Tunneling splittings in formic acid dimer: An adiabatic approximation to the Herring formula

Nonadiabatic Hydrogen Tunneling Dynamics for Multiple Proton Transfer Processes with Generalized Nuclear-Electronic Orbital Multistate Density Functional Theory

Proton transfer and hydrogen tunneling play key roles in many processes of chemical and biological importance. The generalized nuclear-electronic orbital multistate density functional theory (NEO-MSDFT) method was developed in order to capture hydrogen tunneling effects in systems involving the transfer and tunneling of one or more protons. The generalized NEO-MSDFT method treats the transferring protons quantum mechanically on the same level as the electrons and obtains the delocalized vibronic states associated with hydrogen tunneling by mixing localized NEO-DFT states in a nonorthogonal configuration interaction scheme. Herein, we present the derivation and implementation of analytical gradients for the generalized NEO-MSDFT vibronic state energies and the nonadiabatic coupling vectors between these vibronic states. We use this methodology to perform adiabatic and nonadiabatic dynamics simulations of the double proton transfer reactions in the formic acid dimer and the heterodimer of formamidine and formic acid. The generalized NEO-MSDFT method is shown to capture the strongly coupled synchronous or asynchronous tunneling of the two protons in these processes. Inclusion of vibronically nonadiabatic effects is found to significantly impact the double proton transfer dynamics. This work lays the foundation for a variety of nonadiabatic dynamics simulations of multiple proton transfer systems, such as proton relays and hydrogen-bonding networks.

Generalized Nuclear-Electronic Orbital Multistate Density Functional Theory for Multiple Proton Transfer Processes

Proton transfer and hydrogen tunneling play pivotal roles in many chemical and biological processes. The nuclear-electronic orbital multistate density functional theory (NEO-MSDFT) approach was developed to describe hydrogen tunneling systems within the multicomponent NEO framework, where the transferring proton is quantized and treated with molecular orbital techniques on the same level as the electrons. Herein, the NEO-MSDFT framework is generalized to an arbitrary number of quantum protons to allow applications to systems involving the transfer and tunneling of multiple protons. The generalized NEO-MSDFT approach is shown to produce delocalized, bilobal proton densities and accurate tunneling splittings for fixed geometries of the formic acid dimer and asymmetric substituted variants, as well as the porphycene molecule. Investigation of a protonated water chain highlights the applicability of this approach to proton relay systems. This work provides the foundation for nuclear-electronic quantum dynamics simulations of a wide range of multiple proton transfer processes.

An Ab Initio Neural Network Potential Energy Surface for the Dimer of Formic Acid and Further Quantum Tunneling Dynamics

We construct a full-dimensional ab initio neural network potential energy surface (PES) for the isomerization system of the formic acid dimer (FAD). This is based upon ab initio calculations using the DLPNO-CCSD(T) approach with the aug-cc-pVTZ basis set, performed at over 14000 symmetry-unique geometries. An accurate fit to the obtained energies is generated using a general neural network fitting procedure combined with the fundamental invariant method, and the overall energy-weighted root-mean-square fitting error is about 6.4 cm^-1. Using this PES, we present a multidimensional quantum dynamics study on tunneling splittings with an efficient theoretical scheme developed by our group. The ground-state tunneling splitting of FAD calculated with a four-mode coupled method is in good agreement with the most recent experimental measurements. The PES can be applied for further dynamics studies. The effectiveness of the present scheme for constructing a high-dimensional PES is demonstrated, and this scheme is expected to be feasible for larger molecular systems.

Efficient Quantum Mechanical Calculations of Mode-Specific Tunneling Splittings upon Fundamental Excitation in the Dimer of Formic Acid

The formic acid dimer (FAD) is an important benchmark system for understanding the double hydrogen transfer process. Most recently, Zhang et al. measured a few tunneling splittings upon fundamental excitation of FAD precisely (Zhang, Y. et al. J. Chem. Phys. 2017, 146, 244306); however, relevant theoretical studies are very limited. Here, we present a multidimensional quantum dynamics study on mode-specific tunneling splittings upon fundamental excitation in FAD with an efficient theoretical scheme developed by our group in which the process-oriented basis function customization strategy is combined with the preconditioned inexact spectral transform method. Various mode-specific tunneling splittings upon fundamental excitation are systematically calculated, and interesting mode-specific excitation effects on tunneling rate are identified. In particular, the calculated tunneling splittings for the ν₂₂ and ν₂₁ states are in good agreement with experiment, and the remarkable mode-specific suppression effects upon excitation should result from that the antisymmetric vibrational modes hinder the concerted double H-transfer. The present work is helpful to acquire a better understanding of the mode-specific excitation effects on tunneling processes.

