On the reality of residual entropies of glasses and disordered crystals

Configurational entropy of glass-forming liquids

The configurational entropy is one of the most important thermodynamic quantities characterizing supercooled liquids approaching the glass transition. Despite decades of experimental, theoretical, and computational investigation, a widely accepted definition of the configurational entropy is missing, its quantitative characterization remains fraught with difficulties, misconceptions, and paradoxes, and its physical relevance is vividly debated. Motivated by recent computational progress, we offer a pedagogical perspective on the configurational entropy in glass-forming liquids. We first explain why the configurational entropy has become a key quantity to describe glassy materials, from early empirical observations to modern theoretical treatments. We explain why practical measurements necessarily require approximations that make its physical interpretation delicate. We then demonstrate that computer simulations have become an invaluable tool to obtain precise, nonambiguous, and experimentally relevant measurements of the configurational entropy. We describe a panel of available computational tools, offering for each method a critical discussion. This perspective should be useful to both experimentalists and theoreticians interested in glassy materials and complex systems.

Reply to "Comment on 'Glass Transition, Crystallization of Glass-Forming Melts, and Entropy"' by Zanotto and Mauro

A response is given to a comment of Zanotto and Mauro on our paper published in Entropy 20, 103 (2018). Our arguments presented in this paper are widely ignored by them, and no new considerations are outlined in the comment, which would require a revision of our conclusions. For this reason, we restrict ourselves here to a brief response, supplementing it by some additional arguments in favor of our point of view not included in our above-cited paper.

On the Possibility of Calculating Entropy, Free Energy, and Enthalpy of Vitreous Substances

A critical analysis for the arguments in support of, and against, the traditional approach to thermodynamics of vitreous state is provided. In this approach one presumes that there is a continuous variation of the entropy in the glass-liquid transition temperature range, or a "continuous entropy approach" towards 0 K which produces a positive value of the entropy at T → 0 K. I find that arguments given against this traditional approach use a different understanding of the thermodynamics of glass transition on cooling a liquid, because it suggests a discontinuity or "entropy loss approach" in the variation of entropy in the glass-liquid transition range. That is based on: (1) an unjustifiable use of the classical Boltzmann statistics for interpreting the value of entropy at absolute zero; (2) the rejection of thermodynamic analysis of systems with broken ergodicity, even though the possibility of analogous analysis was proposed already by Gibbs; (3) the possibility of a finite change in entropy of a system without absorption or release of heat; and, (4) describing the thermodynamic properties of glasses in the framework of functions, instead of functionals. The last one is necessary because for glasses the entropy and enthalpy are not functions of the state, but functionals, as defined by Gibbs' in his classification.

Hierarchy of Relaxation Times and Residual Entropy: A Nonequilibrium Approach

We consider nonequilibrium (NEQ) states such as supercooled liquids and glasses that are described with the use of internal variables. We classify the latter by the state-dependent hierarchy of relaxation times to assess their relevance for irreversible contributions. Given an observation time τobs, we determine the window of relaxation times that divide the internal variables into active and inactive groups, the former playing a central role in the NEQ thermodynamics. Using this thermodynamics, we determine (i) a bound on the NEQ entropy and on the residual entropy and (ii) the nature of the isothermal relaxation of the entropy and the enthalpy in accordance with the second law. A theory that violates the second law such as the entropy loss view is shown to be internally inconsistent if we require it to be consistent with experiments. The inactive internal variables still play an indirect role in determining the temperature T(t) and the pressure P(t) of the system, which deviate from their external values.

Glass Transition, Crystallization of Glass-Forming Melts, and Entropy

A critical analysis of possible (including some newly proposed) definitions of the vitreous state and the glass transition is performed and an overview of kinetic criteria of vitrification is presented. On the basis of these results, recent controversial discussions on the possible values of the residual entropy of glasses are reviewed. Our conclusion is that the treatment of vitrification as a process of continuously breaking ergodicity with entropy loss and a residual entropy tending to zero in the limit of zero absolute temperature is in disagreement with the absolute majority of experimental and theoretical investigations of this process and the nature of the vitreous state. This conclusion is illustrated by model computations. In addition to the main conclusion derived from these computations, they are employed as a test for several suggestions concerning the behavior of thermodynamic coefficients in the glass transition range. Further, a brief review is given on possible ways of resolving the Kauzmann paradox and its implications with respect to the validity of the third law of thermodynamics. It is shown that neither in its primary formulations nor in its consequences does the Kauzmann paradox result in contradictions with any basic laws of nature. Such contradictions are excluded by either crystallization (not associated with a pseudospinodal as suggested by Kauzmann) or a conventional (and not an ideal) glass transition. Some further so far widely unexplored directions of research on the interplay between crystallization and glass transition are anticipated, in which entropy may play—beyond the topics widely discussed and reviewed here—a major role.

