition disconnectivity graph (TRDG) which is constructed from the same trajectory and show that our approach gives more accurate description of the free energy landscape than the TRDG approach even though the latter can be organized into a simple tree representation. The weighted-graph is a general approach and can be used on any complex system.

Euclidean sections of protein conformation space and their implications in dimensionality reduction

Dimensionality reduction is widely used in searching for the intrinsic reaction coordinates for protein conformational changes. We find the dimensionality-reduction methods using the pairwise root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) as the local distance metric face a challenge. We use Isomap as an example to illustrate the problem. We believe that there is an implied assumption for the dimensionality-reduction approaches that aim to preserve the geometric relations between the objects: both the original space and the reduced space have the same kind of geometry, such as Euclidean geometry vs. Euclidean geometry or spherical geometry vs. spherical geometry. When the protein free energy landscape is mapped onto a 2D plane or 3D space, the reduced space is Euclidean, thus the original space should also be Euclidean. For a protein with N atoms, its conformation space is a subset of the 3N-dimensional Euclidean space R(3N). We formally define the protein conformation space as the quotient space of R(3N) by the equivalence relation of rigid motions. Whether the quotient space is Euclidean or not depends on how it is parameterized. When the pairwise RMSD is employed as the local distance metric, implicit representations are used for the protein conformation space, leading to no direct correspondence to a Euclidean set. We have demonstrated that an explicit Euclidean-based representation of protein conformation space and the local distance metric associated to it improve the quality of dimensionality reduction in the tetra-peptide and β-hairpin systems.

Observation time scale, free-energy landscapes, and molecular symmetry

When structures that interconvert on a given time scale are lumped together, the corresponding free-energy surface becomes a function of the observation time. This view is equivalent to grouping structures that are connected by free-energy barriers below a certain threshold. We illustrate this time dependence for some benchmark systems, namely atomic clusters and alanine dipeptide, highlighting the connections to broken ergodicity, local equilibrium, and "feasible" symmetry operations of the molecular Hamiltonian.

Dual effect of crowders on fibrillation kinetics of polypeptide chains revealed by lattice models

We have developed the lattice model for describing polypeptide chains in the presence of crowders. The influence of crowding confinement on the fibrillation kinetics of polypeptide chains is studied using this model. We observed the non-trivial behavior of the fibril formation time τfib that it decreases with the concentration of crowders if crowder sizes are large enough, but the growth is observed for crowders of small sizes. This allows us to explain the recent experimental observation on the dual effect of crowding particles on fibril growth of proteins that for a fixed crowder concentration the fibrillation kinetics is fastest at intermediate values of total surface of crowders. It becomes slow at either small or large coverages of cosolutes. It is shown that due to competition between the energetics and entropic effects, the dependence of τfib on the size of confined space is described by a parabolic function.

Exploring Energy Landscapes: Metrics, Pathways, and Normal-Mode Analysis for Rigid-Body Molecules

We present new methodology for exploring the energy landscapes of molecular systems, using angle-axis variables for the rigid-body rotational coordinates. The key ingredient is a distance measure or metric tensor, which is invariant to global translation and rotation. The metric is used to formulate a generalized nudged elastic band method for calculating pathways, and a full prescription for normal-mode analysis is described. The methodology is tested by mapping the potential energy and free energy landscape of the water octamer, described by the TIP4P potential.

Learning Kinetic Distance Metrics for Markov State Models of Protein Conformational Dynamics

Statistical modeling of long timescale dynamics with Markov state models (MSMs) has been shown to be an effective strategy for building quantitative and qualitative insight into protein folding processes. Existing methodologies, however, rely on geometric clustering using distance metrics such as root mean square deviation (RMSD), assuming that geometric similarity provides an adequate basis for the kinetic partitioning of phase space. Here, inspired by advances in the machine learning community, we introduce a new approach for learning a distance metric explicitly constructed to model kinetic similarity. This approach enables the construction of models, especially in the regime of high anisotropy in the diffusion constant, with fewer states than was previously possible. Application of this technique to the analysis of two ultralong molecular dynamics simulations of the FiP35 WW domain identifies discrete near-native relaxation dynamics in the millisecond regime that were not resolved in previous analyses.

