Hydrogen evolution from water through metal sulfide reactions

Decomposition of Halogenated Molybdenum Sulfide Dianions [Mo3S7X6]2- (X = Cl, Br, I)

Molybdenum sulfides are considered a promising and inexpensive alternative to platinum as a catalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction. In this study, we perform collision-induced dissociation experiments in the gas phase with the halogenated molybdenum sulfides [Mo₃S₇Cl₆]^2-, [Mo₃S₇Br₆]^2-, and [Mo₃S₇I₆]^2-. We show that the first fragmentation step for all three dianions is charge separation via loss of a halide ion. As a second step, further halogen loss competes with the dissociation of a disulfur molecule, whereas the former becomes energetically more favorable and the latter becomes less favorable from chlorine via bromine to iodine. We show that the leaving S₂ group is composed of sulfur atoms from two bridging groups. These decomposition pathways differ drastically from the pure [Mo₃S₁₃]^2- clusters. The obtained insight into preferred dissociation pathways of molybdenum sulfides illustrate possible reaction pathways during the activation of these substances in a catalytic environment.

Rearrangement and decomposition pathways of bare and hydrogenated molybdenum oxysulfides in the gas phase

Molybdenum sulfides and molybdenum oxysulfides are considered a promising and cheap alternative to platinum as a catalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). To better understand possible rearrangements during catalyst activation, we perform collision induced dissociation experiments in the gas phase with eight different molybdenum oxysulfides, namely [Mo₂O₂S₆]^2-, [Mo₂O₂S₆]^-, [Mo₂O₂S₅]^2-, [Mo₂O₂S₅]^-, [Mo₂O₂S₄]^-, [HMo₂O₂S₆]^-, [HMo₂O₂S₅]^- and [HMo₂O₂S₄]^-, on a Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometer. We identify fragmentation channels of the molybdenum oxysulfides and their interconnections. Together with quantum chemical calculations, the results show that [Mo₂O₂S₄]^- is a particularly stable species against further dissociation, which is reached from all starting species with relatively low collision energies. Most interestingly, H atom loss is the only fragmentation channel observed for [HMo₂O₂S₄]^- at low collision energies, which relates to potential HER activity, since two such H atom binding sites on a surface may act together to release H₂. The calculations reveal that multiple isomers are often very close in energy, especially for the hydrogenated species, i.e., atomic hydrogen can bind at various sites of the clusters. S₂ groups play a decisive role in hydrogen adsorption. These are further features with potential relevance for HER catalysis.

[Mo3 S13 ]2- as a Model System for Hydrogen Evolution Catalysis by MoSx : Probing Protonation Sites in the Gas Phase by Infrared Multiple Photon Dissociation Spectroscopy

Materials based on molybdenum sulfide are known as efficient hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) catalysts. As the binding site for H atoms on molybdenum sulfides for the catalytic process is under debate, [HMo3 S13 ]- is an interesting molecular model system to address this question. Herein, we probe the [HMo3 S13 ]- cluster in the gas phase by coupling Fourier-transform ion-cyclotron-resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS) with infrared multiple photon dissociation (IRMPD) spectroscopy. Our investigations show one distinct S-H stretching vibration at 2450 cm-1 . Thermochemical arguments based on DFT calculations strongly suggest a terminal disulfide unit as the H adsorption site.

Using anion photoelectron spectroscopy of cluster models to gain insights into mechanisms of catalyst-mediated H2 production from water

Metal oxide cluster models of catalyst materials offer a powerful platform for probing the molecular-scale features and interactions that govern catalysis. This perspective gives an overview of studies implementing the combination of anion photoelectron (PE) spectroscopy and density functional theory calculations toward exploring cluster models of metal oxides and metal-oxide supported Pt that catalytically drive the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) or the water-gas shift reaction. The utility in the combination of these experimental and computational techniques lies in our ability to unambiguously determine electronic and molecular structures, which can then connect to results of reactivity studies. In particular, we focus on the activity of oxygen vacancies modeled by suboxide clusters, the critical mechanistic step of forming proximal metal hydride and hydroxide groups as a prerequisite for H2 production, and the structural features that lead to trapped dihydroxide groups. The pronounced asymmetric oxidation found in heterometallic group 6 oxides and near-neighbor group 5/group 6 results in higher activity toward water, while group 7/group 6 oxides form very specific stoichiometries that suggest facile regeneration. Studies on the trans-periodic combination of cerium oxide and platinum as a model for ceria supported Pt atoms and nanoparticles reveal striking negative charge accumulation by Pt, which, combined with the ionic conductivity of ceria, suggests a mechanism for the exceptionally high activity of this system towards the water-gas shift reaction.

