Observation of orbiting resonances in He(3S1) + NH3Penning ionization

Spiers Memorial Lecture: New directions in molecular scattering

The field of molecular scattering is reviewed as it pertains to gas-gas as well as gas-surface chemical reaction dynamics. We emphasize the importance of collaboration of experiment and theory, from which new directions of research are being pursued on increasingly complex problems. We review both experimental and theoretical advances that provide the modern toolbox available to molecular-scattering studies. We distinguish between two classes of work. The first involves simple systems and uses experiment to validate theory so that from the validated theory, one may learn far more than could ever be measured in the laboratory. The second class involves problems of great complexity that would be difficult or impossible to understand without a partnership of experiment and theory. Key topics covered in this review include crossed-beams reactive scattering and scattering at extremely low energies, where quantum effects dominate. They also include scattering from surfaces, reactive scattering and kinetics at surfaces, and scattering work done at liquid surfaces. The review closes with thoughts on future promising directions of research.

The topology of the reaction stereo-dynamics in chemi-ionizations

Details on the stereo-dynamic topology of chemi-ionizations highlight the role of the centrifugal barrier of colliding reactants: it acts as a selector of the orbital quantum number effective for reaction in a state-to-state treatment. Here, an accurate internally consistent formulation of the Optical interaction potentials, obtained by the combined analysis of scattering and spectroscopic experimental findings, casts light on structure, energy and angular momentum couplings of the precursor (pre-reactive) state controlling the stereo-dynamics of prototypical chemi-ionization reactions. The closest approach (turning point) of reagents, is found to control the relative weight of two different reaction mechanisms: (i) A direct mechanism stimulated by exchange chemical forces mainly acting at short separation distances and high collision energy; (ii) An indirect mechanism, caused by the combination of weak chemical and physical forces dominant at larger distances, mainly probed at low collision energy, that can be triggered by a virtual photon exchange between reagents.

Quantum Controlled Cold Scattering Challenges Theory

Our previous rotationally inelastic cold scattering experiments between state prepared D₂ (v = 2, j = 2, m = 0) and He disagreed with theory, raising serious concerns about either our understanding of the anisotropic potential or the accuracy of the measurement. To further interrogate interactions between molecular hydrogen and atomic helium, we study the Δj = 1and Δj = 2 rotational relaxation of HD (v = 2, j = 2, m = 0) by collision with He. The two rotational transitions probe different anisotropic components of the van der Waals potential. Our state resolved scattering study shows that these two transitions are mediated by two different shape resonances l = 1 for Δj = 1 and l = 2 for Δj = 2. The strong l = 1 resonance dominates the Δj = 1 scattering, agreeing with theory. However, the dominance of the weaker l = 2 resonance in the Δj = 2 transition, which matches our earlier D₂-He result, contradicts theoretical calculations. The continued contradiction, when we expect one-to-one correspondence between our stereodynamically controlled scattering experiment and theoretical calculations, makes us question the accuracy of the weaker anisotropic part of the H₂-He interaction potential.

Anisotropic dynamics of resonant scattering between a pair of cold aligned diatoms

The collision dynamics between a pair of aligned molecules in the presence of a partial-wave resonance provide the most sensitive probe of the long-range anisotropic forces important to chemical reactions. Here we control the collision temperature and geometry to probe the dynamics of cold (1-3 K) rotationally inelastic scattering of a pair of optically state-prepared D₂ molecules. The collision temperature is manipulated by combining the gating action of laser state preparation and detection with the velocity dispersion of the molecular beam. When the bond axes of both molecules are aligned parallel to the collision velocity, the scattering rate drops by a factor of 3.5 as collision energies >2.1 K are removed, suggesting a geometry-dependent resonance. Partial-wave analysis of the measured angular distribution supports a shape resonance within the centrifugal barrier of the l = 2 incoming orbital. Our experiment illustrates the strong anisotropy of the quadrupole-quadrupole interaction that controls the dynamics of resonant scattering.

