Two-photon-induced singlet fission in rubrene single crystal

Killer Phonon Caught: Femtosecond Stimulated Raman Spectroscopy Identifies Phonon-Induced Control of Photophysics in Rubrene Derivatives

Molecular reaction coordinates are defined by the interplay of a number of orthogonal nuclear coordinates and are inherently multidimensional for large molecules. Identifying how specific nuclear motions along these reaction coordinates can be used to drive and control chemical processes is a promising approach for the optimization of chemical outcomes and targeted synthetic design. Here, we used femtosecond stimulated Raman spectroscopy (FSRS) to quantify the effects of individual phonon nuclear motions on singlet fission in rubrene derivatives. Rubrene readily undergoes singlet fission and is amendable to chemical derivatization, yet the factors that impact the singlet fission yield are not fully understood. Crystal packing is known to play a significant role in both fission and carrier transport, and thus, we focused on the impact of phonon nuclear motions on the photophysics. We used four halogen-substituted rubrene crystals and successfully identified one specific phonon mode that suppresses singlet fission in these crystals. We used FSRS with single-pulse excitation and double-pulse excitation to coherently amplify each phonon mode and quantify its effects on the excited-state process. We found that coherent amplification of the specific phonon vibration involving twisting of the peripheral phenyl rings and tetracene core motions resulted in less ground-state depletion and fewer triplet state absorption. Our study demonstrated that it is possible to use coherent phonon excitation to influence the photophysical outcome, while also showing that FSRS with double-pulse excitation can be a successful tool for quantifying mode-selective contributions to photophysics.

Activated Singlet Fission Dictated by Anti-Kasha Property in a Rylene Imide Dye

A key challenge in the search of new materials capable of singlet fission (SF) arises from the primary energy conservation criterion, i.e., the energy of the triplet exciton has to be half that of the singlet (E(S1) ≥ 2E(T1)), which excludes most photostable organic materials from consideration and confines the design strategy to materials with low energy triplet states. One potential way to overcome this energy requirement and improve the triplet energy is to enable a SF channel from higher energy ("hot") excitonic states (Sn) in a process called activated SF. Herein, we demonstrate that efficient activated SF is achieved in a rylene imide-based derivative acenaphth[l, 2-a]acenaphthylene diimide (AADI). This process is enabled by an increase in the energy gap to greater than 1.0 eV between the S3 and S1 states due to the incorporation of an antiaromatic pentalene unit, which leads to the emergence of anti-Kasha properties in the isolated molecule. Transient spectroscopy studies show that AADI undergoes ultrafast SF from higher singlet excited states in thin film, with excitation wavelength-dependent SF yields. The SF yield of ∼200% is observed upon higher energy excitation, and long-lived free triplets persist on the μs time scale suggesting that AADI can be used in SF-enhanced devices. Our results suggest that enlarging the Sn-S1 energy gap is an effective way to turn on the activated SF channel and shed light on the development of novel, stable SF materials with high triplet energies.

Singlet fission is incoherent in pristine orthorhombic single crystals of rubrene: no evidence of triplet-pair emission

Singlet fission (SF) and its inverse, triplet-triplet annihilation (TTA), are promising strategies for enhancing photovoltaic efficiencies. However, detailed descriptions of the processes of SF/TTA are not fully understood, even in the most well-studied systems. Reports of the photophysics of crystalline rubrene, for example, are often inconsistent. Here we attempt to resolve these inconsistencies using time-resolved photoluminescence and transient absorption spectroscopy of 'pristine' rubrene orthorhombic single crystals. We find the reported time-resolved photoluminescence behaviour that hinted at triplet-pair emission is found only at specific sites on the crystals and likely arises from surface defects. Using transient absorption spectroscopy of the same crystals, we also observe no evidence of instantaneous generation of triplet-pair population with ∼100 fs excitation, independent of excitation wavelength (532 nm, 495 nm) or excitation angle. Our results suggest that SF occurs incoherently on a relatively slow (picosecond) timescale in rubrene single crystals, as expected from the original theoretical calculations. We conclude that the sub-100 fs formation of triplet pairs in crystalline rubrene films is likely to be due to static disorder.

Generating spin-triplet states at the bulk perovskite/organic interface for photon upconversion

Perovskite-sensitized triplet-triplet annihilation (TTA) upconversion (UC) holds potential for practical applications of solid-state UC ranging from photovoltaics to sensing and imaging technologies. As the triplet sensitizer, the underlying perovskite properties heavily influence the generation of spin-triplet states once interfaced with the organic annihilator molecule, typically polyacene derivatives. Presently, most reported perovskite TTA-UC systems have utilized rubrene doped with ∼1% dibenzotetraphenylperiflanthene (RubDBP) as the annihilator/emitter species. However, practical applications require a larger apparent anti-Stokes than is currently achievable with this system due to the inherent 0.4 eV energy loss during triplet generation. In this minireview, we present the current understanding of the triplet sensitization process at the perovskite/organic semiconductor interface and introduce additional promising annihilators based on anthracene derivatives into the discussion of future directions in perovskite-sensitized TTA-UC.

