Property evaluation and orbital relaxation in coupled cluster methods

Toward Reliable Dipole Moments without Single Excitations: The Role of Orbital Rotations and Dynamical Correlation

The dipole moment is a crucial molecular property linked to a molecular system's bond polarity and overall electronic structure. To that end, the electronic dipole moment, which results from the electron density of a system, is often used to assess the accuracy and reliability of new electronic structure methods. This work analyses electronic dipole moments computed with the pair coupled cluster doubles (pCCD) ansätze and its linearized coupled cluster (pCCD-LCC) corrections using the canonical Hartree-Fock and pCCD-optimized (localized) orbital bases. The accuracy of pCCD-based dipole moments is assessed against experimental and CCSD(T) reference values using relaxed and unrelaxed density matrices and different basis set sizes. Our test set comprises molecules of various bonding patterns and electronic structures, exposing pCCD-based methods to a wide range of electron correlation effects. Additionally, we investigate the performance of pCCD-in-DFT dipole moments of some model complexes. Finally, our work indicates the importance of orbital relaxation in the pCCD model and shows the limitations of the linearized couple cluster corrections in predicting electronic dipole moments of multiple-bonded systems. Most importantly, pCCD with a linearized CCD correction can reproduce the dipole moment surfaces in singly bonded molecules, which are comparable to the multireference ones.

Perspective on Coupled-cluster Theory. The evolution toward simplicity in quantum chemistry

Coupled-cluster theory has revolutionized quantum chemistry. It has provided the framework to effectively solve the problem of electron correlation, the main focus of the field for over 60 years. This has enabled ab initio quantum chemistry to provide predictive quality results for most quantities of interest that are obtainable from first-principle calculations. The best that one can do in a basis is the 'full CI,' the exact solution of the non-relativistic Schrödinger equation or, if need be, the relativistic Dirac equation. With due regard to converging the basis set and adequate consideration of higher clusters and relativity in a calculation, virtually predictive results can be obtained. But in addition to its numerical performance, coupled-cluster theory also offers a conceptually new, many-body foundation for the theory that should be appreciated by all practitioners. The latter is emphasized in this perspective, leading to the 'evolution toward simplicity' in the title. The ultimate theory will benefit from the several features that are uniquely exact in coupled-cluster theory and its equation-of-motion (EOM-CC) extensions.

Excess and excited-state dipole moments of real-life dyes: a comparison between wave-function, BSE/GW, and TD-DFT values

In this work, we assess the accuracy of the Bethe-Salpeter equation (BSE) many-body Green's function formalism, adopting the eigenvalue-self-consistent evGW exchange-correlation kernel, for the calculation of the excited-state (μES) and excess dipole moments (Δμ), the latter ones being the changes of dipole amplitude between the ground and excited states (ES), in organic dyes. We compare the results obtained with wave-function methods [ADC(2), CC2, and CCSD], time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT), and BSE/evGW levels of theory. First, we compute the evolution of the dipole moments of the two lowest singlet excited states of 4-(dimethylamino)benzonitrile (DMABN) upon twisting of the amino group. Next, we use a set of 25 dyes having ES characters ranging from locally excited to charge transfer to determine both μES and Δμ. For DMABN our results show that BSE/evGW provides Δμ values closer to the CCSD reference and more consistent trends than TD-DFT. Moreover, a statistical analysis of both Δμ and μES for the set of 25 dyes shows that the BSE/evGW accuracy is comparable or sometimes slightly better than that of TD-M06-2X and TD-CAM-B3LYP, BSE/evGW outperforming TD-DFT in challenging cases (zwitterionic and cyanine transitions). Finally, the starting point dependency of BSE/evGW seems to be larger for Δμ, ES dipoles, and oscillator strengths than for transition energies.

SOiCISCF: Combining SOiCI and iCISCF for Variational Treatment of Spin-Orbit Coupling

It has recently been shown that the SOiCI approach [Zhang, N.; J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 2022, 34, 224007], in conjunction with the spin-separated exact two-component relativistic Hamiltonian, can provide very accurate fine structures of systems containing heavy elements by treating electron correlation and spin-orbit coupling (SOC) on an equal footing. Nonetheless, orbital relaxations/polarizations induced by SOC are not yet fully accounted for due to the use of scalar relativistic orbitals. This issue can be resolved by further optimizing the still real-valued orbitals self-consistently in the presence of SOC, as done in the spin-orbit coupled CASSCF approach [Ganyushin, D.; et al. J. Chem. Phys. 2013, 138, 104113] but with the iCISCF algorithm [Guo, Y.; J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2021, 17, 7545-7561] for large active spaces. The resulting SOiCISCF employs both double group and time reversal symmetries for computational efficiency and the assignment of target states. The fine structures of p-block elements are taken as showcases to reveal the efficacy of SOiCISCF.