Spin-state-controlled chemi-ionization reactions between metastable helium atoms and ground-state lithium atoms

We demonstrate the control of 4He(23S1)–7Li(22S1/2) chemi-ionization reactions by all-optical electron-spin-state preparation of both atomic species prior to the collision process. Our results demonstrate that chemi-ionization is strongly suppressed (enhanced) for non-spin-conserving (spin-conserving) collisions at thermal energies. These findings are in good agreement with a model based on spin angular momentum coupling of the prepared atomic states to the quasi-molecular states. Small deviations from the model indicate the contribution of the 4Σ+ channel to the reaction rate, which is in violation of spin conservation.

Mapping partial wave dynamics in scattering resonances by rotational de-excitation collisions

One of the most important parameters in a collision is the 'miss distance' or impact parameter, which in quantum mechanics is described by quantized partial waves. Usually, the collision outcome is the result of unavoidable averaging over many partial waves. Here we present a study of low-energy NO-He collisions that enables us to probe how individual partial waves evolve during the collision. By tuning the collision energies to scattering resonances between 0.4 and 6 cm^-1, the initial conditions are characterized by a limited set of partial waves. By preparing NO in a rotationally excited state before the collision and by studying rotational de-excitation collisions, we were able to add one quantum of angular momentum to the system and trace how it evolves. Distinct fingerprints in the differential cross-sections yield a comprehensive picture of the partial wave dynamics during the scattering process. Exploiting the principle of detailed balance, we show that rotational de-excitation collisions probe time-reversed excitation processes with superior energy and angular resolution.

Vortex beams of atoms and molecules

[Figure: see text].

Collisions between Ultracold Molecules and Atoms in a Magnetic Trap

We prepare mixtures of ultracold CaF molecules and Rb atoms in a magnetic trap and study their inelastic collisions. When the atoms are prepared in the spin-stretched state and the molecules in the spin-stretched component of the first rotationally excited state, they collide inelastically with a rate coefficient k_{2}=(6.6±1.5)×10^{-11}  cm^{3}/s at temperatures near 100  μK. We attribute this to rotation-changing collisions. When the molecules are in the ground rotational state we see no inelastic loss and set an upper bound on the spin-relaxation rate coefficient of k_{2}<5.8×10^{-12}  cm^{3}/s with 95% confidence. We compare these measurements to the results of a single-channel loss model based on quantum defect theory. The comparison suggests a short-range loss parameter close to unity for rotationally excited molecules, but below 0.04 for molecules in the rotational ground state.

Dataset of noncovalent intermolecular interaction energy curves for 24 small high-spin open-shell dimers

We introduce a dataset of 24 interaction energy curves of open-shell noncovalent dimers, referred to as the O24 × 5 dataset. The dataset consists of high-spin dimers up to 11 atoms selected to assure diversity with respect to interaction types: dispersion, electrostatics, and induction. The benchmark interaction energies are obtained at the restricted open-shell CCSD(T) level of theory with complete basis set extrapolation (from aug-cc-pVQZ to aug-cc-pV5Z). We have analyzed the performance of selected wave function methods MP2, CCSD, and CCSD(T) as well as the F12a and F12b variants of coupled-cluster theory. In addition, we have tested dispersion-corrected density functional theory methods based on the PBE exchange-correlation model. The O24 × 5 dataset is a challenge to approximate methods due to the wide range of interaction energy strengths it spans. For the dispersion-dominated and mixed-type subsets, any tested method that does not include the triples contribution yields errors on the order of tens of percent. The electrostatic subset is less demanding with errors that are typically an order of magnitude smaller than the mixed and dispersion-dominated subsets.