π-Extended Rubrenes via Dearomative Annulative π-Extension Reaction

Among a large variety of organic semiconducting materials, rubrene (5,6,11,12-tetraphenyltetracene) represents one of the most prominent molecular entities mainly because of its unusually high carrier mobility. Toward finding superior rubrene-based organic semiconductors, several synthetic strategies for related molecules have been established. However, despite its outstanding properties and significant attention in the field of materials science, late-stage functionalizations of rubrene remains undeveloped, thereby limiting the accessible chemical space of rubrene-based materials. Herein, we report on a late-stage π-extension of rubrene by dearomative annulative π-extension (DAPEX), leading to the generation of rubrene derivatives having an extended acene core. The Diels-Alder reaction of rubrene with 4-methyl-1,2,4-triazoline-3,5-dione occurred to give 1:1 and 1:2 cycloadducts which further underwent iron-catalyzed annulative diarylation. The thus-formed 1:1 and 1:2 adducts were subjected to radical-mediated oxidation and thermal cycloreversion to furnish one-side and two-side π-extended rubrenes, respectively. These π-extended rubrenes displayed a marked red shift in absorption and emission spectra, clearly showing that the acene π-system of rubrene was extended not only structurally but also electronically. The X-ray crystallographic analysis uncovered interesting packing modes of these π-extended rubrenes. Particularly, two-side π-extended rubrene adopts a brick-wall packing structure with largely overlapping two-dimensional face-to-face π-π interactions. Finally, organic field-effect transistor devices using two-side π-extended rubrene were fabricated, and their carrier mobilities were measured. The observed maximum hole mobility of 1.49 × 10-3 cm2V-1 s-1, which is a comparable value to that of the thin-film transistor using rubrene, clearly shows the potential utility of two-side π-extended rubrene in organic electronics.

Plenty of Room on the Top: Pathways and Spectroscopic Signatures of Singlet Fission from Upper Singlet States

We investigate dynamic signatures of the singlet fission (SF) process triggered by the excitation of a molecular system to an upper singlet state S_N (N > 1) and develop a computational methodology for the simulation of nonlinear spectroscopic signals revealing the S_N → TT₁ SF in real time. We demonstrate that SF can proceed directly from the upper state S_N, bypassing the lowest excited state, S₁. We determine the main S_N → TT₁ reaction pathways and show by computer simulation and spectroscopic measurements that the S_N-initiated SF can be faster and more efficient than the traditionally studied S₁ → TT₁ SF. We claim that the S_N → TT₁ SF offers novel promising opportunities for engineering SF systems and enhancing SF yields.

Femtosecond stimulated Raman spectroscopy - guided library mining leads to efficient singlet fission in rubrene derivatives

Chromophores undergoing singlet fission are promising candidates for harnessing solar energy as they can generate a pair of charge carriers by the absorption of one photon. However, photovoltaic devices employing singlet fission are still lacking practical applications due to the limitations within the existing molecules undergoing singlet fission. Chemical modifications to acenes can lead to efficient singlet fission devices, but the influence of changes to molecular structure on the rate of singlet fission is challenging to model and predict. Using femtosecond stimulated Raman spectroscopy we have previously demonstrated that the triplet separation process during singlet fission in crystalline rubrene is associated with the loss of electron density from its tetracene core. Based on this knowledge, we mined a library of new rubrene derivatives with electron withdrawing substituents that prime the molecules for efficient singlet fission, without impacting their crystal packing. Our rationally chosen crystalline chromophores exhibit significantly improved singlet fission rates. This study demonstrates the utility and strength of a structurally sensitive spectroscopic technique in providing insights to spectroscopy-guided materials selection and design guidelines that go beyond energy arguments to design new singlet fission-capable chromophores.

In the race to find efficient singlet fission materials, picking a winner is not easy. Femtosecond stimulated Raman spectroscopy can help us choose the best candidates, as demonstrated here in choosing from a library of rubrene derivatives.

Women in the Singlet Fission World: Pearls in a Semi-Open Shell

Singlet fission, a multiple exciton generation process, can revolutionize existing solar cell technologies. Offering the possibility to double photocurrent, the process has become a focal point for physicists, chemists, software developers, and engineers. The following review is dedicated to the female investigators, predominantly theorists, who have contributed to the field of singlet fission. We highlight their most significant advances in the subject, from deciphering the mechanism of the process to designing coveted singlet fission materials.