Temporal disconnectivity of the energy landscape in glassy systems

An alternative graphical representation of the potential energy landscape (PEL) has been developed and applied to a binary Lennard-Jones glassy system, providing insight into the unique topology of the system's potential energy hypersurface. With the help of this representation one is able to monitor the different explored basins of the PEL, as well as how--and mainly when--subsets of basins communicate with each other via transitions in such a way that details of the prior temporal history have been erased, i.e., local equilibration between the basins in each subset has been achieved. In this way, apart from detailed information about the structure of the PEL, the system's temporal evolution on the PEL is described. In order to gather all necessary information about the identities of two or more basins that are connected with each other, we consider two different approaches. The first one is based on consideration of the time needed for two basins to mutually equilibrate their populations according to the transition rate between them, in the absence of any effect induced by the rest of the landscape. The second approach is based on an analytical solution of the master equation that explicitly takes into account the entire explored landscape. It is shown that both approaches lead to the same result concerning the topology of the PEL and dynamical evolution on it. Moreover, a "temporal disconnectivity graph" is introduced to represent a lumped system stemming from the initial one. The lumped system is obtained via a specially designed algorithm [N. Lempesis, D. G. Tsalikis, G. C. Boulougouris, and D. N. Theodorou, J. Chem. Phys. 135, 204507 (2011)]. The temporal disconnectivity graph provides useful information about both the lumped and the initial systems, including the definition of "metabasins" as collections of basins that communicate with each other via transitions that are fast relative to the observation time. Finally, the two examined approaches are compared to an "on the fly" molecular dynamics-based algorithm [D. G. Tsalikis, N. Lempesis, G. C. Boulougouris, and D. N. Theodorou, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 6, 1307 (2010)].

Protein structure prediction using global optimization by basin-hopping with NMR shift restraints

Computational methods that utilize chemical shifts to produce protein structures at atomic resolution have recently been introduced. In the current work, we exploit chemical shifts by combining the basin-hopping approach to global optimization with chemical shift restraints using a penalty function. For three peptides, we demonstrate that this approach allows us to find near-native structures from fully extended structures within 10,000 basin-hopping steps. The effect of adding chemical shift restraints is that the α and β secondary structure elements form within 1000 basin-hopping steps, after which the orientation of the secondary structure elements, which produces the tertiary contacts, is driven by the underlying protein force field. We further show that our chemical shift-restraint BH approach also works for incomplete chemical shift assignments, where the information from only one chemical shift type is considered. For the proper implementation of chemical shift restraints in the basin-hopping approach, we determined the optimal weight of the chemical shift penalty energy with respect to the CHARMM force field in conjunction with the FACTS solvation model employed in this study. In order to speed up the local energy minimization procedure, we developed a function, which continuously decreases the width of the chemical shift penalty function as the minimization progresses. We conclude that the basin-hopping approach with chemical shift restraints is a promising method for protein structure prediction.

Basin Hopping as a General and Versatile Optimization Framework for the Characterization of Biological Macromolecules

Since its introduction, the basin hopping (BH) framework has proven useful for hard nonlinear optimization problems with multiple variables and modalities. Applications span a wide range, from packing problems in geometry to characterization of molecular states in statistical physics. BH is seeing a reemergence in computational structural biology due to its ability to obtain a coarse-grained representation of the protein energy surface in terms of local minima. In this paper, we show that the BH framework is general and versatile, allowing to address problems related to the characterization of protein structure, assembly, and motion due to its fundamental ability to sample minima in a high-dimensional variable space. We show how specific implementations of the main components in BH yield algorithmic realizations that attain state-of-the-art results in the context of ab initio protein structure prediction and rigid protein-protein docking. We also show that BH can map intermediate minima related with motions connecting diverse stable functionally relevant states in a protein molecule, thus serving as a first step towards the characterization of transition trajectories connecting these states.