The F + HD(v = 0, 1; j = 0, 1) reactions: stereodynamical properties of orbiting resonances

The excitation functions (reaction cross-section as a function of collision energy) of the F + HD(v = 0, 1; j = 0, 1) benchmark system have been calculated in the 0.01-6 meV collision energy interval using a time-independent hyperspherical quantum dynamics methodology. Special attention has been paid to orbiting resonances, which bring about detailed information on the three-atom interaction during the reactive encounter. The location of the resonances depends on the rovibrational state of the reactants HD(v,j), but is the same for the two product channels HF + D and DF + H, as expected for these resonances that are linked to the van der Waals well at the entrance. The resonance intensities depend both on the entrance and on the exit channels. The peak intensities for the HF + D channel are systematically larger than those for DF + H. Vibrational excitation leads to an increase of the peak intensity by more than an order of magnitude, but rotational excitation has a less drastic effect. It deceases the resonance intensity of the F + HD(v = 1) reaction, but increases somewhat that of F + HD(v = 0). Polarization of the rotational angular momentum with respect to the initial velocity reveals intrinsic directional preferences in the F + HD(v = 0, 1; j = 1) reactions that are manifested in the resonance patterns. The helicities (Ω = 0, Ω = ±1) possible for j = 1 contribute to the resonances, but that from Ω± 1 is, in general, dominant and in some cases exclusive. It corresponds to a preferential alignment of the HD internuclear axis perpendicular to the initial direction of approach and, thus, to side-on collisions. This work also shows that external preparation of the reactants, following the intrinsic preferences, would allow the enhancement or reduction of specific resonance features, and would be of great help for their eventual experimental detection.

Experimental and theoretical investigation of resonances in low-energy NO-H2 collisions

The experimental characterization of scattering resonances in low energy collisions has proven to be a stringent test for quantum chemistry calculations. Previous measurements on the NO-H₂ system at energies down to 10 cm^-1 challenged the most sophisticated calculations of potential energy surfaces available. In this report, we continue these investigations by measuring the scattering behavior of the NO-H₂ system in the previously unexplored 0.4 cm^-1-10 cm^-1 region for the parity changing de-excitation channel of NO. We study state-specific inelastic collisions with both para- and ortho-H₂ in a crossed molecular beam experiment involving Stark deceleration and velocity map imaging. We are able to resolve resonance features in the measured integral and differential cross sections. Results are compared to predictions from two previously available potential energy surfaces, and we are able to clearly discriminate between the two potentials. We furthermore identify the partial wave contributions to these resonances and investigate the nature of the differences between collisions with para- and ortho-H₂. Additionally, we tune the energy spreads in the experiment to our advantage to probe scattering behavior at energies beyond our mean experimental limit.

Manipulating beams of paramagnetic atoms and molecules using inhomogeneous magnetic fields

We review methods to manipulate the motion of pulsed supersonic atomic and molecular beams using time-independent and -dependent inhomogeneous magnetic fields. In addition, we discuss current and possible future applications and research directions.

Evidence of Nonrigidity Effects in the Description of Low-Energy Anisotropic Molecular Collisions of Hydrogen Molecules with Excited Metastable Helium Atoms

Cold collisions serve as a sensitive probe of the interaction potential. In the recent study of Klein et al. (Nature Phys.2017, 13, 35–38), the one-parameter scaling of the interaction potential was necessary to obtain agreement between theoretical and observed patterns of the orbiting resonances for excited metastable helium atoms colliding with hydrogen molecules. Here, we show that the effect of nonrigidity of the H₂ molecule on the resonant structure, absent in the previous study, is critical to predict the correct positions of the resonances in that case. We have complemented the theoretical description of the interaction potential and revised reaction rate coefficients by proper inclusion of the flexibility of the molecule. The calculated reaction rate coefficients are in remarkable agreement with the experimental data without empirical adjustment of the interaction potential. We have shown that even state-of-the-art calculations of the interaction energy cannot ensure agreement with the experiment if such an important physical effect as flexibility of the interacting molecule is neglected. Our findings about the significance of the nonrigidity effects can be especially crucial in cold chemistry, where the quantum nature of molecules is pronounced.