Exploring Bethe-Salpeter Excited-State Dipoles: The Challenging Case of Increasingly Long Push-Pull Oligomers

The change of molecular dipole moment induced by photon absorption is key to interpret the measured optical spectra. Except for compact molecules, time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) remains the only theory allowing to quickly predict excited-state dipoles (μ^ES), albeit with a strong dependency on the selected exchange-correlation functional. This Letter presents the first assessment of the performances of the many-body Green's function Bethe-Salpeter equation (BSE) formalism for the evaluation of the μ^ES. We explore increasingly long push-pull oligomers as they present an excited-state nature evolving with system size. This work shows that BSE's μ^ES do present the same evolution with oligomeric length as their CC2 and CCSD counterparts, with a dependency on the starting exchange-correlation functional that is strongly decreased as compared to TD-DFT. This Letter demonstrates that BSE is a valuable alternative to TD-DFT for properties related to the excited-state density and not only for transition energies and oscillator strengths.

Strong External Electric Fields Reduce Explosive Sensitivity: A Theoretical Investigation into the Reaction Selectivity in NH2NO2∙∙∙NH3

Controlling the selectivity of a detonation initiation reaction of explosive is essential to reduce sensitivity, and it seems impossible to reduce it by strengthening the external electric field. To verify this, the effects of external electric fields on the initiation reactions in NH2NO2∙∙∙NH3, a model system of the nitroamine explosive with alkaline additive, were investigated at the MP2/6-311++G(2d,p) and CCSD(T)/6-311++G(2d,p) levels. The concerted effect in the intermolecular hydrogen exchange is characterized by an index of the imaginary vibrations. Due to the weakened concerted effects by the electric field along the −x-direction opposite to the “reaction axis”, the dominant reaction changes from the intermolecular hydrogen exchange to 1,3-intramolecular hydrogen transference with the increase in the field strengths. Furthermore, the stronger the field strengths, the higher the barrier heights become, indicating the lower sensitivities. Therefore, by increasing the field strength and adjusting the orientation between the field and “reaction axis”, not only can the reaction selectivity be controlled, but the sensitivity can also be reduced, in particular under a super-strong field. Thus, a traditional concept, in which the explosive is dangerous under the super-strong external electric field, is theoretically broken. Compared to the neutral medium, a low sensitivity of the explosive with alkaline can be achieved under the stronger field. Employing atoms in molecules, reduced density gradient, and surface electrostatic potentials, the origin of the reaction selectivity and sensitivity change is revealed. This work provides a new idea for the technical improvement regarding adding the external electric field into the explosive system.

Electron Propagator Self-Energies versus Improved GW100 Vertical Ionization Energies

Ab initio electron propagator (EP) methods that are free of adjustable parameters in their self-energy formulae and in the generation of their orbital bases have been applied to the calculation of the lowest vertical ionization energies (VIEs) of the GW100 set. An improved set of standard results accompanied by irreducible representation assignments has been produced indirectly with coupled-cluster singles and doubles plus perturbative triples, i.e., CCSD(T), total energy differences at initial-state geometries reoptimized (in 28 cases) with the largest applicable point groups. The best compromises of accuracy and efficiency belong to a new generation of EP self-energies, several members of which may be derived from an intermediately normalized, Hermitized super-operator metric. The following diagonal self-energy methods are optimal: opposite-spin non-Dyson second order (os-nD-D2), approximately renormalized partial third order (P3+), approximately renormalized quasiparticle third order (Q3+), and non-Dyson approximately renormalized linear third order version B (nD-L3+B). Their mean absolute errors (MAEs) in electron volts and arithmetic scaling factors expressed in terms of occupied (O) and virtual (V) orbital dimensions are, respectively, (0.18, OV²), (0.14, O²V³), (0.15, O²V³), and (0.11, OV⁴). The 0.06 eV MAE for the non-diagonal, sixth-power (O²V⁴) Brueckner doubles, triple-field operator (BD-T1) EP method is exceeded by the 0.1 eV MAE with respect to experiments in seventh-power, ΔCCSD(T) calculations and indicates that BD-T1 may serve as a direct, spin-symmetry-conserving alternative in the generation of standard results for VIEs of larger, closed-shell molecules.