Celebrating Soft Matter's 10th anniversary: Testing the foundations of classical entropy: colloid experiments

Defining the entropy of classical particles raises a number of paradoxes and ambiguities, some of which have been known for over a century. Several, such as Gibbs' paradox, involve the fact that classical particles are distinguishable, and in textbooks these are often 'resolved' by appeal to the quantum-mechanical indistinguishability of atoms or molecules of the same type. However, questions then remain of how to correctly define the entropy of large poly-atomic particles such as colloids in suspension, of which no two are exactly alike. By performing experiments on such colloids, one can establish that certain definitions of the classical entropy fit the data, while others in the literature do not. Specifically, the experimental facts point firmly to an 'informatic' interpretation that dates back to Gibbs: entropy is determined by the number of microstates that we as observers choose to treat as equivalent when we identify a macrostate. This approach, unlike some others, can account for the existence of colloidal crystals, and for the observed abundances of colloidal clusters of different shapes. We also address some lesser-known paradoxes whereby the physics of colloidal assemblies, which ought to be purely classical, seems to involve quantum mechanics directly. The experimental symptoms of such involvement are predicted to be 'isotope effects' in which colloids with different inertial masses, but otherwise identical sizes and properties, show different aggregation statistics. These paradoxes are caused by focussing one's attention on some classical degrees while neglecting others; when all are treated equally, all isotope effects are found to vanish.

Change in entropy in thermal hysteresis of liquid-glass-liquid transition and consequences of violating the Clausius theorem

Change in the entropy, dS, with change in the temperature T, with or without phase transformation, is determined only if the thermal path is reversible. For an irreversible thermal path, dS > dqirrev/T, an expression known as inequality in the Clausius theorem. In the glass formation range, Cp and enthalpy show a time-dependent hysteresis between the cooling and heating paths and the two Cp paths cross each other. We provide new data on Cp of poly(styrene) and use the previous Cp data [E. Tombari, C. Ferrari, G. Salvetti, and G. P. Johari, Phys. Rev. B 78, 144203 (2008)], both data obtained from measurements performed on cooling from melt to glass and heating from glass to melt at unusually slow rates, and show that violation of the Clausius theorem in such cases has insignificant consequences for determining the entropy of glass. We also report Cp of the samples annealed for different times at different temperatures in which the enthalpy spontaneously decreased. These measurements also show that violation of the Clausius theorem is relatively inconsequential for interpreting the entropy of the glassy state.

Paramagnetic and glass transitions in sudoku

We study the statistical mechanics of a model glassy system based on sudoku, a familiar and popular mathematical puzzle. Sudoku puzzles provide a very rare example of a class of frustrated systems with a unique ground state without symmetry. Here, the puzzle is recast as a thermodynamic system where the number of violated rules defines the energy. We use Monte Carlo simulation to show that the "sudoku Hamiltonian" exhibits two transitions as a function of temperature, a paramagnetic, and a glass transition. Of these, the intermediate condensed phase is the only one that visits the ground state (i.e., it solves the puzzle, though this is not the purpose of the study). Both transitions are associated with an entropy change, paramagnetism measured from the dynamics of the Monte Carlo run, showing a peak in specific heat, while the residual glass entropy is determined by finding multiple instances of the glass by repeated annealing. There are relatively few such simple models for frustrated or glassy systems that exhibit both ordering and glass transitions; sudoku puzzles are unique for the ease with which they can be obtained, with the proof of the existence of a unique ground state via the satisfiability of all constraints. Simulations suggest that in the glass phase there is an increase in information entropy with lowering temperature. In fact, we have shown that sudoku puzzles have the type of rugged energy landscape with multiple minima that typifies glasses in many physical systems. This puzzling result is a manifestation of the paradox of the residual glass entropy. These readily available puzzles can now be used as solvable model Hamiltonian systems for studying the glass transition.