Universal crossed beam imaging studies of polyatomic reaction dynamics

Crossed-beam imaging studies of polyatomic reactions show surprising dynamics not anticipated by extrapolation from smaller model systems.

Orbiting resonances in the F + HD (v = 0, 1) reaction at very low collision energies. A quantum dynamical study

Time-independent, fully converged, quantum dynamical calculations have been performed for the F + HD (v = 0, j = 0) and F + HD (v = 1, j = 0) reactions on an accurate potential energy surface down to collision energies of 0.01 meV. The two isotopic exit channels, HF + D and DF + H, have been investigated. The calculations reproduce satisfactorily the Feshbach resonance structures for collision energies between 10 and 40 meV, previously reported in the literature for the HF + D channel. Contrary to the results of a former literature work, vibrational excitation of HD is found to enhance reactivity in all cases down to the lowest collision energy investigated. Shape-type orbiting resonances are found for collision energies lower than 2 meV. The resonances appear as peaks in the reaction cross sections that are associated to specific values of the total angular momentum, J. In contrast with the Feshbach resonances at higher energies, the orbiting resonance structure, which is caused by the van der Waals well of the entrance channel, is identical for the HF + D and DF + H exit channels. The orbiting resonance peaks for F + HD (v = 0) are very small, but those for F + HD (v = 1) could be observed, in principle, with a combination of Raman pumping and merged beams methods.

A unified theory of weak-field coherent control of the behavior of a resonance state

A unified weak-field control scheme to modify the two properties that determine the whole behavior of a resonance state, namely the lifetime and the asymptotic fragment distribution produced upon resonance decay, is proposed. Control is exerted through quantum interference induced between overlapping resonances of the system, by exciting two different energies at which the resonances overlap. The scheme applies a laser field consisting of a first pulse that excites the energy of the resonance to be controlled, and two additional pulses that excite another different energy to induce interference, with a delay time with respect to the first pulse. Each of the two additional pulses is used to control one of the two resonance properties, by adjusting its corresponding delay time: with a relatively short delay time the second pulse controls the resonance lifetime, while with a very long delay time the third pulse modifies the asymptotic fragment distribution produced. The efficiency of the control of each resonance property is found to be strongly dependent on the choice of the second interfering energy, which allows for a more flexible control optimization by choosing a different energy for each property. The theory underlying the interference mechanism of the control scheme is developed and presented, and is applied to analyze and explain the results obtained. The present scheme thus appears to be a useful tool for controlling resonance-mediated molecular processes.

Weak-Field Coherent Control of Molecular Photofragment State Distributions

It is known that the long-time energy-resolved photofragment state distribution produced upon photodissociation of a molecule cannot be modified in the weak-field limit for a fixed pump pulse spectral profile. This work, however, demonstrates both computationally and mathematically that the above limitation can be circumvented in practice when the molecule presents overlapping resonances. It is shown that when two or more energies where the resonances overlap are excited by different laser pulses delayed in time, interference is induced between the product fragment states associated with the different energies populated. The occurrence of interference is found to be independent of the delay time between the pulses exciting the different energies. Thus, as demonstrated, this finding makes it possible to modify the fragment distribution at a given energy, as far in time and as many times as desired.

A detailed account of the measurements of cold collisions in a molecular synchrotron

We have recently demonstrated a general and sensitive method to study low energy collisions that exploits the unique properties of a molecular synchrotron (Van der Poel et al., Phys Rev Lett 120:033402, 2018). In that work, the total cross section for ND3 + Ar collisions was determined from the rate at which ammonia molecules were lost from the synchrotron due to collisions with argon atoms in supersonic beams. This paper provides further details on the experiment. In particular, we derive the model that was used to extract the relative cross section from the loss rate, and present measurements to characterize the spatial and velocity distributions of the stored ammonia molecules and the supersonic argon beams.