Singlet fission from upper excited singlet states and polaron formation in rubrene film

Femtosecond fluorescence up-conversion and transient absorption pump-probe setups are applied to study the relaxation dynamics of the lower and upper excited singlet electronic states in easy-to-make rubrene films. Upon 250 nm (4.96 eV) excitation, singlet fission was observed directly from S2 state bypassing S1 state within 30 fs i.e. breaking the classical Kasha rule. From the transient absorption measurements, polaron formation was also detected on the same time scale. Both singlet fission and polaron formation are accelerated from upper excited states compared with S1 state. Our work shows that rubrene films with low degree of crystallinity could display efficient singlet fission, notably in the case of excitation to upper lying electronic states. This can strongly expand the applications of rubrene in organic electronics. Moreover, our results will provide a new direction for synthesizing novel materials with optimized excited state properties for organic photovoltaic applications.

Spectroscopy of Resonant Intermediate States for Triplet-Triplet Annihilation Upconversion in Crystalline Rubrene: Radical Ions as Sensitizers

Photoluminescence upconversion in crystalline rubrene can proceed without an added sensitizer, but the mechanism for this process has not been well-understood. In particular, the species responsible for photon absorption has not been identified to date. To gain insight into the identity of the intermediate state, we measured the near-infrared (NIR) upconversion photoluminescence (UCPL) excitation spectrum of rubrene crystals and found three distinct spectral features. The UCPL yield has a quartic dependence on the laser intensity, implying a four-photon process. On the basis of electronic spectra of radical cations and anions of rubrene, we propose a mechanism in which photoexcited radical anions and cations undergo recombination, forming an excited neutral triplet while conserving spin. The triplets formed this way ultimately undergo triplet-triplet annihilation, resulting in the observed photoluminescence. This mechanism explains the origin of the NIR absorption as well as the four-photon nature of the UCPL process.

Theoretical Modeling of Singlet Fission

Singlet fission is a photophysical reaction in which a singlet excited electronic state splits into two spin-triplet states. Singlet fission was discovered more than 50 years ago, but the interest in this process has gained a lot of momentum in the past decade due to its potential as a way to boost solar cell efficiencies. This review presents and discusses the most recent advances with respect to the theoretical and computational studies on the singlet fission phenomenon. The work revisits important aspects regarding electronic states involved in the process, the evaluation of fission rates and interstate couplings, the study of the excited state dynamics in singlet fission, and the advances in the design and characterization of singlet fission compounds and materials such as molecular dimers, polymers, or extended structures. Finally, the review tries to pinpoint some aspects that need further improvement and proposes future lines of research for theoretical and computational chemists and physicists in order to further push the understanding and applicability of singlet fission.

Femtosecond Raman Microscopy Reveals Structural Dynamics Leading to Triplet Separation in Rubrene Singlet Fission

Singlet fission generates multiple excitons from a single photon, which in theory can result in solar cell efficiencies with values above the Shockley-Queisser limit. Understanding the molecular structural dynamics during singlet fission will help to fabricate efficient organic photovoltaic devices. Here we use femtosecond stimulated Raman spectroscopy to reveal the structural evolution during the triplet separation in rubrene. We observe vibrational signatures of the correlated triplet pair, as well as shifting of the vibrational frequencies of the 1430 and 1542 cm^-1 excited state modes, which increase by more than 25 cm^-1 in 5 ps. Our results indicate that the correlated pair separation into two individual triplets occurs concurrently with the loss of electron density from the tetracene backbone in rubrene. This study provides new insights into the triplet separation process and proves the utility of structurally sensitive ultrafast vibrational techniques to understand the mechanism of singlet fission.