Analytic evaluation of energy first derivatives for spin-orbit coupled-cluster singles and doubles augmented with noniterative triples method: General formulation and an implementation for first-order properties

A formulation of analytic energy first derivatives for the coupled-cluster singles and doubles augmented with noniterative triples [CCSD(T)] method with spin-orbit coupling included at the orbital level and an implementation for evaluation of first-order properties are reported. The standard density-matrix formulation for analytic CC gradient theory adapted to complex algebra has been used. The orbital-relaxation contributions from frozen core, occupied, virtual, and frozen virtual orbitals to analytic spin-orbit CCSD(T) gradients are fully taken into account and treated efficiently, which is of importance to calculations of heavy elements. Benchmark calculations of first-order properties including dipole moments and electric-field gradients using the corresponding exact two-component property integrals are presented for heavy-element containing molecules to demonstrate the applicability and usefulness of the present analytic scheme.

The Role of Relativistic Many-Body Theory in Electron Electric Dipole Moment Searches Using Cold Molecules

In this review article, we survey some of our results pertaining to the search for the electric dipole moment of the electron (eEDM), using heavy polar molecules. In particular, we focus on the relativistic coupled cluster method (RCCM) and its applications to eEDM searches in YbF, HgX (X = F, Cl, Br, and I), BaF, HgA (A = Li, Na, and K), and YbOH. Our results are presented in a systematic manner, by first introducing the eEDM and its measurement using molecules, the importance of relativistic many-body theory, and finally our results, followed by future prospects.

Benchmark coupled-cluster g-tensor calculations with full inclusion of the two-particle spin-orbit contributions

We present a parallel implementation to compute electron spin resonance g-tensors at the coupled-cluster singles and doubles (CCSD) level which employs the ACES III domain-specific software tools for scalable parallel programming, i.e., the super instruction architecture language and processor (SIAL and SIP), respectively. A unique feature of the present implementation is the exact (not approximated) inclusion of the five one- and two-particle contributions to the g-tensor [i.e., the mass correction, one- and two-particle paramagnetic spin-orbit, and one- and two-particle diamagnetic spin-orbit terms]. Like in a previous implementation with effective one-electron operators [J. Gauss et al., J. Phys. Chem. A 113, 11541-11549 (2009)], our implementation utilizes analytic CC second derivatives and, therefore, classifies as a true CC linear-response treatment. Therefore, our implementation can unambiguously appraise the accuracy of less costly effective one-particle schemes and provide a rationale for their widespread use. We have considered a large selection of radicals used previously for benchmarking purposes including those studied in earlier work and conclude that at the CCSD level, the effective one-particle scheme satisfactorily captures the two-particle effects less costly than the rigorous two-particle scheme. With respect to the performance of density functional theory (DFT), we note that results obtained with the B3LYP functional exhibit the best agreement with our CCSD results. However, in general, the CCSD results agree better with the experimental data than the best DFT/B3LYP results, although in most cases within the rather large experimental error bars.

Combining the spin-separated exact two-component relativistic Hamiltonian with the equation-of-motion coupled-cluster method for the treatment of spin–orbit splittings of light and heavy elements

An accurate and efficient treatment of spin–orbit splittings has been achieved by combining the sf-X2C+soc-DKH1 Hamiltonian with the equation-of-motion coupled-cluster method.

Orbital-optimized linearized coupled-cluster doubles with density-fitting and Cholesky decomposition approximations: an efficient implementation

An efficient implementation of the orbital-optimized linearized coupled-cluster double method with the density-fitting (DF-OLCCD) and Cholesky decomposition (CD-OLCCD) approximations is presented.