Computational Screening toward Hydrogen Evolution Reaction by the Introduction of Point Defects at the Edges of Group IVA Monochalcogenides: A First-Principles Study

Exploring materials with high hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) performance is of importance for the development of clean hydrogen energy, and the defects on the surfaces of catalysts are essential. In this work, we evaluate the HER performance among group IVA monochalcogenides MXs (M = Ge/Sn, X = S/Se) with M/X point defects on the edges. Compared with basal planes and bare edges, the GeS edge with Ge vacancy (ΔG_H* = 0.016 eV), GeSe edge with Se vacancy (ΔG_H* = 0.073 eV), and SnSe edge with Sn vacancy (ΔG_H* = -0.037 eV) hold the best HER performances, which are comparable to or even better than the value for Pt (-0.07 eV). Furthermore, the relationships between ΔG_H* and p-band centers of considered models are summarized. The stability of proposed electrocatalysts are analyzed by vacancy-formation energy and strain engineering. In summary, the HER performance of MXs is greatly improved by introduction of point defects at the edges, which is promising for their use as electrocatalysts for the conversion and storage of energy in the future.

Structural Properties of Gas Phase Molybdenum Sulfide Clusters [Mo3S13]2-, [HMo3S13]-, and [H3Mo3S13]+ as Model Systems of a Promising Hydrogen Evolution Catalyst

Amorphous molybdenum sulfide (MoS _x ) is a potent catalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Since mechanistic investigations on amorphous solids are particularly difficult, we use a bottom-up approach and study the [Mo₃S₁₃]^2- nanocluster and its protonated forms. The mass selected pure [Mo₃S₁₃]^2- as well as singly and triply protonated [HMo₃S₁₃]^- and [H₃Mo₃S₁₃]⁺ ions, respectively, were investigated by a combination of collision induced dissociation (CID) experiments and quantum chemical calculations. A rich variety of H _x S _y elimination channels was observed, giving insight into the structural flexibility of the clusters. In particular, it was calculated that the observed clusters tend to keep the Mo₃ ring structure found in the bulk and that protons adsorb primarily on terminal disulfide units of the cluster. Mo-H bonds are formed only for quasi-linear species with Mo centers featuring empty coordination sites. Protonation leads to increased cluster stability against CID. The rich variety of CID dissociation products for the triply protonated [H₃Mo₃S₁₃]⁺ ion, however, suggests that it has a large degree of structural flexibility, with roaming H/SH moieties, which could be a key feature of MoS _x to facilitate HER catalysis via a Volmer-Heyrovsky mechanism.

Small stoichiometric (MoS2)n clusters with the 1T phase

Stoichiometric (MoS₂)_n clusters (n = 1–6) were systematically studied by density functional theory calculations with hybrid B3LYP and pure GGA PW91 functionals.

Bond Activation and Hydrogen Evolution from Water through Reactions with M3S4 (M = Mo, W) and W3S3 Anionic Clusters

Transition metal sulfides (TMS) are being investigated with increased frequency because of their ability to efficiently catalyze the hydrogen evolution reaction. We have studied the trimetallic TMS cluster ions, Mo₃S₄^-, W₃S₄^-, and W₃S₃^-, and probed their efficiency for bond activation and hydrogen evolution from water. These clusters have geometries that are related to the edge sites on bulk MoS₂ surfaces that are known to play a role in hydrogen evolution. Using density functional theory, the electronic structures of these clusters and their chemical reactivity with water have been investigated. The reaction mechanism involves the initial formation of hydroxyl and thiol groups, hydrogen migration to form an intermediate with a metal hydride bond, and finally, combination of a hydride and a proton to eliminate H₂. Using this mechanism, free energy profiles of the reactions of the three metal clusters with water have been constructed. Unlike previous reactivity studies of other related cluster systems, there is no overall energy barrier in the reactions involving the M₃S₄ systems. The energy required for the rate-determining step of the reaction (the initial addition of the cluster by water) is lower than the separated reactants (-0.8 kcal/mol for Mo and -5.1 kcal/mol for W). They confirm the M₃S₄^- cluster's ability to efficiently activate the chemical bonds in water to release H_2. Though the W₃S₃^- cluster is not as efficient at bond activation, it provides insights into the factors that contribute to the success of the M₃S₄ anionic systems in hydrogen evolution.

Hydroxyl migration in heterotrimetallic clusters: an assessment of fluxionality pathways

Water splitting at the unsaturated metal center and subsequent hydroxyl migration are key steps toward successful H2 liberation from cheap and abundant water using transition metal cluster anions. In this report we initiate a theoretical study (DFT) to assess the efficacy of heterometallic cores instead of the widely studied and well established homometallic cores. To accomplish this goal, one tungsten center in W3O6(-) core has been replaced by different transition metals such as titanium, technetium, and osmium. Introduction of the heterometal makes the core asymmetric and electronically anisotropic. To evaluate the efficiency of these heterometallic cores, fluxionality pathways for hydroxyl migration have been studied in detail. We show that the cores W2TcO6(-) (2) and W2OsO6(-) (3) can exhibit fluxionality for hydroxyl migration and thus can potentially facilitate H2 liberation from H2O. Notably, a new class of low-energy structures generated upon oxide bridge opening process and subsequent structural rearrangement facilitates the hydroxyl migration event. To illustrate the heterometallic effect further, we show that previously inaccessible energy barriers for hydroxyl migration in a homometallic trimolybdenum core become energetically achievable when one of the metals is replaced by a 5d element osmium.