Mechanical relaxation and the notion of time-dependent extent of ergodicity during the glass transition

A postulate that ergodicity and entropy continuously decrease to zero on cooling a liquid to a glassy state was used to support the view that glass has no residual entropy, and the features of mechanical relaxation spectra were cited as proof for the decrease. We investigate whether such spectra and the relaxation isochrones can serve as the proof. We find that an increase in the real component of elastic moduli with an increase in spectral frequency does not indicate continuous loss of ergodicity and entropy, and the spectra do not confirm isothermal glass transition or loss of entropy. Variation in ergodicity and entropy with the spectral frequency has untenable consequences for both thermodynamics and molecular dynamics and implies that, despite a broad distribution of its relaxation times, an equilibrium liquid can be considered as always ergodic. Perturbation from equilibrium used to obtain a spectrum does not have the effect of dynamic freezing and unfreezing, and Maxwell-Voigt models for the mechanical response function have neither the characteristic irreversibility of liquid-glass transition nor are commutable to ergodicity or entropy.

On the reality of the residual entropies of glasses and disordered crystals: counting microstates, calculating fluctuations, and comparing averages

In the course of an on-going debate on whether glasses or disordered crystals should have zero entropy at 0 K, i.e., whether the "residual entropy" assigned to them by calorimetric measurements is real, the view has been expressed by some who hold the zero entropy view that to measure entropy, all or an appreciable number of the microstates that contribute to the entropy must be visited. We show here that the entropy calculated on the basis of the number of microstates visited during any conceivable time of measurement would be underestimated by at least 20 orders of magnitude. We also examine and refute the claim that an ensemble average for glassy systems, which predicts a finite residual entropy, also predicts physically impossible properties. We conclude that calorimetrically measured residual entropies are real.

Fictive temperature, structural relaxation, and reality of residual entropy

By determining the fictive temperature, Tf, in two ways from the same Cp data, we investigate whether the residual entropy, Sres, of a glass could be an artifact of using the Cp d ln(T) integral in the glass-liquid temperature range. Although the integral gives only the upper and lower limits of the real entropy change, it is still useful and is distinguished as Delta(sigma). We determine Tf(sigma) from Delta(sigma) and the usual TfH from the Cp dT integral for two metal alloy glasses, a basalt composition glass and a spray-quenched propylene glycol glass from the available data, and find that Tf9sigma is about the same as TfH within errors. To substantiate it, we report a differential scanning calorimetry study performed during cooling of the Mg65Cu25Tb10 and Pd40Ni10Cu30P20 melts and on heating their glassy states at the same rates. In addition, we simulate Cp-T plots from a known model for nonexponential, nonlinear relaxation and analyze the data. The quantity Delta(sigma) on cooling the liquid and heating the glass differs negligibly; that is, net change in a temperature cycle between glass and its melt is close to zero, a characteristic of a nearly reversible change. We conclude that spontaneous enthalpy release has little effect on the entropy change determined from the Cp d ln(T) integral and, contrary to recent suggestions, Sres is real.

Configurational and residual entropies of nonergodic crystals and the entropy's behavior on glass formation

We use thermodynamics of lattice vacancies to test the merits of the view that (i) statistical entropy, k(B) ln Omega, vanishes on vitrification of a liquid and hence there is no residual entropy and (ii) k(B) ln Omega of a nonergodic state would increase with time t as its structure relaxes. We argue that this view conflicts with the precepts of the configurational entropy of a crystal, -R[x ln x+(1-x)ln(1-x)], where x is the fractional population of vacancies, and with the observed decrease in x with t on structural relaxation. The issue of whether the entropy of a kinetically arrested crystal state is equal to k(B) ln Omega or equal to -R[x ln x+(1-x)ln(1-x)] can be resolved by measuring the vapor pressure, the emf of an electrolytic cell, and by scanning calorimetry. We also consider how the energy landscapes of a crystal and liquid differ, and point out that since crystals are in a nonequilibrium state, their thermodynamic data are inappropriate for testing the validity of the third law.