Stretching chimeric DNA: a test for the putative S-form

Force measurements reveal how small binders perturb the dissociation mechanisms of DNA duplex sequences

The force-driven separation of double-stranded DNA is crucial to the accomplishment of cellular processes like genome transactions. Ligands binding to short DNA sequences can have a local stabilizing or destabilizing effect and thus severely affect these processes. Although the design of ligands that bind to specific sequences is a field of intense research with promising biomedical applications, so far, their effect on the force-induced strand separation has remained elusive. Here, by means of AFM-based single molecule force spectroscopy, we show the co-existence of two different mechanisms for the separation of a short DNA duplex and demonstrate how they are perturbed by small binders. With the support of Molecular Dynamics simulations, we evidence that above a critical pulling rate one of the dissociation pathways becomes dominant, with a dramatic effect on the rupture forces. Around the critical threshold, we observe a drop of the most probable rupture forces for ligand-stabilized duplexes. Our results offer a deep understanding of how a stable DNA-ligand complex behaves under force-driven strand separation.

Equilibrium and kinetics of DNA overstretching modeled with a quartic energy landscape

It is well known that the dsDNA molecule undergoes a phase transition from B-DNA into an overstretched state at high forces. For some time, the structure of the overstretched state remained unknown and highly debated, but recent advances in experimental techniques have presented evidence of more than one possible phase (or even a mixed phase) depending on ionic conditions, temperature, and basepair sequence. Here, we present a theoretical model to study the overstretching transition with the possibility that the overstretched state is a mixture of two phases: a structure with portions of inner strand separation (melted or M-DNA), and an extended phase that retains the basepair structure (S-DNA). We model the double-stranded DNA as a chain composed of n segments of length l, where the transition is studied by means of a Landau quartic potential with statistical fluctuations. The length l is a measure of cooperativity of the transition and is key to characterizing the overstretched phase. By analyzing the different values of l corresponding to a wide spectrum of experiments, we find that for a range of temperatures and ionic conditions, the overstretched form is likely to be a mix of M-DNA and S-DNA. For a transition close to a pure S-DNA state, where the change in extension is close to 1.7 times the original B-DNA length, we find l ? 25 basepairs regardless of temperature and ionic concentration. Our model is fully analytical, yet it accurately reproduces the force-extension curves, as well as the transient kinetic behavior, seen in DNA overstretching experiments.

Coarse-grained simulations of DNA overstretching

We use a recently developed coarse-grained model to simulate the overstretching of duplex DNA. Overstretching at 23 °C occurs at 74 pN in the model, about 6-7 pN higher than the experimental value at equivalent salt conditions. Furthermore, the model reproduces the temperature dependence of the overstretching force well. The mechanism of overstretching is always force-induced melting by unpeeling from the free ends. That we never see S-DNA (overstretched duplex DNA), even though there is clear experimental evidence for this mode of overstretching under certain conditions, suggests that S-DNA is not simply an unstacked but hydrogen-bonded duplex, but instead probably has a more exotic structure.

PicoNewton-millisecond force steps reveal the transition kinetics and mechanism of the double-stranded DNA elongation

We study the kinetics of the overstretching transition in λ-phage double-stranded (ds) DNA from the basic conformation (B state) to the 1.7-times longer and partially unwound conformation (S state), using the dual-laser optical tweezers under force-clamp conditions at 25°C. The unprecedented resolution of our piezo servo-system, which can impose millisecond force steps of 0.5-2 pN, reveals the exponential character of the elongation kinetics and allows us to test the two-state nature of the B-S transition mechanism. By analyzing the load-dependence of the rate constant of the elongation, we find that the elementary elongation step is 5.85 nm, indicating a cooperativity of ~25 basepairs. This mechanism increases the free energy for the elementary reaction to ~94 k(B)T, accounting for the stability of the basic conformation of DNA, and explains why ds-DNA can remain in equilibrium as it overstretches.