Unravelling the mechanisms of interference between overlapping resonances

The enhancement of the resonance lifetime that occurs upon interference of two overlapping resonances excited coherently by two pulses with delayed time has been investigated as a function of the pulse temporal width and the delay time between the pulses. A general law predicting quantitatively the optimal delay time that maximizes the lifetime enhancement of the two resonances has been established in terms of the pulse width and of the lifetimes of both resonances when they are excited isolatedly. The specific form of the law and all the results found can be closely related to the characteristic features of the mechanism of interference between the overlapping resonances, providing a detailed understanding on how the mechanism operates. The proposed law is envisioned as a useful tool to design experimental strategies to control the resonance lifetime.

Simple Closed-Form Expression for Penning Reaction Rate Coefficients for Cold Molecular Collisions by Non-Hermitian Time-Independent Adiabatic Scattering Theory

We present a simple expression and its derivation for reaction rate coefficients for cold anisotropic collision experiments based on adiabatic variational theory and time-independent non-Hermitian scattering theory. We demonstrate that only the eigenenergies of the resulting one-dimensional Schrödinger equation for different complex adiabats are required. The expression is applied to calculate the Penning ionization rate coefficients of an excited metastable helium atom with molecular hydrogen in an energy range spanning from hundreds of kelvins down to the millikelvin regime. Except for trivial quantities like the masses of the nuclei and the bond length of the diatomic molecule participating in the collision, one needs as input data only the complex potential energy surface (CPES). In calculations, we used recently obtained ab initio CPES by D. Bhattacharya et al. ( J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2017 , 13 , 1682 - 1690 ) without fitting parameters. The results show good accord with current measurements ( Nat. Phys. 2017 , 13 , 35 - 38 ).

Probing resonant energy transfer in collisions of ammonia with Rydberg helium atoms by microwave spectroscopy

We present the results of experiments demonstrating the spectroscopic detection of Förster resonance energy transfer from NH₃ in the X¹A₁ ground electronic state to helium atoms in 1sns ³S₁ Rydberg levels, where n = 37 and n = 40. For these values of n, the 1sns ³S₁ → 1snp ³P_J transitions in helium lie close to resonance with the ground-state inversion transitions in NH₃ and can be tuned through resonance using electric fields of less than 10 V/cm. In the experiments, energy transfer was detected by direct state-selective electric field ionization of the ³S₁ and ³P_J Rydberg levels and by monitoring the population of the ³D_J levels following pulsed microwave transfer from the ³P_J levels. Detection by microwave spectroscopic methods represents a highly state selective, low-background approach to probing the collisional energy transfer process and the environment in which the atom-molecule interactions occur. The experimentally observed electric-field dependence of the resonant energy transfer process, probed both by direct electric field ionization and by microwave transfer, agrees well with the results of calculations performed using a simple theoretical model of the energy transfer process. For measurements performed in zero electric field with atoms prepared in the 1s40s ³S₁ level, the transition from a regime in which a single energy transfer channel can be isolated for detection to one in which multiple collision channels begin to play a role has been identified as the NH₃ density was increased.

Intrabeam Scattering for Ultracold Collisions

We demonstrate a method to probe cold and ultracold chemistry in a single molecular beam. The approach exploits beam slippage, the velocity difference of different species in the same beam, to establish the relative velocity. Average collision energies of 2.5 mK are achieved but with a spread of 100% or more. However, by implementing a dual-slit chopper that can separately fix the velocities of the two species at the interaction region, we achieve precise control over the relative velocity and narrow its spread. Relative velocities of 7-10 ± 1.1 m/s are achieved with an angular divergence less than 0.25°. In the present study, we observe l-changing collisions occurring between Xe Rydberg atoms and Xe ground state atoms at subKelvin temperatures. We show that in this case the collision energies are tunable between 200 to 450 mK with a root-mean-square deviation of ∼18%. Application of the method to other species and access to much lower energies is straightforward.