Unusual Nonemissive Behavior of Rubrene J-Aggregates: A Rare Violation

Structure-property correlations in rubrene (RB) colloidal J-aggregates were unravelled by steady state and time-resolved spectroscopy in conjunction with excited state density functional calculations. The RB J-aggregate with a slippage angle θ = 30.4°, estimated from the monomeric transition dipole moment directions, exhibited a broad fwhm of 1073 cm^-1 and a 5 nm red-shifted absorption band carrying a transition dipole moment (M⃗_λagg = 1.80 D) almost equivalent to the monomeric dye (M⃗_λmon = 1.89 D). A significantly low magnitude of exciton coupling energy, ΔE_exc = -358 cm^-1 for the rhombic-RB colloidal J-aggregates resulted owing to the weaker electronic communication between the largely separated RB subunits (r = 7.2 Å) and a restricted exciton delocalization over the RB J-dimer (N = 2). The RB J-dimer exhibited a perfect balance between the computed singlet (2.53 eV) and the triplet (1.29 eV) exciton energies for singlet fission (SF). Supporting this, the PL decay profile of the J-aggregates revealed a delayed fluorescence, substantiating triplet pair formation via SF. The experimental evidence for the long-lived triplet formation was furthermore confirmed by its transient absorption (T₁ → T_N) at 530 nm. Consequently, a high probability for SF and a low probability for triplet-triplet recombination, leading to a dramatic lowering in photoluminescence quantum yield from 0.172 down to 0.035 was noted. The electronic structure calculations for the RB J-dimer followed TD-DFT-M062X/6-31G+(d,p) level of theory following integral equation formalism polarizable continuum model (IEFPCM) in water. S₁ excited state for RB J-dimer was carefully analyzed using integral overlap of electron and hole density distribution (ϕ) and the defined t-indexes along all three spatial directions, and was found to be of locally excited in character.

Single photon triggered dianion formation in TCNQ and F4TCNQ crystals

Excited state dynamics in two strong organic electron acceptor systems, TCNQ and F₄TCNQ single crystals, was studied. After absorption of a single photon, dianions are formed in both crystals on ultrashort timescale: TCNQ τ < 50 fs, F₄TCNQ τ = 4 ps. By use of transient absorption spectroscopy, we demonstrate that the dianion formation in F₄TCNQ is mediated by the radical anion precursor which is described by a two-step model. Our measurements show the phenomenon that in this quinoid acceptor crystals in the absence of additional donor molecule, it is possible to resolve the two step formation of a doubly charged anion upon absorption of a single low energy photon (2.6 eV).

The excitation intensity dependence of singlet fission dynamics of a rubrene microcrystal studied by femtosecond transient microspectroscopy

When a rubrene crystal was excited with an intense fs pulse (397 nm), transient local heating (∼ps) of the crystal through nonradiative relaxation from S_N to S₁ accelerates singlet fission of the S₁.

Singlet exciton fission in thin films of tert-butyl-substituted terrylenes

Two terrylene chromophores, 2,5,10,13-tetra(tert-butyl)terrylene (1) and 2,5-di(tert-butyl)terrylene (2), were synthesized and studied to determine their singlet exciton fission (SF) efficiencies. Compound 1 crystallizes in one-dimensional stacks, whereas 2 packs in a slip-stacked, herringbone pattern of dimers motif. Strongly quenched fluorescence and rapid singlet exciton decay dynamics are observed in vapor-deposited thin films of 1 and 2. Phosphorescence measurements on thin films of 1 and 2 show that SF is only 70 meV endoergic for these chromophores. Femtosecond transient absorption experiments using low laser fluences on these films reveal rapid triplet exciton formation for both 1 (τ = 120 ± 10 ps) and 2 (τ = 320 ± 20 ps) that depends strongly on film crystallinity. The transient absorption data are consistent with formation of an excimer state prior to SF. Triplet exciton yield measurements indicate nearly quantitative SF in thin films of both chromophores in highly crystalline solvent-vapor-annealed films: 170 ± 20% for 1 and 200 ± 30% for 2. These results show that significantly different crystal morphologies of the same chromophore can both result in high-efficiency SF provided that the energetics are favorable.

Excited-state dynamics in an α-perylene single crystal: two-photon- and consecutive two-quantum-induced singlet fission

Excited-state dynamics in α-perylene single crystals is studied by time-resolved fluorescence and transient absorption techniques under different excitation conditions. The ultrafast lifetimes of the "hot" excimer (Y) state were resolved. Three competing excited-states decay channels are observed: excimer formation, dimer cation generation, and singlet fission. The singlet fission induced by two-photon and consecutive two-quantum absorption is reported for the first time in an α-perylene crystal.

Activated singlet exciton fission in a semiconducting polymer

Singlet exciton fission is a spin-allowed process to generate two triplet excitons from a single absorbed photon. This phenomenon offers great potential in organic photovoltaics, but the mechanism remains poorly understood. Most reports to date have addressed intermolecular fission within small-molecular crystals. However, through appropriate chemical design chromophores capable of intramolecular fission can also be produced. Here we directly observe sub-100 fs activated singlet fission in a semiconducting poly(thienylenevinylene). We demonstrate that fission proceeds directly from the initial 1Bu exciton, contrary to current models that involve the lower-lying 2Ag exciton. In solution, the generated triplet pairs rapidly recombine and decay through the 2Ag state. In films, exciton diffusion breaks this symmetry and we observe long-lived triplets which form charge-transfer states in photovoltaic blends.