Concerted Pair Motion Due to Double Hydrogen Bonding: The Formic Acid Dimer Case

Formic acid dimer as the prototypical doubly hydrogen-bonded gas-phase species is discussed from the perspective of the three translational and the three rotational degrees of freedom which are lost when two formic acid molecules form a stable complex. The experimental characterisation of these strongly hindered translations and rotations is reviewed, as are attempts to describe the associated fundamental vibrations, their combinations, and their thermal shifts by different electronic structure calculations and vibrational models. A remarkable match is confirmed for the combination of a CCSD(T)-level harmonic treatment and an MP2-level anharmonic VPT2 correction. Qualitatively correct thermal shifts of the vibrational spectra can be obtained from classical molecular dynamics in CCSD(T)-quality force fields. A detailed analysis suggests that this agreement between experiment and composite theoretical treatment is not strongly affected by fortuitous error cancellation but fully converged variational treatments of the six pair or intermolecular modes and their overtones and combinations in this model system would be welcome.

Double Proton Transfer in the Dimer of Formic Acid: An Efficient Quantum Mechanical Scheme

Double proton transfer plays an important role in biology and chemistry, such as with DNA base pairs, proteins and molecular clusters, and direct information about these processes can be obtained from tunneling splittings. Carboxylic acid dimers are prototypes for multiple proton transfer, of which the formic acid dimer is the simplest one. Here, we present efficient quantum dynamics calculations of ground-state and fundamental excitation tunneling splittings in the formic acid dimer and its deuterium isotopologues. These are achieved with a multidimensional scheme developed by us, in which the saddle-point normal coordinates are chosen, the basis functions are customized for the proton transfer process, and the preconditioned inexact spectral transform method is used to solve the resultant eigenvalue problem. Our computational results are in excellent agreement with the most recent experiments (Zhang et al., 2017; Li et al., 2019).

Quantum approaches to vibrational dynamics and spectroscopy: is ease of interpretation sacrificed as rigor increases?

The subject of this Perspective is quantum approaches, beyond the harmonic approximation, to vibrational dynamics and IR spectroscopy.

Quantum and classical IR spectra of (HCOOH)2, (DCOOH)2 and (DCOOD)2 using ab initio potential energy and dipole moment surfaces

Full-dimensional (24 modes) quantum calculation of the IR spectrum of (DCOOD)₂, and comparison with classical MD one.

Full- and reduced-dimensionality instanton calculations of the tunnelling splitting in the formic acid dimer

Nearly all degrees of freedom need to be included for accurate theoretical predictions of quantum dynamics.

Quantum free energy landscapes from ab initio path integral metadynamics: Double proton transfer in the formic acid dimer is concerted but not correlated

With the goal of computing quantum free energy landscapes of reactive (bio)chemical systems in multi-dimensional space, we combine the metadynamics technique for sampling potential energy surfaces with the ab initio path integral approach to treating nuclear quantum motion. This unified method is applied to the double proton transfer process in the formic acid dimer (FAD), in order to study the nuclear quantum effects at finite temperatures without imposing a one-dimensional reaction coordinate or reducing the dimensionality. Importantly, the ab initio path integral metadynamics technique allows one to treat the hydrogen bonds and concomitant proton transfers in FAD strictly independently and thus provides direct access to the much discussed issue of whether the double proton transfer proceeds via a stepwise or concerted mechanism. The quantum free energy landscape we compute for this H-bonded molecular complex reveals that the two protons move in a concerted fashion from initial to product state, yet world-line analysis of the quantum correlations demonstrates that the protons are as quantum-uncorrelated at the transition state as they are when close to the equilibrium structure.

An ab initio potential energy surface for the formic acid dimer: zero-point energy, selected anharmonic fundamental energies, and ground-state tunneling splitting calculated in relaxed 1–4-mode subspaces

We report a full-dimensional, permutationally invariant potential energy surface (PES) for the cyclic formic acid dimer.

Mode-Specific Tunneling Splittings for a Sequential Double-Hydrogen Transfer Case: An Accurate Quantum Mechanical Scheme

We present the first accurate quantum dynamics calculations of mode-specific tunneling splittings in a sequential double-hydrogen transfer process. This is achieved in the vinylidene-acetylene system, the simplest molecular system of this kind, and by large-scale parallel computations with an efficient theoretical scheme developed by us. In our scheme, basis functions are customized for the hydrogen transfer process; a 4-dimensional basis contraction strategy is combined with the preconditioned inexact spectral transform method; efficient parallel implementation is achieved. Mode-specific permutation tunneling splittings of vinylidene states are reported and tremendous mode-specific promotion effects are revealed; in particular, the CH2 rock mode enhances the ground-state splitting by a factor of 10(3). We find that the ground-state vinylidene has a reversible-isomerization time of 622 ps, much longer than all previous estimates. Our calculations also shed light on the importance of the deep intermediate well and vibrational excitation in the double-hydrogen transfer processes.