Equation-of-Motion Coupled-Cluster Theory for Excitation Energies of Closed-Shell Systems with Spin-Orbit Coupling

Excitation energies of closed-shell systems based on the equation-of-motion (EOM) coupled-cluster theory at the singles and doubles (CCSD) level with spin-orbit coupling (SOC) included in the post-Hartree-Fock treatment are implemented in the present work. SOC can be included in both the CC and EOM steps (EOM-SOC-CCSD) or only in the EOM part (SOC-EOM-CCSD). The latter approach is an economical way to account for SOC effects, but excitation energies with this approach are not size-intensive. When the unlinked term in the latter approach is neglected (cSOC-EOM-CCSD), size-intensive excitation energies can be obtained. Time-reversal symmetry and spatial symmetry are exploited to reduce the computational effort. Imposing time-reversal symmetry results in a real matrix representation for the similarity-transformed Hamiltonian, which facilitates the requirement of time-reversal symmetry for new trial vectors in Davidson's algorithm. Results on some closed-shell atoms and molecules containing heavy elements show that EOM-SOC-CCSD can provide excitation energies and spin-orbit splittings with reasonable accuracy. On the other hand, the SOC-EOM-CCSD approach is able to afford accurate estimates of SOC effects for valence electrons of systems containing elements up to the fifth row, while cSOC-EOM-CCSD is less accurate for spin-orbit splittings of transitions involving p1/2 spinors, even for Kr.

Investigating Multireference Character and Correlation in Quantum Chemistry

We review a range of multireference diagnostics for quantum chemistry and discuss them in terms of choices of the molecular orbitals. We show how an approach1 of P.-O. Löwdin can also be viewed as quantifying the electron correlation via the spatial entanglement relative to a single determinant. We consider three example systems from quantum chemistry that exhibit three different combinations of multireference character and correlation: not strongly multireference and not strongly correlated, strongly multireference but not strongly correlated, and strongly multireference together with strong correlation. We find that a multireference measure (MR) does not change substantially with the cutoff used for a Monte Carlo configuration interaction calculation and investigate the effect of using natural orbitals. We see that a coupled-cluster singles and doubles diagnostic and a density-functional theory diagnostic give a correct general prediction of the multireference character for these systems. We also look at the issue of multireference character for a collection of noninteracting hydrogen molecules and the effect of basis size on the multireference character of a stretched hydrogen molecule.

Block diagonalization of the equation-of-motion coupled cluster effective Hamiltonian: treatment of diabatic potential constants and triple excitations

We present a diabatization method applicable to spectroscopic studies based on Equation-of-Motion Coupled Cluster (EOM-CC) energies and biorthogonal wavefunctions that uses the Block Diagonalization (BD) approaches of Cederbaum et al. [L. S. Cederbaum, J. Schirmer, and H. D. Meyer, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 22, 2427 (1989)] and Domcke et al. [W. Domcke and C. Woywod, Chem. Phys. Lett. 216, 362 (1993); W. Domcke, C. Woywod, and M. Stengle, Chem. Phys. Lett. 226, 257 (1994)]. The method gives excellent agreement with coupling constants calculated using the analytic gradient approach of Ichino et al. [T. Ichino, J. Gauss, and J. F. Stanton, J. Chem. Phys. 130, 174105 (2009)]. While the BD method is a finite difference approach, it can be applied at any geometry, can generate (pointwise) diabatic potential energy surfaces, and can be used with EOM wavefunctions that include triple (or higher) excitations. The method is applied to several model systems and its sensitivity to orbital choice, excitation space, and projection space is explored.

Optimization of augmentation functions for correlated calculations of spin-spin coupling constants and related properties

A new hierarchy of augmented basis sets optimized for the calculation of molecular properties such as indirect spin-spin coupling constants is presented. Based on the Dunning hierarchy of cc-pVXZ (X = D, T, Q, and 5) basis sets augmentation functions with tight exponents have been optimized for coupled-cluster calculations of indirect spin-spin coupling constants. The optimal exponents for these tight functions have been obtained by optimizing the sum of the absolute values of all contributions to the coupling constant. On the basis of a series of test cases (CO, HF, N(2), F(2), H(2)O, NH(3), and CH(4)) we propose a set of tight s, p, and d functions to be added to the uncontracted Dunning basis sets, and, subsequently, to recontract. The resulting ccJ-pVXZ (X = D, T, Q, and 5) basis sets demonstrate excellent cost efficiency in benchmark calculations. These new basis sets should generally be applicable for the calculation of spin-spin coupling constants and other properties that have a strong dependence on powers of 1r or even contain a delta distribution for correlated ab initio methods.