Transition dynamics and selection of the distinct S-DNA and strand unpeeling modes of double helix overstretching

Recent studies have revealed two distinct pathways for the DNA overstretching transition near 65 pN: ‘unpeeling’ of one strand from the other, and a transition from B-DNA to an elongated double-stranded ‘S-DNA’ form. However, basic questions concerning the dynamics of these transitions, relative stability of the two competing overstretched states, and effects of nicks and free DNA ends on overstretching, remain open. In this study we report that: (i) stepwise extension changes caused by sequence-defined barriers occur during the strand-unpeeling transition, whereas rapid, sequence-independent extension fluctuations occur during the B to S transition; (ii) the secondary transition that often occurs following the overstretching transition is strand-unpeeling, during which the extension increases by 0.01–0.02 nm per base pair of S-DNA converted to single-stranded DNA at forces between 75 and 110 pN; (iii) even in the presence of nicks or free ends, S-DNA can be stable under physiological solution conditions; (iv) distribution of small GC-rich islands in a large DNA plays a key role in determining the transition pathways; and (v) in the absence of nicks or free ends, torsion-unconstrained DNA undergoes the overstretching transition via creation of S-DNA. Our study provides a new, high-resolution understanding of the competition between unpeeling and formation of S-DNA.

Direct observation of multiple pathways of single-stranded DNA stretching

We observed multiple pathways of stretching single-stranded polydeoxynucleotides, poly(dA). Poly(dA) has been shown to undergo unique transitions under mechanical force, and such transitions were attributed to the stacking characteristics of poly(dA). Using single-molecule manipulation studies, we found that poly(dA) has two stretching pathways at high forces. The previously observed pathway has a free energy that is less than what is expected of single-stranded DNA with a random sequence, indicating the existence of a novel conformation of poly(dA) at large extensions. We also observed stepwise transitions between the two pathways by pulling the molecule with constant force, and found that the transitions are cooperative. These results suggest that the unique mechanical property of poly(dA) may play an important role in biological processes such as gene expression.

Microscopic implications of S-DNA

Recent experiments [J. van Mameren, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 106, 18231 (2009)] provide a detailed spatial picture of overstretched DNA, showing that under certain conditions the two strands of the double helix separate at about 65 pN. It was proposed that this observation rules out the existence of an elongated, hybridized form of DNA (S-DNA). Here, we argue that the S-DNA picture is consistent with the observation of unpeeling during overstretching. We demonstrate that assuming the existence of S-DNA does not imply DNA overstretching to consist of the complete or near-complete conversion of the molecule from B to S form. Instead, this assumption implies in general a more complex dynamic coexistence of hybridized and unhybridized forms of DNA. We argue that such coexistence can rationalize several recent experimental observations.

The nature of the force-induced conformation transition of dsDNA studied by using single molecule force spectroscopy

Single-stranded DNA binding proteins (SSB) interact with single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) specifically. Taking advantage of this character, we have employed Bacillus subtilis SSB protein to investigate the nature of force-induced conformation transition of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) by using AFM-based single molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) technique. Our results show that, when a dsDNA is stretched beyond its contour length, the dsDNA is partially melted, producing some ssDNA segments which can be captured by SSB proteins. We have also systematically investigated the effects of stretching length, waiting time, and salt concentration on the conformation transition of dsDNA and SSB-ssDNA interactions, respectively. Furthermore, the effect of proflavine, a DNA intercalator, on the SSB-DNA interactions has been investigated, and the results indicate that the proflavine-saturated dsDNA can be stabilized to the extent that the dsDNA will no longer melt into ssDNA under the mechanical force even up to 150 pN, and no SSB-DNA interactions are detectable.

Biophysical characterization of DNA binding from single molecule force measurements

Single molecule force spectroscopy is a powerful method that uses the mechanical properties of DNA to explore DNA interactions. Here we describe how DNA stretching experiments quantitatively characterize the DNA binding of small molecules and proteins. Small molecules exhibit diverse DNA binding modes, including binding into the major and minor grooves and intercalation between base pairs of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Histones bind and package dsDNA, while other nuclear proteins such as high mobility group proteins bind to the backbone and bend dsDNA. Single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding proteins slide along dsDNA to locate and stabilize ssDNA during replication. Other proteins exhibit binding to both dsDNA and ssDNA. Nucleic acid chaperone proteins can switch rapidly between dsDNA and ssDNA binding modes, while DNA polymerases bind both forms of DNA with high affinity at distinct binding sites at the replication fork. Single molecule force measurements quantitatively characterize these DNA binding mechanisms, elucidating small molecule interactions and protein function.

Different pulling modes in DNA overstretching: a theoretical analysis

We study the thermally driven denaturation of a double-stranded polymer in the presence of a stretching force via Monte-Carlo simulations. When one strand only is stretched, the denaturation transition is first order, while when both strands are stretched, melting is second order. By revisiting the Poland-Scheraga model for DNA melting, we show that at room temperature, the most likely scenario is that DNA melts as it overstretches. Our results are in general agreement with the most recent experiments and suggest how varying temperature and stretching mode may help settle the question whether S-DNA exists or not.