Native state conformational heterogeneity of HP35 revealed by time-resolved FRET

The villin headpiece subdomain (HP35) has become one of the most widely used model systems in protein folding studies, due to its small size and ultrafast folding kinetics. Here, we use HP35 as a test bed to show that the fluorescence decay kinetics of an unnatural amino acid, p-cyanophenylalanine (Phe(CN)), which are modulated by a nearby quencher (e.g., tryptophan or 7-azatryptophan) through the mechanism of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), can be used to detect protein conformational heterogeneity. This method is based on the notion that protein conformations having different donor-acceptor distances and interconverting slowly compared to the fluorescence lifetime of the donor (Phe(CN)) would exhibit different donor fluorescence lifetimes. Our results provide strong evidence suggesting that the native free energy basin of HP35 is populated with conformations that differ mostly in the position and mean helicity of the C-terminal helix. This finding is consistent with several previous experimental and computational studies. Moreover, this result holds strong implications for computational investigation of the folding mechanism of HP35.

MC EMiNEM maps the interaction landscape of the Mediator

The Mediator is a highly conserved, large multiprotein complex that is involved essentially in the regulation of eukaryotic mRNA transcription. It acts as a general transcription factor by integrating regulatory signals from gene-specific activators or repressors to the RNA Polymerase II. The internal network of interactions between Mediator subunits that conveys these signals is largely unknown. Here, we introduce MC EMiNEM, a novel method for the retrieval of functional dependencies between proteins that have pleiotropic effects on mRNA transcription. MC EMiNEM is based on Nested Effects Models (NEMs), a class of probabilistic graphical models that extends the idea of hierarchical clustering. It combines mode-hopping Monte Carlo (MC) sampling with an Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm for NEMs to increase sensitivity compared to existing methods. A meta-analysis of four Mediator perturbation studies in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, three of which are unpublished, provides new insight into the Mediator signaling network. In addition to the known modular organization of the Mediator subunits, MC EMiNEM reveals a hierarchical ordering of its internal information flow, which is putatively transmitted through structural changes within the complex. We identify the N-terminus of Med7 as a peripheral entity, entailing only local structural changes upon perturbation, while the C-terminus of Med7 and Med19 appear to play a central role. MC EMiNEM associates Mediator subunits to most directly affected genes, which, in conjunction with gene set enrichment analysis, allows us to construct an interaction map of Mediator subunits and transcription factors.

Evolution of the potential energy landscape with static pulling force for two model proteins

The energy landscape is analyzed for off-lattice bead models of protein L and protein G as a function of a static pulling force. Two different pairs of attachment points (pulling directions) are compared in each case, namely, residues 1/56 and 10/32. For the terminal residue pulling direction 1/56, the distinct global minimum structures are all extended, aside from the compact geometry that correlates with zero force. The helical turns finally disappear at the highest pulling forces considered. For the 10/32 pulling direction, the changes are more complicated, with a variety of competing arrangements for beads outside the region where the force is directly applied. These alternatives produce frustrated energy landscapes, with low-lying minima separated by high barriers. The calculated folding pathways in the absence of force are in good agreement with previous work. The N-terminal hairpin folds first for protein L and the C-terminal hairpin for protein G, which exhibits an intermediate. However, for a relatively low static force, where the global minimum retains its structure, the folding mechanisms change, sometimes dramatically, depending on the protein and the attachment points. The scaling relations predicted by catastrophe theory are found to hold in the limit of short path lengths.

Energy landscapes of colloidal clusters: thermodynamics and rearrangement mechanisms

New experiments involving direct observation of colloidal clusters by optical microscopy promise to deliver a wealth of new information about such systems. Calculations suggest that some of the observable properties may be predicted using a simple pairwise potential to represent the interparticle forces, but in a range of parameter space that is distinctly different from previous representations of atomic clusters. The present contribution provides some benchmark calculations and predictions of structure, thermodynamics and rearrangement mechanisms for colloidal clusters containing up to 80 particles. The results suggest that distinct features characteristic of short-ranged interactions should be observable in terms of the structure, thermodynamics and dynamical properties. Analysis of a kinetic transition network for the 19-particle cluster reveals super-Arrhenius behaviour in the dynamics, analogous to a 'fragile' glass-former.