Energy Dependent Stereodynamics of the Ne(^{3}P_{2})+Ar Reaction

The stereodynamics of the Ne(^{3}P_{2})+Ar Penning and associative ionization reactions have been studied using a crossed molecular beam apparatus. The experiment uses a curved magnetic hexapole to polarize the Ne(^{3}P_{2}), which is then oriented with a shaped magnetic field in the region where it intersects with a beam of Ar(^{1}S). The ratios of Penning to associative ionization were recorded over a range of collision energies from 320 to 500  cm^{-1} and the data were used to obtain Ω state dependent reactivities for the two reaction channels. These reactivities were found to compare favorably to those predicted in the theoretical work of Brumer et al.

The structure of a resonance state

The existence of a structure in a resonance state is systematically investigated. A resonance structure is defined as the energy dependence across the resonance width of the fragment state distributions produced upon resonance decay. Different types of resonances, both isolated and overlapping ones, have been explored for this purpose. It is found that isolated resonances do not present an appreciable energy dependence on the product state distributions. On the contrary, overlapping resonances exhibit a clear structure regarding the fragment distributions, which becomes increasingly more pronounced as the intensity of the overlap between the resonances increases. Such an energy dependence of the product distributions arises from the quantum interference between the amplitudes of the overlapping resonances, as demonstrated formally here by the equations derived from the condition of resonance overlap. The application of the present effect to the control of the fragment state distributions produced in a wide variety of molecular processes governed by resonance states is envisioned.

Unraveling Cold Molecular Collisions: Stark Decelerators in Crossed-Beam Experiments

In the last two decades, enormous progress has been made in the manipulation of molecular beams. In particular, molecular decelerators have been developed with which advanced control over neutral molecules in a beam can be achieved. By using arrays of inhomogeneous and time-varying electric (or magnetic) fields, bunches of molecules can be produced with a tunable velocity, narrow velocity spreads, and almost perfect quantum-state purity. These monochromatic or "tamed" molecular beams are ideally suited to be used in crossed-molecular-beam scattering experiments. Here, we review the first generation of these "cold and controlled" scattering experiments that have been conducted in the last decade and discuss the prospects for this emerging field of research in the years to come.

Production of high density molecular beams with wide velocity scanning

We describe modifications of a pulsed rotating supersonic beam source that improve performance, particularly increasing the beam density and sharpening the pulse profiles. As well as providing the familiar virtues of a supersonic molecular beam (high intensity, narrowed velocity distribution, and drastic cooling of rotation and vibration), the rotating source enables scanning the translational velocity over a wide range. Thereby, beams of any atom or molecule available as a gas can be slowed or speeded. Using Xe beams in the slowing mode, we have obtained lab speeds down to about 40 ± 5 m/s with density near 10(11) cm(-3) and in the speeding mode lab speeds up to about 660 m/s and density near 10(14) cm(-3). We discuss some congenial applications. Providing low lab speeds can markedly enhance experiments using electric or magnetic fields to deflect, steer, or further slow polar or paramagnetic molecules. The capability to scan molecular speeds facilitates merging velocities with a codirectional partner beam, enabling study of collisions at very low relative kinetic energies, without requiring either beam to be slow.

Observation of quantum dynamical resonances in near cold inelastic collisions of astrophysical molecules

Quantum resonances in inelastic collisions, predicted by theory and detected at low energies in a crossed-beam experiment, are reviewed.

This mini review summarizes experimental findings of quantum dynamical resonances in inelastic collisions at energies equivalent to temperatures of a few to a few tens of Kelvin, corresponding to physical conditions prevailing in dense molecular clouds of the interstellar medium. Information obtained is thus relevant to collision energy transfer modelling in such media. Crossed-beam scattering experiments performed at Bordeaux university for inelastic collisions of important astrophysical molecules such as CO with H₂ or He and O₂ with H₂ are described. The peaks that show up in the collision energy dependence of the state-to-state integral cross sections for the lowest rotational excitation transitions reveal the quantum nature of such processes. They are ascribed as shape and Feshbach resonances by comparison with the results of close coupling quantum mechanical calculations performed concomitantly on accurate potential energy surfaces.