Performance assessment of different constraining potentials in computational structure prediction for disulfide-bridged proteins

The presence of disulfide bonds in proteins has very important implications on the three-dimensional structure and folding of proteins. An adequate treatment of disulfide bonds in de-novo protein simulations is therefore very important. Here we present a computational study of a set of small disulfide-bridged proteins using an all-atom stochastic search approach and including various constraining potentials to describe the disulfide bonds. The proposed potentials can easily be implemented in any code based on all-atom force fields and employed in simulations to achieve an improved prediction of protein structure. Exploring different potential parameters and comparing the structures to those from unconstrained simulations and to experimental structures by means of a scoring function we demonstrate that the inclusion of constraining potentials improves the quality of final structures significantly. For some proteins (1KVG and 1PG1) the native conformation is visited only in simulations in presence of constraints. Overall, we found that the Morse potential has optimal performance, in particular for the β-sheet proteins.

Modelling proteins: conformational sampling and reconstruction of folding kinetics

In the last decades biomolecular simulation has made tremendous inroads to help elucidate biomolecular processes in-silico. Despite enormous advances in molecular dynamics techniques and the available computational power, many problems involve long time scales and large-scale molecular rearrangements that are still difficult to sample adequately. In this review we therefore summarise recent efforts to fundamentally improve this situation by decoupling the sampling of the energy landscape from the description of the kinetics of the process. Recent years have seen the emergence of many advanced sampling techniques, which permit efficient characterisation of the relevant family of molecular conformations by dispensing with the details of the short-term kinetics of the process. Because these methods generate thermodynamic information at best, they must be complemented by techniques to reconstruct the kinetics of the process using the ensemble of relevant conformations. Here we review recent advances for both types of methods and discuss their perspectives to permit efficient and accurate modelling of large-scale conformational changes in biomolecules. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein Dynamics: Experimental and Computational Approaches.

The energy landscape, folding pathways and the kinetics of a knotted protein

The folding pathway and rate coefficients of the folding of a knotted protein are calculated for a potential energy function with minimal energetic frustration. A kinetic transition network is constructed using the discrete path sampling approach, and the resulting potential energy surface is visualized by constructing disconnectivity graphs. Owing to topological constraints, the low-lying portion of the landscape consists of three distinct regions, corresponding to the native knotted state and to configurations where either the N or C terminus is not yet folded into the knot. The fastest folding pathways from denatured states exhibit early formation of the N terminus portion of the knot and a rate-determining step where the C terminus is incorporated. The low-lying minima with the N terminus knotted and the C terminus free therefore constitute an off-pathway intermediate for this model. The insertion of both the N and C termini into the knot occurs late in the folding process, creating large energy barriers that are the rate limiting steps in the folding process. When compared to other protein folding proteins of a similar length, this system folds over six orders of magnitude more slowly.

Probing the folding transition state structure of the villin headpiece subdomain via side chain and backbone mutagenesis

Backbone-backbone hydrogen bonds are a common feature of native protein structures, yet their thermodynamic and kinetic influence on folding has long been debated. This is reflected by the disparity between current protein folding models, which place hydrogen bond formation at different stages along the folding trajectory. For example, previous studies have suggested that the denatured state of the villin headpiece subdomain contains a residual helical structure that may provide a bias toward the folded state by confining the conformational search associated with its folding. Although helical hydrogen bonds clearly stabilize the folded state, here we show, using an amide-to-ester mutation strategy, that the formation of backbone hydrogen bonds within helices is not rate-limiting in the folding of the subdomain, thereby suggesting that such hydrogen bonds are unlikely to be formed en route from the denatured to the transition state. On the other hand, elimination of hydrogen bonds within the turn region elicits a slower folding rate, consistent with the hypothesis that these residues are involved in the formation of a folding nucleus. While illustrating a potentially conserved aspect of helix-turn-helix folding, our results further underscore the inherent importance of turns in protein supersecondary structure formation.